Slavery at American colleges and universities

The role of slavery at American colleges and universities has been a focus of historical investigation and controversy. Enslaved Africans labored to build institutions of higher learning in the United States, and the slave economy was involved in funding many universities. People, forced to labor and seen as less than human, were used to build academic buildings and residential halls. Though slavery has long been presented as a uniquely Southern institution, colleges and universities in Northern states benefited from the labor of slaves. The economics of slavery brought some slave owners great wealth, enabling them to become major donors to fledgling colleges. Many colleges founded in states with legalized slavery utilized enslaved people and benefited from the slavocracy. Slaves were also sold by university administrators to generate capital. In some parts of the nation it was also not uncommon for wealthy students to bring an enslaved person with them to college. Ending almost 250 years of slavocracy did not end white supremacy, structural racism, or other forms of oppression at American colleges and the legacy of slavery still persists in many establishments.

In 2004, Ira Berlin wrote that the study of slavery at universities can be controversial and can lead to tense debates. "Accompanied by the charge that the interpreters have said too much (why do you dwell upon it?) or too little (why can't you face the truth?)." He states that by reckoning with slavery, “Americans—white and black—can have a past that is both memorable and, at last, a past.”

In 2006, Brown University became the first university to publish a report detailing its ties to slavery. Over the following decades, a number of American colleges and universities have made efforts to research, address, and teach about their historical connections to slavery. In 2014, a number of institutions led by the University of Virginia established Universities Studying Slavery (USS), an informal working group and later consortium dedicated to investigating institutional histories as they relate to slavery or racism. Efforts and calls to address historical connections to slavery and enduring racism at American universities were renewed in the wake of the 2020 George Floyd protests.

Brown University

A number of Brown University's founders and early administrators owned slaves. Among them were Stephen Hopkins, Brown's first chancellor; and James Manning, the college's first president.

The Brown family

The Brown family, the university's namesake, were instrumental in the establishment and endowment of the college. They owned slaves and participated in the slave trade, investing in two slaving voyages (1736 and 1759). Compared to fellow members of Rhode Island’s elite mercantile class, the Browns were not major slave traders. According to historian Joanne Melish, "many Providence residents held more slaves than John Brown."

The family's relationship with slavery was neither monolithic nor constant. In 1773, Moses Brown experienced an emotional and spiritual crisis which led to his conversion to Quakerism. At that time, Moses, who had previously enslaved six people, renounced chattel slavery. Moses freed his slaves the same year, writing:

Over the following years, Moses emerged as a prominent abolitionist and began an anti-slavery crusade. These views clashed with those of his brother, John, who defend the practice, leading to a period of vocal public debate between the two. John Brown continued to participate in the international slave trade into the 1790s, following its federal abolition. For this violation, John was tried in federal court, making him the first person charged under the law.

Brown's oldest building, University Hall, maintains a number of connections to slavery. Prominent Newport merchant and slave trader Aaron Lopez donated timber to the building project while the company of fellow slave trader Nicholas Brown, Sr. led the construction. The workforce involved in the construction of the building was diverse, reflecting the ethnic and social admixture of colonial Providence's population. Slaves, free people of color, indigenous people, and white skilled and unskilled laborers worked to erect the structure.

''Slavery and Justice''

In 2003, then-University president Ruth Simmons launched a steering committee to research its eighteenth-century ties to slavery. In October 2006, the committee released a report documenting its findings. Entitled "Slavery and Justice," the document detailed the ways in which the university benefited both directly and indirectly from the transatlantic slave trade and the labor of enslaved people. The report included seven recommendations for how the university should address this legacy. Brown has since completed a number of these recommendations, including the establishment of the Center for the Study of Slavery and Justice and the funding of a $10 million permanent endowment for Providence Public Schools. Brown's Slavery and Justice report marked the first major effort by an American university to address its ties to slavery and prompted other institutions to do the same.

