Daspletosaurus torosus

''Daspletosaurus'' ( ; meaning "frightful lizard") is a genus of tyrannosaurid dinosaur that lived in Laramidia between about 79.5 and 74 million years ago, during the Late Cretaceous Period. The genus ''Daspletosaurus'' contains three species. Fossils of the earlier type species, ''D. torosus'', have been found in Alberta, and fossils of a later second species, ''D. wilsoni,'' and third species, ''D. horneri'', have been found only in Montana. A possible fourth species, also from Alberta, awaits formal identification. The taxon ''Thanatotheristes'' has been suggested to represent a species of ''Daspletosaurus'', ''D. degrootorum'', but this has not been widely supported. ''Daspletosaurus'' is closely related to the much larger and more recent tyrannosaurid ''Tyrannosaurus rex''. Like most tyrannosaurids, ''Daspletosaurus'' was a multi-tonne bipedal predator equipped with dozens of large, sharp teeth. ''Daspletosaurus'' had the small forelimbs typical of tyrannosaurids, although they were proportionately longer than in other genera.

As an apex predator, ''Daspletosaurus'' was at the top of the food chain, probably preying on large dinosaurs like the ceratopsid ''Centrosaurus'' and the hadrosaur ''Hypacrosaurus''. In some areas, ''Daspletosaurus'' coexisted with another tyrannosaurid, ''Gorgosaurus'', though there is some evidence of niche differentiation between the two. While ''Daspletosaurus'' fossils are not as common as other tyrannosaurid fossils, the available specimens allow some analysis of the biology of these animals, including social behavior, diet, and life history.

Discovery and naming

The type specimen of ''Daspletosaurus torosus'' ( CMN 8506) is a partial skeleton including the skull, the shoulder, a forelimb, the pelvis, a femur, and all of the vertebrae from the neck, torso, and hip, as well as the first eleven tail vertebrae. It was discovered in 1921 near Steveville, Alberta, by Charles Mortram Sternberg, who thought it was a new species of ''Gorgosaurus''. It was not until 1970 that the specimen was fully described by Dale Russell, who made it the type of a new genus, ''Daspletosaurus'', from the Greek δασπλής (', stem and connective vowel resulting in '-) ("frightful") and () ("lizard"). The type species is ''Daspletosaurus torosus'', the specific name ''torosus'' being Latin for 'muscular' or 'brawny'. Aside from the type, there is only one other well-known specimen, RTMP 2001.36.1, a relatively complete skeleton discovered in 2001. Both specimens were recovered from the Oldman Formation in the Judith River Group of Alberta. The Oldman Formation was deposited during the middle Campanian stage of the Late Cretaceous, from about 79.5 to 77 Ma (million years ago).

Dale Russell also suggested that a specimen of an immature ''Albertosaurus'' (CMN 11315) from the younger Horseshoe Canyon Formation in Alberta actually belonged to a third specimen of ''Daspletosaurus'' as ''D.'' cf. ''torosus'', extending the temporal range of the genus by approximately 3.5 million years into the Maastrichtian. He based this referral on features of its limb and pelvic girdle, as well as the curvature of the hand claws, which he interpreted as traits matching ''Daspletosaurus''. This reassignment was not universally accepted, and thorough re-examination of the specimen favoured its initial referral to ''Albertosaurus sarcophagus'', despite lacking many of the diagnostic skeletal traits used to identify mature tyrannosaurids. An additional maxilla and various teeth from an ''Edmontosaurus''-dominated bonebed in the Horseshoe Canyon Formation was also mistakenly referred to ''Daspletosaurus'', but all the tyrannosaurid material has all since been confirmed to belong to ''Albertosaurus''.

Assigned species

Over the years, various additional species have been assigned to the genus ''Daspletosaurus'' Though some have been designated as ''Daspletosaurus'' spp, this does not imply that they all represent the same species.

