"WHO IS A JEW?" (
Hebrew : מיהו יהודי pronounced ) is
a basic question about
Jewish identity and considerations of Jewish
self-identification . The question is based on ideas about Jewish
personhood, which have cultural , ethnic religious , political ,
genealogical , and personal dimensions. Orthodox
Judaism follow the
Halakha , deeming a person to be
Jewish if their mother is Jewish, or they underwent a proper
conversion . Reform
Judaism and Reconstructionist
Judaism accept both
matrilineal and patrilineal descent. Karaite
follows patrilineal descent.
Jewish identity is also commonly defined through ethnicity . Opinion
polls have suggested that the majority of
Jews see being
predominantly a matter of ancestry and culture, rather than religion.
Jews , being the most common
Jewish ethnic division, have
been the subject of numerous genealogical studies and have been found
to be a distinct, homogeneous ethnic group. However, other studies
found overlap between
Ashkenazi Jews, Italians and Greeks.
* 1 Traditional interpretation and variations
* 2 Tannaitic
* 3 Contemporary
Jewish by birth
* 3.3 Converts to
Jews who have practiced another religion
* 4 Religious definitions
* 4.1 Halakhic perspective
* 4.2 Karaite
* 4.3 Reform
* 4.3.1 Controversies
* 5 Ethnic definitions
* 5.1 Public opinion
Israeli immigration law
* 5.3 Historical European definitions
* 5.5 "Half-Jewish"
* 6 Other non-religious definitions
* 7 Legal structure in
Law of Return
* 7.3 Israeli laws governing marriage and divorce
* 7.4 Israeli definition of nationality
* 7.5 Outside of
* 8 Other definitions
* 8.1 Sociology and anthropology
* 8.2 The Inquisition
* 8.3 Secular philosophy
* 8.4 Antisemitic definitions
Israelite identity loss claims
Jews (Indian Jews)
* 9.5 The Kaifeng
* 9.6 The Lemba
* 9.7 New Mexico\'s Crypto-
* 9.8 Other claims
* 10 See also
* 11 Notes and references
* 11.1 Notes
* 11.2 References
* 12 External links
TRADITIONAL INTERPRETATION AND VARIATIONS
The definition of who is a Jew varies according to whether it is
being considered by
Jews on the basis of religious law and tradition
or self-identification, or by non-
Jews for other reasons, sometimes
for prejudicial purposes. Because
Jewish identity can include
characteristics of an ethnicity , a religion, or peoplehood, the
definition depends on either traditional or newer interpretations of
Jewish law and custom.
Law of Return stipulates that a Jew is someone with a Jewish
mother or someone who has converted to Judaism. The Israeli Chief
Rabbinate requires documents proving the Jewishness of one’s mother,
grandmother, great-grandmother and great-great-grandmother when
applying for marriage . The Office of the Chief
Rabbi (OCR) has
underlined the basic principle that a child is not recognised by the
OCR and other bodies as
Jewish unless his or her mother is Jewish.
According to the simplest definition used by most
self-identification, a person is a Jew by birth, or becomes one
through religious conversion. However, there are differences in
interpretations when it comes to non-Orthodox
Jewish denominations in
the application of this definition, including
* Should a person with only one
Jewish parent be considered Jewish?
* Which conversion processes should be considered valid?
* Can one remain a Jew after converting to another religion?
* How does being unaware of having
Jewish parents affect one's
* How is
Jewish identity determined in different countries
* How is the claim to Israeli citizenship adjudicated in the context
of the Basic Laws of Israel?
According to the
Mishnah , the first written source for halakha , the
status of the offspring of mixed marriages was determined
According to historian
Shaye J. D. Cohen , in the Bible, the status
of the offspring of mixed marriages was determined patrilineally. He
brings two likely explanations for the change in Mishnaic times:
Mishnah may have been applying the same logic to mixed
marriages as it had applied to other mixtures (kilayim). Thus, a mixed
marriage is forbidden as is the union of a horse and a donkey, and in
both unions the offspring are judged matrilineally. Second, the
Tannaim may have been influenced by Roman law, which dictated that
when a parent could not contract a legal marriage, offspring would
follow the mother .
Jewish religious movements agree that a person may be a Jew
either by birth or through conversion. According to halakha , a Jew by
birth must be born to a
Halakha states that the
acceptance of the principles and practices of
Judaism does not make a
person a Jew. But, those born
Jewish do not lose that status because
they cease to be observant Jews, even if they adopt the practices of
Reform and Reconstructionist
Judaism often accept a child as Jewish
even if only the father is
Jewish and if the child chooses to identify
as Jewish. As the various denominations of
Judaism differ on their
conversion processes, conversions performed by more liberal
denominations are not accepted by those that are less so.
JEWISH BY BIRTH
According to halakha, to determine a person's
Jewish status (Hebrew:
yuhasin) one needs to consider the status of both parents. If both
parents are Jewish, their child will also be considered Jewish, and
the child takes the status of the father (e.g., as a kohen ). If
either parent is subject to a genealogical disability (e.g., is a
mamzer ) then the child is also subject to that disability. If one of
the parents is not Jewish, the rule is that the child takes the status
of the mother (Kiddushin 68b,
Shulchan Aruch , EH 4:19). The ruling
is derived from various sources including Deuteronomy 7:1–5,
Ezra 10:2–3. Accordingly, if the mother is Jewish,
so is her child, and if she is not Jewish, neither is her child
considered Jewish. In Orthodox
Judaism the child of a non-Jewish
mother can be considered
Jewish only by a process of conversion to
Judaism . The child is also freed from any disabilities and special
status to which the father may have been subject (e.g., being a mamzer
or kohen ) under
The Orthodox and Conservative branches of
Judaism maintain that the
halakhic rules (i.e. matrilineal descent) are valid and binding.
Reform and Liberal
Judaism do not accept the halakhic rules as
binding, and most branches accept a child of one
whether father or mother, as
Jewish if the parents raise the child as
a Jew and foster a
Jewish identity in the child, noting that "in the
Bible the line always followed the father, including the cases of
Moses , who married into non-
Israelite priestly families."
(However, according to the oral tradition of Orthodox Judaism, the
spouses of both Joseph and
Moses converted to
Judaism prior to
marrying them.) The Reform movement's standard states that "for those
beyond childhood claiming
Jewish identity, other public acts or
declarations may be added or substituted after consultation with their
rabbi". Advocates of patrilineal descent point to Genesis 48:15–20
and Deuteronomy 10:15. This policy is commonly known as patrilineal
descent , though "bilineal" would be more accurate.
In 1983, the Reform
Central Conference of American Rabbis passed the
Patrilineal Descent, declaring that "the child of one
Jewish parent is under the presumption of
Jewish descent. This
presumption of the status of the offspring of any mixed marriage is to
be established through appropriate and timely public and formal acts
of identification with the
Jewish faith and people... Depending on
circumstances, mitzvot leading toward a positive and exclusive Jewish
identity will include entry into the covenant, acquisition of a Hebrew
Torah study, Bar/Bat Mitzvah, and Kabbalat
For those beyond childhood claiming
Jewish identity, other public acts
or declarations may be added or substituted after consultation with
Rabbi Mark Washofsky summarizes the 1983 CCAR resolution and
subsequent interpretations in Reform responsa literature as follows:
* "The resolution is advisory rather than halachic in the
traditional sense. It does not establish a new definition of Jewish
identity, for its preamble states expressly that it means to be
operative only for Reform
Jews in North America, not for all Jews
Jewish descent may be from either parent....The Reform Movement
presumes the child of one
Jewish parent, either mother or father, as
Jewish. In fact, the 1983 resolution is in one significant respect
more stringent than the traditional definition of
Jewish status. The
child of a
Jewish mother and gentile father, whom halachah regards as
clearly Jewish, enjoys but a presumption of
Jewish status that must be
"established" by "appropriate and timely public and formal acts of
* "Biology remains a crucial factor. In the determination of Jewish
identity...the child of two gentile parents is, as before, definitely
a non-Jew and must undergo a formal conversion in order to become a
* "Both descent and behavior are crucial in determining Jewish
status under the resolution. The
Jewish status of a child of an
intermarriage cannot be determined "automatically" either by biology
or behavior. Both elements—descent from one
Jewish parent and the
performance of mitzvot that lead to a "positive and exclusive Jewish
identity -- must be present, and they must be present during
* "The resolution applies only to children raised exclusively as
Jews....A child raised simultaneously in
Judaism and another religious
tradition does not develop a "positive and exclusive"
therefore the presumption of
Jewish status is disproved, and the
resolution does not apply to that child. He or she will require
conversion prior to observing bar or bat mitzvah in the synagogue."
Waiving the need for formal conversion for anyone with at least one
Jewish parent who has made affirmative acts of
Jewish identity was a
departure from the traditional position requiring formal conversion to
Judaism for children without a
Jewish mother .
The CCAR's 1983 resolution has had a mixed reception in Reform Jewish
communities outside of the United States. Most notably, the Israel
Movement for Progressive
Judaism has rejected patrilineal descent and
requires formal conversion for anyone not born of a
Judaism believes that
Jewish identity can only be transmitted
by patrilineal descent. They argue that only patrilineal descent can
Jewish identity on the grounds that all descent in the Torah
went according to the male line, basing this idea "on the fact that,
in the Bible, tribes are given male names and that biblical characters
are always referenced by their fathers' names. However, a minority of
modern Karaites believe that
Jewish identity requires that both
parents be Jewish, and not only the father.
