Silent Parade

The Negro Silent Protest Parade, commonly known as the Silent Parade, was a political protest in New York City on July 28, 1917. The primary objective of the march was to draw national attention to the widespread racial violence and entrenched systemic discrimination endured by African Americans. It was organized in direct response to a series of racially motivated attacks in 1916 and 1917, including the East St. Louis massacre and lynchings in Waco and Memphis.

The parade was organized by a coalition of African American groups, led by the recently formed NAACP. Starting at 57th Street, the parade route proceeded down Fifth Avenue, ending at Madison Square. It was a silent procession, with an estimated 8,000 to 15,000 African American participants marching in protest, accompanied by a muffled drum beat.

The event was widely publicized and drew attention to violence against African Americans. Organizers hoped the parade would prompt the federal government to enact anti-lynching legislation, but President Woodrow Wilson did not act on their demands. Federal legislation was required because Southern states often refused to prosecute lynchings under existing state statutes that outlawed murder, kidnapping, and assault. The federal government would not pass an anti-lynching law until 2022, when the Emmett Till Antilynching Act was passed.

Background

Lynching

Lynchings are extrajudicial killings carried out—often under the pretense of punishing alleged crimes—by individuals or groups lacking legal or law enforcement authority. These acts frequently involve mob violence and are commonly driven by racial animus. In the United States, documented instances of lynching date back to the 1830s. Lynching was a brutal manifestation of racism directed at African Americans, occurring alongside systemic forms of discrimination such as disenfranchisement and segregation. The frequency of lynchings steadily increased after the Civil War (18611865) peaking around 1892. They remained common into the early 1900s, with a notable spike in 1915 following the founding of the Second Ku Klux Klan.

Southern states often failed to prosecute lynchings under existing state laws prohibiting murder, kidnapping, and assault. Federal authorities lacked the legal means to intervene, as no federal statutes at the time specifically criminalized lynching. In response, anti-lynching activists in the early 1900s advocated for new federal legislation to empower federal prosecutors to take action when state officials refused to do so.

The Silent Parade took place at a time when the anti-lynching movement was gaining momentum, led in large part by the NAACP. Founded in 1909, the NAACP sought to advance equal rights for African Americans. Two years before the Silent Parade, the NAACP's magazine ''The Crisis'' published an article titled "The Lynching Industry", which contained a year-by-year tabulation of 2,732 lynchings, spanning the years 1884 to 1914. During the year leading up to the parade, ''The Crisis''edited by W. E. B. Du Boispublished a series of articles documenting specific lynchings, including: a group lynching of six African Americans in Lee County, Georgia; the lynching of Jesse Washington, a mentally impaired 17-year-old African American, in Waco, Texas; "The Waco Horror" was an eight page supplement at the end of the magazine, with its own page numbering, pages 1 to 8.
and the lynching of Ell Persons in Memphis, Tennessee.
Anger over these lynchings was one of the motivations for the Silent Parade.

World War I

In April 1917, one month before the East St. Louis massacre, the United States declared war on the German Empire and joined the Allied Powers of World War I. The mobilization effort dominated the headlines in the United States. African American soldiers of that era were treated as second-class citizens, and were segregated from white troops. African Americans had mixed feelings about the war: some recognized military service as an opportunity to demonstrate their worth; others viewed it as yet another situation where they would be exploited by their country. Some African American leaders, such as Du Bois, voiced pro-war sentiments, and encouraged African Americans to join the military.

East St. Louis massacre

The Silent Parade was triggered by a series of riots in East St. Louis between May and July 1917. The rioting, by white residents, originated when the mostly white employees of the Aluminum Ore Company voted in Spring 1917 for a labor strike and the company recruited hundreds of African Americans to replace them.

The ensuing racial tensions led to widespread violence, with an estimated 39 to 200 African Americans killed by white people. In addition, hundreds were injured, and thousands were displaced from their homes. Nine white Americans were killed.

Du Bois and activist Martha Gruening visited the city after the massacre and spoke with witnesses and survivors. In September 1917, they published a photo-essay in ''The Crisis'' that described the riots in graphic terms. After the riots, many African Americans were discouraged, and felt that it was unlikely that the United States would ever permit African Americans to enjoy full citizenship and equal rights. The brutality of the attacks by mobs of white people, coupled with the failure of police to protect the African American community, led to renewed calls for African American civil rights from leaders such as Du Bois, Hubert Harrison, and Marcus Garvey. In response, the NAACP began planning a public protest.

The parade

Planning

James Weldon Johnson, the Field Secretary of the NAACP, worked with a group of influential community leaders from St. Philip's Church in New York to determine how best to protest the recent violence against African Americans.

