A nation state is a state
in which a great majority shares the same culture
and is conscious of it. The nation state is an ideal in which cultural boundaries
match up with political boundaries
. According to one definition, "a nation state is a sovereign state
of which most of its subjects are united also by factors which defined a nation such as language
or common descent." It is a more precise concept than "country
", since a country does not need to have a predominant ethnic group
, in the sense of a common ethnicity
, may include a diaspora
s who live outside the nation state; some nations of this sense do not have a state where that ethnicity predominates. In a more general sense, a nation state is simply a large, politically sovereign country or administrative territory. A nation state may be contrasted with:
* A multinational state
, where no one ethnic group dominates (such a state may also be considered a multicultural
state depending on the degree of cultural assimilation
of various groups).
* A city-state
which is both smaller than a "nation" in the sense of "large sovereign country" and which may or may not be dominated by all or part of a single "nation" in the sense of a common ethnicity.
* An empire
, which is composed of many countries (possibly non-sovereign states) and nations under a single monarch
or ruling state government
* A confederation
, a league of sovereign states, which might or might not include nation-states.
* A federated state
which may or may not be a nation-state, and which is only partially self-governing within a larger federation
(for example, the state boundaries of Bosnia and Herzegovina
are drawn along ethnic lines, but those of the United States
This article mainly discusses the more specific definition of a nation-state as a typically sovereign country dominated by a particular ethnicity.
The relationship between a nation (in the ethnic sense) and a state can be complex. The presence of a state can encourage ethnogenesis
, and a group with a pre-existing ethnic identity can influence the drawing of territorial boundaries or argue for political legitimacy
This definition of a "nation-state" is not universally accepted. "All attempts to develop terminological consensus around "nation" resulted in failure", concludes academic Valery Tishkov
discusses the impressions surrounding the characters of "nation
", "(sovereign) state
", "nation state", and "nationalism
". Connor, who gave the term "ethnonationalism
" wide currency, also discusses the tendency to confuse nation and state and the treatment of all states as if nation states.
History and origins
The origins and early history
of nation states are disputed. A major theoretical question is: "Which came first, the nation or the nation state?" Scholars such as Steven Weber
, David Woodward
, Michel Foucault
and Jeremy Black
have advanced the hypothesis that the nation state did not arise out of political ingenuity or an unknown undetermined source, nor was it a political invention; but is an inadvertent byproduct of 15th-century intellectual discoveries in political economy
, political geography
, and geography
combined together with cartography
and advances in map-making technologies
. It was with these intellectual discoveries and technological advances that the nation state arose. For others, the nation existed first, then nationalist movements arose for sovereignty
, and the nation state was created to meet that demand. Some "modernization theories
" of nationalism see it as a product of government policies to unify and modernize an already existing state. Most theories see the nation state as a 19th-century European phenomenon, facilitated by developments such as state-mandated education, mass literacy
and mass media
. However, historians also note the early emergence of a relatively unified state and identity in Portugal
and the Dutch Republic
In France, Eric Hobsbawm
argues, the French state preceded the formation of the French people
. Hobsbawm considers that the state made the French nation, not French nationalism
, which emerged at the end of the 19th century, the time of the Dreyfus Affair
. At the time of the 1789 French Revolution
, only half of the French people spoke some French, and 12–13% spoke the version of it that was to be found in literature and in educational facilities, according to Hobsbawm.
During the Italian unification
, the number of people speaking the Italian language
was even lower. The French state promoted the replacement of various regional dialects and languages by a centralised French language
. The introduction of conscription
and the Third Republic
's 1880s laws on public instruction
facilitated the creation of a national identity under this theory.
Some nation states, such as Germany
, came into existence at least partly as a result of political campaigns by nationalists
, during the 19th century. In both cases, the territory was previously divided among other states, some of them very small. The sense of common identity was at first a cultural movement, such as in the ''Völkisch movement
'' in German-speaking states, which rapidly acquired a political significance. In these cases, the nationalist sentiment and the nationalist movement clearly precede the unification of the German and Italian nation states.