Along with the holotype, Russell designated a specimen collected by Barnum Brown in 1913 as the paratype of ''D. torosus''. This specimen (AMNH 5438) consists of parts of the hindleg, the pelvis, and some of its associated vertebrae. It was discovered in the Dinosaur Park Formation in Alberta. The Dinosaur Park Formation was formerly known as the Upper Oldman Formation and dates back to the middle Campanian, between 76.5 and 74.8 million years ago.Eberth, D.A. (2005). "The geology." In: Currie, P.J., and Koppelhus, E.B. (eds), ''Dinosaur Provincial Park: A Spectacular Ancient Ecosystem Revealed''. Indiana University Press: Bloomington and Indianapolis, 54–82. ''Daspletosaurus'' fossils are known specifically from the middle to upper section of the formation, between 75.6 and 75.0 million years ago. In 1914, Brown collected a nearly complete skeleton and skull; forty years later his American Museum of Natural History sold this specimen to the Field Museum of Natural History in Chicago. It was mounted for display in Chicago and labeled as ''Albertosaurus libratus'' for many years, but after several skull features were later found to be modeled in plaster, including most of the teeth, the specimen ( FMNH PR308) was reassigned to ''Daspletosaurus torosus'' by Thomas Carr in 1999. A total of eight specimens have been collected from the Dinosaur Park Formation over the years since, most of them within the boundaries of Dinosaur Provincial Park. Phil Currie believes that the Dinosaur Park specimens represent a new species of ''Daspletosaurus'', distinguished by certain features of the skull. Pictures of this new species have been published, but it still awaits a name and full description in print.

A new tyrannosaurid specimen ( OMNH 10131), including skull fragments, ribs, and parts of the hindlimb, was reported from New Mexico in 1990 and assigned to the now-defunct genus ''Aublysodon''. Many later authors have reassigned this specimen, along with a few others from New Mexico, to yet another unnamed species of ''Daspletosaurus''. However, research published in 2010 showed that this species, from the Hunter Wash Member of the Kirtland Formation, is actually a more primitive tyrannosauroid, and was classified in the genus ''Bistahieversor''.

In 1992, Jack Horner and colleagues published an extremely preliminary report of a tyrannosaurid from the upper parts of the Campanian Two Medicine Formation in Montana, which was interpreted as a transitional species between ''Daspletosaurus'' and the later ''Tyrannosaurus''. Currie (2003) stated that the tyrannosaurid from the Two Medicine Formation mentioned by Horner ''et al.'' (1992) may be an unnamed third species of ''Daspletosaurus''. Another partial skeleton was reported from the Upper Two Medicine in 2001, preserving the remains of a juvenile hadrosaur in its abdominal cavity. This specimen was assigned to ''Daspletosaurus'' but not to any particular species. DOI
10.1666/0022-3360(2001)075<0401:GCFACT>2.0.CO;2
/ref> The remains of at least three more ''Daspletosaurus'' have also been described in a Two Medicine bonebed by Currie ''et al.'' (2005); the authors stated that this fossil material likely represents then-unnamed species mentioned by Horner ''et al.'' (1992), but cautioned that further study and description of ''Daspletosaurus'' would be necessary before the species can be determined with certainty. In 2017, the Two Medicine Formation taxon was named as the new species ''D. horneri''.

Isolated tyrannosaurid teeth in the upper portions of the Judith River Formation are likely from ''Gorgosaurus'' as well as some species of ''Daspletosaurus'', probably ''D. torosus''. However, in the lower portion Judith River Formation, around 78 million years ago, there is some evidence for a new undescribed tyrannosaurid taxon. A specimen in the collections of Triebold Paleontology excavated between 2002 and 2004, known as "Sir William", shows some characteristics of ''Daspletosaurus'' suggesting a new earlier species to the genus. However the specimen shows many characteristics typical of early tyrannosaurines such as ''Teratophoneus'' and even some of the later ''Tyrannosaurus'', which may suggest an entirely new genus.

In 2017, John Wilson discovered the bones of a tyrannosaurid, including a partial disarticulated skull, cervical, sacral, and caudal vertebrae, and a rib, chevron, and first metatarsal, from the "Jack’s B2" site of the Judith River Formation. Elías A. Warshaw and Denver W. Fowler described these remains ( BDM 107) in 2022 as belonging to a new species of ''Daspletosaurus'', ''D. wilsoni''. It represents a transitional species between ''D. torosus'' and ''D. horneri'', as it existed between them in time. These three species likely evolved directly through anagenesis.

Description

While very large by the standard of modern predators, ''Daspletosaurus'' was not the largest tyrannosaurid. Adults could reach a length of 8–9 meters (26–30 ft) from snout to tail, and a body mass of .

Skull

''Daspletosaurus'' had a massive skull that could reach more than in length. The bones were heavily constructed and some, including the nasal bones on top of the snout, were fused for strength. Large fenestrae (openings) in the skull reduced its weight. An adult ''Daspletosaurus'' was armed with about six dozen teeth that were very long but oval in cross section rather than blade-like. Unlike its other teeth, those in the premaxilla at the end of the upper jaw had a D-shaped cross section, an example of heterodonty always seen in tyrannosaurids. Unique skull features included the rough outer surface of the maxilla (upper jaw bone) and the pronounced crests around the eyes on the lacrimal, postorbital, and jugal bones. The orbit (eye socket) was a tall oval, somewhere in between the circular shape seen in ''Gorgosaurus'' and the 'keyhole' shape of ''Tyrannosaurus''. Split carinae (edges) have been found on ''Daspletosaurus'' teeth.

