Heretics Society

Charles Kay Ogden (; 1 June 1889 – 20 March 1957) was an English linguist, philosopher, and writer. Described as a polymath but also an eccentric and outsider, he took part in many ventures related to literature, politics, the arts, and philosophy, having a broad effect particularly as an editor, translator, and activist on behalf of a reformed version of the English language. He is typically defined as a linguistic psychologist, and is now mostly remembered as the inventor and propagator of Basic English.

Early life and education

Charles Kay Ogden was born at Rossall School in Fleetwood, Lancashire, on 1 June 1889 to Charles Burdett Ogden (13 July 1849 – 10 December 1923) and Fanny Hart (1850 – 21 December 1944), who were married in 1888 at Chorlton, Lancashire. His father was employed in various capacities at the Rossall School during the years 1873–1909.

Charles Kay Ogden was educated at Buxton and Rossall, won a scholarship to Magdalene College, Cambridge, and commenced his undergraduate study of Classics in 1908.

He visited continental Europe to investigate methods of language teaching in 1912 and 1913. Ogden obtained a M.A. in 1915.

Career

The Heretics Society

In 1909, while still an undergraduate, Ogden co-founded the Heretics Society in Cambridge which questioned traditional authorities in general and religious dogmas in particular, in the wake of the paper ''Prove All Things'', read by William Chawner, Master of Emmanuel College, a past Vice-Chancellor. The Heretics began as a group of 12 undergraduates interested in Chawner's agnostic approach.

The Society was nonconformist and open to women, and Jane Harrison found an audience there, publishing her inaugural talk for the Society of 7 December 1909 as the essay ''Heresy and Humanity'' (1911), an argument that warned of the dangers of group-think and implored the audience to realize that we are constantly negotiating the line between egotism and herd instinct, but that how we navigate that line matters. Investigating the origins of the word 'heresy,' her lecture, later published in ''Alpha and Omega'' (1915), challenged many of the religious restrictions and rules of the Anglican Church and its connections with the university. The talk of the following day was from J. M. E. McTaggart, and was also published, as ''Dare to Be Wise'' (1910). Another early member with anthropological interests was John Layard; Herbert Felix Jolowicz (1890–1954), Frank Plumpton Ramsey and Philip Sargant Florence were among the members. Alix Sargant Florence, sister of Philip, was active both as a Heretic and on the editorial board of the ''Cambridge Magazine''.

Ogden was President of the Heretics from 1911, for more than a decade; he invited a variety of prominent speakers and linked the Society to his role as editor. In November 1911 G. K. Chesterton used a well-publicised talk to the Heretics, titled ''The Future of Religion'', to reply to George Bernard Shaw, who in May had talked on ''The Religion of the Future''. On this occasion Chesterton produced one of his well known ''bons mots'':
:Questioner: ... I say it is perfectly true that I have an intuition that I exist.
:Mr. Chesterton: Cherish it.

In 1912 T. E. Hulme and Bertrand Russell spoke. Hulme's talk on ''Anti-Romanticism and Original Sin'' was written up by Ogden for the ''Cambridge Magazine'', where in 1916 both Hulme and Russell would write on the war, from their opposite points of view. Rupert Brooke addressed them on contemporary theatre, and an article based on his views of Strindberg appeared in the ''Cambridge Magazine'' in October 1913. Another talk from 1913 that was published was from Edward Clodd on ''Obscurantism in Modern Science''. Ogden was very active at this period in seeing these works into print.

On 4 February 1923, the biologist J.B.S. Haldane lectured the Society on "Daedalus; or, Science and the Future", a speculative vision that enjoy some success in print and spurred in 1924 a less optimistic response from Bertrand Russell entitled "Icarus or the Future of Science".

The Heretics continued as a well-known forum, with Virginia Woolf on 18 May 1924 using it to formulate a reply to criticisms from Arnold Bennett arising from her ''Jacob's Room'' (1922), in a talk ''Character in Fiction'' that was then published in ''The Criterion''. This paper contains the assertion, now proverbial, that "on or about December 1910 human character changed." The Heretics met in November 1929, when Ludwig Wittgenstein lectured to it on ethics, at Ogden's invitation, producing in ''A Lecture on Ethics'' a work accepted as part of the early Wittgenstein canon.

''Cambridge Magazine''

In 1912 Ogden founded the weekly ''Cambridge Magazine'', which he edited until it ceased publication in 1922. The initial period was troubled. Ogden was studying for Part II of the Classical Tripos when offered the chance to start the magazine by Charles Granville, who ran a small but significant London publishing house, Stephen Swift & Co. Thinking that the editorship would mean giving up first class honours, Ogden consulted Henry Jackson, who advised him not to miss the opportunity. Shortly after, Stephen Swift & Co. went bankrupt. Ogden continued to edit the magazine during World War I, when its nature changed, because rheumatic fever as a teenager had left him unfit for military service.