Historians Hans Kohn, Liah Greenfeld, Philip White and others have classified nations such as Germany or Italy, where cultural unification preceded state unification, as ''ethnic nations'' or ''ethnic nationalities''. However, "state-driven" national unifications, such as in France, England or China, are more likely to flourish in multiethnic societies, producing a traditional national heritage of ''civic nations'', or ''territory-based nationalities''.
[White, Philip L. (2006). 'Globalization and the Mythology of the Nation State', In A.G.Hopkins, ed. ''Global History: Interactions Between the Universal and the Local'' Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 257–284]
Some authors deconstruct the distinction between ethnic nationalism
and civic nationalism
because of the ambiguity of the concepts. They argue that the paradigmatic case of Ernest Renan
is an idealisation and it should be interpreted within the German tradition and not in opposition to it. For example, they argue that the arguments used by Renan at the conference ''What is a nation?'' are not consistent with his thinking. This alleged civic conception of the nation would be determined only by the case of the loss gives Alsace and Lorraine in the Franco-Prussian War
The idea of a nation state was and is associated with the rise of the modern system of states, often called the "Westphalian system
" in reference to the Treaty of Westphalia
(1648). The balance of power
, which characterized that system, depended on its effectiveness upon clearly defined, centrally controlled, independent entities, whether empire
s or nation states, which recognize each other's sovereignty and territory. The Westphalian system did not create the nation state, but the nation state meets the criteria for its component states (by assuming that there is no disputed territory).
The nation state received a philosophical underpinning in the era of Romanticism
, at first as the "natural" expression of the individual peoples (romantic nationalism
: see Johann Gottlieb Fichte
's conception of the ''Volk
'', later opposed by Ernest Renan
). The increasing emphasis during the 19th century on the ethnic and racial origins of the nation, led to a redefinition of the nation state in these terms.
, which in Boulainvilliers
's theories was inherently antipatriotic
and antinationalist, joined itself with colonialist imperialism
and "continental imperialism", most notably in pan-Germanic
The relation between racism and ethnic nationalism reached its height in the 20th century fascism
. The specific combination of "nation" ("people") and "state" expressed in such terms as the ''Völkische Staat'' and implemented in laws such as the 1935 Nuremberg laws
made fascist states such as early Nazi Germany
qualitatively different from non-fascist nation states. Minorities
were not considered part of the people (''Volk''), and were consequently denied to have an authentic or legitimate role in such a state. In Germany, neither Jews
nor the Roma
were considered part of the people and were specifically targeted for persecution. German nationality law
defined "German" on the basis of German ancestry, excluding ''all'' non-Germans from the people.
In recent years, a nation state's claim to absolute sovereignty
within its borders has been criticized.
A global political system based on international agreements
and supra-national blocs characterized the post-war era. Non-state actors, such as international corporation
s and non-governmental organizations
, are widely seen as eroding the economic and political power of nation states.
According to Andreas Wimmer and Yuval Feinstein, nation-states tended to emerge when power shifts allowed nationalists to overthrow existing regimes or absorb existing administrative units. Xue Li and Alexander Hicks links the frequency of nation-state creation to processes of diffusion that emanate from international organizations.
Before the nation state
, during the 18th century, the classic non-national states were the ''multiethnic'' empire
s, the Austrian Empire
, Kingdom of France
, Kingdom of Hungary
, the Russian Empire
, the Portuguese Empire
, the Spanish Empire
, the Ottoman Empire
, the British Empire
and smaller nations at what would now be called sub-state level. The multi-ethnic empire was an absolute monarchy
ruled by a king, emperor
. The population belonged to many ethnic groups, and they spoke many languages. The empire was dominated by one ethnic group, and their language was usually the language of public administration. The ruling dynasty
was usually, but not always, from that group.
This type of state is not specifically European: such empires existed in Asia, Africa and the Americas. In the Muslim world
, immediately after Muhammad's death in 632, Caliphate
s were established. Caliphates were Islamic state
s under the leadership of a political-religious successor to the Islamic prophet Muhammad
developed into multi-ethnic trans-national empires. The Ottoman sultan, Selim I
(1512–1520) reclaimed the title of caliph, which had been in dispute and asserted by a diversity of rulers and "shadow caliphs" in the centuries of the Abbasid
Caliphate since the Mongols' sacking of Baghdad
and the killing of the last Abbasid Caliph
in Baghdad, Iraq 1258.
