Café Lafayette

Hotel Lafayette (formerly Hotel Martin) was a hotel located on University Place in the Greenwich Village neighborhood of Manhattan, New York City. It was founded by Raymond Orteig in 1902. The hotel was particularly known for its restaurant, the Café Lafayette, and drew its clientele from New York's French expatriates and the bohemians of Greenwich Village. John Reed described the hotel as "the real link between the old Village and the new,
since it was the cradle of artistic life in New York." After Orteig's retirement in 1929, the 65-room hotel and its restaurant were run by his sons until its closure in 1949. The building was demolished in the late 1950s.

History

The Hotel Lafayette began its life as Hotel Martin. In 1883 Jean-Baptiste Martin, who had previously run a hotel in Panama bought a small pension on University Place run by Eugene Larru and opened it under the name Hotel de Panama. Three years later he changed its name to Hotel Martin. According to Martin, he decided on the name change because: "Panama gave people a bad impression. They associated it with fever and Spaniards, and neither were popular." In the ensuing years Martin took over the adjoining houses and built extensions until the small pension became a large building.

A late 1880s advertisement for the Martin described it as "the only first-class French hotel in New York." In addition to the artists and writers of Greenwich Village, the Martin's clients over the years included the opera singers Jean and Édouard de Reszke, Pol Plançon and Nelly Melba as well as the painter Théobald Chartran, the violinist Eugène Ysaÿe, and the French statesman Jules Cambon.

At the turn of the 20th century, Martin decided to open a restaurant on 26th Street near Madison Square Park and in 1902 sold the hotel's lease to Raymond Orteig who had been the head-waiter at the Café Martin. Orteig immediately renamed it Hotel Lafayette after General Lafayette, the French aristocrat and military officer who had fought in the American Revolutionary War. However, for many years the Lafayette remained informally known as "Old Martin's".

Orteig retained the Hotel Martin's French restaurant which had its own entrance on the corner of University Place and 9th Street. Rechristened Café Lafayette, it had a tile floor and marble-topped tables, some of which were placed outside on warm days and was stocked with foreign newspapers and board games. Adjoining it were a more formal restaurant where an orchestra played in the evening and several private dining rooms. Orteig subscribed to the Paris weekly ''Brasserie Universelle'' and introduced its latest dishes in his restaurant. The Lafayette was particularly known for its mixed hors d'oeuvres, squab in casserole, filet mignon in bearnaise sauce, and pears flamed in a secret blend of French liqueurs.

A bust of General Lafayette by Houdon was displayed in the hotel lobby, and from the late 1920s, the foyer was decorated with memorabilia from Charles Lindbergh's 1927 flight in the ''Spirit of St. Louis'' from New York to Paris. It was the first solo transatlantic flight and the first non-stop flight between North America and the European mainland. In the process Lindbergh won the Orteig Prize. Raymond Orteig first became interested in aviation during World War I and its immediate aftermath when the Lafayette became a favorite gathering place for American and French airmen. The American flag which Lindbergh had carried on his flight had hung on the wall of the Café Lafayette until November 1941. At that point Orteig's son moved it to a private office in the hotel, explaining to '' The New York Times'': "Too many pros and cons. Particularly for a restaurant. The flag hung there since 1927 when Lindbergh was an aviator and everyone was proud of him. But now he's talking politics. And lately when people noticed the flag a discussion began."

After his retirement in 1929, Orteig's three sons, Raymond Jr., Jean Blaise, and Evariste ran the Lafayette until its closure in 1949. Their father died in 1939.

Closure

The Lafayette's building was owned by the Sailors' Snug Harbor Trust. When the building's lease came up for renewal in 1949, the Orteig brothers were unable to negotiate terms with the Snug Harbor trustees which would have kept the Layfayette economically viable. The hotel and its restaurant closed on 31 March 1949, when the last dinner was served at the Café Lafayette. Among the last hotel guests to check out were the author Elliot Paul and the artist Niles Spencer. Among the last-night diners who had filled the café were actor Winston Ross, cartoonist Dorothy McKay, producer Gilbert Miller, and Lady Hubert Wilkins who was writing an article on the Lafayette's closure for Australian Consolidated Press. That evening several of the café's habitués bought items from the hotel, including its barber pole. The remainder of the Lafayette's fixtures and furnishings were sold during a three-day auction which began on 26 April.

In October 1949, New York University Law School took out a short-term lease on the old Lafayette building to rehouse tenants from a nearby apartment house which they were planning to demolish to make way for a new law center. The Lafayette building itself was demolished in 1957 to make way for a 12-storey apartment building.

Notes

References

{{reflist, 30em, refs=

Chapin, Anna Alice (1917)
''Greenwich Village''
pp. 200–205. Dodd, Mead

MacClennan, Nancy (1 April 1949)
"Lafayette's Doors Shut On 47 years"
'' New York Times''. Retrieved 20 September 2018 {{subscription.

Batterberry, Michael and Batterberry, Ariane Ruskin (1999)
''On the Town in New York: The Landmark History of Eating, Drinking, and Entertainments from the American Revolution to the Food Revolution''
pp. 226–228; 315. Routledge. {{ISBN, 0415920205

Bak, Richard (2011). ''The Big Jump - Lindbergh and the Great Atlantic Air Race'', pp. 24–28. John Wiley & Sons. {{ISBN, 1118043782

Cole, Wayne S. (1974). ''Charles A. Lindbergh and the Battle Against American Intervention in World War II'', P. 131. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich. {{ISBN, 0151181683

s.n. (15 November 1941)
Orteig Shelves Lindbergh Relic"
'' New York Times''. Retrieved 20 September 2018 {{subscription.

s.n. (8 June 1939)
"Raymond Orteig, Hotel Man, Dies"
'' New York Times''. Retrieved 20 September 2018 {{subscription.

s.n. (27 April 1949)
"Auction Bidders Throng Lafayette"
'' New York Times''. Retrieved 20 September 2018 {{subscription.

Cox, Jim (2012)
''Musicmakers of Network Radio: 24 Entertainers, 1926–1962''
p. 271. McFarland. {{ISBN, 0786489626

Horn, Maurice and Marschall, Richard (1980). "McKay, Dorothy". ''The World Encyclopedia of Cartoons'', p. 375. Chelsea House. {{ISBN, 0877540888

s.n. (3 October 1949)
"N.Y.U. Takes Over Lafayette Hotel"
'' New York Times''. Retrieved 20 September 2018 {{subscription.

"Bohemian Flair Fades in Village"
'' New York Times''. Retrieved 20 September 2018 {{subscription.

s.n. (1903)
''Where and How to Dine in New York''
pp. 151–152. Lewis, Scribner & Co.

External links

with copies of menus from the original Hotel Martin restaurant as well as Martin's later establishment on 26th street (theamericanmenu.com)
Hotel Lafayette menu from 14 July 1925
(The New York Public Library digital collection)
Letter on Hotel Lafayette stationery
from Aaron Copland to Serge Koussevitzky, October 5, 1936 ( Library of Congress)
Photograph of habitués of the Cafe Lafayette on the day it closed
carrying the barber pole which had stood in front of the hotel's barbershop. Photo by Morris Warman for the ''New York Herald Tribune'' ( Museum of the City of New York)

Defunct hotels in Manhattan
Hotels established in 1902
Hotels disestablished in 1949
Demolished buildings and structures in Manhattan
Buildings and structures demolished in 1957
Demolished hotels in New York City
Defunct French restaurants in Manhattan