The divergence of views has become an issue because Orthodox and
Conservative communities do not recognize a person as
Jewish if only
their father is Jewish. For the person to be accepted as
Jewish by an
Orthodox or Conservative community (for example, on an occasion of
their bar/bat mitzvah or marriage), they require a formal conversion
(in accordance with halakhic standards). Orthodox
Judaism has a
predominant position in Israel. Although Orthodox and Conservative
Judaism do not recognize Jewishness through patrilineal descent, "it
should also be noted, however, that in the case of a child born to a
Jewish father but to a non-
Jewish mother, most Orthodox rabbis will
relax the stringent demands normally made of would-be converts", and
Rabbinical Assembly of the Conservative movement "agreed that
Jews by choice' should be warmly welcomed into the
CONVERTS TO JUDAISM
Main article: Conversion to
All mainstream forms of
Judaism today are open to sincere converts,
with most subgroups accepting converts by the process accepted within
the group. Not all conversions are recognised by all varieties of
Judaism , the laws of conversion are based on the
classical sources of
Jewish law , especially discussions in the Talmud
, and the law as codified in the
Shulkhan Arukh . This corpus of
Jewish law (halakha) is regarded as authoritative by the
Orthodox and Conservative movements. The traditional halakhic
requirements for conversion are instruction in the commandments,
circumcision (if male), and immersion in an acceptable body of water
before valid witnesses, and acceptance of the commandments before a
rabbinical court . If a male is already circumcised, a drop of blood
is drawn from the penis.
Orthodox authorities require that conversions be performed in accord
Jewish law and recognise only those conversions in
which a convert accepts and undertakes to observe
Jewish law as
interpreted by Orthodox rabbis . Because rabbis in the other movements
do not require that converts make this commitment, Orthodox
authorities do not generally accept as valid conversions performed
outside the Orthodox community.
Conservative authorities likewise require that conversions be
conducted according to traditional
Jewish law. Conducting a conversion
absent the traditional requirements of immersion in a ritual bath and
circumcision for males is a violation of a Standard of the Rabbinical
Assembly and grounds for expulsion. Conservative authorities
generally recognize any conversion done in accord with the
Jewish law, even if done outside the Conservative
movement. Accordingly, Conservative rabbis may accept the validity of
some conversions from other non-Orthodox movements.
The Union for Reform
Judaism states that "people considering
conversion are expected to study
Jewish theology, rituals, history,
culture and customs, and to begin incorporating
Jewish practices into
their lives. The length and format of the course of study will vary
from rabbi to rabbi and community to community, though most now
require a course in basic
Judaism and individual study with a rabbi,
as well as attendance at services and participation in home practice
and synagogue life." Its Central Conference of American Rabbis
recommends that three rabbis be present for the conversion ceremony.
The Rabbinical Court of the
Israel Movement for Progressive Judaism
requires an average of a year of study to become conversant in Jewish
life and tradition. Following this, converts are required to immerse
in a ritual bath, be circumcised if male, and accept the commandments
before the rabbinical court.
Although an infant conversion might be accepted in some circumstances
(such as in the case of adopted children or children whose parents
convert), children who convert would typically be asked if they want
Jewish after reaching religious adulthood – which is 12
years of age for a girl and 13 for a boy, as required by
Judaism does not accept the oral legal traditions of Rabbinic
Judaism. It has different requirements for conversion, and refrained
from accepting any converts until recently. Traditionally
non-proselytizing, on August 1, 2007, the Karaites reportedly
converted their first new members in 500 years. At a ceremony in their
Northern California synagogue, ten adults and four minors swore fealty
Judaism after completing a year of study. This conversion came 15
years after the Karaite Council of Sages reversed its centuries-old
ban on accepting converts.
Jewish communities do not normally carry out conversions,
particularly where the conversion is suspected of being for the sake
of marriage. Nor do they accept such converts from other communities,
or the children of mixed marriages or marriages involving such
JEWS WHO HAVE PRACTICED ANOTHER RELIGION
In general, Orthodox
Judaism considers individuals born of Jewish
mothers to be Jewish, even if they convert to or are raised in another
Jews who convert to or are raised in
another religion as non-Jews. For example "...anyone who claims that
Jesus is their savior is no longer a Jew..." .
Historically, a Jew who has been declared to be a heretic (
min , מין) or Christian (Hebrew: notzri , נוצרי, meaning
"Nazarene") may have had a cherem (similar to excommunication ) placed
on him or her; but the practice of communal and religious exclusion
does not affect their status of
Judaism also views as
Jewish those who involuntarily convert from
Judaism to another
Hebrew : anusim , אנוסים, meaning "forced ones"), and
their matrilineal descendants are likewise considered to be Jewish.
Judaism has a category for those who are
Jewish but who do not
practice or who do not accept the tenets of Judaism, whether or not
they have converted to another religion. The traditional view
regarding these individuals, known as Meshumadim (
משומדים), is that they are Jewish; however, there is much
debate in the rabbinic literature regarding their status vis-a-vis the
Jewish law and their participation in
but not to their status as Jews.
A Jew who leaves
Judaism is free to return to the religion at any
time. In general, no formal ceremony or declaration is required to
Jewish practices. All movements of
Judaism welcome the
Judaism of those who have left, or been raised in another
religion. When returning to Judaism, these individuals would be
expected to abandon their previous practices and adopt
The same rules in principle apply to the matrilineal descendants of
such persons, though some rabbinical authorities may require stricter
Jewish descent than others. Whether such persons are required
to undergo a full formal conversion depends on the community and their
individual circumstances. For example, a male who has had a brit milah
, who has a general understanding of Judaism, but who has been raised
in a secular home might not be required to undergo ritual conversion.
However, a male who has not had a brit milah, a male or female who has
converted to or been brought up in another religion, or an individual
raised in a completely secular home without any
Jewish education, in
most communities, may be required to undergo a full ritual conversion.
For full participation in the community (for example, to marry with
the participation of a rabbi), they may be required to display
sincerity, such as a declaration of commitment to Judaism.
Another example of the issues involved is the case of converts to
Judaism who cease to practice
Judaism (whether or not they still
regard themselves as Jewish), do not accept or follow halakha, or now
adhere to another religion. Technically, such a person remains Jewish,
like all Jews, provided that the original conversion is valid.
However, in some recent cases, Haredi rabbinical authorities , as well
as the current Religious Zionist
Israeli Chief Rabbinate , have taken
the view that a given convert's lapse from Orthodox
is evidence that he or she cannot, even at the time of the conversion,
have had the full intention to observe the commandments, and that the
conversion must therefore have been invalid.
Jewish court of sufficient stature has the ability to revoke
a person's or a group's status as Jews. This was done for the lost Ten
Israel and the
According to the traditional Rabbinic view, which is maintained by
all branches of Orthodox
Judaism , Conservative
Judaism and Reform
Judaism today, only halakha can define who is or is not a Jew when a
Jewish identity, lineage, or parentage arises about any
person seeking to define themselves or claim that they are Jewish.
As a result, mere belief in the principles of
Judaism does not make
one a Jew. Similarly, non-adherence by a Jew to the
613 Mitzvot , or
even formal conversion to another religion, does not make one lose
Jewish status. Thus, the immediate descendants of all female
Jews (even apostates ) are still considered to be Jews, as are those
of all their female descendants. Even those descendants who are not
aware they are Jews, or practice a religion other than Judaism, are
defined by this perspective as Jews, as long as they come from an
unbroken female line of descent. As a corollary, the children of a
Jewish father and a non-
Jewish mother are not considered to be
Halakha unless they formally convert according to Halakha, even if
raised fully observant in the Mitzvot.
Those not born to a
Jewish mother may become accepted as
Jews by the
Orthodox and Conservative communities through a formal process of
Judaism in order to become "righteous converts" (Gerei
Hebrew : גרי צדק). In addition,
that the new convert commit himself to observance of its tenets; this
is called Kabbalat Ol Mitzvot (
Hebrew : קבלת עול
מצוות), "Acceptance of the Yoke of the Commandments".
Kabbalat mitzvot (
Hebrew : קבלת מצוות) is used by
Judaism in accordance with reform responsa and Halakhah.
Judaism and Modern Orthodox
Judaism accept a similar set
of rules regarding
Jewish status based on classical rabbinic Judaism,
including both matrilineal descent and requirements that conversions
be performed by Orthodox rabbis and that converts promise to strictly
observe elements of traditional
Judaism such as
However, their application of these rules have been different, and the
difference has been increasing in recent years. Modern Orthodox
authorities have been more inclined to rule in favor of
and to accept non-Orthodox Jews' word in doubtful cases involving
people claiming to be Jews, while Haredi authorities have in recent
years tended to presume non-
Jewish status and require more stringent
rules and standards of evidence in order for
Jewish status to be
proven, and have tended to distrust the evidence of
Jews who are not
personally Orthodox. Haredi rabbis have tended to look at a convert's
current personal observance and to regard deficiencies or lack of
Orthodoxy in current observance as evidence that the convert never
intended to validly convert. In addition, the contemporary situation
is further complicated by the fact that some Haredi rabbis no longer
regard some Modern Orthodox rabbis as reliable.
