Kenshō

Kenshō (Rōmaji; Japanese and classical Chinese: 見性, Pinyin: ''jianxing'', Sanskrit: dṛṣṭi- svabhāva) is an East Asian Buddhist term from the Chan / Zen tradition which means "seeing" or "perceiving" ( 見) "nature" or "essence" ( 性), or 'true face'. It is usually translated as "seeing one's ruenature," with "nature" referring to buddha-nature, ultimate reality, the Dharmadhatu. The term appears in one of the classic slogans which define Chan Buddhism: to see oneʼs own nature and accomplish Buddhahood (見性成佛).

Kenshō is an ''initial'' insight or sudden awakening, not full Buddhahood. It is to be followed by further training which deepens this insight, allows one to learn to express it in daily life and gradually removes the remaining defilements.

The Japanese term kenshō is often used interchangeably with satori, which is derived from the verb satoru, and means "comprehension; understanding".Denshi Jisho – Online Japanese dictionary
/ref>

Terminology

The Chinese Buddhist term ''jianxing'' () compounds:
* ''jian'' 見 "see, observe, meet with, perceive";
* ''xing'' 性 "(inborn) nature, character, personality, disposition, property, quality, gender"; also 'true face'.Martin Goodson (April 14, 2021)
A Sermon on the Original Face
/ref>

History

Buddhist monks who produced Sanskrit-Chinese translations of sutras faced many linguistic difficulties:
* They chose Chinese ''jian'' 見 to translate Sanskrit ''dṛś'' दृश् "see, look", and the central Buddhist idea of '' dṛṣṭi'' दृष्टि "view, seeing (also with the mind's eye), wisdom, false view".
* Translators used ''xing'' 性 or ''zixing'' 自性 "self-nature" for Sanskrit '' svabhāva'' स्वभाव "intrinsic nature, essential nature".
Thus, ''jianxing'' was the translation for ''dṛṣṭi-svabhāva'', to "view one's essential nature".

The term is found in the Chinese '' Platform Sutra'' (c. 8th century; 2, Prajñā "wisdom, understanding").

Pronunciations

The Standard Chinese pronunciation ''jianxing'' historically derives from (c. 7th century CE) Middle Chinese ''kien^Csjäŋ^C''. Sino-Xenic pronunciations of this term exist:
* ''kenshō'' 見性 or ケンショウ (''on'yomi'') in Sino-Japanese vocabulary
* in Sino-Korean vocabulary
* ''kiến tính'' in Sino-Vietnamese vocabulary.

Meanings

Translating ''kenshō'' into English is semantically complex.

Encyclopedic and dictionary definitions

Some encyclopedia and dictionary definitions are:
* Soothill (1934): "To behold the Buddha-nature within oneself, a common saying of the Chan (Zen) or Intuitive School."
* Fischer-Schreiber (1991): Lit. "seeing nature"; Zen expression for the experience of awakening (enlightenment). Since the meaning is "seeing one's own true nature," ''kenshō'' is usually translated "self-realization." Like all words that try to reduce the conceptually ungraspable experience of enlightenment to a concept, this one is also not entirely accurate and is even misleading, since the experience contains no duality of "seer" and "seen" because there is no "nature of self' as an object that is seen by a subject separate from it.
* Baroni (2002): "Seeing one's nature," that is, realizing one's own original Buddha Nature. In the Rinzai school, it most often refers more specifically to one's initial enlightenment attained through kōan practice.
* Muller (year unknown): To see one's own originally enlightened mind. To behold the Buddha-nature within oneself, a common saying of the Chan school, as seen for example, in the phrase 'seeing one's nature, becoming Buddha' 見性成佛.