The Ottoman Caliphate
as an office of the Ottoman Empire
was abolished under Mustafa Kemal Atatürk
in 1924 as part of Atatürk's Reforms
Some of the smaller European states were not so ethnically diverse, but were also dynastic
states, ruled by a royal house
. Their territory could expand by royal intermarriage
or merge with another state when the dynasty merged. In some parts of Europe, notably Germany
, very small territorial units existed. They were recognized by their neighbors as independent, and had their own government and laws. Some were ruled by prince
s or other hereditary rulers, some were governed by bishop
s or abbot
s. Because they were so small, however, they had no separate language or culture: the inhabitants shared the language of the surrounding region.
In some cases these states were simply overthrown by nationalist uprisings in the 19th century. Liberal ideas of free trade
played a role in German unification, which was preceded by a customs union
, the Zollverein
. However, the Austro-Prussian War
, and the German alliances in the Franco-Prussian War
, were decisive in the unification. The Austro-Hungarian Empire
and the Ottoman Empire
broke up after the First World War
, and the Russian Empire
became the Soviet Union
after the Russian Civil War
A few of the smaller states survived: the independent principalities of Liechtenstein
, and the republic of San Marino
. (Vatican City
is a special case. All of the larger Papal State
s save the Vatican itself were occupied and absorbed by Italy by 1870. The resulting Roman Question
was resolved with the rise of the modern state under the 1929 Lateran treaties
and the Holy See
"Legitimate states that govern effectively and dynamic industrial economies are widely regarded today as the defining characteristics of a modern nation-state."
Nation states have their own characteristics, differing from those of the pre-national states. For a start, they have a different attitude to their territory when compared with dynastic monarchies: it is semisacred and nontransferable. No nation would swap territory with other states simply, for example, because the king's daughter married. They have a different type of border
, in principle defined only by the area of settlement of the national group, although many nation states also sought natural borders (rivers, mountain ranges). They are constantly changing in population size and power because of the limited restrictions of their borders.
The most noticeable characteristic is the degree to which nation states use the state as an instrument of national unity, in economic, social and cultural life.
The nation state promoted economic unity, by abolishing internal customs
. In Germany, that process, the creation of the Zollverein
, preceded formal national unity. Nation states typically have a policy to create and maintain a national transportation infrastructure, facilitating trade and travel. In 19th-century Europe, the expansion of the rail transport
networks was at first largely a matter for private
railway companies, but gradually came under control of the national governments. The French rail network, with its main lines radiating from Paris to all corners of France, is often seen as a reflection of the centralised French nation state, which directed its construction
. Nation states continue to build, for instance, specifically national motorway
networks. Specifically transnational infrastructure programmes, such as the Trans-European Networks
, are a recent innovation.
The nation states typically had a more centralised and uniform public administration
than its imperial predecessors: they were smaller, and the population less diverse. (The internal diversity of the Ottoman Empire
, for instance, was very great.) After the 19th-century triumph of the nation state in Europe, regional identity was subordinate to national identity, in regions such as Alsace-Lorraine
. In many cases, the regional administration was also subordinated to central (national) government. This process was partially reversed from the 1970s onward, with the introduction of various forms of regional autonomy
, in formerly centralised
states such as France
The most obvious impact of the nation state, as compared to its non-national predecessors, is the creation of a uniform national culture
, through state policy. The model of the nation state implies that its population constitutes a nation
, united by a common descent, a common language and many forms of shared culture. When the implied unity was absent, the nation state often tried to create it. It promoted a uniform national language, through language policy
. The creation of national systems of compulsory primary education
and a relatively uniform curriculum
in secondary schools, was the most effective instrument in the spread of the national language
s. The schools also taught the national history, often in a propagandistic and mythologised version
, and (especially during conflicts) some nation states still teach this kind of history.