Postcranial skeleton

''Daspletosaurus'' shared the same body form as other tyrannosaurids, with a short, S-shaped neck supporting the massive skull. It walked on its two thick hindlimbs, which ended in four-toed feet, although the first digit (the hallux) did not contact the ground. In contrast, the forelimbs were extremely small and bore only two digits, although ''Daspletosaurus'' had the longest forelimbs in proportion to body size of any tyrannosaurid. A long, heavy tail served as a counterweight to the head and torso, with the center of gravity over the hips.

Classification and systematics

''Daspletosaurus'' belongs in the subfamily Tyrannosaurinae within the family Tyrannosauridae, along with ''Tarbosaurus'', ''Tyrannosaurus'', and Alioramini. Animals in this subfamily are more closely related to ''Tyrannosaurus'' than to ''Albertosaurus'' and are known – with the exception of ''Alioramus'' – for their robust build with proportionally larger skulls and longer femora than in the other subfamily, the Albertosaurinae. It further belongs to the tribe Daspletosaurini, consisting of it and the taxon ''Thanatotheristes''.

''Daspletosaurus'' is usually considered to be closely related to ''Tyrannosaurus rex'', or even a direct ancestor through anagenesis. Gregory Paul reassigned ''D. torosus'' to the genus ''Tyrannosaurus'', creating the new combination ''Tyrannosaurus torosus'', but this has not been generally accepted. Many researchers believe ''Tarbosaurus'' and ''Tyrannosaurus'' to be sister taxa or even to be the same genus, with ''Daspletosaurus'' a more basal relative. On the other hand, Phil Currie and colleagues find ''Daspletosaurus'' to be more closely related to ''Tarbosaurus'' and other Asian tyrannosaurids like ''Alioramus'' than to the North American ''Tyrannosaurus''. The systematics (evolutionary relationships) of ''Daspletosaurus'' have become clearer as new species have been described.

Below is a cladogram of Tyrannosaurinae based on the phylogenetic analysis conducted by Warshaw & Fowler (2022). Here, it is proposed that the three ''Daspletosaurus'' species evolved through anagenesis in the Tyrannosaurinae in a line leading to ''Zhuchengtyrannus'', ''Tarbosaurus'', and ''Tyrannosaurus''. Due to their more fragmentary nature, ''Thanatotheristes'' and ''Nanuqsaurus'' were excluded from this analysis.

Paleobiology

Senses

There are indications of ''D. horneri'' possessing integumentary sensory organs, possibly used in touch, modulation of precise jaw movements, temperature reading, and prey detection. The large flat scales may have further protected the snout during prey capture and intra-specific combat.

Social behavior

A young specimen of the Dinosaur Park ''Daspletosaurus'' species (TMP 94.143.1) shows bite marks on the face that were inflicted by another tyrannosaur. The bite marks are healed over, indicating that the animal survived the bite. A full-grown Dinosaur Park ''Daspletosaurus'' (TMP 85.62.1) also exhibits tyrannosaur bite marks, showing that attacks to the face were not limited to younger animals. While it is possible that the bites were attributable to other species, intraspecific aggression, including facial biting, is very common among predators. Facial bites are seen in other tyrannosaurs like ''Gorgosaurus'' and ''Tyrannosaurus'', as well as in other theropod genera like ''Sinraptor'' and ''Saurornitholestes''. Darren Tanke and Phil Currie hypothesize that the bites are due to intraspecific competition for territory or resources, or for dominance within a social group. ot printed until 2000/ref>

Evidence that ''Daspletosaurus'' lived in social groups comes from a bonebed found in the Two Medicine Formation of Montana. The bonebed includes the remains of three ''Daspletosaurus'', including a large adult, a small juvenile, and another individual of intermediate size. At least five hadrosaurs are preserved at the same location. Geologic evidence indicates that the remains were not brought together by river currents but that all of the animals were buried simultaneously at the same location. The hadrosaur remains are scattered and bear numerous marks from tyrannosaur teeth, indicating that the ''Daspletosaurus'' were feeding on the hadrosaurs at the time of death. The cause of death is unknown. Currie speculates that the daspletosaurs formed a pack, although this cannot be stated with certainty. Other scientists are skeptical of the evidence for social groups in ''Daspletosaurus'' and other large theropods;

Brian Roach and Daniel Brinkman have suggested that ''Daspletosaurus'' social interaction would have more closely resembled the modern Komodo dragon, where non-cooperative individuals mob carcasses, frequently attacking and even cannibalizing each other in the process.

