"Question!" is a song by
Armenian American
Armenian Americans ( hy, ամերիկահայեր, ''amerikahayer'') are citizens or residents of the United States who have total or partial Armenian ancestry. They form the second largest community of the Armenian diaspora after Armenians i ...
heavy metal band
System of a Down
System of a Down (also known as SoaD or simply System) is an Armenian-American heavy metal band formed in Glendale, California, in 1994. Since 1997, the band has consisted of Serj Tankian (lead vocals, keyboards); Daron Malakian (guitar, v ...
, released in July 2005 as the second
single from their fourth studio album ''
Mezmerize
''Mezmerize'' is the fourth studio album by the American heavy metal band System of a Down, released on May 17, 2005, by American Recordings and Columbia Records. Upon its release, the album received acclaim from critics. The album sold over 4 ...
''.
Release
After the release of
B.Y.O.B., the band were deciding what song to release as a single. They eventually chose "Question!" after finding out radio stations had already been playing the track.
Music video
Shavo Odadjian produced the video (and co-directed it alongside
Howard Greenhalgh
Howard Douglas Greenhalgh (born 19 February 1963) is a British director of music videos and advertising.
Biography
Greenhalgh was born in Halifax, West Riding of Yorkshire and studied at the Royal College of Art, setting up the firm Why No ...
) after allegedly having an image of the video in a nightmare, which consisted of a boy offering a girl berries, unaware that the berries were poisonous.
It is claimed that before the dream he did not intend to produce the video and did not want any special treatment over other possible producers for being in the band, thus submitting the idea anonymously.
The video was shot in the now-closed Los Angeles Theater, which opened in 1931. Tankian described the place, "It's an amazing old theater that is due for renovation. I'm glad they haven't renovated it yet, because it has the right character for what we were looking for. It has a fairy tale vibe."
[System of a Down Pose "Question!"](_blank)
Rolling Stone
The video opens with a boy with gray hair, clothes, and skin shooting a red bird with a slingshot, which coincides with the start of the song. It then switches to a scene of the band members on a theater stage performing music for a play, similar to an orchestra playing under the pit. Based on a theme of life, death, and reincarnation, the play revolves around two lovers, a man in a dark suit and a woman in a red dress, who are shown both as children and as adults. As the music reaches its climax, the woman collapses after eating a red berry and the man screams in grief. The video closes with an intense scene of a woman giving birth followed by a shot of a newborn baby wrapped in red cloth. The color red is central to the video, linking the bird, the girl, the woman, and the baby in a cycle of rebirth.
Track listing
Personnel
System of a Down
*
Serj Tankian
Serj Tankian (born August 21, 1967) is an Armenian-American singer, musician, songwriter, political activist and entrepreneur. He is best known as the lead vocalist, primary lyricist, keyboardist, and occasional rhythm guitarist of heavy metal ...
– lead vocals, acoustic guitar
*
Daron Malakian
Daron Malakian (born July 18, 1975) is an Armenian-American musician. He is best known as the guitarist, songwriter, and second vocalist of metal band System of a Down, and as the lead vocalist, lead guitarist, multi-instrumentalist, and songwrit ...
– backing vocals, electric guitar
*
Shavo Odadjian – bass
*
John Dolmayan – drums, percussion
Additional personnel
*
Marc Mann – string arrangements
* Vartan Malakian – artwork
* Brandy Flower – graphic design
Production
*
Rick Rubin
Frederick Jay Rubin (; born March 10, 1963) is an American record producer. He is the co-founder (alongside Russell Simmons) of Def Jam Recordings, founder of American Recordings, and former co-president of Columbia Records.
Rubin helped popu ...
– production
*
Andy Wallace – mixing
* David Schiffman – engineering
*
Jason Lader – editing
* Dana Neilsen – editing
* Phillip Broussard – engineering assistance
* John O'Mahony –
Pro Tools
Pro Tools is a digital audio workstation (DAW) developed and released by Avid Technology (formerly Digidesign) for Microsoft Windows and macOS. It is used for music creation and production, sound for picture ( sound design, audio post-prod ...
engineering
* Steve Sisco – mixing assistance
* Joe Peluso – mixing assistance
Chart positions
Certifications
References
{{System of a Down
Song recordings produced by Rick Rubin
System of a Down songs
Songs about death
2005 singles
2004 songs
Music videos directed by Howard Greenhalgh
Songs written by Serj Tankian