Malapropisms

A malapropism (also called a malaprop, acyrologia, or Dogberryism) is the mistaken use of an incorrect word in place of a word with a similar sound, resulting in a nonsensical, sometimes humorous utterance. An example is the statement attributed to baseball player Yogi Berra, regarding switchhitters, "He hits from both sides of the plate. He's amphibious." Malapropisms often occur as errors in natural speech and are sometimes the subject of media attention, especially when made by politicians or other prominent individuals. Philosopher Donald Davidson has said that malapropisms show the complex process through which the brain translates thoughts into language.

Humorous malapropisms are the type that attract the most attention and commentary, but bland malapropisms are common in speech and writing.

Etymology

The word "malapropism" (and its earlier form, "malaprop") comes from a character named "Mrs. Malaprop" in Richard Brinsley Sheridan's 1775 play ''The Rivals''. Mrs. Malaprop frequently misspeaks (to comic effect) by using words which do not have the meaning that she intends but which sound similar to words that do. Sheridan chose her name in humorous reference to the word ''malapropos,'' an adjective or adverb meaning "inappropriate" or "inappropriately", derived from the French phrase ''mal à propos'' (literally "poorly placed"). According to the ''Oxford English Dictionary'', the first recorded use of "malapropos" in English is from 1630, and the first person known to have used the word "malaprop" specifically in the sense of "a speech error" is Lord Byron in 1814.

The synonymous term "Dogberryism" comes from the 1598 Shakespeare play ''Much Ado About Nothing'' in which the character Dogberry utters many malapropisms to humorous effect. Though Shakespeare was an earlier writer than Sheridan, "malaprop/malapropism" seems an earlier coinage than "Dogberryism", which is not attested until 1836.

Distinguishing features

An instance of speech error is called a malapropism when a word is produced which is nonsensical or ludicrous in context yet similar in sound to what was intended.

Definitions differ somewhat in terms of the cause of the error. Some scholars include only errors that result from a temporary failure to produce the word which the speaker intended. Such errors are sometimes called "Fay–Cutler malapropism", after David Fay and Anne Cutler, who described the occurrence of such errors in ordinary speech. Most definitions, however, include any actual word that is wrongly or accidentally used in place of a similar sounding, correct word. This broader definition is sometimes called "classical malapropism", or simply "malapropism".

Malapropisms differ from other kinds of speaking or writing mistakes, such as eggcorns or spoonerisms, as well as the accidental or deliberate production of newly made-up words (neologisms).

For example, it is not a malapropism to use ''obtuse'' ide or dullinstead of ''acute'' arrow or sharp it is a malapropism to use ''obtuse'' tupid or slow-wittedwhen one means ''abstruse'' soteric or difficult to understand

Malapropisms tend to maintain the part of speech of the originally intended word. According to linguist Jean Aitchison, "The finding that word selection errors preserve their part of speech suggest that the latter is an integral part of the word, and tightly attached to it." Likewise, substitutions tend to have the same number of syllables and the same metrical structure – the same pattern of stressed and unstressed syllables – as the intended word or phrase. If the stress pattern of the malapropism differs from the intended word, unstressed syllables may be deleted or inserted; stressed syllables and the general rhythmic pattern are maintained.

Examples from fiction

The fictional Mrs. Malaprop in Sheridan's play ''The Rivals'' utters many malapropisms. In Act 3 Scene III, she declares to Captain Absolute, "Sure, if I ''reprehend'' any thing in this world it is the use of my ''oracular'' tongue, and a nice ''derangement'' of ''epitaphs''!" This nonsensical utterance might, for example, be corrected to, "If I ''apprehend'' anything in this world, it is the use of my ''vernacular'' tongue, and a nice ''arrangement'' of ''epithets''", —although these are not the only words that can be substituted to produce an appropriately expressed thought in this context, and commentators have proposed other possible replacements that work just as well.

Other malapropisms spoken by Mrs. Malaprop include "''illiterate'' him quite from your memory" (instead of "obliterate"), "he is the very ''pineapple'' of politeness" (instead of ''pinnacle'') and "she's as headstrong as an ''allegory'' on the banks of the Nile" (instead of ''alligator'').

Malapropisms appeared in many works before Sheridan created the character of Mrs. Malaprop. William Shakespeare used them in a number of his plays, almost invariably spoken by comic ill-educated lower class characters. Mistress Quickly, the inn-keeper associate of Falstaff in several Shakespeare plays, is a regular user of malapropisms. In ''Much Ado About Nothing'', Constable Dogberry tells Governor Leonato, "Our watch, sir, have indeed ''comprehended'' two ''auspicious'' persons" (i.e., ''apprehended'' two ''suspicious'' persons) (Act 3, Scene V).

Malapropism was one of Stan Laurel's comic mannerisms. In '' Sons of the Desert'', for example, he says that Oliver Hardy is suffering a nervous "shakedown" (rather than "breakdown"), calls the Exalted Ruler of their group the "exhausted ruler" and says that he and Oliver are like "two peas in a pot" (instead of "pod"); in ''The Music Box'', he inadvertently asked a policeman, "Don't you think you're bounding over your steps?" meaning "overstepping your bounds", which has much in common with the transposition of a Spoonerism.