Initial plans considered a protest at Carnegie Hall, but after the East St. Louis riots, Johnson proposed a silent march. The idea of a silent protest was based on a suggestion made in 1916 by Oswald Garrison Villard during a NAACP Conference. The Silent Parade was not the nation's first silent march: Villard's mother, anti-war activist Fanny Garrison Villard, had organized a silent march in 1914 to protest the war.

Johnson orchestrated the march, and his use of silencewhich contrasted sharply with the brutality of lynchings and race riotsserved to emphasize the message. Silence as a rhetorical tool was also employed by the Silent Sentinels suffrage protest group, which staged silent protests in front of the White House starting in January 1917.

The parade was organized by a committee composed of representatives from the NAACP, churches, and businesses. Two prominent members of the New York clergy served as executives of the parade: the president was Hutchens Chews Bishop, rector of the city's oldest African American Episcopal parish; and the secretary was Charles Martin, founder of the Fourth Moravian Church. Frederick Asbury Cullen served as vice president. Parade marshals included nationally prominent African Americans J. Rosamond Johnson, Christopher Payne, Everard W. Daniel, James Weldon Johnson, and John E. Nail. Du Bois marched within the group of parade leaders.

While the organizers of the Silent Parade did not explicitly exclude white people from marching (many NAACP leaders were white), no white people participated because the parade was intended to be a demonstration of African American solidarity and unity.

A week before the parade, an announcement in the African American newspaper ''The New York Age'' described it as a "mute but solemn protest against the atrocities and discrimination practiced against the race in various parts of the country." The official name of the parade was the Negro Silent Protest Parade, although some contemporary sources referred to it as the Negro Silent Parade. Men, women, and children alike were invited to take part. It was hoped that ten thousand people would participate, and that African Americans in other cities might hold their own parades. During the week before the parade, major newspapers in several states published articles announcing the march.

The goal of the parade was to protest lynching in particular, and violence against African Americans in general. A specific objective was to urge President Woodrow Wilson to support the enactment of federal anti-lynching legislation. Organizers prepared a leaflet which was distributed before the parade as an invitation, and during the parade to bystanders. The leaflet contained a section titled "Why We March" which read, in part:

The leaflet was signed by Martin "Yours in righteous indignation."

The march

In the midst of a record heat wave in New York City on Saturday, July 28, an estimated 8,000 to 15,000 African Americans marched in silent protest. The march began at 57th Street, and proceeded down Fifth Avenue, ending at Madison Square. Mounted police escorted the parade.

Many marchers carried signs and banners that described contributions of African Americans to American society, or gave reasons for the protest. Some signs appealed directly to President Wilson. One banner displayed an African American family in the ruins of East St. Louis, pleading with Wilson to bring democracy to the U.S. before he brought it to Europe. Police deemed the banner in "bad taste", so parade organizers withdrew the banner before the parade began.

Several hundred children led the parade, followed by several thousand women dressed in white, then men. The men wore formal attire or military uniforms, and they marched in rows. Some of the men carried drums, which were muffled, and beat a slow cadence.

The placement of children and women at the front of the parade drew attention to the profound impact that lynching and racism had on African American families. Following the march, ''The Crisis'' published several photographs of the parade, all but one of which featured women and children. Their refined attire visually highlighted the connection between respectability and civil rights. Visual cues also made a connection between the military service of African Americans and their demands for equal rights. Some of the men wore their U.S. Army uniforms and carried placards drawing attention to the fact thatjust a few months before the parade African Americans were among the first U.S. soldiers to arrive in France after the U.S. joined WWI. A large sign carried at the front of the women's section read “The first blood for American independence was shed by a NegroCrispus Attucks.”

Over 20,000 spectators of all races looked on from both sides of Fifth Avenue, including an estimated 15,000 African Americans. African American boy scouts handed out leaflets describing why they were marching. Some white people stopped to listen to marchers explain the reasons for the march, while other white bystanders expressed support for the parade. Many spectators were moved by the spectacle; in his autobiography, organizer James Johnson wrote "the streets of New York have witnessed many strange sights, but I judge, never one stranger than this; among the watchers were those with tears in their eyes."

Legacy

Aftermath

The protest was widely reported in newspapers across the country, and successfully raised public awareness of the lynchings and other acts of violence committed against African Americans. ''The New York Times'' described the parade in an article published the following day:

Historian Patricia Sullivan described it as "one of the most stunning protest marches in the annals of the black freedom struggle." The parade was the first large, exclusively African American protest in New York. Media coverage of the march helped to counter the dehumanization of African Americans in the United States: the demeanor and appearance of the marchers was dignified, civilized, and respectable. The ''New York Age'' described the parade as " e coming together of all classes of Negroes to further a common cause”, noting that that several disparate groups of black people marched in unity, including Haitians and West Indians.