Language and cultural policy was sometimes negative, aimed at the suppression of non-national elements. Language prohibition
s were sometimes used to accelerate the adoption of national languages and the decline of minority language
s (see examples: Anglicisation
In some cases, these policies triggered bitter conflicts and further ethnic separatism
. But where it worked, the cultural uniformity and homogeneity of the population increased. Conversely, the cultural divergence at the border became sharper: in theory, a uniform French identity extends from the Atlantic coast to the Rhine
, and on the other bank of the Rhine, a uniform German identity begins. To enforce that model, both sides have divergent language policy
and educational systems.
In some cases, the geographic boundaries of an ethnic population and a political state largely coincide. In these cases, there is little immigration
, few members of ethnic minorities, and few members of the "home" ethnicity living in other countries.
Nation states where a single ethnic group makes up more than 85% of the population include the following:
: The vast majority of the population is ethnically Albanian
at about 98.6% of the population, with the remainder consisting of a few small ethnic minorities.
: The vast majority of Armenia's population consists of ethnic Armenian
s at about 98% of the population, with the remainder consisting of a few small ethnic minorities.
: The vast majority ethnic group of Bangladesh are the Bengali people
, comprising 98% of the population, with the remainder consisting of mostly Bihari
migrants and indigenous tribal groups. Therefore, Bangladeshi society is to a great extent linguistically and culturally homogeneous, with very small populations of foreign expatriates and workers, although there is a substantial number of Bengali workers living abroad.
: The vast majority of China's population is Han
, making up 92% of the population and geographically distributed on the eastern side of China. The government also recognizes 55 ethnic minorities
, including Turks, Tibetans
, Mongols and others. Some scholars think that China is not a typical nation state, but a civilization state.
: The vast majority of Egypt's population consists of ethnic Egyptian
s at about 99% of the population, with the remainder consisting of a few small ethnic minorities, as well as refugees or asylum seekers. Modern Egyptian identity is closely tied to the geography of Egypt
and its long history
; its development over the centuries saw overlapping or conflicting ideologies. Though today an Arab people, that aspect constitutes for Egyptians a cultural dimension of their identity, not a necessary attribute of or prop for their national political being. Today most Egyptians see themselves, their history, culture and language (the Egyptian variant of Arabic
) as specifically Egyptian and at the same time as part of the Arab world
: Defined as a nation state in its 1920 constitution
, up until the period of Soviet incorporation, Estonia was historically a very homogenous state with 88.2% of residents being Estonians
, 8.2% Russians
, 1.5% Germans
and 0.4% Jews
according to the 1934 census.
As a result of Soviet policies the demographic situation significantly changed with the arrival of Russian speaking settlers. Today Estonians
form 69%, Russians
2.04% and Belarusians
1.1% of the population (2012).
A significant proportion of the inhabitants (84.1%) are citizens of Estonia
, around 7.3% are citizens of Russia
and 7.0% as yet undefined citizenship (2010).
: The vast majority of the population is ethnically Swazi
at about 98.6% of the population, with the remainder consisting of a few small ethnic minorities.
: 91.6% of the permanent residents are ethnic Greek; the remaining 911929 inhabitants consist of immigrants from Albania (480,824), Bulgaria (75,915), Romania (46,253), former USSR (70,000), Western Europe (77,000) and the rest of the world (161,937).
: The Hungarians
(or ''Magyar'') people consist of about 95% of the population, with a small Roma
minority: see Demographics of Hungary
: Although the inhabitants are ethnically related to other Scandinavian groups, the national culture and language are found only in Iceland. There are no cross-border minorities as the nearest land is too far away: see Demographics of Iceland
: Japan is also traditionally seen as an example of a nation state and also the largest of the nation states, with population in excess of 120 million. Japan has a small number of minorities such as Ryūkyū peoples
, and on the northern island of Hokkaidō
, the indigenous Ainu
minority. However, they are either numerically insignificant (Ainu), their difference is not as pronounced (though Ryukyuan culture is closely related to Japanese culture, it is nonetheless distinctive in that it historically received much more influence from China and has separate political and nonpolitical and religious traditions) or well assimilated (Zainichi
population is collapsing due to assimilation/naturalisation).