Ogden often used the pseudonym ''Adelyne More'' (add-a-line more) in his journalism. The magazine included literary contributions by Siegfried Sassoon, John Masefield, Thomas Hardy, George Bernard Shaw and Arnold Bennett.

It evolved into an organ of international comment on politics and the war, supported in the background by a group of Cambridge academics including Edward Dent (who sent Sassoon's work), Theo Bartholomew and Goldsworthy Lowes Dickinson. A survey of the foreign press filled more than half of each issue, being the ''Notes from the foreign press'' supplied by Dorothy Buxton which appeared there from October 1915 onwards until 1920, and its circulation rose to over 20,000. Buxton was in fact then leading a large team translating and collating articles from up to 100 foreign newspapers; for instance Italian articles were supplied in translation in numbers by Dent. This digest of European press coverage was exclusive to the ''Magazine'', and gave it disproportionate influence in political circles. For example, Robert Reid, 1st Earl Loreburn, used the ''Notes from the foreign press'' to advocate to the Marquess of Lansdowne in 1916 against bellicose claims and attitudes on the British side.

During 1917 the ''Magazine'' came under heavy criticism, with its neutral use of foreign press extracts being called pacifism, particularly by the pro-war patriotic Fight for Right Movement headed by Francis Younghusband. Dorothy Buxton's husband Charles Roden Buxton was closely associated with the Union of Democratic Control. Sir Frederick Pollock who chaired Fight for Right wrote to '' The Morning Post'' in February 1917 charging the ''Magazine'' with pacifist propaganda, and with playing on its connection with the university as if it had official status. Gilbert Murray, a supporter of Fight for Right but also a defender of many conscientious objectors and the freedom of the press, intervened to protest, gaining support from Bennett and Hardy. John George Butcher, Conservative Member of Parliament for the City of York, asked a question in Parliament about government advertising in the ''Magazine'', during November 1917. The parliamentary exchange had two Liberal Party politicians, William Pringle and Josiah Wedgwood, pointing out that the ''Magazine'' was the only way they could read German press comments.

The ''Cambridge Magazine'' continued in the post-war years, but wound down to quarterly publication before closing in 1922. When Claude McKay arrived in London in 1919 he had a letter of introduction to Ogden from Walter Fuller. He contacted Ogden in March 1920 and Ogden published his poetry in the ''Magazine''.

Author, bookseller and editor

Ogden published four books during WWI. One was ''The Problem of the Continuation School'' (1914), with Robert Hall Best (1843–1925) of the Best & Lloyd lighting company of Handsworth, and concerned industrial training. He also translated a related work by Georg Kerschensteiner (1854–1932) who had introduced him to Best, which appeared as ''The Schools and the Nation'' (1914). ''Militarism versus Feminism'' (1915, anonymous) was co-written with Mary Sargant Florence mother of Alix. ''Uncontrolled Breeding, or, Fecundity versus Civilization'' (1916) was a tract in favour of birth control, published under his pseudonym Adelyne More.

Ogden ran two bookshops in Cambridge as well as a gallery where he sold works of art by members of the Bloomsbury Group. One of his bookshops was looted on the day the First World War ended.

Ogden built up a position as editor for Kegan Paul, publishers in London. In 1920, he was one of the founders of the psychological journal ''Psyche'', and later took over the editorship; ''Psyche'' was initially the ''Psychic Research Quarterly'' set up by Walter Whately Smith"; the latter series included about 100 volumes after one decade. From its launch in 1924, he edited the "To-day and To-morrow" series, another extensive series running to about 150 volumes, of popular books in essay form with provocative titles. The first of the series after an intervention by Fredric Warburg was ''Daedalus; or, Science and the Future'' by J. B. S. Haldane, an extended version of a talk to the Heretics Society. Other series were "Science for You" and "Psyche Miniatures".

Language and philosophy

Ogden helped with the English translation of Wittgenstein's ''Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus''. The translation itself was the work of F. P. Ramsey; Ogden as a commissioning editor assigned the task of translation to Ramsey, supposedly on earlier experience of Ramsey's insight into another German text, of Ernst Mach. Ogden adopted the Latinate title now given to the work in English, with its nod to Baruch Spinoza's ''Tractatus Theologico-Politicus'', which is attributed to G. E. Moore.