Memorialization

In September 2014, the university erected a memorial to acknowledge the institution's connection to the trans-Atlantic slave trade and memorialize the Africans and African-Americans, both enslaved and free, who were instrumental in the building of the school. Its creation was one of the recommendations established in Brown's 2006 ''Slavery and Justice'' report. The memorial, designed by contemporary sculptor Martin Puryear and located adjacent to University Hall, resembles a massive ball and chain half submerged in the ground.

Reparations

In a 2021 vote, more than 80% of participating Brown University students voted in favor of a non-binding referendum calling for the university to pay reparations to the descendants of people enslaved by its founders and benefactors. In April 2021, President Christina Paxson declined to commit to a university policy of direct financial compensation to descendants of enslaved people, calling the issue a "really complicated question."

Columbia University

Columbia University (then known as King's College) was formed in 1754. By the end of the Civil War, ten men had served as president of the school; of those, at least half were slave-owners, as were the first four treasurers of the school.

The report, ''Columbia University and Slavery'' identifies the slave owners among its first presidents: Samuel Johnson, Benjamin Moore, William Samuel Johnson, William Alexander Duer, and Frederick A. P. Barnard. Duer's family wealth derived from the transatlantic slave trade. The school does not appear to have ever owned any slaves directly. Since a 2015 course on the school's connections to slavery, Columbia has maintained a website with the findings.

Barnard College

The namesake of Barnard College, Frederick A. P. Barnard enslaved an unknown number of people, many of whose names are absent in official records. The women's college is named after him in part due to his support for coeducation of women and men.

Sometime after he began working at the University of Alabama, Barnard began enslaving people. Some of these slaves would work as research assistants in his labs, including one named Sam, while others would serve as domestics in his home. During his time there, Barnard also allegedly sexually abused enslaved black women, a behavior tolerated by his peers on the faculty. A list of other enslaved people associated with Barnard in Alabama included: "Little Mary", Morgan, Luna, Tom, and Johnson. Barnard described his 16 years at the University of Alabama as "some of the happiest and most fruitful years of his life".

One of the people he enslaved, Jane, was assaulted in 1859 by a student while she was working for Barnard at the University of Mississippi. Barnard, who was away at the time of the assault, sought expulsion of the offending student by the university faculty. It is unclear whether Barnard's motivation for this was retributive justice for Jane or restitution for himself after the intrusion on his home and lost labor as Jane recovered. Jane did not get justice as her testimony was not deemed credible according to Mississippi law, and the faculty did not expel her assailant. This incident created a wedge between Barnard and the rest of the university establishment, leading to his eventual departure - in which he left much of his property, including his slaves, behind.

Barnard was not perceived fondly by his colleagues at universities in the South, an antipathy motivated in large part by his Northern upbringing. Despite being a slaveowner, he was often suspected by his peers of having sympathies for the abolitionist cause. In response to claims of being an abolitionist sympathizer, Barnard continually reiterated his support for the South and for the institution of slavery. However, upon his return to the North during the Civil War, Barnard published an open letter to Abraham Lincoln in which he affirmed loyalty to the Union and defended past pro-slavery statements as necessary political strategy. The explanation provided in the letter to President Lincoln does not at all provide resolution to the controversial issue of Barnard's owning of slaves during his tenure at the University of Alabama.

Dartmouth College

Dartmouth's founder Eleazar Wheelock enslaved at least 18 black people during his lifetime. Eight slaves accompanied Wheelock when he and his pupils set out to establish Dartmouth's Hanover campus in 1770. According to Craig Wilder "there were more slaves than faculty, administrators, or active trustees; in fact, there were arguably as many enslaved black people at Dartmouth as there were students in the college course, and Wheelock's slaves outnumbered his Native American students."

Dartmouth College president Nathan Lord defended slavery in the lead up to the American Civil War, causing controversy and leading to his eventual resignation.