Fossils of other tyrannosaurids like ''Teratophoneus'' and ''Albertosaurus'' among other genera suggest that gregarious behavior may have been widespread in tyrannosaurs and thus may vindicate the hypothesis of ''Daspletosaurus'' being a social animal, as bonebeds of these genera containing multiple specimens in a wide range of ages have been excavated and described from these different genera.

Evidence of cannibalism in ''Daspletosaurus'' was published in 2015.

Life history

Paleontologist Gregory Erickson and colleagues have studied the growth and life history of tyrannosaurids. Analysis of bone histology can determine the age of a specimen when it died. Growth rates can be examined when the ages of various individuals are plotted against their size on a graph. Erickson has shown that after a long time as juveniles, tyrannosaurs underwent tremendous growth spurts for about four years midway through their lives. After the rapid growth phase ended with sexual maturity, growth slowed down considerably in adult animals. Erickson only examined ''Daspletosaurus'' from the Dinosaur Park Formation, but these specimens show the same pattern. Compared to albertosaurines, ''Daspletosaurus'' showed a faster growth rate during the rapid growth period due to its higher adult weight. The maximum growth rate in ''Daspletosaurus'' was 180 kilograms (400  lb) per year, based on a mass estimate of in adults. Other authors have suggested higher adult weights for ''Daspletosaurus''; this would change the magnitude of the growth rate but not the overall pattern.

By tabulating the number of specimens of each age group, Erickson and his colleagues were able to draw conclusions about life history in a population of ''Albertosaurus''. Their analysis showed that, while juveniles were rare in the fossil record, subadults in the rapid growth phase and adults were far more common. While this could be due to preservation or collection biases, Erickson hypothesized that the difference was due to low mortality among juveniles over a certain size, which is also seen in some modern large mammals like elephants. This low mortality may have resulted from a lack of predation, since tyrannosaurs surpassed all contemporaneous predators in size by the age of two. Paleontologists have not found enough ''Daspletosaurus'' remains for a similar analysis, but Erickson notes that the same general trend seems to apply.

A 2009 study found evidence of ''Trichomonas gallinae''-like infection in the jaws of various specimens of ''Daspletosaurus''.

Paleoecology

All known ''Daspletosaurus'' fossils have been found in formations dating to the middle to late Campanian stage of the Late Cretaceous Period, between 77 and 74 million years ago. Since the middle of the Cretaceous, North America had been divided in half by the Western Interior Seaway, with much of Montana and Alberta below the surface. However, the uplift of the Rocky Mountains in the Laramide Orogeny to the west, which began during the time of ''Daspletosaurus'', forced the seaway to retreat eastwards and southwards. Rivers flowed down from the mountains and drained into the seaway, carrying sediment along with them that formed the Two Medicine Formation, the Judith River Group, and other sedimentary formations in the region. About 73 million years ago, the seaway began to advance westwards and northwards again, and the entire region was covered by the Bearpaw Sea, represented throughout the western United States and Canada by the massive Bearpaw Shale.

''Daspletosaurus'' lived in a vast floodplain along the western shore of the interior seaway. Large rivers watered the land, occasionally flooding and blanketing the region with new sediment. When water was plentiful, the region could support a great deal of plant and animal life, but periodic droughts also struck the region, resulting in mass mortality as preserved in the many bonebed deposits found in Two Medicine and Judith River sediments, including the ''Daspletosaurus'' bonebed. Similar conditions exist today in East Africa. Volcanic eruptions from the west periodically blanketed the region with ash, also resulting in large-scale mortality, while simultaneously enriching the soil for future plant growth. It is these ash beds that allow precise radiometric dating as well. Fluctuating sea levels also resulted in a variety of other environments at different times and places within the Judith River Group, including offshore and nearshore marine habitats, coastal wetlands, deltas, and lagoons, in addition to the inland floodplains. The Two Medicine Formation was deposited at higher elevations farther inland than the other two formations.

