Gaza Temporary Pier

The Gaza floating pier was a floating dock facility created by the U.S. military after being proposed immediately before U.S. President Biden's 2024 State of the Union Address on March 7, 2024. It was in use between May 2024 and July 2024.

It was constructed by U.S. military forces based on ships offshore of the Gaza Strip, then connected to the shore by causeway, to enable the delivery of maritime cargo for humanitarian assistance to Gaza. The unloading point joins the Netzarim Corridor. The World Food Programme will be responsible for receiving and distributing the aid.

President Biden stated that Israel "must also do its part." He noted, "Humanitarian assistance cannot be a secondary consideration or a bargaining chip. Protecting and saving innocent lives has to be a priority."
Israel will inspect the humanitarian aid in Cyprus before shipping and again at checkpoints in Gaza when it is delivered off the pier. The pier can deliver 150 trucks of aid per day. After its collapse, it was dismissed by Stephen Walt as an expensive PR stunt to sidestep pressuring issues to open its border crossings.Stephen Walt
'Biden's Foreign-Policy Problem Is Incompetence,'
Foreign Policy 4 June 2024. The United States denied allegations that Israeli forces had used the Gaza floating pier during the Nuseirat refugee camp massacre or the rescue operation.

At its closure announcement on July 17, the pier had been operational for 20 days, delivering of aid. The pier had been dismantled three times because of high sea states.

Background

A blockade has been imposed on the movement of goods and people in and out of the Gaza Strip since Hamas's takeover in 2007, led by Israel and supported by Egypt. The blockade's current stated aim is to prevent the smuggling of weapons into Gaza; previously stated motivations have included exerting economic pressure on Hamas.

Attempts to bring in humanitarian aid by water into Gaza have been attempted multiple times and have ended with intervention by the Israeli military. In May 2010, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) participated in a military operation dubbed the Gaza flotilla raid against six civilian ships in international waters, resulting in contested events; nine passengers of the flotilla killed and thirty passengers and 10 IDF troops wounded. In July 2011, a second flotilla was planned by 22 NGOs to attempt to break the maritime blockade but did not take place. In the summer of 2015, a third flotilla was planned to break the blockade and set out from Sweden with multiple stops before being intercepted by the Israeli military in international waters and participants detained.

The Gaza Strip is experiencing a humanitarian crisis as a result of the Israel–Hamas war, which began after the Hamas attack on Israel on October 7, 2023. The crisis includes both a famine and a healthcare collapse. At the start of the war, Israel tightened its blockade of the Gaza Strip on October 9, 2023, with Israel's Defense Minister Yoav Gallant announced a "total blockade", blocking the entry of food, water, medicine, fuel, and electricity. This has resulted in significant shortages of fuel, food, medication, water, and essential medical supplies. After receiving pressure from U.S. President Biden, Gallant changed his position of a complete blockade and a deal was made on 19 October for Israel and Egypt to allow aid into Gaza.

In January 2024, Israeli authorities blocked 56% of humanitarian aid to northern Gaza. On February 9, 2024, UNRWA's director Philippe Lazzarini reported that Israel had blocked food for 1.1 million Palestinians in Gaza.

Outline plan

During October and November 2023, Cypriot President Nikos Christodoulides developed the maritime aid corridor idea, named the Amalthea Initiative, with European Union leaders at a humanitarian conference in Paris and elsewhere. On November 5, 2023, U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken visited Cyprus to discuss the maritime aid corridor.

On November 20, 2023, Christodoulides said Cyprus was ready to ship large quantities of humanitarian aid to Gaza when a pause in fighting was declared. He noted that shallow-draft vessels could be used in the short term to ferry aid, and in the medium term, a floating dock off Gaza could be used. He had regularly contacted the Israeli Prime Minister about the proposal, but getting authorization required careful negotiations. An Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesperson said Israel was "definitely in favor of the project."

''The Jerusalem Post'' reported that a senior Israeli diplomatic source said the plan was based on a proposal for a maritime route to Gaza via Cyprus for humanitarian assistance initiated by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in collaboration with President Biden on October 22, 2023. ''The Jerusalem Post'' reported that on October 31, Netanyahu outlined this proposal to Cypriot President Christodoulides. On January 19, 2024, Netanyahu proposed to Biden that a team should be set up to explore the proposal, including inspecting all goods transported. On December 20, Israeli Foreign Minister Eli Cohen said, "The creation of a maritime corridor to Gaza will help Israel's economic disengagement from the Strip", following a meeting with Cypriot Foreign Minister Constantinos Kombos to discuss the maritime aid corridor. Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman had proposed a similar plan to Cyprus in 2010 when it was called the Lieberman Proposal, and again in 2018 when he was Defense Minister. In 2021, Israeli Foreign Minister Yair Lapid proposed the Gaza Development Plan which included a sea port on an artificial island under Israeli security control off Gaza.

The pier was designed to allow delivery of thousands of tons of food aid at a time, equivalent to "hundreds of truckloads", via barges embarked in Cyprus and screened for contraband there by Cyprus Police.

