[ and if this equivalence were allowed, the kraken-hafgufa's range would extend, at least legendarily, to waters approaching Helluland ( Baffin Island, Canada), as described in '' Örvar-Odds saga''.]
Contrary opinion
The description of the ''hafgufa'' in the ''King's Mirror'' suggests a garbled eyewitness account of what was actually a whale, at least to . also reads the work as describing the ''hafgufa'' as a type of whale.
Finnur Jónsson
Finnur Jónsson (May 29, 1858 – March 30, 1934) was an Icelandic-Danish philologist and Professor of Nordic Philology at the University of Copenhagen. He made extensive contributions to the study of Old Norse literature.
Finnur Jónsson was b ...
(1920) having arrived at the opinion that the kraken probably represented an inkfish (squid/octopus), as discussed earlier, expressed his skepticism towards the standing notion that the kraken originated from the ''hafgufa''.
Pontoppidan
Erik Pontoppidan's ''Det første Forsøg paa Norges naturlige Historie'' (1752, actually volume 2, 1753) made several claims regarding kraken, including the notion that the creature was sometimes mistaken for a group of small islands with fish swimming in-between, Norwegian fishermen often took the risk of trying to fish over kraken, since the catch was so plentiful (hence the saying "You must have fished on Kraken").
However, there was also the danger to seamen of being engulfed by the whirlpool
A whirlpool is a body of rotating water produced by opposing currents or a current running into an obstacle. Small whirlpools form when a bath or a sink is draining. More powerful ones formed in seas or oceans may be called maelstroms ( ). ''Vo ...
when it submerged, and this whirlpool was compared to Norway's famed Moskstraumen
The Moskstraumen or Moskenstraumen is a system of tidal eddies and whirlpools, one of the strongest in the world, that forms at the Lofoten archipelago in Nordland county, Norway between the Norwegian Sea and the Vestfjorden. It is located bet ...
often known as "the Maelstrom".
Pontoppidan also described the destructive potential of the giant beast: "it is said that if he creature's armswere to lay hold of the largest man-of-war, they would pull it down to the bottom".[Sjögren, Bengt (1980). ''Berömda vidunder''. Settern. ]
Kraken purportedly exclusively fed for several months, then spent the following few months emptying its excrement, and the thickened clouded water attracted fish. Later Henry Lee commented that the supposed excreta may have been the discharge of ink
Ink is a gel, sol, or solution that contains at least one colorant, such as a dye or pigment, and is used to color a surface to produce an image, text, or design. Ink is used for drawing or writing with a pen, brush, reed pen, or quill. Thicker ...
by a cephalopod.
Taxonomic identifications
Pontoppidan wrote of a possible specimen of the krake, "perhaps a young and careless one", which washed ashore and died at Alstahaug, Norway, in 1680. He observed that it had long "arms", and guessed that it must have been crawl
Crawl, The Crawl, or crawling may refer to:
Biology
* Crawling (human), any of several types of human quadrupedal gait
* Limbless locomotion, the movement of limbless animals over the ground
* Undulatory locomotion, a type of motion characteriz ...
ing like a snail/slug with the use of these "arms", but got lodged in the landscape during the process. 20th century malacologist Paul Bartsch
Paul Bartsch (14 August 1871 Tuntschendorf, Silesia – 24 April 1960 McLean, Virginia) was an American malacologist and carcinologist. He was named the last of those belonging to the "Descriptive Age of Malacology".
Early life
Bartsch emigrat ...
conjectured this to have been a giant squid
The giant squid (''Architeuthis dux'') is a species of deep-ocean dwelling squid in the family Architeuthidae. It can grow to a tremendous size, offering an example of abyssal gigantism: recent estimates put the maximum size at around Trac ...
, as did literary scholar Finnur Jónsson.
However, what Pontoppidan actually stated regarding what creatures he regarded as candidates for the kraken is quite complicated.
Pontoppidan did tentatively identify the kraken to be a sort of giant crab, stating that the alias ''krabben'' best describes its characteristics.) described by Swedish magnate in ''Min son på galejan'' ("My son on the galley", 1781):
However, further down in his writing, compares the creature to some creature(s) from Pliny, Book IX, Ch. 4: the sea-monster called ''arbor'', with tree-branch like multiple arms, complicated by the fact that Pontoppidan adds another of Pliny's creature called ''rota'' with eight arms, and conflates them into one organism. Pontoppidan is suggesting this is an ancient example of ''kraken'', as a modern commentator analyzes.
Pontoppidan then declared the kraken to be a type of ''polypus'' (octopus) or "starfish", particularly the kind Gesner called ''Stella Arborescens'', later identifiable as one of the northerly ophiurids or possibly more specifically as one of the Gorgonocephalids or even the genus '' Gorgonocephalus'' (though no longer regarded as family/genus under order ''Ophiurida'', but under '' Phrynophiurida'' in current taxonomy).
This ancient ''arbor'' (admixed ''rota'' and thus made eight-armed) seems like an octopus at first blush but with additional data, the ophiurid starfish now appears bishop's preferential choice.
The ophiurid starfish seems further fortified when he notes that "starfish" called "Medusa's heads" (''caput medusæ''; pl. ''capita medusæ'') are considered to be "the young of the great sea-krake" by local lore. Pontoppidan ventured the 'young krakens' may rather be the eggs (''ova'') of the starfish. Pontopiddan was satisfied that "Medusa's heads" was the same as the foregoing starfish (''Stella arborensis'' of old), but "Medusa's heads" were something found ashore aplenty across Norway according to von Bergen, who thought it absurd these could be young "Kraken" since that would mean the seas would be full of (the adults). The "Medusa's heads" appear to be a Gorgonocephalid, with '' Gorgonocephalus spp. being tentatively suggested.
In the end though, Pontoppidan again appears ambivalent, stating "Polype, or Star-fish elongs tothe whole genus of Kors-Trold cross troll' ... some that are much larger, .. even the very largest ... of the ocean", and concluding that "this Krake must be of the Polypus kind". By "this Krake" here, he apparently meant in particular the giant ''polypus'' octopus of Carteia from Pliny, Book IX, Ch. 30 (though he only used the general nickname " ozaena" 'stinkard' for the octopus kind).
Denys-Montfort
*
Plate XXX (The Kraken)
"The Kraken supposed a sepia or cuttle fish (from Denys Montfort)", p. 326a via Biodiversity.
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
digital copy
National Library Norway
*
*
*
*
External links
{{Authority control
Monster
Mythological cephalopods
Scandinavian legendary creatures
Sea monsters