Kainé

is a fictional character from the 2010 video game ''Nier'', a spin-off of the ''Drakengard'' series developed by Cavia and published by Square Enix. A leading character of ''Nier'' and prominent in its related media, she accompanies the game's protagonist in his quest to help a young girl called Yonah, first to cure her disease and then to rescue her from a being called the Shadowlord in a post-apocalyptic world beset by creatures called Shades. Kainé's storyline focuses around her quest for revenge against a monstrous Shade called Hook, and her history of discrimination due to being possessed by a Shade and being born intersex.

Kainé was created Yoko Taro, director and writer of ''Nier'', as an unconventional female-identifying lead, with writer Sawako Natori, and novelist Jun Eishima contributing to her backstory. She was designed by Korean illustrator D.K, and originally had a less provocative design. For the 2021 remaster, her design was updated by Akihiko Yoshida. Across all spoken appearances, she is voiced by Laura Bailey in English and Atsuko Tanaka in Japanese. The character was noted and generally praised by critics for her portrayal, though her outfit and swearing drew some mixed reactions. She is also a popular character with fans of ''Nier'', appearing in crossovers and merchandise.

Appearances

''Nier''

Kainé is a Replicant, one of the soulless artificial humans that populate the Earth following an apocalyptic magical pandemic; human souls exist as shadow-like beings called Gestalts intended to rejoin with their Replicant counterparts. After the Replicants gained sentience and see the Gestalts as monsters dubbing them "Shades", the two sides ended up in conflict. Kainé was intended to be born female, but a fault in the Replicant production system caused her to be born intersex. Suffering discrimination from her home village the Aerie, she was cared for by her grandmother Kali, who treated her as a woman, encouraged her to use feminine clothing, and influenced her tendency to swear. When the two were attacked by the monstrous Shade Hook and Kali is killed, Kainé survived by being possessed by the disembodied Shade Tyrann. This caused further discrimination, and Kainé chose to live only for revenge against Hook.

Kainé ultimately faces Hook with the game's protagonist, who kills Hook and encourages her to live and help him search for a cure to the Black Scrawl appearing among the Replicants and infecting the young girl Yonah. She becomes a loyal ally and "sword" to the protagonist, shares a bickering relationship with the talking book Grimoire Weiss, and forms a sibling relationship with the young Emil who suffers a self-imposed isolation due to his powers and later discrimination when his body is transformed into a skeleton-like form. She briefly sacrifices herself by allowing Emil to petrify her to seal away a powerful Shade when the Gestalt leader Shadowlord kidnaps Yonah, being released five years later and helping the protagonist and Emil hunt down the Shadowlord. During one fight with Shades, the Aerie and its people are destroyed.

In subsequent playthroughs picking up after she is freed from the seal, players are able to understand the Gestalts' speech through Tyrann, revealing them to have been defending their friends and loved ones from the protagonist and other Replicants who saw them only as monsters. Additional story elements also reveal Kainé's past. In the first two endings, Kainé helps the protagonist kill the Shadowlord and rescue Yonah before leaving them; the Shadowlord's death will eventually lead to the extinction of both Replicants and Gestalts. The game's final two endings are based around a choice after Kainé is overwhelmed by Tyrann and goes berserk following the Shadowlord's death; the protagonist can either kill her to end her suffering, or sacrifice his and Tyrann's existence to restore her normal form, leaving her and Yonah with no memories of him.

Related media and crossovers

Further details around Kainé's backstory are included in ''Grimoire Nier'', a guidebook featuring plot and character summaries, short stories, concept art and developer commentary. She is the lead character in the ''Grimoire Nier'' short story ''The Lost World'', and a playable character in the new ending section of the 2021 expanded remaster ''Nier Replicant ver.1.22474487139...'' based on this story. As the world grows worse following the Shadowlord's death, Kainé has recurring dreams of the protagonist, and through a confrontation with the plant-like Sleeping Beauty computer system ends up restoring the protagonist's human form. Kainé is featured in the 2011 CD Drama ''NieR Replicant Drama CD The Lost Words and the Red Sky'', which included both the in-game version and a non-canon version in a high school setting. She is also featured as a character in a special event in the mobile game ''Nier Reincarnation'' (2021).

Kainé was featured as a downloadable content costume for ''Drakengard 3'' (2013) and '' Nier: Automata'' (2017), and featured in a crossover with '' PUBG: Battlegrounds'' (2017) Kainé was considered as a featured character in a collaboration with the mobile game ''SINoALICE'' alongside the ''Nier'' protagonist and Emil, but she was not included due to budgetary limits relating to her voice actress. Promotional merchandise themed after Kainé has been produced, including a plushy toy, a Nendoroid figureine, and a Play Arts Kai figurine which includes different accessories and pieces for poses.

Creation and design

Kainé was created by Yoko Taro, director and story writer of ''Nier'' (2010), in response to a female staff member's request for a "male heroine". Originally assuming her intersexality would be a hidden aspect of her backstory, Yoko was surprised that it formed part of the game's marketing. Yoko did not emphasise her intersexuality or the parallel narrative of Emil being gay, stating that people like them existed in real-life and it felt natural to represent them. He also described Kainé's intersexuality as fitting with her tragic backstory. Important to her in-game portrayal was the main cast's acceptance of her presented gender, with Grimoire Weiss never using insults based on her intersexuality. Her backstory was expanded through later short stories, something scenario co-writer Sawako Natori was keen on.