Definitions by Buddhist scholars

Buddhist scholars have defined ''kenshō'' as:
* D.T. Suzuki: "Looking into one's nature or the opening of satori"; "This acquiring of a new point of view in our dealings with life and the world is popularly called by Japanese Zen students 'satori' (''wu'' in Chinese). It is really another name for Enlightenment ('' Annuttara-samyak-sambodhi'')".
* Dumoulin (1988/2005): "Enlightenment is described here as an insight into the identity of one's own nature with all of reality in an eternal now, as a vision that removes all distinctions. This enlightenment is the center and the goal of the Zen way. Hakuin prefers the term "seeing into one's nature", which for him means ultimate reality. The Buddha nature and the cosmic Buddha body, wisdom (''prajna''), and emptiness (''sunyata''), the original countenance one had before one was born, and other expressions from the rich palette of Mahayana terms were all familiar to him from his continued study of the sutras and Zen literature."
* Peter Harvey (1990): "It is a blissful realization where a person's inner nature, the originally pure mind, is directly known as an illuminating emptiness, a thusness which is dynamic and immanent in the world."
* G. Victor Sogen Hori (2000): "The term consists of two characters: ''ken'', which means "see" or "seeing", and ''sho'', which means "nature", "character", "quality." To "see one's nature" is the usual translation for ''kensho''".

Definitions by Buddhist teachers and practitioners

Buddhist teachers and practitioners have defined ''kenshō'' as:
* Jiyu-Kennett: "To see into one's own nature. The experience of enlightenment, satori."
* Myodo Ni Satomi, a student of Hakuun Yasutani (1993): "Seeing the-self, that is, the true self or Buddha nature."

Further notions

According to Hori, the term ''kenshō'' refers to the realization of non-duality of subject and object in general, but the term ''kenshō'' may also be applied in other contexts: "How do you ''kenshō'' this?"

''Kenshō'' is not a single experience, but refers to a whole series of realizations from a beginner's shallow glimpse of the nature of mind, up to a vision of emptiness equivalent to the 'Path of Seeing' or to Buddhahood itself. In all of these, the same 'thing' is known, but in different degrees of clarity and profundity.

"Kenshō" is commonly translated as enlightenment, a word that is also used to translate bodhi, prajna, satori and buddhahood. Western discourse tends to use these terms interchangeably, but there is a distinction between a first insight and the further development toward Buddhahood.

Insight versus experience

Kensho is insight, an understanding of our essential nature as Buddha-nature, or the nature of mind, the perceiving subject itself, which was equated with Buddha-nature by the East Mountain school.

Contemporary understanding also describes kensho as an ''experience'', as in "enlightenment experience"; the term "enlightenment experience" is itself a tautology: "Kensho (enlightenment) is an enlightenment (kensho)-experience". The notion of "experience" fits in a popular set of dichotomies: pure (unmediated) versus mediated, noncognitive versus cognitive, experiential versus intellectual, intuitive versus intellectual, nonrational versus rational, nondiscursive versus discursive, nonpropositional versus propositional.

The notion of ''pure experience'' (''junsui kuiken'') to interpret and understand kensho was introduced by Nishida Kitaro in his An Inquiry into the Good (1911), under influence of "his somewhat idiosyncratic reading of western philosophy", especially William James, who wrote The Varieties of Religious Experience. Wayne Proudfoot traces the roots of the notion of "religious experience" to the German theologian Friedrich Schleiermacher (1768–1834), who argued that religion is based on a feeling of the infinite. The notion of "religious experience" was used by Schleiermacher to defend religion against the growing scientific and secular critique. It was adopted by many scholars of religion, of which William James was the most influential. D.T. Suzuki, who introduced Nishida Kitaro to western philosophy, took over this notion of ''pure experience'', describing it as the essence of all religions, but best represented in what he considered the "superior Japanese culture and religion".

The influence of western psychology and philosophy on Japanese Buddhism was due to the persecution of Buddhism at the beginning of the Meiji Restoration, and the subsequent efforts to construct a New Buddhism (''shin bukkyo''), adapted to the modern times. It was this New Buddhism which has shaped the understanding of Zen in the west, especially through the writings of D.T. Suzuki and the Sanbo Kyodan, an exponent of the Meiji-era opening of Zen-training for lay-followers.

