The Info List - The Woman's Prize

--- Advertisement ---

The Woman's Prize, or the Tamer Tamed is a Jacobean comedy written by John Fletcher. It was first published in the first Beaumont and Fletcher folio of 1647, though it was written several decades earlier (Fletcher died in 1625). There is no doubt that the play is the work of Fletcher alone; his highly distinctive and characteristic pattern of linguistic preferences is continuous through the text.[1] The play is a counterpart to Shakespeare's The Taming of the Shrew, in which (as the subtitle indicates) the gender tables are turned and Petruchio
the "tamer" is "tamed" by his second wife Maria, whom he marries after the death of Katherine, the "shrew" in Shakespeare's text. As a "reply" to Shakespeare's play, The Woman's Prize
The Woman's Prize
attracted critical attention in later generations and centuries. Maria's principal weapon, a refusal to consummate her marriage, shows the influence of Aristophanes' play Lysistrata.


1 Synopsis 2 Date 3 Sources 4 The 1633 revival 5 The manuscript 6 Performance history 7 See also 8 Notes 9 References 10 External links

Synopsis[edit] Petruchio's stormy marriage to Katherine ended with her death. Petruchio
is now married to Maria, who is even more resistant to domination than Katherine initially had been. Petruchio's tactics and manipulations are no longer effective, and Maria has some resourceful tricks of her own. Maria refuses to consummate their marriage till Petruchio
changes his ways; she bands together with other women in abstension from sex with their husbands. The women barricade themselves with provisions in the upper floor of Maria's house, to the displeased surprise of their husbands below. In Act Three Maria settles in to pursue a career of scholarship and horsemanship at Petruchio's country estate, but the peace is again broken when Maria once more refuses to perform her conjugal duties and imposes further demands on her husband. Petruchio
resolves to play ill in an attempt to awaken his wife's pity. His ruse fails totally when Maria catches on: in an extremely effective and humorous scene has Petruchio
walled up in his house on the pretext that he has caught the plague. Petruchio
finally fights his way out, but in Act Four he discovers that his wife has "gone mad"—she has begun to dress like a common whore (in a perfect counterpart to Petruchio's entrance in fantastic attire in the earlier play) and is busy flirting with his friends. When Petruchio
announces that he has had enough of marriage and is abandoning Maria for foreign travel, she encourages him to depart on the pretext that his journeys may broaden his vision and turn him into a better human being. Almost totally defeated as Act Five opens, Petruchio
tries one final stratagem in an attempt to awaken some spark of compassion in Maria. He decides to play dead, and in one of the Elizabethan theater's celebrated scenes he is borne onstage in a coffin before his wife and friends. Maria is indeed moved to tears, but they are inspired, as she tells us in a famous speech, not by his person but by his "unmanly, wretched, foolish life......how far below a man, how far from reason" Petruchio
has remained. This last salvo of abuse brings Petruchio
back from the dead: he sits up in his coffin, prompting in Maria a state of final bafflement if not total respect. The two pledge that they will start life anew together amidst the richly comic and ironic mood that ends the play. In the play's subplot, Livia joins in the protest of the married women, though her primary motive is to avoid an arranged marriage with the old and unpleasant Moroso and marry her own choice of husband, Roland. Both Maria and Livia succeed in attaining their wishes by the play's end. Date[edit] The date of the play is very uncertain and has attracted a large body of dispute and opinion. A reference to the Siege of Ostend
Siege of Ostend
in Act I, scene iii has led some commentators to date the play as early as 1604 (the siege ended on 8 September that year) [2] — though this is significantly earlier than the generally recognized start of Fletcher's dramatic career. Some scholars have argued for an early date, on the reasoning that a date closer in time to Shakespeare's play makes more sense than a later date. The non-Shakespearean or pre-Shakespearean version of the story, The Taming of a Shrew, was reprinted in 1607,[3] and may have influenced Fletcher to make a reply. Other critics are of the belief the play was written between November 1609 and February 1610. Because of the riots that took place in 1607, a number of scholars believe the play could not have been written earlier than the final months of 1609 and attribute the play to the early years of the reign of King James I. Others have favored a date as late as 1618-22 for the original version of the play, based on internal characteristics of Fletcher's evolving style.[4] Scholars who see a debt in the play to Ben Jonson's Epicene favor a date c. 1611. However, the first surviving reference to the play is contained in a government document dating on the morning of 18 October 1633 when Sir Henry Herbert, the Master of the Revels, `sent a warrant by messenger of the chamber to suppress The Tamer Tamed, to the King’s players for the afternoon`. The question of date is complicated by the matter of revision. The characters all have Italian names, and the original was likely set in Italy — but the existing version is set in London instead.