: The Lebanese Arabs
comprise about 95% of the population, with the remainder consisting of a few small ethnic minorities, as well as refugees or asylum seekers. Modern Lebanese identity is closely tied to the geography of Lebanon
and its history
. Although they are now an Arab people and ethnically homogeneous, its identity oversees overlapping or conflicting ideologies between its Phoenicia
n heritage and Arab
heritage. While many Lebanese regard themselves as Arab, some Lebanese Christians, especially the Maronites, regard themselves, their history, and their culture as Phoenician and not Arab, while still other Lebanese regard themselves as both.
: Lesotho's ethno-linguistic structure consists almost entirely of the Basotho
(singular Mosotho), a Bantu-speaking people; about 99.7% of the population are Basotho.
: The vast majority of the population is ethnically Dhivehi
at about 98% of the population, with the remainder consisting of foreign workers; there are no indigenous ethnic minorities.
: The vast majority of the population is ethnically Maltese
at about 95.3% of the population, with the remainder consisting of a few small ethnic minorities.
: The vast majority of the population is ethnically Mongol
at about 95.0% of the population, with the remainder consisting of a few ethnic minorities included in Kazakhs.
and South Korea
are among the most ethnically and linguistically homogeneous countries in the world. According to The World Factbook
, North Korea is homogeneous
. South Korea is considered one of the most ethnically homogeneous societies in the world with ethnic Koreans representing approximately 96%
of total population.
: After World War II
, with the genocide of the Jews
by the invading German Nazis
during the Holocaust
, the expulsion of Germans after World War II
and the loss of eastern territories (Kresy
), 96.7% of the people of Poland
claim Polish nationality
, while 97.8% declare that they speak Polish
at home (Census 2002.).
* Several Polynesia
n countries such as Tonga
: Although surrounded by other lands and people, the Portuguese nation
has occupied the same territory since the romanization or latinization
of the native population during the Roman
era. The modern Portuguese nation
is a very old amalgam of formerly distinct historical populations that passed through and settled in the territory of modern Portugal: native Iberian peoples, Celts
, ancient Mediterraneans (Greeks
), invading Germanic peoples
like the Suebi
and the Visigoths
, and Muslim Arabs
. Most Berber/Arab people and the Jews were expelled from the Iberian Peninsula
during the Reconquista
and the repopulation by Christians
* San Marino
: The Sammarinese make up about 97% of the population and all speak Italian
and are ethnically and linguistically identical to Italians
. San Marino is a landlocked enclave, completely surrounded by Italy. The state has a population of approximately 30,000, including 1,000 foreigners, most of whom are Italians.
The notion of a unifying "national identity" also extends to countries that host multiple ethnic or language groups, such as India
. For example, Switzerland
is constitutionally a confederation of cantons
, and has four official languages, but it has also a "Swiss" national identity, a national history and a classic national hero, Wilhelm Tell
Innumerable conflicts have arisen where political boundaries did not correspond with ethnic or cultural boundaries.
After World War II in the Josip Broz Tito
era, nationalism was appealed to for uniting South Slav
peoples. Later in the 20th century, after the break-up of the Soviet Union, leaders appealed to ancient ethnic feuds or tensions that ignited conflict between the Serbs
, as well as Bosniaks
, eventually breaking up the long collaboration of peoples. Ethnic cleansing was carried out in the Balkans, resulting in the destruction of the formerly socialist republic
and producing the civil wars in Bosnia and Herzegovina
in 1992–95, resulting in mass population displacements and segregation that radically altered what was once a highly diverse and intermixed ethnic makeup of the region. These conflicts were largely about creating a new political framework of states, each of which would be ethnically and politically homogeneous. Serbs, Croats and Bosniaks insisted they were ethnically distinct although many communities had a long history of intermarriage. Presently Slovenia
(89% Slovene), Croatia
(90.4% Croat) and Serbia
(83% Serb) could be classified as nation states per se, whereas North Macedonia
(66% Macedonian), Montenegro
(42% Montenegrin) and Bosnia and Herzegovina
(50.1% Bosniak) are multinational states.
is a classic example of a state that is not a nation state. The state was formed by secession
from the United Kingdom of the Netherlands
in 1830, whose neutrality and integrity was protected by the Treaty of London 1839
; thus it served as a buffer state
after the Napoleonic Wars between the European powers France
(after 1871 the German Empire
) and the United Kingdom
until World War I
, when its neutrality was breached by the Germans. Currently, Belgium is divided between the Flemings
in the north, the French-speaking
population in the south, and the German-speaking population in the east. The Flemish
population in the north speaks Dutch, the Walloon
population in the south speaks either French
or, in the east of Liège Province
, German. The Brussels population speaks French or Dutch.