Unlike the denominations of Rabbinical Judaism, Karaite Judaism
maintains that it is the responsibility of each Jew to study the
Tanakh for themselves. The
Oral Law are not considered
canonical, and rabbinical opinions are not considered authoritative
either, but every interpretation is held up to the same scrutiny,
regardless of its source. Karaite
Judaism relies on the
indicate that Jewishness is passed down through the paternal line, not
the maternal line as is maintained by Orthodox
Judaism (though a
minority hold that both parents need to be Jewish). Karaite
Aliyah under the
Law of Return . The eligibility of
Judaism through the Karaite movement to make
Law of Return has not yet been addressed in Israeli courts.
Jewish denominations have a conversion process
based on their principles . In the US, an official Reform resolution
in 1893 abolished circumcision as a requirement for converts, and
Reform does not require converts to have tevilah, ritual immersion. A
"prospective convert declares, orally and in writing, in the presence
of a rabbi and no less than two lay leaders of the congregation and
community, acceptance of the
Jewish religion and the intention to live
in accordance with its mitzvot".
The controversy in determining "who is a Jew" concerns four basic
One issue arises because North American Reform and UK Liberal
movements have changed some of the halakhic requirements for a Jewish
identity in two ways: A. Children born of just one
Jewish parent –
regardless of whether the father or mother is
Jewish – can claim a
Jewish identity. A child of only one
Jewish parent who does not claim
this identity has, in the eyes of the Reform movement, forfeited
Jewish identity. By contrast, the halakhic view is that any
child born to a
Jewish mother is Jewish, whether or not he/she is
raised Jewish, or even whether the mother considers herself Jewish. As
an example, the children of
Madeleine Albright (who was raised
Catholic and was unaware of her
Jewish heritage) would all be Jewish
according to halakha, since their mother's traceable female ancestors
Jewish and all three of her children were female. However,
this is not the belief of progressive Judaism, which views
convert to or are raised in another religion as non-Jews. B. The
requirement of brit milah has been relaxed, as has the requirement of
ritual immersion. (While the Conservative movement permits conversion
without circumcision in some cases, most Orthodox
Jews do not, except
in cases specifically exempted by the
Talmud , such as one who has had
three brothers die as a result of circumcision;
Jewish children who
are hemophiliacs are exempt from circumcision. )
Judaism asserts that non-Orthodox rabbis are not
qualified to form a beit din . This has led to non-Orthodox
conversions generally being unaccepted in Orthodox communities. Since
Judaism maintains the traditional standards for conversion
– in which the commitment to observe halakha is required –
non-Orthodox conversions are generally not accepted in Orthodox
communities because the non-Orthodox movements perform conversions in
which the new convert does not undertake to observe halakha as
understood by Orthodox Judaism.
A third controversy concerns persons (whether born
Jews or converts
to Judaism) who have converted to another religion. The traditional
view is such persons remain Jewish. Reform
Judaism regards such
people as apostates, and states regarding Messianic
"'Messianic Jews' claim that they are Jews, but we must asked
ourselves whether we identify them as Jews. We can not do so as they
consider Jesus of Nazareth as the Messiah who has fulfilled the
Messianic promises. In this way, they have clearly placed themselves
within Christianity. They may be somewhat different from other
Christians as they follow various
Jewish rites and ceremonials, but
that does not make them Jews." Regardless, such people do not count
Jewish for the purposes of the Israeli citizenship laws.
A fourth controversy stems from the manner in which the Chief
Israel has been handling marriage and conversion
decisions in recent years. Conversions and marriages within
legally controlled by the Orthodox Israeli Chief Rabbinate; therefore,
a person not proven to be a Jew to the Rabbinate's satisfaction is not
legally permitted to marry a Jew in
Israel today. Although the
Rabbinate has always refused to accept non-Orthodox conversions, until
recent years it was more willing to accept the
Jewish parentage of
applicants based on personal testimony, and the validity of
conversions based on the testimony of Orthodox Rabbis. However, in
recent years the rabbinate, whose rabbis historically had a more
Modern Orthodox orientation, has increasingly been filled by the more
stringent Haredi camp. It has increasingly been inclined to presume
that applicants are not
Jewish until proven otherwise, and require
more stringent standards of proof than in the past. It has implemented
a policy of refusing to accept the testimony of non-Orthodox
Jewish status, on grounds that such testimony is not
reliable. It also has been increasingly skeptical of the reliability
of Orthodox rabbis ordained by institutions not subject to its
accreditation, particularly in matters of conversion. Accordingly,
Jews born to
Jewish parents, and some
Jews converted by
Orthodox rabbis, have been increasingly unable to prove their
Jewishness to the Rabbinate's satisfaction, because they are unable to
find an Orthodox rabbi who is both acceptable to the Rabbinate, and
familiar with and willing to vouch for the Jewishness of their
maternal lineage or the validity of their conversion.
There have been several attempts to convene representatives of the
three major movements to formulate a practical solution to this issue.
To date, these have failed, though all parties concede the importance
of the issue is greater than any sense of rivalry among them.
This article NEEDS ADDITIONAL CITATIONS FOR VERIFICATION . Please
help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources .
Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. (February 2008)
(Learn how and when to remove this template message )
See also: Secular
Ethnic Jew is a term generally used to describe a person of Jewish
parentage and background who does not necessarily actively practice
Judaism, but still identifies with
Judaism or other
Jews culturally or
fraternally, or both. The term "ethnic Jew" does not specifically
exclude practicing Jews, but they are usually simply referred to as
"Jews" without the qualifying adjective "ethnic".
The term can refer to people of diverse beliefs and backgrounds
because genealogy largely defines who is "Jewish". "Ethnic Jew" is
sometimes used to distinguish non-practicing from practicing
(religious) Jews. Other terms include "non-observant Jew",
"non-religious Jew", "non-practicing Jew", and "secular Jew".
The term may also refer to
Jews who do not practice the religion of
Judaism. Typically, ethnic
Jews are cognizant of their Jewish
background, and may feel strong cultural (even if not religious) ties
Jewish traditions and to the
Jewish people or nation. Like people
of any other ethnicity, non-religious ethnic
Jews often assimilate
into a surrounding non-
Jewish culture, but, especially in areas where
there is a strong local
Jewish culture, they may remain largely part
of that culture instead.
"Ethnic Jews" include atheists , agnostics, non-denominational deists
Jews with only casual connections to
Jewish denominations or
converts to other religions, such as Christianity,
Buddhism , or
Jews of all denominations sometimes engage in
outreach to non-religious ethnic Jews. In the case of some Hasidic
Chabad-Lubavitch ), this outreach extends to
actively proselytizing more secular Jews.
The 2013 Pew Research study of American
Jews found that 62% thought
Jewish was mainly a matter of ancestry and culture, while
15% thought that it was mainly a matter of religion. Of those who
stated themselves to be
Jews by religion, 55% thought that being
Jewish was mainly a matter of ancestry and culture, while two-thirds
thought that it was not necessary to believe in God to be Jewish.
ISRAELI IMMIGRATION LAW
Israeli immigration laws will accept an application for Israeli
citizenship if there is proven documentation that any
grandparent—not just the maternal grandmother—was Jewish. This
does not mean that person is an "ethnic Jew", but Israeli immigration
will accept that person because he or she has an ethnically Jewish
connection, and because this same degree of connection was sufficient
to be persecuted as a Jew by the Nazis .
HISTORICAL EUROPEAN DEFINITIONS
The traditional European definition of Jewishness (although it was
not uniform across Europe) differs markedly from the definition used
by the United States. In the former
Soviet Union , "Jewish" was a
nationality by law, as with other nationalities such as Russians,
Ukrainians, Georgians and others. There were certain restrictions on
their civil liberties in the early years of the Soviet Union.
The European definition is traditional in many respects, and reflects
not only how the Europeans saw Jews, but also how
Jews saw themselves.
It has been argued that the Israeli
Law of Return draws on external
definitions of Jewishness (such as the Nazi and Soviet definitions),
rather than traditional halakhic criteria.
The modern genealogical DNA test of ethnicity is certainly a
non-religious definition of 'who is a Jew?' as increasing numbers of
persons discover their biological and cultural origins outside of the
traditional religious setting. The top two
Jewish haplogroups for the
Haplogroup J-M267 and Haplogroup E-M215 (Y-DNA)
have genetic origins in the vast
Arabian Peninsula , Egypt, the Horn
of Africa , and the Levant, which indicates a more complex cultural
genesis and potential identity.
In the United States and Europe, because of intermarriage , the
population of "half-Jews" is beginning to rival that of
Jews with two
Jewish parents. Self-identified "half-Jews" consider the term a
familial category, which reflects multiple heritages and possible
Jewish cultural or spiritual practices. Other similar terms that
have been used include: "part-Jewish" and "partial-Jews". The term
"Gershom", "Gershomi" or "Beta Gershom" has also been used as an
alternative to "half-Jewish" and "part-Jewish" in connection with
descendants of intermarriage,
Gershom being the son of
Moses and his
Zipporah . The term typically has no religious
meaning, as terms like
Jewish Christian do, but rather describes
OTHER NON-RELIGIOUS DEFINITIONS
The Society for Humanistic
Judaism defines a Jew as "someone who
identifies with the history, culture and fate of the
In their view it is therefore possible for a non-religious individual
Judaism and join a Humanistic
Jewish community, and for the
Society for Humanistic
Judaism to adopt the person wanting to be part
of the Humanistic
Jewish family. As Israeli author
Amos Oz puts it,
"a Jew is anyone who chooses or is compelled to share a common fate
with other Jews." Oz summed up his position more succinctly in a
monologue published in Tikkun , saying "
Who is a Jew? Everyone who is
mad enough to call himself or herself a Jew is a Jew."