The parade and its coverage depicted the NAACP as well-organized and efficient, and helped increase the visibility of the NAACP among both white and black people. The march sparked a revival of the New York branch of the NAACP: initially established in 1911, the branch had become dormant by 1916, but was reactivated in November 1917.

President Wilson

Marchers hoped to persuade President Wilson to implement anti-lynching legislation and support African American civil rights. Four days after the Silent Parade, a group of NAACP leaders traveled to Washington D.C. for a prearranged appointment with Wilson. Upon arrival at the White House, the group was told that Wilson was unable to meet with them due to another appointment. They left a petition they had prepared for Wilson, which reminded him of African Americans serving in World War I and asked him to take steps to prevent lynchings in the future. Two weeks later, Wilson met with a smaller delegation from the NAACP and listened to their concerns. Eleven months later, in July 1918, Wilson issued a written statement discouraging mob violence, but it fell short of calling for anti-lynching legislation. Discrimination against African Americans significantly increased during the Wilson presidency (19131921) as a result of Wilson's policy of segregating the federal government workforce.

Impact on lynching

The annual number of African American lynchings increased following the parade and did not decline below the 1917 level until 1923. Lynchings persisted in the United States at least into the 1960s. In 1918, the Dyer Anti-Lynching Bill was introduced in Congress, but it failed to become law, suffering the same fate as nearly 200 anti-lynching bills that were introduced between the end of the Civil War and the civil rights movement. The Civil Rights Act of 1968 created new federal crimes for violent acts based on the race of the victim. In 2022, Congress passed the Emmett Till Antilynching Act, which extended existing federal hate crime laws to encompass any members of a mob who conspired to injure a victim.

Subsequent silent marches

After the Silent Parade, James Johnson sent letters to all NAACP branches, suggesting that they organize similar marches. Three months after the Silent Parade, a smaller version of the march with 1,800 African Americanstook place in Providence, Rhode Island, in October 1917. After the Dyer Anti-Lynching Bill was introduced in Congress, two silent marches were organized by African Americans to show support, including one on June 14, 1922 in Washington, where about 5,000 people marched in front of the White House and the Capitol holding signs supporting the anti-lynching legislation. In the same month, female members of the NAACP in Newark, New Jersey, organized a similar silent parade.

During WWII, the African American advocacy group March on Washington Movement organized a march in Washingtonmodeled on the Silent Paradeprotesting the execution of Odell Waller and segregation in the armed forces. Seventy-two years after the Silent Parade, another NAACP-sponsored silent march took place in Washington DC on August 26, 1989, to protest recent Supreme Court decisions which restricted affirmative action programs. The U.S. Park Service estimated over 35,000 people participated. After two African American transexual women were killed in 2020, a protest was organized in Brooklyn, drawing thousands of attendees; organizers used the Silent Parade as inspiration, and asked protesters to wear white and remain silent for the initial part of the demonstration.

100th anniversary

Several events commemorated the hundredth anniversary of the Silent Parade, on July 28, 2017. The Google Doodle for that day depicted the Silent Parade, and linked to the parade's Wikipedia articlemany people reported that the Doodle was the first time they learned about the march. In East St. Louis, a series of events were held to commemorate the 1917 riots. Around 300 people marched from the Southern Illinois University Edwardsville Higher Learning Center to the Eads Bridge. The marchers reenacted the 1917 parade, walking in silence, with many women in white and men wearing black suits.

A group of artists, along with the NAACP, reenacted the silent march in New York on the evening of July 28, 2017. The event, with around 100 people and many participants wearing white, was not able to march down Fifth Avenue because the city would not grant access due to Trump Tower's location on that street. The commemoration took place on Sixth Avenue instead, and the group held up portraits of contemporary victims of violence by both police and vigilantes in the United States.

References

Notes

Citations

Sources

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

* This article describes the 1836 lynching of African American Francis McIntosh in St. Louis.

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

* Discussion of state versus federal prosecution is throughout the entire article, but an overview is on pages 777795.

Further reading

*

*

*

*

External links

* Collection of photos of the Silent Parade.

{{authority control, state=collapsed

1917 in New York City
1917 protests
1910s in Manhattan
African-American history between emancipation and the civil rights movement
African-American history in New York City
Anti-lynching movement
Articles containing video clips
Civil rights protests in the United States
History of African-American civil rights
July 1917 in the United States
Lynching in the United States
NAACP
Presidency of Woodrow Wilson
Protest marches in New York City
Racially motivated violence against African Americans
Silence
United States home front during World War I