The excellent vertebrate fossil record of Two Medicine and Judith River rocks resulted from a combination of abundant animal life, periodic natural disasters, and the deposition of large amounts of sediment. Many types of freshwater and estuarine fish are represented, including sharks, rays, sturgeons, gars, and others. The Judith River Group preserves the remains of many aquatic amphibians and reptiles, including frogs, salamanders, turtles, ''Champsosaurus'' and crocodilians. Terrestrial lizards, including whiptails, skinks, monitors, and alligator lizards have also been discovered. Azhdarchid pterosaurs, and birds like ''Apatornis'' and ''Avisaurus'' flew overhead, while several varieties of mammals coexisted with ''Daspletosaurus'' and other types of dinosaurs in the various formations that make up the Judith River wedge.

In the Oldman Formation (the geological equivalent of the Judith River formation), ''Daspletosaurus torosus'' could have preyed upon the hadrosaur species ''Brachylophosaurus canadensis'', the ceratopsians ''Coronosaurus brinkmani'' and '' Albertaceratops nesmoi'', pachycephalosaurs, ornithomimids, therizinosaurs, and possibly ankylosaurs. Other predators included troodontids, oviraptorosaurs, the dromaeosaurid ''Saurornitholestes'', and possibly an albertosaurine tyrannosaur (genus currently unknown). The younger Dinosaur Park and Two Medicine Formations had faunas similar to the Oldman, with the Dinosaur Park in particular preserving an unrivaled array of dinosaurs. The albertosaurine ''Gorgosaurus'' lived alongside unnamed species of ''Daspletosaurus'' in the Dinosaur Park and Upper Two Medicine environments. Young tyrannosaurs may have filled the niches in between adult tyrannosaurs and smaller theropods, which were separated by two orders of magnitude in mass. A ''Saurornitholestes'' dentary has been discovered in the Dinosaur Park Formation that bore tooth marks left by the bite of a young tyrannosaur, possibly ''Daspletosaurus''.

Coexistence with ''Gorgosaurus''

In the late Campanian of North America, ''Daspletosaurus'' was a contemporary of the albertosaurine tyrannosaurid ''Gorgosaurus''. This is one of the few examples of two tyrannosaur genera coexisting. In modern predator guilds, similar-sized predators are separated into different ecological niches by anatomical, behavioral or geographical differences that limit competition. Several studies have attempted to explain niche differentiation in ''Daspletosaurus'' and ''Gorgosaurus''.

Dale Russell hypothesized that the more lightly built and more common ''Gorgosaurus'' may have preyed on the abundant hadrosaurs of the time, while the more robust and less common ''Daspletosaurus'' may have specialized on the less prevalent but better-defended ceratopsids, which may have been more difficult to hunt. However, a specimen of ''Daspletosaurus'' ( OTM 200) from the Two Medicine Formation preserves the digested remains of a juvenile hadrosaur in its gut region. The higher and broader muzzles of tyrannosaurines like ''Daspletosaurus'' are mechanically stronger than the lower snouts of albertosaurines like ''Gorgosaurus'', although tooth strengths are similar between the two groups. This may indicate a difference in feeding mechanics or diet.

Other authors have suggested that competition was limited by geographical separation. Unlike some other groups of dinosaurs, there appears to be no correlation with distance from the sea. Neither ''Daspletosaurus'' nor ''Gorgosaurus'' was more common at higher or lower elevations than the other. However, while there is some overlap, ''Gorgosaurus'' appears to be more common at northern latitudes, with species of ''Daspletosaurus'' more abundant to the south. The same pattern is seen in other groups of dinosaurs. Chasmosaurine ceratopsians and hadrosaurine hadrosaurs (a group now generally referred to as ''saurolophines'') are also more common in the Two Medicine Formation and in southwestern North America during the Campanian. Thomas Holtz has suggested that this pattern indicates shared ecological preferences between tyrannosaurines, chasmosaurines and hadrosaurines. Holtz notes that, at the end of the later Maastrichtian stage, tyrannosaurines like ''Tyrannosaurus rex'', hadrosaurines and chasmosaurines like ''Triceratops'' were widespread throughout western North America, while albertosaurines and centrosaurines became extinct, and lambeosaurines were very rare.

See also

* Timeline of tyrannosaur research
*2017 in archosaur paleontology

References

External links

Discussion and specimen list
at The Theropod Database.


of the Dinosaur Park Formation ''Daspletosaurus'' at The Graveyard.

{{Taxonbar, from=Q132665

Tyrannosaurids
Late Cretaceous dinosaurs of North America
Campanian genus extinctions
Campanian genus first appearances
Dinosaur Park fauna
Oldman fauna
Paleontology in Alberta
Fossil taxa described in 1970
Taxa named by Dale Russell
Campanian life