[5] The date of revision and the identity of the reviser are equally unknown, though a reasonable conjecture holds that the revision was likely done just before the 1633 revival of the play by the King's Men, when the play was acted in conjunction with Shakespeare's. Sources[edit] Fletcher borrowed the name, age, and nuptial desire of Moroso from the character Morose in Ben Jonson’s comedy The Silent Woman. In Jonson’s play, Morose chooses a young bride for her demure silence, then after he marries her learns she the opposite of this. Fletcher reverses this by providing a "gentle tame" Maria, who is spurred to rebellion by marriage. Fletcher references the title of Jonson's play `I never will believe a silent woman;/ When they break out they are bonfires`(1.3.110-11). In both plays the conflict between the married couple begins after the nuptials. Fletcher's classical source for his play was Lysistrata. The Tamer Tamed was one of the first English plays based on Aristophanes, and Fletcher one of the first European critics to pay special attention to Lysistrata. The 1633 revival[edit] The 1633 revival provoked the wrath of Sir Henry Herbert, the Master of the Revels and the overseer of London theatre in the Caroline era. On 19 October 1633, Herbert ordered the King's Men not to perform The Woman's Prize that day, because of complaints of the "foul and offensive matters" it contained; the company acted the Beaumont/Fletcher play The Scornful Lady
The Scornful Lady
instead. The warrant prohibited `the acting of your play called The Tamer Tamed or The Taming of the Tamer, this afternoon, or any more till you have leave from me – and this is at your peril`. Five days later, on 24 October, John Lowin and Eliard Swanston, two of the leading actors in the company, came to Herbert's office to apologize personally for having given offense; their fellow actors Joseph Taylor and Robert Benfield were also present at the meeting, but apparently uninvolved in either the original offense or the apology. In regard to the same matter, Herbert addressed a 21 October letter to Edward Knight, the "book-keeper" or prompter of the King's Men, on the subject of "oaths, profaneness, and public ribaldry" in the company's plays.[6] Herbert's reaction to the play, which may have been caused by accusations of leniency from his superiors, specifically the Archbishop of Canterbury, William Laud, caused tension between the acting companies and the censor. Herbert's intervention in the performance that day resulted in a greater focus on the re-licensing of old plays that were being revived at the time. In order to de-politicise the play, a new prologue was introduced for the 1633 revival. Fletcher's play was cleaned up in time for a Court performance the next month: The Taming of the Shrew
The Taming of the Shrew
and The Woman's Prize were acted before the King and Queen at St. James's Palace
St. James's Palace
on 26 and 28 November respectively.[7] According to Herbert, Shakespeare's play was "liked" but Fletcher's was "very well liked." The existing Prologue and Epilogue, perhaps by the unknown reviser, may date from this performance; the Epilogue claims that Fletcher's play urges "both sexes due equality...to love mutually" (lines 7-8). The manuscript[edit] A manuscript of The Woman's Prize
The Woman's Prize
also survives, dating from this era. Appearing under the title of The Woman’s Prize: or, The Tamer Tamed the play was contained in the 1647 folio edition of thirty-four Comedies and Tragedies attributed to Beaumont and Fletcher. The text of this manuscript comes from Herbert's licensed playbook. The editing of the manuscript has been interpreted by some scholars as showing that Herbert had other goals besides suppressing "public ribaldry." Some elements of vulgarity still appear in the manuscript despite Herbert's intervention. The original text of the play had some blatant anti-Catholic elements, which, according to this view, Herbert wanted to suppress out of deference to the Queen, Henrietta Maria.[8] Now residing in the Folger Library, another undated and untitled seventeenth-century manuscript survives. It appears to have been copied from the original source text, before Herbet's revision of the text in 1633. This, in turn, means that much of the content that was deemed by Herbert to be "offensive" is contained in this manuscript and the original text can be restored somewhat. Performance history[edit] The play was probably first performed between December 1609 and April 1610 in the Whitefriars Theatre by the Children of the Queen’s Revels, and would have been performed by a troupe of boys. It was revived in 1633, to the objection of the Master of Revels, who viewed it as vulgar. After the return of Charles II, it was one of the first plays performed after the official re-opening of the theatres. The play was popular and was revived early and often in the Restoration era. Samuel Pepys
Samuel Pepys
saw it performed at the Cockpit Theatre on Tuesday 30 October 1660; it was played at the Vere Street theatre in Dec. 1661, and at Theatre Royal, Drury Lane
Theatre Royal, Drury Lane
in November 1668. When Fletcher's sequel and Shakespeare's original were revived jointly, in 1633 and in the 1660s, Fletcher's proved the more popular work; around 1667 The Shrew was adapted by John Lacy to make it a better match with The Woman's Prize.[9] It was performed before Charles II twice, once at court in 1668 and again in a public theatre in 1674. David Garrick adapted the play, but removed the subplot; it was performed at least three times, twice in 1757 and once in 1760, with Hannah Pritchard playing Maria. A performance in 1979 opened the Harbor Shakespeare
Festival in Baltimore, Maryland. Another adaption was performed at the Arcola Theatre in London in 2001 and featured a combination of Fletcher’s play and Shakespeare’s The Taming of the Shrew. The Woman's Prize; or, The Tamer Tamed was revived by the Royal Shakespeare Company
Royal Shakespeare Company
in early 2003; their production opened on 6 March that year.[10] The play subsequently moved to the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts.[11] See also[edit]