LEGAL STRUCTURE IN ISRAEL
Israel has no single document called a constitution (the Basic Laws
Israel function as an uncodified constitution ); however, the
definition of "who is a Jew" has become an important issue in Israeli
politics due to the involvement of religious parties in the
The issue of who is considered a Jew has given rise to legal
controversy in Israel. There have been court cases in
1962 that have addressed the question.
As of 2010 , anyone who immigrated to
Israel after 1990 and wishes to
marry or divorce via the
Jewish tradition within the state limits must
go through a "
Judaism test" at an Orthodox Rabbinical court . In this
test, a person would need to prove their claim to be
Jewish to an
investigator beyond a reasonable doubt. They would need to present
original documentation of their matriline up to their
great-grandmother (4 generations), or in the case of Ethiopian
7 generations back. In addition, they should provide government
documents with nationality/religion shown as
Jewish (e.g., birth/death
certificates, marriage documents, etc.).
In the case of people whose original documents have been lost or
never existed, it may take a lot of work to prove their being Jewish.
The court rulings are not final, and any clerk has the power to
question them even 20 years later, changing one's citizenship status
to "on hold", and putting them in jeopardy of deportation.
The two biggest communities suffering from this problem are:
* Immigrants from the former
Soviet Union (FSU) – a study
conducted between 2003 and 2005 showed that 83% of people from the FSU
who started the
Judaism test process successfully finished it. An
estimated 10% left the process before completion. In a later study, in
2011, a 90% success rate was achieved in the FSU immigrant community.
Jews in the former
Soviet Union took steps to hide their
Jewishness. Besides post-Soviet copies of documents are suspected by
the tribunal after widespread falsification, and the archived
originals are difficult to access for genealogists.
* Immigrants from the United States, where government documents
generally do not show religion or
LAW OF RETURN
Law of Return
Following the birth of the modern State of
Israel in 1948, the Law of
Return was enacted to give any Jew the right to immigrate to Israel
and become a citizen. However, due to an inability on the lawmakers
to agree, the Law did not define who was a Jew, relying instead on the
issue to resolve itself over time. As a result, the Law relied in form
on the traditional halakhic definition. But, the absence of a
definition of who is a Jew, for the purpose of the Law, has resulted
in the divergent views of the various streams of
Judaism competing for
Besides the generally accepted halakhic definition of who is a Jew,
the Law extended the categories of person who are entitled to
immigration and citizenship to the children and grandchildren of Jews,
regardless of their present religious affiliation, and their spouses.
Also, converts to
Judaism whose conversion was performed outside of
the State of Israel, regardless of who performed it, were entitled to
immigration under the Law. Once again, issues arose as to whether a
conversion performed outside of
Israel was valid. The variation of the
definition in the Law and the definition used by various branches of
Judaism has resulted in practical difficulties for many people.
It has been estimated that in the past twenty years about 300,000
Jews and even practicing Christians have entered Israel
from the former
Soviet Union on the basis of being a child or
grandchild of a Jew or by being married to a Jew.
However, there was an exception in the case of a person who had
formally converted to another religion derived from the Rufeisen Case
in 1962. Such a person, no matter what their halakhic position, was
not entitled to immigration under the Law. This created a divergence
between political Zionist interpretation of Jewishness and that of
halakha. In the 1970 Shalit case the Israeli Supreme Court ruled in
favour of a family which sought to register children born in Israel
from a Scottish mother as
Jewish by nationality, but the 1972
amendment to the Population Registry Law prevented their third child
being registered as Jewish.
Current Israeli definitions specifically exclude
Jews who have openly
and knowingly converted to or were raised in a faith other than
Judaism, including Messianic
Judaism . This definition is not the same
as that in traditional
Jewish law; in some respects it is deliberately
wider, so as to include those non-
Jewish relatives of
Jews who may
have been perceived to be Jewish, and thus faced antisemitism .
Law of Return does not, of itself, define the
Jewish status of a
person; it only deals with those who have a right of immigration to
In the early 1950s, the
Israeli Chief Rabbinate originally objected
to the immigration of Karaite
Jews to Israel, and unsuccessfully tried
to obstruct it. In 2007
David Chayim Chelouche, the chief rabbi
of Netayana, was quoted in the
Jerusalem Post as saying: "A Karaite is
a Jew. We accept them as
Jews and every one of them who wishes to come
back we accept back. There was once a question about whether Karaites
needed to undergo a token circumcision in order to switch to rabbinic
Judaism, but the rabbinate agrees that today that is not necessary."
ISRAELI LAWS GOVERNING MARRIAGE AND DIVORCE
See also: Marriage in
In relation to marriage , divorce , and burial, which are under the
jurisdiction of the Israeli Interior Ministry , the halakhic
definition of who is a Jew is applied. When there is any doubt, the
Israeli Chief Rabbinate generally determines the issue.
In terms of social relations, most secular
Jews view their Jewish
identity as a matter of culture, heritage, nationality, or ethnicity.
Ancestral aspects can be explained by the many
Jews who view
themselves as atheist and are defined by matrilineal descent or a
Cohen (Kohen) or
Levi , which is connected by ancestry. The question
of "who is a Jew" is a question that is under debate. Issues related
to ancestral or ethnic
Jews are dealt with by the Israeli Chief
Orthodox halachic rules apply to converts who want to marry in
Israel. Under these rules, a conversion to
Judaism must strictly
follow halachic standards to be recognised as valid. The rabbinate
even scrutinizes Orthodox conversions, with some who have converted by
orthodox authorities outside of
Israel not being permitted to marry in
If one's ancestral line of Jewishness is in doubt, then a proper
conversion would be required in order to be allowed to marry in the
Orthodox community, or in Israel, where such rules govern all
ISRAELI DEFINITION OF NATIONALITY
Jewish status of a person in
Israel is considered a matter of
In the registering of "nationality" on Israeli Teudat Zehut
("identity card"), which is administered by the Ministry of the
Interior, a person had to meet the halakhic definition to be
registered as a "Jew". However, in a number of cases the Supreme Court
Israel has ordered the Interior Ministry to register Reform and
Conservative converts as Jews. The right of people who convert in the
Diaspora under Reform or Conservative auspices to make aliyah, or
Israel and claim citizenship as Jews, is detailed in
Until recently, Israeli identity cards had an indication of
nationality, and the field was left empty for those who immigrated not
solely on the basis of being
Jewish (i.e. as a child, grandchild or
spouse of a Jew only) to indicate that the person may not be a Jew.
Many Israeli citizens who are not recognised by the Rabbinate as
Jewish have been issued with Israeli identity cards that do not
Hebrew calendar birth date.
OUTSIDE OF ISRAEL
This section IS INCOMPLETE. (November 2013)
In 2010 the Labour Court of
South Africa addressed the question of
who is a Jew for the purposes of the Employment Equity Act.
The question has also arisen in the United Kingdom, where religious
schools are allowed to select all, or a proportion of their intake
based upon religion. A 2009 ruling,
R(E) v Governing Body of JFS
R(E) v Governing Body of JFS ,
determined that the definition of
Jewish religion based upon descent
constituted discrimination on ethnic grounds, and therefore
contravened racial discrimination laws.
This section IS INCOMPLETE. (November 2013)
There have been other attempts to determine
Jewish identity beside
Jewish approaches. These range from genetic population
studies to controversial evolutionary perspectives including those
Kevin B. MacDonald and
Yuri Slezkine . Historians, such as
Kamal Salibi , have utilized etymology and geography to
reconstruct the prehistoric origin of the
Jewish people in the Arabian
SOCIOLOGY AND ANTHROPOLOGY
As with any other ethnic identity,
Jewish identity is, to some
degree, a matter of either claiming that identity or being perceived
by others (both inside and outside the ethnic group) as belonging to
that group, or both. Returning again to the example of Madeleine
Albright – during her Catholic childhood, her being in some sense
Jewish was presumably irrelevant. It was only after she was nominated
to be Secretary of State that she, and the public, discovered her
Ido Abram states that there are five aspects to contemporary Jewish
* Religion, culture, and tradition.
* The tie with
Israel and Zionism.
* Dealings with antisemitism, including issues of persecution and
* Personal history and life-experience.
* Relationship with non-
Jewish culture and people.
The relative importance of these factors may vary enormously from
place to place. For example, a typical Dutch Jew might describe his or
Jewish identity simply as "I was born Jewish," while a Jew in
Romania , where levels of antisemitism are higher, might say, "I
consider any form of denying as a proof of cowardice."
During the time of the Spanish and Portuguese Inquisitions ,
conversion to Roman Catholicism did not result in total termination of
Jewish status. Legally, the converts were no longer
regarded as Jews, and thus allowed to stay in the Iberian Peninsula.
During the Inquisition in Spain and
Portugal , however, many
forced to convert, but thereafter were regarded by many people, though
not in a legal form, as
New Christians , distinguishing them as
separate from the Old Christians of non-
Jewish lineage. Since legal,
political, religious and social pressure pushed many people to untrue
conversions (public behaviour as Christians while retaining some
Jewish beliefs and practices privately, a kind of crypto-
they were still treated with suspicion, a stigma sometimes carried for
several generations by their identifiable descendants. The limpieza de
sangre ("Cleanliness of blood") required public officials or
candidates for membership of many organizations to prove that they did
Jewish or Muslim ancestry.