Ogden's most durable work is his monograph (with I. A. Richards) titled ''The Meaning of Meaning'' (1923), which went into many editions. This book straddled the boundaries among linguistics, literary analysis, and philosophy. It drew attention to the significs of Victoria Lady Welby of whom Ogden was a disciple and the semiotics of Charles Sanders Peirce. A major step in the "linguistic turn" of 20th century British philosophy, ''The Meaning of Meaning'' set out principles for understanding the function of language and described the so-called semantic triangle. It included the inimitable phrase "The gostak distims the doshes."

Advocacy for Basic English

From 1925 until his death in 1957, the advocacy of Basic English became Ogden's primary activity. Basic English is an auxiliary international language of 850 words comprising a system that covers everything necessary for day-to-day purposes. These 850 words, together with its five combinatory rules, were designed to do the work of some 20,000 English words, which appealed to many of the leading communications philosophers and theorists of the time, including Otto Neurath and Willard C. Brinton. To promote Basic English, Ogden in 1927 founded the Orthological Institute, from ''orthology'', the abstract term he proposed for its work (see orthoepeia). Its headquarters were on King's Parade of a passage from a draft of '' Finnegans Wake''. In summer of that year ''Tales Told of Shem and Shaun'' had been published, an extract from the work as it then stood, and Ogden had been asked to supply an introduction. When Joyce was in London in August, Ogden approached him to do a reading for a recording. In 1932 Ogden published a translation of the ''Finnegans Wake'' passage into Basic English.

By 1943 the Institute had moved to Gordon Square in London.

Ogden was also a consultant with the International Auxiliary Language Association, which presented Interlingua in 1951. He furthermore was the editor for Kenneth Searight's book Sona (constructed language).

Personal life

Ogden collected a large number of books. His ''incunabula'', manuscripts, papers of the Brougham family, and Jeremy Bentham collection were purchased by University College London. The balance of his enormous personal library was purchased after his death by the University of California - Los Angeles.
Ogden died on 20 March 1957 in London.

Legacy

Although neither a trained philosopher nor an academic, Ogden had a material effect on British academic philosophy. ''The Meaning of Meaning'' enunciated a theory of emotivism. Ogden went on to edit as ''Bentham's Theory of Fictions'' (1932) a work of Jeremy Bentham, and had already translated in 1911 as ''The Philosophy of ‘As If’'' a work of Hans Vaihinger, both of which are regarded as precursors of the modern theory of fictionalism.

In 1973 Georg Henrik von Wright edited Wittgenstein's ''Letters to C.K. Ogden with Comments on the English Translation of the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus'', including correspondence with Ramsey.Nils-Eric Sahlin, ''The Philosophy of F. P. Ramsey'' (1990), p. 227.

See also

* Simple English
* Universal language

References

Further reading

*
*
Complete text

*
*
* , in
* Ogden, C. K., and Richards, I. A., 1949. ''The Meaning of Meaning: A Study of the Influence of Language upon Thought and of the Science of Symbolism'', 10th ed. With supplementary essays by Bronislaw Malinowski and F. G. Crookshank. Routledge & Kegan Paul. 1st ed., 1923.
* P. Sargant Florence and J. R. L. Anderson (editors) (1977), ''C. K. Ogden: A Collective Memoir''
* Damon Franke (2008), ''Modernist Heresies: British Literary History, 1883–1924'', particularly on Ogden and the Heretics Society.

External links

*
*
*
*

Ogden papers collected by his lawyer, Mark Haymon


*

Ogden Library
at University College London

Ogden Manuscript Collection
at University College London

{{DEFAULTSORT:Ogden, Charles Kay
1889 births
1957 deaths
20th-century English male writers
20th-century English non-fiction writers
20th-century English philosophers
20th-century essayists
20th-century linguists
20th-century translators
Alumni of Magdalene College, Cambridge
Analytic philosophers
British activists
British cultural critics
British ethicists
British semioticians
British social commentators
Constructed language creators
English activists
English logicians
English male non-fiction writers
English non-fiction writers
English social commentators
Epistemologists
History of linguistics
Interlinguistics
Linguists from England
Metaphysicians
Moral philosophers
Ontologists
People associated with University College London
People educated at Rossall School
People from Fleetwood
Philosophers of art
Philosophers of culture
Philosophers of education
Philosophers of ethics and morality
Philosophers of language
Philosophers of literature
Philosophers of logic
Philosophers of mind
Philosophers of psychology
Philosophers of social science
Philosophy writers
Political philosophers
Pragmatists
Social critics
Social philosophers
Writers about activism and social change