The notion of "experience" has been criticised. Robert Sharf points out that "experience" is a typical western term, which has found its way into Asian religiosity via western influences. The notion of "experience" introduces a false notion of duality between "experiencer" and "experienced", where-as the essence of kensho is the realisation of the "non-duality" of observer and observed. "Pure experience" does not exist; all experience is mediated by intellectual and cognitive activity. The specific teachings and practices of a specific tradition may even determine what "experience" someone has, which means that this "experience" is not the ''proof'' of the teaching, but a ''result'' of the teaching. A pure consciousness without concepts, reached by "cleaning the doors of perception", would be an overwhelming chaos of sensory input without coherence.

Ama Samy describes the notion of kensho-experience or awakening-experience as inherently dualistic and misguided:

Daoxin remarks on the experience of "seeing emptiness":

The notion of "experience" also over-emphasises kensho, as if it were the single goal of Zen-training, where-as the Zen-tradition clearly states that "the stink of Zen" has to be removed and the "experience" of kensho has to be integrated into daily life. In the Rinzai-school this post-satori training includes the study and mastering of great amounts of classical Chinese poetry, which is far from "universal" and culture-transcending. On the contrary, it demands an education in culture-specific language and behaviour, which is measured by specific and strict cultural norms. Emphasising "experience" "reduces the sophisticated dialectic of Ch'an/Zen doctrine and praxis to a mere "means" or set of techniques intended to inculcate such experiences".

Kenshō accounts

Classical accounts

Classical Zen texts, such as the ''Kao-seng-chuan'' (Biographies of Eminent Monks) and the transmission lists, called "Transmission of the Lamp" the ''yü-lü'' genre (the recorded sayings of the masters, such as the Línjì yǔlù); and the various koan-collections, contain accounts of "enlightenment experiences". These accounts are not verbatim recordings of such "experiences", but well-edited texts, written down decades after the supposed sayings and meetings.

''The Denkōroku'', "The Record of the Transmission of the Light", written by Keizan Jōkin 瑩山紹瑾 (1268–1325), is an example of the "Transmission of the Lamp" genre. It contains literary accounts of the patriarchs of the Soto-lineage, from Shakyamuni Buddha to Koun Ejō, in which kensho plays a central role. They are not to be taken as literal accounts of awakening, but as stories underpinning the legitimacy of the Dogen-shu, which in its early history had seen a fierce internal conflict over the correct lineage during the Sandai sōron.

Dōgen Zenji's awakening is recalled in the Denkoroku:

Hakuin gives this description of his first kensho, when he was 21:

Hakuin's ''kensho'' was not approved by Shoju Rojin, who subjected Hakuin to more koan-training. This resulted in a second kensho, where-after Hakuin left Shoju Rojin. It was only when he was 41 that he attained "his final great enlightenment":

Contemporary accounts

Although the Zen tradition is reluctant to speak openly about the 'experience' of kensho, personal accounts can be found in Zen texts. Keido Fukushima, a 20th-century Rinzai abbott, gives the following description:

Spontaneous kenshō

Kenshō may be attained without the aid of a teacher. For example, Richard Clarke (1933), who studied with Philip Kapleau, states that he had a spontaneous kensho when he was 13.Japanischer Buddhismus in Amerika. Chronik Ab 1970
/ref> Dennis Genpo Merzel states he had what he described as an "awakening experience" in 1971:Big Mind: An Interview with Genpo Roshi

More descriptions of "spontaneous kensho" can be found throughout the Zen-literature,

Alternate accounts

Houn Jiyu-Kennett, a 20th-century Soto Zen Oshō,Seikai Luebke
''Why Are Roshi Jiyu Kennett's Disciples So Reclusive?''
i.e. "priest" or "teacher," and the first Western female Zen priest, had a prolonged religious experience in the 1970s, including a series of visions and recalling past lives, when she was severely ill. She regarded these experiences as "a profound kensho (enlightenment) experience," constituting a third kensho, and published an account of these visions, and an elaborate scheme of stages of awakening, in ''How to Grow a Lotus Blossom''. Her interpretations, which parallel Christian mysticism, were controversial, and rejected by some as '' makyo'' ("illusion"). According to Jiyu-Kennett, such experiences are not uncommon, but are rarely spoken of; she regarded publishing her own experiences as a way to acknowledge the existence and validity of such experiences, which, according to her, may contribute to further insight after initial awakening. She acknowledged the risks and potential for controversy in publishing her account, but felt that the benefits of releasing such information outweighed the risks.