Kainé's relationship with the protagonist was not portrayed as explicitly romantic in-game as Yoko both felt unequipped to write a romance and saw the group dynamic as familial, though in the guidebook interview Yoko confirmed Kainé developed romantic feelings for the protagonist. The choice whether to kill or save Kainé during the game's final endings was based around how much players would have come to like her. ''Nier'' short story writer Jun Eishiman felt that each ending was better suited to different versions of the protagonist; the father would choose to kill Kainé, while the brother would sacrifice himself. The ending scenario included in ''Grimoire Nier'' was initially an alternate proposal if the fourth ending, which involved players' save data being deleted, was not approved. It was included in playable form in the remaster as a combination of fan service and a new addition possible due to a larger budget.

Kainé's character design was by Korean illustrator D.K. Her early design was less provocative, having a long dress and feminine manner which hid her violent personality. Yoko's request was for a character with one arm and one leg exposed. D.K's designs shocked Yoko and other members of staff as they mostly revolved around underwear. Yoko attempted to adjust the design himself by adding a "front flap" to hide her most exposed areas. While fearing it would be vetoed, Yoko successfully pushed through her final design. For the remaster, it was intended to bring D.K back for Kainé's redesign, but he had moved back to Korea and was unable to work with them, though he supported both the remaster and the new artist. Kainé was instead redesigned by Akihiko Yoshida, lead character designer on ''Nier: Automata''. Yoshida was invited onto the project, alongside fellow artists Kimihiko Fujisaka and Toshiyuki Itahana, as an earlier collaborator with Yoko.

Portrayal

Across all her appearances, Kainé is voiced by Laura Bailey in English and Atsuko Tanaka in Japanese. The English voice recording was done first, with Yoko supervising. Yoko was not impressed by the cute-sounding voices being considered for her, pushing for Tanaka in the role due to her "sharp and bold voice". Tanaka returned for the drama CD, describing her role involving a lot of screaming, but noting that the high school scenario allowed her to show a different side to the character.

For the 2021 remaster, Yoko wanted the English voices to sound different compared to the original, and the team were worried about whether Bailey would want to reprise the role as she had become a prominent voice actress. Bailey was happy to reprise the role, as it remained popular among her fans. Bailey described Kainé as having "so many different aspects" to her that each scene could show something new. She also enjoyed playing off Liam O'Brien, who voiced Grimoire Weiss. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, voice recording was done remotely.

A prominent feature of the character was her swearing, which was used in early trailers. In the Japanese version, Kainé's swearing was censored out using bleeps. This was done as a joke, and a reference to both Japan's stricter rules around swearing and his trouble with censorship with the original ''Drakengard''. In the English version, the beeping was left out due to negative feedback from Western playtesters, and localization company 8-4 "went nuts" with the first draft's swearing. Square Enix ultimately asked them to tone down the swearing in the final script. Yoko oversaw the English dubbing, with Kainé's swearing needing to be matched with where the beeps were in the Japanese version.

Reception

The character of Kainé is popular among fans of ''Nier''. In a popularity poll run to commemorate the release of ''Nier: Automata'', Kainé earned nearly 30% of votes, ranking as the most popular leading character in the game. In a 2022 article on women in RPGs, ''RPGFan''s Zach Wilkerson called her the "beating heart" of ''Nier'' and Yoko's best character. Bailey has called Kainé is one of her best-liked performances, with fans regularly asking her to autograph copies of ''Nier'' as the character.

Kainé saw positive responses from journalists in reviews of the original ''Nier''. Dustin Quillen of ''1Up.com'' highlighted Kainé as a unique video game character, feeling that her portrayal and nature may have contributed to the game's M rating in North America. ''GameSpot''s Kevin VanOrd found Kainé " otwholly unlikable" but felt her swearing was out of place, while ''IGN''s Ryan Clements called her a fantastic character and one of the game's redeeming features. ''Eurogamer'' writer Chris Schilling described the character as a "profanity-spitting Lady Gaga-alike".

Reviews of the remaster also mentioned her positively. Michael Higham of ''GameSpot'' said Kainé would win players' hearts with her attitude and character growth. Mitchell Saltzman, writing for ''IGN'', described the character as "an absolute badass ndhilarious in her vulgarity". ''Electronic Gaming Monthly''s Mollie E. Patterson attributed both Kainé and Emil with holding the narrative together through their interactions with the protagonist. Alan Wen of ''Video Games Chronicle'' positively noted Kainé among the cast, positively contrasting her clothing against the revealing outfit of ''Metal Gear'' character Quiet. Pascal Tekaia of ''RPGamer'' praised both Bailey's performance as Kainé and her banter with O'Brian as Grimoire Weiss. Jose Torres, writing for ''RPG Site'', took some time to grow accustomed to Kainé's redesign but eventually compared it positively to her concept art. ''PCGamesN''s Ian Boudreau described Kainé as "a powerful but troubled swordswoman who curses a lot and spends the entire game in a distractingly incongruous nightgown." Malindy Hetfeld of ''Eurogamer'' noted that there was little to define Kainé beyond her outfit and swearing until the late game.

Kainé's intersexuality has seen commentary. In a 2016 article on LGBT representation in gaming for the ''International Journal of Communication'', Adrienne Shaw and Elizaveta Friesem noted Kainé as potentially the only prominent intersex character in video games despite her female-identifying behaviour and clothing. Alana Hagues of ''RPGFan'', in an article on queer representation in the ''Nier'' games in relation to her own coming out, highlighted Kainé for her support of other marginalised characters in the narrative. Her major criticism was a trophy in the remaster for looking up Kainé's skirt, which she described as undermining the positive representation. Austin Jones of '' Paste'', speaking of his own experience with coming out, highlighted how Kainé and Emil support each other and committed themselves to selfless actions despite being isolated from the world they defended.

References

Notes

{{Drakengard

Fictional intersex characters
Fictional swordfighters in video games
Role-playing video game characters
Drakengard
Square Enix protagonists
Video game characters introduced in 2010