Jean-Paul Sartre , who was not Jewish, suggested in Anti-Semite and
Jew (1948) that
Jewish identity "is neither national nor
international, neither religious nor ethnic, nor political: it is a
quasi-historical community." While
Jews as individuals may be in
danger from the antisemite who sees only "Jews" and not "people",
Sartre argues that the
Jewish experience of antisemitism
preserves—even creates—the sense of
Jewish community. In his most
extreme statement of this view he wrote, "It is the anti-Semite who
creates the Jew." Conversely, that sense of specific
may be threatened by the democrat who sees only "the person" and not
Hannah Arendt repeatedly asserted a principle of claiming Jewish
identity in the face of antisemitism. "If one is attacked as a Jew,
one must defend oneself as a Jew. Not as a German, not as a
world-citizen, not as an upholder of the Rights of Man, or whatever";
"A man attacked as a Jew cannot defend himself as an Englishman or a
Frenchman. The world can only conclude from this that he is simply not
defending himself at all."
Wade Clark Roof (1976), a sociologist at the University of California
at Santa Barbara, proposed that social sectors in modern life , in
which traditional symbols and rituals are meaningful, provide an
alternative approach for explaining the social basis of religion in a
secular order, in doing so, he turned to the local community as a
sphere in modern society that still persists "as a complex system of
friendship and kinship networks, formal and informal associations, as
well as symbolic attachments, very much rooted in family life and
ongoing socialization processes".
The question "who is a Jew?" is also sometimes of importance to
non-Jews. It has had exceptional significance historically when
considered by anti-
Jewish groups for the purpose of targeting
persecution or discrimination. The definition can impact on whether a
person may have a certain job, live in certain locations, receive a
free education , live or continue to live in the country, be
imprisoned , or executed.
The question was of critical importance during the rule of the Nazi
party in Germany , which persecuted the
Jews and defined them for the
government's purposes by the
Nuremberg Laws . In 2009, a United
Kingdom court considered whether the question was a racial issue, in
R(E) v Governing Body of JFS
R(E) v Governing Body of JFS (2009).
The Nazi regime instituted laws discriminating against Jews, declared
a race by the Nazis, and thus needed a working definition of who is a
Jew as to its law-defined race system. These definitions almost
completely categorised persons through the religions followed by each
individual's ancestors, according to membership registries. Thus,
personal faith or individual observance, as well as the religious
Judaism as given by the
Halacha , were mostly ignored.
In Germany itself, the
Nuremberg Laws classified people
as being of the
Jewish race if they descended from three or four
grandparents enrolled in
Jewish congregations. A person with one or
two grandparents enrolled in a
Jewish congregation could be classified
Mischling , a crossbreed, of "mixed blood", if they were not a
member of a
Jewish congregation at the time the
Nuremberg Laws were
enacted. Only people with at least two of their grandparents of
"German blood" could be German Reich's citizens, other Germans dropped
into the new second class group of citizens, the so-called state
citizens. If a person, with grandparents of the same religious
combination, was enrolled as a member of a
Jewish congregation in 1935
or would join later, they switched from the discriminatory class of
Mischlinge into that of
Geltungsjude , "Jew by legal validity",
despite of not fulfilling the no less law-defined discriminating
criterion of descending from three or four
Mischling could anytime drop into the class of
Geltungsjude by joining a
Jewish congregation, the Nuremberg Laws
provided for the unchanged classification of any Geltungsjude,
regardless if she or he tried to evade harm by seceding from the
Jewish congregation after 1935, considering such secessions as being
of no effect as to the discrimination. Let alone people with three or
Jewish grandparents who themselves could never alter their
law-defined racial categorisation as Jews. Any
Mischling with two
Jewish grandparents, colloquially called a half-Jew, marrying after
1935 anybody classified as Jew would drop into the discriminatory
class of Geltungsjude. Mischlinge with one
Jewish grandparent were
usually forbidden to marry anybody with any
One could not become a non-Jew in the eyes of the Nazi government by
seceding from one's
Jewish congregation, becoming non-practicing,
marrying outside the religion, or converting to Christianity. In 1935
Nuremberg Laws forbade new marriages of people classified as Jews
with people of other classifications. Earlier contracted marriages
between spouses of different classifications (so-called mixed
marriages; Mischehe) provided the Jewish-classified spouse with an
uncertain protection from some discriminations and atrocities.
There were very few Karaites in Europe during the Nazi era; most
lived in the region of Turkey, Greece, and the
Crimea . Karaites were
Jewish for the purpose of the Holocaust extermination
policy; according to SS Obergruppenführer Gottlob Berger, writing on
November 24, 1944, discrimination against the Karaites had been
prohibited due to their proximity to the Crimean
Tatars , to whom
Berger views the Karaites as being related. Nazis still retained
hostility towards the Karaites, on grounds of their religion; and
there were a number of small scale massacres of Karaites.
In German-occupied France an ordinance defined a Jew as an individual
who belonged to the
Jewish religion or who had more than two Jewish
The Vichy régime in southern France defined a Jew as an individual
Jewish grandparents or two grandparents if his/her spouse
was Jewish. Richard Weisberg points out that this was a potentially
broader classification than the one used in Occupied France, for
Mischling could not be classified a Jew under the Nazi
dictate, by her/his spouse's classification if the marriage was
contracted before the imposition of anti-Semitic marriage laws there,
but would be deemed one under the Vichy act if he/she had married a
Jew, regardless when.
ISRAELITE IDENTITY LOSS CLAIMS
Ten Lost Tribes
There are various groups besides
Jews that have claimed descent from
the biblical Israelites . The question nowadays arises in relation to
Law of Return , with various groups seeking to migrate
there. Some claims have been accepted, some are under consideration,
while others have been rejected by Israel's rabbinate.
COCHIN JEWS (INDIAN JEWS)
Some sources say that the earliest
India were those
who settled in the
Malabar Coast during the times of King
Israel, and after the Kingdom of
Israel split into two. There is
historical documentation of the
Jews being in
Cochin after the fall of
the Second Temple, from around the first century CE. Later additions
were a smaller immigration of Sephardic
Jews from Europe in the
sixteenth century after the expulsion from Spain, and Baghdadi
Jews who arrived in the late eighteenth century, at
the beginning of the British colonial era. Following the independence
India and the establishment of
Israel , most
Israel in the mid-1950s. Some have gone on to North America or
Bene Israel in
India claim to be descended from
Jews who escaped
Galilee in the 2nd century BCE. The Bene Israel
resemble the non-
Marathi people in appearance and customs,
which indicates some intermarriage between
Jews and Indians. The Bene
Israel, however, maintained the practices of
Jewish dietary laws ,
male circumcision and observation of the Sabbath as a day of rest.
From the late eighteenth century, other
Jewish communities instructed
them in normative Judaism.
Initially the Orthodox rabbinate in
Israel said that the Bene Israel
would have to undergo conversion in order to marry other Jews, as
matrilineal descent could not be proven. In 1964 the Israeli Rabbinate
declared that the
Bene Israel are "full
Jews in every respect".
Bene Israel claim a lineage to the
Kohanim , the Israelite
priestly class, which claims descent from Aaron, the brother of Moses.
In 2002, DNA testing revealed that the
Bene Israel shared some genetic
markers of the Kohanim. These are not exclusive to the Kohanim, but
appear among them at a higher frequency. These are also shared with
Jewish Semitic peoples.
Many of the
Bene Israel emigrated from
India to Israel, where around
Jews of this group reside. About 5,000 remain in India. They
maintain 65 synagogues in Israel.
Beta Israel or
Falasha is a group formerly living in
have a tradition of descent from the lost tribe of Dan . They have a
long history of practicing such
Jewish traditions as kashrut, Sabbath
and Passover, and had
Jewish texts. In 1975, their claim of Jewishness
was accepted by the
Chief Rabbinate of
Israel and the Israeli
government. The government assisted them in emigrating en masse to
Israel during the 1980s and 1990s as
Jews under the
Law of Return ,
Ethiopia was undergoing civil war. Some who claim to be Beta
Israel still live in Ethiopia.
Bnei Menashe is a group in
India claiming to be descendants of
the half-tribe of Menashe . Members who have studied
Hebrew and who
observe the Sabbath and other
Jewish laws in 2005 received the support
of the Sephardic Chief
Israel to arrange formal conversion to
Judaism. Some have converted and immigrated to
Israel under the Law of
THE KAIFENG JEWS
For more details on this topic, see History of the
Jews in China .
Jews , a Mandarin-speaking group from
Henan Province ,
China, experienced first contact with Europeans in 1605 via the
Matteo Ricci . Modern researchers believe these Jews
were descended from Persian merchants who settled in China during the
Song Dynasty . They prospered during the
Ming Dynasty as
Confucian civil servants, soldiers, and merchants, but they quickly
assimilated and lost much of their
Jewish heritage. By the beginning
of the 19th century, the last rabbi with knowledge of
leaving no successor. The community had become extinct religiously by
Qing Dynasty due to anti-foreign persecutions brought on by
Taiping Rebellion and
Boxer Rebellion . There are a small number
of Chinese people today who consider themselves to be descendants of
Despite their isolation from the rest of the
Jewish diaspora , the
Jews of Kaifeng preserved
Jewish traditions and customs for many
centuries. In the 17th century, assimilation began to erode these
traditions. The rate of intermarriage between
Jews and other ethnic
groups, such as the
Han Chinese , and the Hui and
Manchu minorities in
China, increased. The destruction of the synagogue in the 1860s led to
the community's demise. However, J.L. Liebermann, the first Western
Jew to visit Kaifeng in 1867, noted that "they still had a burial
ground of their own". S.M. Perlmann, the Shanghai businessman and
scholar, wrote in 1912 that "they bury their dead in coffins, but of a
different shape than those of the Chinese are made, and do not attire
the dead in secular clothes as the Chinese do, but in linen". To
date, there is only one scholar, Zhou Xu, who doubts the Kaifeng
community's Jewishness and claims them to have been a western
Today, 600-1,000 residents of Kaifeng trace their lineage to this
community. After contact with
Jewish tourists, the
Jews of Kaifeng
have reconnected to mainstream Jewry. With the help of Jewish
organizations, some members of the community have emigrated to Israel.