Training towards kenshō

According to Harris, working towards kensho is usually a lengthy process stretched out over years or even decades. Contrary to this, Victor Hori notes that with koan-study kensho may appear within six months.

Sōtō tends towards a gradual approach, preferring to let the experiences happen on their own. Rinzai tends toward the use of Koans as a technique to unroot the habitual workings of the mind.

During intensive zazen various hallucinations and psychological disturbances may arise. These are referred to as makyo. Distinguishing these delusions from actual kensho is the primary function of the teacher, as the student may be erroneously convinced they have realized kensho.

Rinzai

In the Rinzai school, kensho is seen as indispensable:

In the Rinzai-training, the student is expected to pour oneself totally into both koan-study and daily activities 'to become one' with it. Kenshō is used to describe the first breakthrough in kōan study.

Sōtō

Contemporary Japanese Sōtō downplays the importance of ''kenshō'', due to the sectarian rivalry with Rinzai, which emphasizes ''kenshō''. Nevertheless, ''kenshō'' also has its role in Sōtō. The " genjo-koan", or the "koan of everyday life" which "appears naturally in daily life", is emphasized. Students are not encouraged to actively seek out kenshō experiences. In Sōtō practice kenshōs "are allowed to occur naturally, as a by-product of practice. Meditative training is seen as the unfolding of one great ''kenshō'':

According to Brad Warner, in the Sōtō school there are two kinds of awakening. One is the practice of shikantaza, which is the "actual enlightened activity of the Buddha". The other is the accumulation of little bits of understanding, which come together, giving way to a deeper intuitive knowledge.

Sanbō Kyōdan

Kenshō also plays a central in the Sanbō Kyōdan, a Japanese Zen organisation which played a decisive role in the transmission of Zen to the United States. Yasutani, the founder of the Sanbo Kyodan, was disappointed about the lack of interest in kensho in the Soto school. Yasutani's emphasis on koan training and the importance of kensho was transmitted to his American students:

It is also reflected in the inclusion of a relative great amount of kensho stories in "The Three Pillars of Zen", written by Philip Kapleau, a student of Yasutani.

Training after kenshō

After kensho, further practice is needed to attain a natural, effortless, down-to-earth state of being, the "ultimate liberation", "knowing without any kind of defilement". Kensho may bring insight, but not change the mental dispositions, a shortcoming experienced by both Hakuin and modern teachers like Jack Kornfield and Barry Magid.Magid, B (2013). Nothing is Hidden: The Psychology of Zen Koans. Wisdom

Further practice

Zen Buddhist training does not end with kenshō. Practice is to be continued to deepen the insight and to express it in daily life. According to the contemporary Chan Master Sheng Yen:

And the Soto Zen Master Jiyu-Kennett:

To deepen the initial insight of kensho, shikantaza and kōan-study are necessary. This trajectory of initial insight followed by a gradual deepening and ripening is expressed by Linji Yixuan in his Three mysterious Gates, Dongshan Liangjie's (Japanese: Tōzan Ryōkan) Five Ranks, the Four Ways of Knowing of Hakuin,Biographical essay by GHarada Sogaku
/ref> and the Ten Ox-Herding Pictures which detail the steps on the Path.

Seitai choyo

Post-awakening practice is called ''seitai choyo'', the "long nurturing of the sacred fetus". According to Spiegelberg,

During the T'ang-era, the term became associated with the ideal of the recluse who leaves the world. An ideal period of "twenty years" was taken for it, echoing a story from the ''Lotus Sutra'' about a prodigal son who wandered in poverty for twenty years before returning home. References to these twenty years are found throughout the Chán-tradition, for example Linji, who is reported to have studied under Huang-po for twenty years, and Daito, the founder of Daitoku-ji, who famously spent twenty years living under a bridge with beggars.

