It's Different For Girls

"It’s Different for Girls" is a song by Joe Jackson appearing on his 1979 album, '' I'm the Man''. The song has since become one of his most successful singles, notably being the highest charting Joe Jackson single in the UK. Covers have been recorded and released by several artists.

Background

"It's Different for Girls" contained lyrics that feature Jackson "deliberately turn ngclichés on their head" in that, while originally sounding as if the song would suggest that the male protagonist was looking for sex and his female partner was looking for love, the opposite is revealed to be the case. Jackson later said on the song's lyrics:

Taken from the Gold-certified 1979 album '' I'm the Man'', "It's Different for Girls" was Joe Jackson's biggest UK chart single, peaking at #5 in the UK Singles Chart and #101 in ''Billboard''. The song was backed with another track from ''I'm the Man'', "Friday," in Britain, but in America, a live cover of the Chuck Berry song "Come On" was used instead.

Other appearances

Apart from appearing as a single and on the album ''I'm the Man'', "It's Different for Girls" has also appeared on other Joe Jackson albums. A live version appeared on '' Live 1980/86'' in 1987, having been recorded on Jackson's ''Big World'' tour in 1986. A different live version appeared on the 2000 album '' Summer in the City: Live in New York''.

A new studio recording of the song by Jackson, slightly retitled "Different For Girls" and recorded as a duet with Joy Askew, was included on the 12-inch vinyl and CD formats of Jackson's 1991 single " Stranger than Fiction". On the '' Laughter and Lust'' tour in 1991, it was performed as a duet with Mindy Jostyn, and their performance of the song at Sydney was included on the 1992 release ''Laughter & Lust Live''.

The original version of the song was also included on Jackson's 1990 compilation '' Stepping Out: The Very Best of Joe Jackson'' and again on the 1997 compilation ''This Is It! (The A&M Years 1979–1989)''. "Come On" was released as a bonus track on the 2001 reissue of ''I'm the Man'' - prior to this it had only been available on ''Propaganda'', a 1979 A&M records sampler notable for live tracks from Joe Jackson and The Police.

In 1999, it was featured on the soundtrack of the MTV film ''200 Cigarettes''.

Composition

The song opens with a simple repeated two-note pattern on guitar which is quickly joined by a pulse on bass and drums. The first section of the verse remains quiet, with these instruments and the singer's voice being the main components. In the second section of the verse the dynamics change, with two strident beats on the lyrics "She said", and then drop back down to a quieter chorus driven by a slow arpeggiated guitar pattern, over which the vocal floats in a more complex melody, before returning to the original two-note guitar and bass pulse of the introduction.

Critical reception

Upon its release, David Hepworth of ''Smash Hits'' described "It's Different for Girls" as "a very good song but a mite too sprawling and unfocused to be much of a hit". James Belsey of the ''Bristol Evening Post'' picked it as the newspaper's "single of the week" and noted the "attractive sound" and "nicely observed lyrics". He concluded it was "by far the best single release so far from the talented Joe Jackson". In the US, ''Billboard'' wrote, "Though the lyrics may be scathing, the instrumentation is laidback and backup singers provide nice harmonies." ''Record World'' called it "a power pop ballad with echoing vocals and keyboards that carry Jackson's thoughtfully poignant message about male/female roles."

In 2007, ''Freaky Trigger'' ranked the song at number 52 in its list of "The Top 100 Songs of All Time". ''Glide Magazine'' ranked it as Jackson's 5th best song.

Personnel

*Joe Jackson – vocals
*Gary Sanford – guitar
*Graham Maby – bass, vocals
*David Houghton – drums, vocals

Charts

Cover versions

Siskin version

"It's Different for Girls" was covered by English duo Siskin, as their debut single in 2008. It is the group's only cover version to date.

Personnel

*Galen Ayers - guitar, vocals
*Kirsty Newton - keyboards, bass, vocals

Other versions

*In 2008, The Feeling released a cover of the song as a B side to their single Without You, the second single from their second studio album Join with us.
*In 2019, Trevor Horn performed an orchestral arrangement of the song on his album '' Trevor Horn Reimagines the Eighties'', featuring Marillions Steve Hogarth on lead vocals.
*In January 2022, the Smile, comprising Radiohead members Thom Yorke and Jonny Greenwood and drummer Tom Skinner, performed the song at two of their debut shows in London.

References

{{authority control

Joe Jackson (musician) songs
A&M Records singles
1979 singles
2008 debut singles
Songs written by Joe Jackson (musician)
Song recordings produced by David Kershenbaum
1979 songs