The Flemish identity is also cultural, and there is a strong separatist movement espoused by the political parties, the right-wing Vlaams Belang
and the Nieuw-Vlaamse Alliantie
. The Francophone Walloon
identity of Belgium is linguistically distinct and regionalist
. There is also unitary Belgian nationalism
, several versions of a Greater Netherlands
ideal, and a German-speaking community of Belgium
annexed from Germany
in 1920, and re-annexed by Germany in 1940–1944. However, these ideologies are all very marginal and politically insignificant during elections.
covers a large geographic area and uses the concept of "Zhonghua minzu
" or Chinese nationality, in the sense of ethnic group
s, but it also officially recognizes the majority Han
ethnic group which accounts for over 90% of the population, and no fewer than 55 ethnic national minorities
According to Philip G. Roeder, Moldova
is an example of a Soviet era "segment-state" (Moldavian SSR
), where the "nation-state project of the segment-state trumped the nation-state project of prior statehood. In Moldova, despite strong agitation from university faculty and students for reunification with Romania
, the nation-state project forged within the Moldavian SSR trumped the project for a return to the interwar nation-state project of Greater Romania
See Controversy over linguistic and ethnic identity in Moldova
for further details.
was founded as a Jewish state
in 1948. Its "Basic Laws
" describe it as both a Jewish and a democratic state. The Basic Law: Israel as the Nation-State of the Jewish People
(2018) explicitly specifies the nature of the State of Israel
as the nation-state
of the Jewish people
. According to the Israel Central Bureau of Statistics
, 75.7% of Israel's population are Jews. Arabs
, who make up 20.4% of the population, are the largest ethnic minority in Israel. Israel also has very small communities of Armenians
. There are also some non-Jewish spouses of Israeli Jews. However, these communities are very small, and usually number only in the hundreds or thousands.
Kingdom of the Netherlands
A similar unusual example is the Kingdom of the Netherlands
. As of 10 October 2010, the Kingdom of the Netherlands consists of four countries:
* Sint Maarten
Each is expressly designated as a ''land'' in Dutch law
by the Charter for the Kingdom of the Netherlands
. Unlike the German ''Länder'' and the Austrian ''Bundesländer'', ''landen'' is consistently translated as "countries" by the Dutch government.
, even being an ethnically diverse country and officially a federation, is regarded as a nation state
due to its ideological basis
on which it was given independence
from British India
as a separate nation rather than as part of a unified India
. Different ethnic groups in Pakistan
are strongly bonded by their common Muslim identity, common cultural and social values, common historical heritage, a national ''lingua franca
) and joint political, strategic and economic interests.
The United Kingdom
is an unusual example of a nation state due to its claimed "countries within a country
" status. The United Kingdom, which is formed by the union of England
and Northern Ireland
, is a unitary state
formed initially by the merger of two independent kingdoms, the Kingdom of England
(which already included Wales) and the Kingdom of Scotland
, but the Treaty of Union
(1707) that set out the agreed terms has ensured the continuation of distinct features of each state, including separate legal systems
and separate national churches
In 2003, the British Government
described the United Kingdom as "countries within a country". While the Office for National Statistics
and others describe the United Kingdom as a "nation state", others, including a then Prime Minister, describe it as a "multinational state
", and the term Home Nations
is used to describe the four national teams that represent the four nations of the United Kingdom (England
, Northern Ireland
). Some refer to it as a "Union State".
There has been academic debate over whether the United Kingdom can be legally dissolved as it is normally recognized internationally as a single nation state. English law jurist A.V. Dicey
from an English legal perspective wrote that the question is based on whether the legislation giving rise to the union (the Union with Scotland Act), one of the two pieces of legislation which created the state, can be repealed. Dicey claimed because the Law of England does not acknowledge the word "unconstitutional", as a matter of English law
it can be repealed. He also stated any tampering with the Acts of Union 1707
would be political madness.