Swetnam the Woman-Hater


^ Hoy/Erdman, pp. 204-23. ^ Chambers, Vol. 3, p. 222. ^ Q3, printed by Valentine Simmes for the bookseller Nicholas Ling. ^ Logan and Smith, p. 61. ^ Oliphant, pp. 155-6. ^ Halliday, p. 268. ^ "EMLoT: db/browse/?page=24&resulttype=event&ordering=default". www.emlot.kcl.ac.uk. Retrieved 2015-06-06.  ^ Dutton, pp. 13, 42, 56-60. ^ Dobson, p. 23. ^ Hodgdon, Barbara, ed. (2010). The Taming of the Shrew. The Arden Shakespeare, Third Series. London: Methuen. p. 72. ISBN 9781903436936.  ^ Tarloff, Erik (14 December 2003). "Theatre: The Play That Tamed Taming of the Shrew". The New York Times. Retrieved 9 January 2015. 


Chambers, E. K. The Elizabethan Stage. 4 Volumes, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1923. Daileader, Celia R. Eroticism on the Renaissance Stage: Transcendence, Desire, and the Limits of the Visible. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1998. Dobson, Michael S. The Making of the National Poet: Shakespeare, Adaptation and Authorship, 1660-1769. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1995. Dutton, Richard. Licensing, Censorship, and Authorship in Early Modern England. London, Palgrave, 2001. Downes, John. Roscius Anglicanus. original edition, London, H. Playford, 1708. Montague Summers, ed., New York, Benjamin Blom, 1929; reprinted Ayers Publishing, 1968. Fischlin, Daniel, and Mark Fortier. Adaptations of Shakespeare: A Critical Anthology of Plays From the Seventeenth Century to the Present. London, Routledge, 2000. Halliday, F. E. A Shakespeare
Companion 1564–1964. Baltimore, Penguin, 1964. Hoy, Cyrus. "The Shares of Fletcher and His Collaborators in the Beaumont and Fletcher Canon." Studies in Bibliography VIII (1956), pp. 129–46. Reprinted in: Evidence for Authorship: Essays on Problems of Attribution, edited by David V. Erdman and Ephim G. Fogel. Ithaca, NY, Cornell University Press, 1996. Logan, Terence P., and Denzell S. Smith, eds. The Later Jacobean and Caroline Dramatists: A Survey and Bibliography of Recent Studies in English Renaissance Drama. Lincoln, NE, University of Nebraska Press, 1978. Oliphant, E. H. C. The Plays of Beaumont and Fletcher: An Attempt to Determine Their Respective Shares and the Shares of Others. New Haven, Yale University Press, 1927.