In 2009, Chinese
Jews from Kaifeng arrived in
Israel as immigrants.
Judaism in Africa
The Lemba , a Bantu-speaking group of people from southern Africa,
South Africa , consider themselves of Jewish
descent, although most practice Christianity or Islam. They emphasize
eating only meats slaughtered by special ritual. They have endogamous
marriage practices. If a man wants to marry a non-Lemba woman, she
must adopt all the Lemba practices and traditions, including keeping
meat and dairy foods separate. No male non-Lemba are accepted into the
group, even by conversion.
The Lemba follow a patrilineal tradition.
Y-DNA testing has shown a
high percentage of Semitic ancestry, perhaps Jewish, among some of the
Y-DNA testing has shown markers indicative of Semitic ancestry,
including markers associated with
Kohanim . These are present at a
high rate among men in their Buba clan , traditionally known as the
one to have led the men to south Africa from
Yemen after they left
Israel. The women are exclusively of African origin, which is
consistent with the tribe's origin story of
Jewish men coming to
NEW MEXICO\'S CRYPTO-JEWS
A small Hispano group of Sephardic
Jews in northern
New Mexico may be
one of the oldest groups of practicing
Jews in North America, dating
back to the early Spanish settlers of
Jewish descent who had been
forcibly converted to Catholicism as
New Christians , or
both after 1492. Some families of
Conversos began to settle in Mexico
City in the 1530s and 1540s. Some converted back to Judaism; others
Jewish beliefs and practices in secret. After the
Spanish Inquisition came to the New World in 1571, the conversos were
threatened with death if it was found they were practicing Judaism.
In 1598 the first expedition was made to New Mexico, and included
conversos. After that, other conversos fled to the northwestern
frontier of the
Spanish Empire , now the American Southwest, to evade
the scrutiny and threat of discovery in the more monitored
settlements. Outwardly Catholic, these forced converts maintained
Jewish practices and customs for generations in secret, hence their
Jews ". They have been the subject of recent academic
study. Some of New Mexico's Crypto-
Jews have begun to return to
Judaism in recent years, through study and ritual
conversion. Others feel enlarged by learning this part of their
history, but continue as practicing Catholics.
A genetic study of men in the early 2000s showed that many Hispanos
of the American Southwest are descended from
Anusim (Sephardic Jews
who were forcibly converted to Roman Catholicism). Only Catholic
Spanish were allowed to go to the New World with the exploration and
colonial expeditions. Families first kept their secrets for protection
and then out of habit. Michael Hammer, a research professor at the
University of Arizona and an expert on
Jewish genetics, said that
fewer than 1% of non-Semites possessed the male-specific "Cohanim
marker " or
Cohen Modal Haplotype
Cohen Modal Haplotype , which is prevalent among Jews
claiming descent from hereditary priests. 30 of 78 Latinos tested in
New Mexico (38.5%), were found to have
Y-DNA with the Cohanim marker.
Wider DNA testing of
Hispanic populations has revealed between 10% and
15% of men living in New Mexico, south Texas and northern Mexico have
a Y chromosome associated with the Middle East. Their history makes it
most likely that they are
Jewish rather than
In 2008, a gene mutation that is typically found only in Ashkenazi
Jews, and is linked to a virulent form of breast cancer in women, was
discovered in a cluster of
Hispanic Catholic women in southern
Colorado, many of whom trace their family's roots to northern New
Mexico. It was conclusively shown to be related to
given the history of the people in the area, and many families
reported knowledge of a high incidence of cancer. After testing and
notification of families, researchers worked with the extended
families on genetic counseling and to develop health strategies for
monitoring, early detection and treatment, as they were faced with the
higher risk associated with the gene.
Other evidence of
Jewish ancestry is language. According to a Jewish
genealogy blog, so-called "Mountain Spanish", a Spanish dialect spoken
by many of the old families of northern
New Mexico and southern
Colorado—and chiefly only among themselves—appears to be a form of
Ladino or Judezmo . This was a hybrid language that developed among
Jews in Iberia, from Old Spanish, Portuguese and
with sprinklings of
Arabic , Greek and other languages, depending on
the geographic region of the speakers or their ancestors.
Other claims of lost tribe status or other
Jewish origin, have not
yet been accepted by normative Jews.
* A tribe of Siberian Asian origin based in Central
their claims of
Jewish rather than pantheistic practices with the
Khazars . The latter, an invading tribe from either
Kazakhstan that conquered and ruled
Russia in the 9th century, is said
to have adopted
Judaism instead of Christianity or Islam, by their
* A tribe in western
Burma near the Indian and Bangladeshi borders
has sought genetic research to vindicate its tradition that their
ancestors were Syrian and Iranian
Judaism has not become a
major theological force in Southeast Asia. Introduced religions such
Hinduism and Islam, which converted several tribal groups, have
existed in Indochina (
Thailand , Cambodia and
Vietnam ) for hundreds
or thousands of years.
Groups claiming affiliation with Israelites
Interfaith marriage in
What is a Nation?
NOTES AND REFERENCES
* ^ See
Ethnic group .
* ^ See
Jewish ethnic divisions
Jewish ethnic divisions .
* ^ See
* ^ See
* ^ See Anti-miscegenation laws#
Nazi Germany , Mischlinge
* ^ Seldin MF, Shigeta R, Villoslada P, et al. (September 2006).
"European population substructure: clustering of northern and southern
populations". PLoS Genet. 2 (9): e143. PMC 1564423 . PMID 17044734
. doi :10.1371/journal.pgen.0020143 .
* ^ Bauchet, Marc; McEvoy, Brian; Pearson, Laurel N.; Quillen,
Ellen E.; Sarkisian, Tamara; Hovhannesyan, Kristine; Deka, Ranjan;
Bradley, Daniel G.; Shriver, Mark D. (2007). "Measuring European
Population Stratification with Microarray Genotype Data". American
Journal of Human Genetics. 80 (5): 948–956. ISSN 0002-9297 . doi
* Ethnic minorities in English law. Google Books. Retrieved
* Edgar Litt (1961). "
Jewish Ethno-Religious Involvement and
Political Liberalism". Social Forces. 39 (4): 328–332.
. doi :10.2307/2573430 .
Jews a Religious Group or an Ethnic Group?" (PDF). Institute
for Curriculum Services. Retrieved 21 October 2013.
* Sean Ireton (2003). "The
Samaritans – A
Jewish Sect in Israel:
Strategies for Survival of an Ethno-religious Minority in the Twenty
First Century". Anthrobase. Retrieved 2009-12-30.
* Levey, Geoffrey Brahm. "Toward a Theory of Disproportionate
Jewish Liberalism" (PDF).
* J. Alan Winter (March 1996). "Symbolic
Ethnicity or Religion Among
Jews in the United States: A Test of Gansian Hypotheses". Review of
Religious Research. 37 (3).
* ^ Sharot, Stephen, "
Jewish Ethnicity: Changing
Interrelationships and Differentiations in the Diaspora and Israel,"
in Ernest Krausz, Gitta Tulea, (eds.)
Jewish Survival: The Identity
Problem at the Close of the Twentieth Century, pp. 87–104
* ^ Will Herberg,
David G. Dalin, From Marxism to Judaism: the
Collected Essays of Will Herberg, p.240
* ^ Shaye J.D. Cohen (1999). The Beginnings of Jewishness. U.
California Press. pp. 305–306. ISBN 0-585-24643-2 .
* ^ Katz, Lisa. "Am I Jewish?". About.com. Retrieved 8 November
* ^ A B C "Who Is a Jew?". Judaism101. Retrieved 8 November 2013.
* ^ A B "In-Laws and
Shabbat Law". Ohr Somayach . 2009.
* ^ "Who Is A Jew?".
Jewish Virtual Library. Retrieved 2015-10-24.
* ^ The Principles of
Jewish Law, Ed.
Menachem Elon , p. 429m ISBN
Jewish Virtual Library, . Retrieved
September 2, 2008.
* ^ "Reform Movement's Resolution on
Patrilineal Descent, The
Status of Children of Mixed Marriages" from the final text of the
Report of the Committee on
Patrilineal Descent adopted on March 15,
1983, Central Conference of American Rabbis
* ^ Fighting for
Jewish Justice, . Retrieved
September 2, 2008.
Jewish Living: A Guide to Reform Contemporary Practice by Rabbi
Mark Washofsky (URJ Press)
Jewish Living: A Guide to Reform Contemporary Practice, Rabbi
Mark Washofsky (URJ Press)
* ^ Reform Movement\'s Resolution on
* ^ "The Establishment of Reform
Judaism in Israel". American
Jewish Committee. Retrieved July 26, 2015.