The most obvious deviation from the ideal of "one nation, one state" is the presence of minorities, especially ethnic minorities
, which are clearly not members of the majority nation. An ethnic nationalist definition of a nation
is necessarily exclusive: ethnic nations typically do not have open membership. In most cases, there is a clear idea that surrounding nations are different, and that includes members of those nations who live on the "wrong side" of the border. Historical examples of groups who have been specifically singled out as ''outsiders'' are the Roma
Negative responses to minorities within the nation state have ranged from cultural assimilation
enforced by the state, to expulsion
, persecution, violence, and extermination
. The assimilation policies are usually enforced by the state, but violence against minorities is not always state-initiated: it can occur in the form of mob violence
such as lynching
s. Nation states are responsible for some of the worst historical examples of violence against minorities not considered part of the nation.
However, many nation states accept specific minorities as being part of the nation, and the term ''national minority'' is often used in this sense. The Sorbs
in Germany is an example: for centuries they have lived in German-speaking states, surrounded by a much larger ethnic German population, and they have no other historical territory. They are now generally considered to be part of the German nation and are accepted as such by the Federal Republic of Germany, which constitutionally guarantees their cultural rights. Of the thousands of ethnic and cultural minorities in nation states across the world, only a few have this level of acceptance and protection.
is an official policy in many states, establishing the ideal of peaceful existence among multiple ethnic, cultural, and linguistic groups. Many nations have laws protecting minority rights
When national boundaries that do not match ethnic boundaries are drawn, such as in the Balkans
and Central Asia
, ethnic tension, massacres and even genocide
, sometimes has occurred historically (see Bosnian genocide
and 2010 South Kyrgyzstan ethnic clashes
Ideally, the border of a nation state extends far enough to include all the members of the nation, and all of the national homeland
. Again, in practice, some of them always live on the 'wrong side' of the border. Part of the national homeland may be there too, and it may be governed by the 'wrong' nation. The response to the non-inclusion of territory and population may take the form of irredentism
: demands to annex ''unredeemed'' territory and incorporate it into the nation state.
Irredentist claims are usually based on the fact that an identifiable part of the national group lives across the border. However, they can include claims to territory where no members of that nation live at present, because they lived there in the past, the national language is spoken in that region, the national culture has influenced it, geographical unity with the existing territory, or a wide variety of other reasons. Past grievances are usually involved and can cause revanchism
It is sometimes difficult to distinguish irredentism from pan-nationalism
, since both claim that all members of an ethnic and cultural nation belong in one specific state. Pan-nationalism is less likely to specify the nation ethnically. For instance, variants of Pan-Germanism
have different ideas about what constituted Greater Germany
, including the confusing term ''Grossdeutschland'', which, in fact, implied the inclusion of huge Slav
ic minorities from the Austro-Hungarian Empire
Typically, irredentist demands are at first made by members of non-state nationalist movements. When they are adopted by a state, they typically result in tensions, and actual attempts at annexation are always considered a ''casus belli
'', a cause for war
. In many cases, such claims result in long-term hostile relations between neighbouring states. Irredentist movements typically circulate maps of the claimed national territory, the ''greater'' nation state. That territory, which is often much larger than the existing state, plays a central role in their propaganda.
Irredentism should not be confused with claims to overseas colonies, which are not generally considered part of the national homeland. Some French overseas colonies would be an exception: French rule in Algeria
unsuccessfully treated the colony as a ''département
'' of France.
It has been speculated by both proponents of globalization
and various science fiction
writers that the concept of a nation state may disappear with the ever-increasing interconnectedness of the world.
Such ideas are sometimes expressed around concepts of a world government
. Another possibility is a societal collapse
and move into communal anarchy or zero world government
, in which nation states no longer exist.
Globalization especially has helped to bring about the discussion about the disappearance of nation states, as global trade
and the rise of the concepts of a 'global citizen
' and a common identity have helped to reduce differences and 'distances' between individual nation states, especially with regards to the internet.