Cultivating bodhicitta

According to Hakuin, the main aim of "post-satori practice" (''gogo no shugyo'' or ''kojo'', "going beyond") is to cultivate the "Mind of Enlightenment", "benefiting others by giving them the gift of the Dharma teaching". According to Yamada Koun, "if you cannot weep with a person who is crying, there is no kensho". According to Kay,

According to Barry, regarding Hakuin's practice after awakening,

Self-purification and intellectual understanding

One also has to purify oneself by ongoing practice, since

And "experience" has to be supplemented by intellectual understanding and study of the Buddhist teachings; otherwise one remains a ''zen temma'', a "Zen devil".

Sudden insight

Kenshō is described as appearing suddenly, upon an interaction with someone else, at hearing or reading some significant phrase, or at the perceiving of an unexpected sound or sight. The idea of "sudden insight" has been hotly debated in the history of Zen. It became part of the Traditional Zen Narrative in the 8th century.

Chinul, a 12th-century Korean Seon master, emphasized that insight into our true nature is sudden, but is to be followed by practice to ripen the insight and attain full Buddhahood. The contemporary Korean Seon master Seongcheol opposed this, emphasizing "sudden enlightenment, sudden cultivation". But Jiyu-Kennett, a contemporary western teacher, warns that attaining kenshō does not mean that a person is free from morality, the laws of karma, or the consequences of ones actions. This warning is reflected in the Wild fox koan.

Mushi-dokugo and mushi-dokkaku

Kenshō may be attained without the aid of a teacher, as in the case of mushi-dokugo or (mushi-)dokkaku, a self-awakened pratyeka-buddha.Kyosho. The Awakening Gong. No.350, September/October 2011. Pages 14–15

Though the literal meaning is ''self-awakened'' or ''awakened on one's own'', the emphasis in Zen, when using these terms, lies in the ultimate reliance on one's own insight, instead of the authority of a teacher:

Similarities with other traditions

While the Japanese term "kenshō" is generally used by practitioners of Zen Buddhism, the insight it refers to is not limited to Japanese Zen Buddhism, or even to Buddhism in general.

Theravada

The Theravada tradition, which is best known in the west through the modern Vipassana movement, discerns four stages of enlightenment, in which Nirvana is reached in four succeeding sudden steps of insight.

Dzogchen

An analogy given by Dzogchen masters is that one's nature is like a mirror which reflects with complete openness, but is not affected by the reflections. Rigpa is the knowledge that ensues from recognizing this mirror-like clarity, which cannot be found by searching nor identified. One ''knows'' that there is a primordial freedom from grasping his or her mind.

Advaita Vedanta

In Advaita Vedanta moksha is attained by jnana, insight-knowledge. In Shankara's philosophical synthesis insight samadhi is used as a subsidiary to this goal. Swami Vivekananda emphasized the ''experience'' of nirvikalpa samadhi as a means to validate religious, transcendental knowledge.

See also

* Enlightenment in Buddhism
* Satori
* Daigo
* Mushi dokugo
* Shoshin
* Epiphany
* Samadhi
* Gnosis

Notes

References

Sources

Printed sources

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*

*
*

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*

*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*

*
*

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

Web sources

Further reading

Soto
*
Critical

Stuart Lachs, ''Coming Down from the Zen Clouds: A Critique of the Current State of American Zen''
An attempt at demythologizing Zen-practice, emphasizing the integration into daily life

External links

Ama Samy, ''Koan, Hua-t’ou, and Kensho''

Rev.Master Jiyu-Kennett (2000), ''The Roar of the Tigress Volume I, An Introduction to Zen: Religious Practice for Everyday Life
biography of Jiyu-Kennett, with a description of het kensho-experiences, and teishos by Jiyu-Kennett

After Non Duality, a blog centering on the question "What happens ''after'' awakening?"

{{Buddhism topics

Zen Buddhist philosophical concepts
Nonduality