Emily Litella, a fictional character created and performed by American comedian Gilda Radner used malapropism to entertain viewers on the late-night comedy show Saturday Night Live, including one skit in which she was puzzled over the hubbub surrounding the "plight of Soviet jewelry" instead of "Soviet Jewry".

British comedian Ronnie Barker also made great use of deliberate malapropisms in his comedy, notably in such sketches as his "Appeal on behalf of the Loyal Society for the Relief of Suffers from Pismronunciation", which mixed malapropisms and garbled words for comic effect – including news of a speech which "gave us a few ''well-frozen worms'' (i.e., well-chosen words) in praise of the society."

Ring Lardner used malapropism extensively for comic effect. For example, in his short story ''The Young Immigrunts'', the four-year-old narrator repeatedly refers to a bride and groom as the "bride and glum."

Archie Bunker, a character in the American TV sitcom ''All in the Family'', used malapropisms frequently: he refers, for example, to "off-the-docks Jews" ( Orthodox Jews) and the "Women's ''Lubrication'' Movement" (rather than ''Liberation''). Intending to refer to the medical specialized field of gynecology and to specialist in that field as a gynecologist, he would mispronounce the words as "groinecology" and "groinecologist."

Tyler Perry's fictional character Madea is known for her Southern dialectical usage of malapropisms, which some critics link to the Mammy archetype.

Real-life examples

Malapropisms do not occur only as comedic literary devices. They also occur as a kind of speech error in ordinary speech. Examples are often quoted in the media.

Former Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott once claimed that no one "is the ''suppository'' of all wisdom" (i.e., ''repository'' or ''depository'').

Similarly, as reported in ''New Scientist'', an office worker had described a colleague as "a vast ''suppository'' of information". The worker then apologised for his "'' Miss-Marple-ism''" (i.e., ''malapropism''). ''New Scientist'' noted this as possibly the first time anyone had uttered a malapropism for the word ''malapropism'' itself.

Bertie Ahern, former Taoiseach of Ireland, warned his country against "upsetting the ''apple tart''" (''apple cart'') of his country's economic success.

Former Chicago Mayor Richard J. Daley referred to a tandem bicycle as a "tantrum bicycle" and made mention of "Alcoholics ''Unanimous''" (Alcoholics Anonymous).

Hall of Fame baseball player Yogi Berra was well known for corrupting speech, such as "Texas has a lot of electrical votes", rather than " electoral votes". Berra was so adept at twisting both words and logic the term " ''Yogism''" was coined to describe his quirky utterances and observations, first recorded on his being honored in his hometown of St. Louis during his rookie season with, "I want to thank everybody for making this day necessary."

Former Texas Governor Rick Perry has been known to commonly utter malapropisms; for example, he described states as " lavatories of innovation and democracy" instead of "laboratories".

During a Senate hearing, Philippine presidential communications assistant secretary Mocha Uson stumbled on the legal phrase "right against self-incrimination" by invoking her "right against self-discrimination" instead.

Former world Heavyweight champion boxer Mike Tyson, upon being asked about his next plans moments after losing in a world title fight with Lennox Lewis, declared that "I might fade into Bolivian" (oblivion).

During the COVID-19 pandemic, a common meme format was introduced where Internet users feigned malapropism by substituting the word “pandemic” with similar sounding words (such as “panorama”, “pandemonium”, or “panini”), a practice often attributed to Black Twitter.

United States congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene uses malapropisms in both communications directed at her base as well as when she communicates with the rest of the world, including references to: "peach tree dish" (petri dish), "gazpacho police," (gestapo), and "fragrantly violated..." (flagrantly), among others.

American Republican Senate hopeful Herschel Walker speaking about the upcoming election, has been mocked online after claiming "this erection is about the people," during an interview on Fox News.

Philosophical implications

In his essay "A Nice Derangement of Epitaphs", philosopher Donald Davidson suggests that malapropisms reveal something about how people process the meanings of words. He argues that language competence must not simply involve learning a set meaning for each word, and then rigidly applying those semantic rules to decode other people's utterances. Rather, he says, people must also be continually making use of other contextual information to interpret the meaning of utterances, and then modifying their understanding of each word's meaning based on those interpretations.

See also

* Anti-proverb
* Bushism
* Catachresis
* Chernomyrdinka
* Colemanballs
* Dundrearyism
* Error (linguistics)
* Freudian slip
* Goldwynisms
* Homonym
* Johnny Dangerously
* Mondegreen
* Mumpsimus
* Norm Crosby
* Trailer Park Boys
* Yogiism

References

Further reading

* Weingarten, Gene. (2014-02-16
"An add homonym attack"
Retrieved 2014-02-25.

External links

*

{{Authority control

Speech error
Puns
Lexicology