* ^ A B p.154, Levinson,
David (Ed.), Encyclopedia of World
Cultures Vol 9 : Africa and the Middle East, G. K. Hall & Co., Boston,
* ^ "Karaite FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions About Karaism".
karaite-korner.org. Retrieved July 26, 2015.
* ^ "
Jewish Virtual Library. Retrieved
January 6, 2015.
* ^ Lisa Katz. "Who is a Jew via Descent". About. Retrieved January
* ^ Conversion to Judaism. Retrieved January 6, 2015.
* ^ Ben Rafael, Eliezer,
Jewish identities: fifty intellectuals
answer Ben Gurion , p.210
* ^ Elon, Menachem (1994).
Jewish Law : History, Sources,
Jewish Publication Society . ISBN 978-0-8276-0387-5 .
as quoted in "
Jewish Law Research Guide". University of Miami School
of Law . 2011. Retrieved August 16, 2011. The Shulchan Aruch,
completed in 1565, is probably the most important of the legal codes.
For hundreds of years, it has been accepted as the final and
authoritative codification of the laws found in the Talmud. (3 ELON at
1368–1422.) Even the work's title indicates its authority. Shulchan
Aruch translates as "set table," thereby symbolically stating that the
Jewish law has finally be set and settled in a clear code. (The
authoritative code of
Jewish law is the
Shulchan Aruch along with
glosses on the
Shulchan Aruch added by Moshe Isserles (c.
1525–1572), also called Rama or Remu, that present legal opinions
omitted by Karo, especially opinions specific to the Ashkenazic
(German and Eastern European)
Jewish customs. The glosses are called
the "table cloth" to the "set table" of the Shulchan Aruch. The two
together still form the definitive codification of
Jewish law. 3 ELON
* ^ Schechter,
Louis Ginzberg (1906). "Law, Codification
Jewish Encyclopedia .
Funk & Wagnalls . pp. 645–647. Retrieved
August 16, 2011. Only when authorities like Samuel b.
Shabbethai b. Meïr, notwithstanding their scholarship and
independence, accepted most of the decisions of the Shulḥan 'Aruk as
authoritative, did the work become what it now is, the codex par
excellence of rabbinical Judaism.
* ^ Klein, Isaac. A Guide to
Jewish Religious Practice. The Jewish
Theological Seminary, 1979. p. 442-443
* ^ "Conversion to
judaismconversion.org. Retrieved July 26, 2015.
* ^ "Proving
* ^ "The Status of Non-Halakhic Conversions" (PDF). Archived from
the original (PDF) on 2005-12-28.
* ^ "Should the
Kashrut of Conversions be Investigated?" (PDF).
Archived from the original (PDF) on 2006-06-28.
* ^ "www.templeisrael-ne.org". Retrieved January 6, 2015.
* ^ "Guidelines for Rabbis Working with Prospective Gerim"
* ^ Zemer, Moshe. Evolving Halakha.
Jewish Lights Publishing, 1999.
* ^ Robinson, George. Essential Judaism: A Complete Guide to
Beliefs, Customs and Rituals. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2000. ISBN
0-671-03480-4 , pgs 229–232.
* ^ "S.C.J. FAQ: Section 2.3. Who We Are: What is Conservative
Judaism?". Retrieved January 6, 2015.
* ^ Karaites hold first conversion in 500 years. August 2, 2007,
JTA Breaking News.
* ^ Although no scientific studies have been completed in regard to
Jewish intermarriage rate, anecdotal evidence suggests that
the Syrian community's current rate of intermarriage with non-
between 2 and 3%. The National
Jewish Population Survey study cited by
Gordon and Horowitz Antony Gordon and Richard Horowitz. "Will Your
Grandchildren Be Jewish". Retrieved 2008-02-19. gives intermarriage
rates for Centrist and Hasidic
Jews of 3% for those between the ages
of 18-39 and 6% overall, as compared with 32% for Conservative Jews,
46% for Reform
Jews and 49% for secular Jews. Gordon and Horowitz
suggest that the main reason for the difference is the growing
Jewish Day School education: "The combination of Jewish
commitment and having experienced a complete K-12 Orthodox
School education results in an intermarriage rate of not greater than
3%." This suggests that
Jewish day schools, rather than the edict, are
the decisive factor in discouraging intermarriage.
* ^ A B Katz, Lisa. "Who is a Jew?". Judaism. About.com. Retrieved
July 17, 2008.
* ^ "Question 18.3.4: Reform\'s Position On...What is unacceptable
practice?". FAQs.org. July 17, 2008. Retrieved July 17, 2008.
* ^ Voll, Fritz. "What about Christian
Jewish-Christian Relations. International Council of Christians and
Jews. Retrieved July 17, 2008.
* ^ Federow, Stuart (2003). "
Jews believe that "
Jews for Jesus,"
"Messianic Jews," and "
Hebrew Christians" are no longer Jews, even if
they were once Jews". What
Jews Believe.org. Archived from the
original on June 28, 2008. Retrieved July 17, 2008.
* ^ A B Lichtenstein, Aharon (March 2004). Leaves of Faith:
Selected Essays of
Rabbi Aharon Lichtenstein. KTAV Publishing House,
Inc. ISBN 0-88125-668-4 . Retrieved July 17, 2008.
* ^ Zelizer, Gerald L. (June 14, 1995). "The Return of Second
Generation Apostates" (PDF). YD. The Rabbinical Assembly. 268 (12):
146–50. Retrieved March 8, 2013.
* ^ Babylonian Talmud, Yebamoth 16b)
* ^ Pirke De-
Rabbi Elieze, chapter 36
* ^ "Reform
Judaism - Halachah". Retrieved 8 November 2013.
* ^ Angel, Marc, Choosing to be Jewish: the Orthodox road to
* ^ "Guidelines for Rabbis Working with Prospective gerim". Central
Conference of American Rabbis. September 6, 2001. Prior to completing
the process of giur, a rabbi should require that each prospective
ger/gioret make commitments within each of the following areas. These
commitments should be viewed as a demonstration of a dedication to
kabbalat mitzvot within the context of the brit between God and the
Jewish people and as a starting point for increased
by the prospective ger/gioret.
* ^ A B "As Rabbinate Stiffens Rules, Orthodox Rites Face
Scrutiny". Forward . June 2, 2006.
* ^ A B Schmemann, Serge (February 10, 1998). "Israel\'s Chief
Rabbis Reject Call By Non-Orthodox on Conversion". The New York Times.
* ^ A B C Gersom Gorenberg (March 2, 2008). "How do you prove
you\'re a Jew?". The New York Times.
* ^ Yaron, Y., Joe Pessah, and
Abraham Qanai. An Introduction to
Karaite Judaism: History, Theology, Practice, and Culture. N.p.:
Qirqisani Center, 2003. Print.
* ^ Meyer, Michael "Berit Mila within the History of the Reform
Movement" in Barth, Lewis (1990) Berit Mila in the Reform Context. New
York: Berit Milah Board of reform Judaism
* ^ "The Tenets of Reform Judaism".
Jewish Virtual Library.
Retrieved January 6, 2015.
* ^ A B Menachem Posner. "Is a convert who is a hemophiliac
required to have a circumcision?". Chabad.org.
* ^ Efforts to convert
Jews draw fire from interdenominational
* ^ "
Jewish People - Define". Retrieved January 6, 2015.
Apostate in the Synagogue
* ^ "American Reform Responsa : 71. An
Apostate Proselyte". An
adult proselyte who has become a Jew voluntarily cannot annul this
process in any way
* ^ "Contemporary American Reform Responsa : 67. Burial of
* ^ Orly Halpern (December 22, 2006). "
Knesset Mulls Ban on
Jewish Daily Forward.
* ^ Andrew Buckser (Spring 2005). "Chabad In Copenhagen:
Jewish Denmark". Ethnology. 44 (2):
JSTOR 3773993 . doi :10.2307/3773993 .
* ^ "492 U.S. 573". Retrieved January 6, 2015.
* ^ Samuel G. Freedman (April 13, 2003). "Men In Black". The New
* ^ "A Portrait of
Jewish Americans". Pew Research Center's
Religion & Public Life Project. October 1, 2013. Retrieved January 6,
* ^ Decter, Moshe (January 1963). "The Status of the
Jews in the
Soviet Union". The Council on Foreign Relations. Retrieved 21 April
* ^ Vence, Tracy. (July 10, 2014) "DNA Ancestry for All". The
Scientist. Retrieved 4 July 2015. The Scientist website
* ^ "The Half
Jewish Network: Welcoming Adult Children &
Grandchildren of Intermarriage". The Half-
Jewish Network: Welcoming
Adult Children & Grandchildren of Intermarriage. Retrieved January 6,
* ^ "Beta-Gershom.org". Retrieved January 6, 2015.
* ^ Daniel Klein and Freke Vuijst, The Half-
Jewish Book: A
Celebration, New York: Villard Books, 2000.
* ^ "Beta-Gershom.org". Retrieved January 6, 2015.
* ^ "SHJ Philosophy". Retrieved 8 November 2013.
* ^ Yair Auron (2012). Israeli Identities:
Jews and Arabs Facing
the Self and the Other. Berghahn Books. p. 25. ISBN 978-0-85745-305-1
Amos Oz (March 1998). "Behind the Sound and the Fury" (PDF).
Tikkun. Retrieved January 28, 2014.