External links[edit]

Audio recording of The Woman's Prize, Librivox.org The Taming of the Tamer:The Voice of the Dramaturg: Artist, Adaptor, or Scholar? Creating an Acting Version and an Annotated Edition of John Fletcher's The Taming of the Tamer The Woman‘s Prize. From the Rare Book Room.

v t e

The "Beaumont and Fletcher" Canon

Francis Beaumont John Fletcher Philip Massinger

Nathan Field William Shakespeare James Shirley Thomas Middleton William Rowley John Ford Ben Jonson George Chapman John Webster

Plays (some attributions conjectural)


The Knight of the Burning Pestle The Masque of the Inner Temple and Gray's Inn

Beaumont and Fletcher

The Woman Hater Cupid's Revenge The Coxcomb Philaster The Captain The Maid's Tragedy A King and No King Love's Pilgrimage The Scornful Lady The Noble Gentleman


The Faithful Shepherdess The Woman's Prize Valentinian Bonduca Monsieur Thomas The Mad Lover The Chances The Loyal Subject Women Pleased The Humorous Lieutenant The Island Princess The Pilgrim The Wild Goose Chase A Wife for a Month Rule a Wife and Have a Wife

Fletcher and Massinger

†Barnavelt The Little French Lawyer The False One The Double Marriage The Custom of the Country The Lovers' Progress The Spanish Curate The Prophetess The Sea Voyage The Elder Brother †A Very Woman

Fletcher and others

with Beaumont & Massinger Thierry and Theodoret Beggars' Bush Love's Cure with Massinger & Field The Honest Man's Fortune The Queen of Corinth The Knight of Malta with Field Four Plays, or Moral Representations, in One with Shakespeare †Henry VIII The Two Noble Kinsmen with Shirley The Night Walker Wit Without Money with Rowley The Maid in the Mill with Massinger, Chapman & Jonson Rollo, Duke of Normandy with Massinger, Ford & Webster The Fair Maid of the Inn


The Nice Valour (Middleton) Wit at Several Weapons (Middleton & Rowley) The Laws of Candy (Ford) The Coronation (Shirley)

Performance and Publication

English Renaissance theatre King's Men Beaumont and Fletcher folios Humphrey Moseley Humphrey Robinson


The History of Cardenio ( Shakespeare
& Fletcher?) † Double Falsehood
Double Falsehood
(possibly based on Cardenio)

† = Not published in the Beaumont and Fletcher folios

v t e

William Shakespeare's The Taming of the Shrew


Katherina Minola Petruchio Bianca Minola Baptista Minola Christopher Sly

Stage adaptations

The Woman's Prize
The Woman's Prize
(c1611) Catharine and Petruchio
(1754) Las bravías
Las bravías
(1896) Der Widerspänstigen Zähmung
Der Widerspänstigen Zähmung
(1872) Sly, ovvero La leggenda del dormiente risvegliato (1927) Kiss Me, Kate
Kiss Me, Kate
(1948) The Taming of the Shrew
The Taming of the Shrew
(1953) Ukroshchenye Stroptivoy (1957) Christopher Sly
Christopher Sly

Direct adaptations

1908 1929 1962 (TV) 1967 1980 (TV) 1994 (TV)

Other adaptations

Daring Youth
Daring Youth
(1924) You Made Me Love You (1933) Second Best Bed
Second Best Bed
(1938) Kiss Me Kate (1953) Abba Aa Hudugi
Abba Aa Hudugi
(1959) Gundamma Katha
Gundamma Katha
(1962) Manithan Maravillai
Manithan Maravillai
(1962) McLintock!
(1963) Arivaali
(1963) Pattikada Pattanama
Pattikada Pattanama
(1972) Il Bisbetico Domato
Il Bisbetico Domato
(1980) Nanjundi Kalyana
Nanjundi Kalyana
(1989) 10 Things I Hate About You
10 Things I Hate About You
(1999) O Cravo e a Rosa
O Cravo e a Rosa
(2000; TV) Deliver Us from Eva
Deliver Us from Eva
(2003) The Taming of the Shrew
The Taming of the Shrew
(2005; TV) Frivolous Wife
Frivolous Wife
(2008) 10 Things I Hate About You
10 Things I Hate About You
(2009; TV) Isi Life Mein
Isi Life Mein


The Taming of the Shrew
The Taming of the Shrew
in performance The Taming of the Shrew
The Taming of the Shrew
on screen Shrew (stock character) Inductio