Over 1,000 U.S. military personnel were involved in the construction of the pier and long Joint Logistics Over-The-Shore (JLOTS) type modular causeway over 60 days. The part of the JLOTS system included in this project is a large floating modular unloading platform secured by sea anchors stationed about three miles offshore, allowing supplies to be then transferred by lighters to a modular causeway off the shore. The project, known internally as the Blue Beach Plan, was partially developed by an advisory group called Fogbow, co-founded by Michael Mulroy, a former deputy assistant secretary of defense, and Sam Mundy, a retired Marine Lt. Gen. The plan includes potentially dredging a corridor on a private beachfront to aid unloading. The goal is to allow barges to approach the shore for aid distribution onto trucks. The military pier, once operational, could provide another way for aid delivery. The Joint Logistics Over-The-Shore (JLOTS) was not required under the original Blue Beach Plan.

Fogbow plan

The Fogbow plan is a strategy created by the American advisory group Fogbow, founded by Michael Mulroy and Sam Mundy and managed by former US Military, Intelligence, and United Nations personnel, to establish a maritime corridor. According to the initial Fogbow plan, a significant portion of aid will be transported using Masri trucks to the Gaza Industrial Zone, a specified area within the Gaza sector. Additionally, Fogbow aims to set up a new beach landing site to deliver humanitarian aid. This initiative seeks to improve aid distribution by increasing the number of drop zones along the coast, making it easier to transport aid to remote areas that are difficult to reach by typical overland routes. The IDF agreed to provide security assistance to Fogbow. To support the implementation of this plan, funding will be directed through a recently established foundation called the "Maritime Humanitarian Aid Foundation."

As of June 2024, Fogbow has delivered over a thousand pallets of food.

Temporary interim jetty

On March 12, prior to construction of the U.S. pier, a barge "testing" the delivery route, operated by Spanish charity Proactiva Open Arms and loaded with 200 tons of food from World Central Kitchen, left the port of Larnaca in Cyprus for Gaza. A jetty for unloading the barge was built at a location that was initially "not disclosed for security reasons", but later discerned to be south of Gaza City () by journalists using commercial satellite imagery or talking to local construction workers. The Cyprus foreign minister, Constantinos Kombos, said on March 13 that the US pier and the food route out of Larnaca would become a single operation. The first barge arrived and began to be unloaded at the World Central Kitchen jetty on March 15.

Construction and route history

On March 9, 2024, the U.S. Army support ship '' General Frank S. Besson'' was sent from Norfolk to begin pier construction. Four more ships with 500 Army troops left on March 12. The ships included landing craft USAV ''Wilson Wharf'', USAV ''Matamoros'' and USAV ''Monterrey''; and ''Besson''-class support ship USAV ''SP4 James A. Loux''. In addition to Army, Naval Beach Group 1 from San Diego, and from an East Coast maritime reserve force were assigned to assist in construction. ''Roy P. Benavidez'' departed from Virginia on March 21.

The Senate Intelligence and Foreign Relations Committee chairpersons Mark Warner and Ben Cardin (both Democrats) requested briefings from the Biden administration on the force protection plan for the U.S. units participating in the construction. On March 28, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs told the press that Israel would be providing security during the installation of the pier.

By April 5, ''Besson'' and ''Benavidez'' had reached the Mediterranean. By April 17, ''Besson'', ''Benavidez'' and three other Army vessels had reached Crete. During April the IDF prepared the concrete walled landing site which included a storage zone for aid awaiting movement by trucking contractors into Gaza.
The Royal Navy participated in the effort; RFA ''Cardigan Bay'' was used by American soldiers and sailors as a dormitory.

On April 26, construction of the pier by US forces began, and satellite photos published a few days later showed ''Benavidez'' building the dock from the Gaza shore.

On May 1, a Pentagon spokesperson said that the floating pier was complete, and the causeway was under construction, with the total project more than half completed. On May 7, it was reported that the causeway had been assembled offshore and was ready to be moved and connected to the shore.

A Centurion C-RAM (Counter-Rocket, Artillery, and Mortar) and the M-LIDS anti-drone systems were installed in May by the shore-attached section of the pier for force protection.

On May 16, the U.S. military announced that the causeway had been anchored and connected to the Gaza shoreline. Trucks began delivering aid off of the pier on May 17. On May 21, a Pentagon spokesperson said that 569 tonnes of aid had crossed the temporary pier but had so far not been distributed, and that moving forward on "safety and security" for humanitarian aid organization workers was critical.

The U.S. military cost estimate to build the pier and operate it for 90 days was $320 million, roughly double the initial estimate.

Damage and repair

On May 25, 2024, the U.S. military announced that four boats that were part of the pier's support system broke off from the structure following choppy waters. The four boats became beached, with the military stating that the structure would remain operational. It also added that efforts were underway to retrieve the four vessels.