* ^ A B C Navot, Suzi, Constitutional law of Israel, p.189
* ^ Uzi Rebhun, Chaim
Jews in Israel: contemporary
social and cultural patterns, pp.296–297
* ^ "
Judaism Test Guidelines" (PDF) (in Hebrew). Israel: Israeli
Rabbanut. 2010. Retrieved 2012-06-24.
* ^ "(unknown title)" (MSWord doc) (in Hebrew). Rabbinical Court,
State of Israel. Retrieved 2012-06-24.
* ^ "(unknown title)" (PDF) (in Hebrew). Israel: Ministry of
Religious Affairs, State of Israel. p. 1. Retrieved 2012-06-24.
* ^ "מחפשים את האמא היהודיה - בגליון
השבוע". ערוץ 7. Retrieved January 6, 2015.
* ^ "All non-Jews. Until proven otherwise". YNet (in Hebrew).
Israel. 2010-05-25. Retrieved 2012-06-24.
* ^ Hasson, Nir (2011-06-16). "Said in an interview that his mother
Jewish and Interior Ministry investigates the status". Haaretz
(in Hebrew). Israel. Retrieved 2012-06-24.
* ^ Ettinger, Yair (2011-12-02). "A New Role for Former Mossad
Haaretz (in Hebrew). Israel. Retrieved
* ^ Farber,
Rabbi Dr. Seth (2007-08-06). "Good for the
Jews / Big
winners in the proposal for civil marriages are actually Jewish
Haaretz (in Hebrew). Israel. Retrieved 2012-06-24.
* ^ Getting Married in Israel: Why It So Often Means Hiring a
Detective, Daniel Estrin ,
The Atlantic , February 13, 2013.
* ^ Gorenberg,
Gershom (2008-03-02). "How Do You Prove You\'re a
Jew?". The New York Times. New York. Retrieved 2012-06-24.
* ^ Hammer, Reuven (2012-01-13). "Removing stumbling blocks to
Jewish identity". The
Jerusalem Post. Israel. Retrieved 2012-06-24.
* ^ Ahren, Raphael (2010-07-30). "Sokolow\'s niece "not Jewish
enough" to marry here". Haaretz. Israel. Retrieved 2012-06-24.
* ^ Armangue, Bernat (2010-11-01). "Israeli
Jews at odds with
Judaism in U.S.". USA Today. Retrieved 2012-06-24.
* ^ Navot, Suzi, Constitutional law of Israel, p.188
* ^ Law of Return, paragraph 4A. This provision does not extend to
the spouse of an Israeli Jew (a non-Israeli person who married an
* ^ Jonathan Rosenblum, "Our New Mixed Multitude",
Home Page. Retrieved March 16, 2006.
* ^ "The Conversion Crisis: Testing the Principles". Retrieved
January 6, 2015.
Joshua Freeman (May 22, 2007). "Laying down the (Oral) law".
* ^ Rich, Tracey R. "What Is Judaism?".
Judaism 101. Retrieved July
* ^ "
Judaism in Israel". Judaism. About.com. Retrieved July 17,
* ^ "The Tribe". The Cohen-
Family Heritage. Retrieved July 17,
* ^ Weiner, Rebecca. "Who is a Jew?".
Jewish Virtual Library.
Retrieved July 17, 2008.
* ^ "Amar:
Bnei Menashe are Descendants of Ancient Israelites".
Haaretz. January 4, 2005. Retrieved July 17, 2008.
* ^ Freund, Michael (October 3, 2006). "Right On: A Miracle of
Biblical Proportions". The
Jerusalem Post. Retrieved July 17, 2008.
* ^ "Chief
Rabbi Says Indian Community Descended From Israelites".
Jewish Virtual Library. July 20, 2006. Retrieved July 17, 2008.
* ^ A B Tigay, Chanan (May 26, 2006). "Israel\'s Chief Rabbinate
Rejects some Diaspora Orthodox Conversions". New Jersey Jewish
Standard. Retrieved July 17, 2008.
* ^ Meyers, Nechemia (July 12, 1997). "Are Israel\'s Marriage Laws
\'Archaic and Irrelevant\'?".
Jewish News Weekly. Retrieved July 17,
* ^ Nathan Jeffay (March 16, 2011). "Israeli Government Rejects
Orthodox Converts\' Bids To Immigrate as Jews". The
* ^ "Lewis v Media 24 Ltd (C88/2007) ZALC 218; (2010) 31 ILJ 2416
(LC) (4 May 2010)". Retrieved January 6, 2015.
* ^ Salibi, Kamal S. (1988). Secrets of the Bible People. New York:
Interlink Books. p. 75 sqq. ISBN 0-940793-16-4
* ^ "What does it mean to be Jewish",
Jewish Historical Museum.
Retrieved March 16, 2006.
* ^ Monica Săvulescu Voudouris and Camil Fuchs,
after the Second World War, Editura Hasefer, Bucharest, 1999, p. 16.
* ^ Monica Săvulescu Voudouris and Camil Fuchs (1999), p. 56.
* ^ Alice Goldstein, "
Jews on the move: implications for Jewish
identity'", in eds.
Ivan Kalmar &
Derek Penslar , Orientalism and The
Jews, pp. 4.
SUNY Press , 1995 (ISBN 0-7914-2747-1 )
* ^ Nazi Germany's
Nuremberg Laws sources:
* Rich, Danny (October 29, 2009). "When state and religion mix". The
Sarah (November 8, 2009). "Who Is a Jew? Court Ruling in
Britain Raises Question". The New York Times.
Jewish school admissions unlawful". BBC News. June 25, 2009.
* Chabad.Info – News ‘Who Is A Jew’ Goes to Supreme Court
R(E) v Governing Body of JFS
R(E) v Governing Body of JFS EWCA Civ 626 (25 June 2009)
* ^ A
Mischling was called
Mischling of first degree, or
colloquially half-Jew, if they had two grandparents enrolled in a
Jewish congregation, and
Mischling of second degree, or colloquially
quarter-Jew, respectively, if they had one grandparent enrolled in a
* ^ Nazi guide to the Nuremberg laws .
* ^ Ruth Tsoffar (2006). The Stains of Culture: An Ethno-Reading of
Jewish Women. Detroit: Wayne State University Press,. p. 41.
* ^ A B Daniel C. Kramer, "Review of Vichy Law and the Holocaust in
France by Rishard H. Weisberg", Law Koder 1973; Thomas Puthiakunnel
David de Beth Hillel, 1832; Lord, James Henry 1977.
* ^ Ahmed, Rashmee Z (July 20, 2002). "India\'s children of Israel
find their roots". The Times of India. India.
* ^ Parfitt, T.; Egorova, Y. (June 2005). "Genetics, History, and
Identity: The Case of the
Bene Israel and the Lemba". Culture,
Medicine and Psychiatry. 29 (2): 193–224. PMID 16249950 . doi
* ^ "Indian
Jewish Community in Israel". indjews.com. Retrieved
July 26, 2015.
* ^ Xu, Xin. The
Jews of Kaifeng, China: History, Culture, and
Religion. Jersey City, NJ: KTAV Pub. House, 2003.
* ^ A B C Pfeffer, Anshel (June 27, 2008). "Taking the Silk Route
Haaretz . Retrieved December 28, 2009.
* ^ Dawid, Heinz (1998). Goldstein, Jonathan, ed. "From Berlin To
Jews of China. 1: 117. ISBN 978-0-7656-0103-2 .
* ^ Xun Zhou, "The Kaifeng Jew Hoax: Constructing the 'Chinese
Jews'", in eds.
Ivan Kalmar & Derek Penslar, Orientalism and The Jews,
pp. 68–80. Brandeis University Press (USA), 2004 (ISBN 1-58465-411-2
* ^ "Descendants of Chinese
Jews arrive in Israel". Jewish
Telegraphic Agency. October 26, 2009.
* ^ "Chinese
Jews from Kaifeng arrive in
Israel 2009". A short
documentary produced by Shavei
Israel on the aliyah of
Kaifeng China to Israel.
Rebecca Bitton (August 24, 2010). "Kaifeng
Jews study in
* ^ A B Jeff Wheelwright (October 2008). "The \'Secret Jews\' of
San Luis Valley". Smithsonian Magazine.
* ^ A B Kelly,
David (December 5, 2004). "DNA Clears the Fog Over
Latino Links to
Judaism in New Mexico". Los Angeles Times.
* ^ Hordes, Stanley M. (2005). To The End of The Earth: A History
of the Crypto-
Jews of New Mexico, Columbia University Press. pp. 376.
ISBN 978-0-231-12937-4 .
* ^ Romero, Simon (October 29, 2005). "Hispanics Uncovering Roots
as Inquisition\'s \'Hidden\' Jews". The New York Times.
* ^ "Turkey: A Ladino newspaper". Tracing the Tribe: The Jewish
Genealogy Blog. October 9, 2009. In northern New Mexico, the
descendants of Converso settlers who arrived as early as the late 16th
century, still speak "Mountain Spanish." In reality, it is 16th
century Ladino, and scholars who have visited them have been amazed at
how well the language has been transmitted down through the
* Kertzer, Morris (1996). What is a Jew?. New York: Touchstone. ISBN
* Siedman, Lauren (2007). What Makes Someone a Jew?. Woodstock,
Jewish Lights Publishing. ISBN 978-1-58023321-7 .
Jewish Identity on
Judaism view on Who is a Jew
* Reform view of who is a Jew by the Union for Reform
* Who is a Jew by