Clash of civilizations
The theory of the clash of civilizations
lies in direct contrast to cosmopolitan
theories about an ever more connected world that no longer requires nation states. According to political scientist Samuel P. Huntington
, people's cultural and religious identities
will be the primary source of conflict in the post–Cold War
The theory was originally formulated in a 1992 lecture at the American Enterprise Institute
, which was then developed in a 1993 ''Foreign Affairs
'' article titled "The Clash of Civilizations?",
[Official copy (free preview): ]
in response to Francis Fukuyama
's 1992 book, ''The End of History and the Last Man
''. Huntington later expanded his thesis
in a 1996 book ''The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order''.
Huntington began his thinking by surveying the diverse theories about the nature of global politics in the post–Cold War
period. Some theorists and writers argued that human rights
, liberal democracy
and capitalist free market
economics had become the only remaining ideological alternative for nations in the post–Cold War world. Specifically, Francis Fukuyama
, in ''The End of History and the Last Man
'', argued that the world had reached a Hegelian
"end of history".
Huntington believed that while the age of ideology
had ended, the world had reverted only to a normal state of affairs characterized by cultural conflict. In his thesis, he argued that the primary axis of conflict in the future will be along cultural and religious lines.
As an extension, he posits that the concept of different civilization
s, as the highest rank of cultural identity, will become increasingly useful in analyzing the potential for conflict.
In the 1993 ''Foreign Affairs
'' article, Huntington writes:
:''It is my hypothesis that the fundamental source of conflict in this new world will not be primarily ideological or primarily economic. The great divisions among humankind and the dominating source of conflict will be cultural. Nation states will remain the most powerful actors in world affairs, but the principal conflicts of global politics will occur between nations and groups of different civilizations. The clash of civilizations will dominate global politics. The fault lines between civilizations will be the battle lines of the future.''
Sandra Joireman suggests that Huntington may be characterised as a neo-primordialist
, as, while he sees people as having strong ties to their ethnicity, he does not believe that these ties have always existed.
Historians often look to the past to find the origins of a particular nation state. Indeed, they often put so much emphasis on the importance of the nation state in modern times, that they distort the history of earlier periods in order to emphasize the question of origins. Lansing and English argue that much of the medieval history of Europe was structured to follow the historical winners—especially the nation states that emerged around Paris and London. Important developments that did not directly lead to a nation state get neglected, they argue:
:one effect of this approach has been to privilege historical winners, aspects of medieval Europe that became important in later centuries, above all the nation state.... Arguably the liveliest cultural innovation in the 13th century was the Mediterranean, centered on Frederick II
's polyglot court and administration in Palermo...Sicily and the Italian South in later centuries suffered a long slide into overtaxed poverty and marginality. Textbook narratives, therefore, focus not on medieval Palermo, with its Muslim and Jewish bureaucracies and Arabic-speaking monarch, but on the historical winners, Paris and London.
as an alternative to nation states.
* Civilization state
* National personification
* Titular nation
* Westphalian sovereignty
* Anderson, Benedict
. 1991. ''Imagined Communities
* Colomer, Josep M.
. 2007. ''Great Empires, Small Nations. The Uncertain Future of the Sovereign State''. .
* Gellner, Ernest (1983). ''Nations and Nationalism.'' Ithaca: Cornell University Press. .
* Hobsbawm, Eric J. (1992). ''Nations and Nationalism Since 1780: Programme, Myth, Reality.'' 2nd ed. Cambridge University Press. .
* Khan, Ali (1992)The Extinction of Nation states
* Renan, Ernest
. 1882. "Qu'est-ce qu'une nation?"
("What is a Nation?
* Malesevic, Sinisa (2006). ''Identity as Ideology: Understanding Ethnicity and Nationalism'' New York: Palgrave.
* Smith, Anthony D. (1986). ''The Ethnic Origins of Nations'' London: Basil Blackwell. pp 6–18. .
* White, Philip L. (2006). "Globalization and the Mythology of the Nation State," In A.G.Hopkins, ed. ''Global History: Interactions Between the Universal and the Local'' Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 257–28
From Paris to Cairo: Resistance of the Unacculturated
on identity and the nation state.
Category:Political science terminology