On May 28, 2024, the U.S. military suspended aid delivery to Gaza after the floating pier was damaged by bad weather. The Pentagon confirmed that a portion of the causeway was damaged and broken off, and must be repaired before being returned to use. Spokeswoman Sabrina Singh stated that the pier will be removed from the sea with help from the Israeli Navy and undergo over a week of repairs in Ashdod before returning. Fogbow is directly involved with the JLOTS in moving the pier to and from the safe harbor in Ashdod.

At the beginning of June, the Pentagon estimated that up to the suspension over 1,000 tonnes of aid had been delivered to shore, 900 tonnes of which had reached UN warehouses.

The repaired pier was reinstalled by June 7.
Around June 18, 2024, after being operative for ten days, US officials indicated that the pier could be dismantled by early July. On 22 June, parts of the pier washed up on Frishman Beach in Tel Aviv. The US said on 28 June that they were for the third time moving the pier due to weather conditions and said that it may not be restored.

The pier constructed by the U.S. military to deliver humanitarian aid to Gaza was scheduled for reinstallation on July 10, 2024, for temporary use. As of July 11, the pier was authorized for operation through the end of the month of July, with possible extension until weather makes it untenable. On July 11, US officials confirmed that the pier would soon cease operations.

Shutdown

Vice Admiral Brad Cooper announced on July 17 that " e maritime surge mission involving the pier is complete". Cooper said the pier had been operational for 20 days, delivering of aid. The remaining aid in Cyprus will be delivered to the port of Ashdod in Israel with the assistance of the US military, then delivered to Gaza by trucks via the Erez Crossing.

Alleged role in Nuseirat attack

On June 8, 2024, Israel initiated a military action that rescued 4 hostages and killed 274 Palestinians (mostly civilians), according to Gaza Health Authorities. While the United States acknowledged assisting Israel in the operation, it denied that the floating pier was used. A video emerged on social media showing an Israeli Black Hawk helicopter close to the pier picking up IDF soldiers and hostages. The video also shows military equipment, including a US counter-drone system, on the pier.

The Popular Resistance Committees in Gaza released a statement in which it "confirms the participation of American enemy forces stationed on the floating dock" to conduct an attack on the Nuseira refugee camp. Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor said IDF didn't just evacuate using the pier and that it was likely that the IDF entered into Gaza using the pier as well. United States officials told CBS News reporters that the video appearing to show the helicopter taking off from the beach near the pier, showed the helicopter landing south of the facility and not within the cordoned off area of the pier.

Shortly after the rescue operation, it was announced that the United Nations World Food Program would pause all of its work with the pier, until a security review and review of how the IDF may have utilized the pier was completed. Due to this, humanitarian aid has been piling up on the beach, as the UN works to transfer the aid to warehouses and local aid teams within Gaza.

Reactions

On May 17, 2024, the spokesperson for UNOCHA stated that getting aid into Gaza "cannot and should not depend on a floating dock far from where needs are most acute". On May 21, the UN stated aid had not entered Gaza from the pier in two days, and that it was at risk of failure unless Israel provided safe operating conditions for humanitarian organizations. The White House National Security communications adviser stated, "This temporary pier is not enough... Clearly not enough is being done to open up the crossings. That's just unacceptable". In June 2024, the media office for Hamas government in the Gaza Strip criticized the pier, stating only 120 trucks had come through it and that it was "useless".

Stephen Walt criticized the whole operation for its cost – after the damage expected to run into hundreds of millions – arguing that the project arose from the Biden administration's reluctance to pressure Israel into opening its borders to allow relief aid in sufficient quantities to overcome the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and sustain the population.
Military experts noted that JLOTS (Joint Logistics Over-the-Shore) type piers were not designed to operate in rough seas and were last used in Haiti in 2010. Since then, relatively little investment has been directed to the technology; the watercraft are old, and funds for repairs have been scarce, with available craft rusting. Firms that had earlier supplied parts had now gone out of business. One military source said that the Army has long underestimated the difficulty of constructing and maintaining a floating pier. The administration itself admits that the best way to supply Gaza is through land routes.Haley Britzky, Priscilla Alvarez, Kylie Atwood and Kayla Tausche
High seas and low maintenance: Inside the turbulent US effort to build a pier into Gaza
CNN, June 1, 2024

The ''Financial Times'' estimated less than 600 trucks of aid were delivered via the pier, about two days of aid to Gaza before the war, calling the pier a "colossal failure".

At a press conference on July 11, US President Biden said he was disappointed with the failures in providing aid through the Gaza floating pier.

See also

* Port of Gaza
* Gaza Seaport plans

References

Further reading

*
*
*
*
*
*

External links

"Pentagon Briefs on Fourth Aid Airdrop and Off-Shore Pier to Deliver Aid Into Gaza"
excerpt of press briefing by Major General Patrick S. Ryder, USAF, March 8, 2024
*
*
{{Israel–Hamas war

Transport buildings and structures in the State of Palestine
2024 in the Gaza Strip
Piers
Military engineering of the United States
Gaza Strip in the Israel–Hamas war
State of Palestine–United States relations
Gaza Strip humanitarian crisis
United States Navy in the 21st century
Closed military installations of the United States