Georgetown University

1838 Jesuit slave sale

In 1838, 272 the Maryland Province of the Society of Jesus, which ran, among other schools, Georgetown College, sold 272 slaves; about 10% of the proceeds was used to satisfy Georgetown's debts. The slaves had lived on plantations belonging to the Jesuits in Maryland, and they were sold to Henry Johnson and Jesse Batey. The sale price was $115,000, . Of the $25,000 down-payment, $17,000 was used to pay down building debt that Thomas F. Mulledy, the provincial superior who orchestrated the sale, had previously accrued as Georgetown's president.

In 1821, Georgetown's procurator objected to the food served to the enslaved peoples who were on campus as being too expensive and generous. He wrote that the slave rations were “carried there in abundance” and called for more austere food provisions.

Contemporary response

National revelations of this connection were reported in a 2016 article in ''The New York Times''. In response to the revelations, Georgetown University held a service called the "Liturgy of Remembrance, Contrition and Hope." At the liturgy, Fr. Timothy Kesicki, the president of the Jesuit Conference of Canada and the United States, said, “Those 272 souls...received the same sacraments, read from the same scriptures, prayed the same prayers, sang the same hymns, and praised the same God—how did we, the Society of Jesus, fail to see us all as one body in Christ? We betrayed the very name of Jesus for whom our least Society is named.”

Following broad publicity regarding the transaction, the university moved to rename two buildings that bore the names of Jesuits at Georgetown who had played significant roles in the 1838 sale, Thomas Mulledy and William McSherry. In November 2015, Mulledy Hall was renamed Freedom Hall and McSherry Hall was renamed Remembrance Hall as temporary measures while other names were being considered. In 2017, the two buildings were rededicated in the names of Isaac, the first slave listed in the 1838 sale document, and Anne Marie Becraft, a free woman of color who established a school in Georgetown for black girls.

Hamilton College

Hamilton College's alumni included several abolitionists and the school was among several New England colleges where abolitionist groups formed in the 1830s. The groups were inspired by William Lloyd Garrison's American Anti-Slavery Society. The New York State Legislature threatened to withhold funding, leading the college's president, Joseph Penny, to ban the group.

While the college's namesake, Alexander Hamilton, was involved in the early emancipation movement there is recently uncovered evidence that he was a slave owner and also sold or leased some of his slaves.

Harvard University

Slaves “served Harvard leaders" and "slave labor played a vital role in the unprecedented appreciation of wealth by New England merchants that laid the foundation of Harvard.” Furthermore, “Harvard students slept in beds and ate meals prepared by slaves, and many grew up to be prominent slave-holders and leaders in early America."

Presidential Initiative on Harvard and the Legacy of Slavery

The Initiative on Harvard and the Legacy of Slavery was announced in November 2019 by Harvard President Larry Bacow in an effort to better understand Harvard’s historic ties with slavery and the slave trade, and the impacts of those ties on the modern university. A committee was formed to examine and research the history, led by Tomiko Brown-Nagin, Dean of the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study, and including Sven Beckert, Paul Farmer, Annette Gordon-Reed, Stephen Gray, Evelynn Hammonds, Nancy Koehn, Meira Levinson, Tiya Miles, Martha Minow, Maya Sen, Daniel Smith, David Williams, and William Julius Wilson.

The report was released in April 2022 and found that Harvard had extensive ties to slavery. Harvard affiliates, including past presidents and faculty, enslaved more than 70 people during the earliest years, many of whom served the College’s earliest students. It also documented that the university continued to benefit financially from slavery even after it was outlawed in Massachusetts in 1783, via the financial support of donors enriched by the slave trade and the trading of goods harvested by enslaved people.

Also in the report were recommendations from the committee on how the university should move forward and redress its legacy of slavery. Among them were educational support for descendent communities, memorialization of enslaved persons, forming partnerships with HBCUs, and directly engaging and identifying descendants, among others.

Bacow and members of the Harvard Corporation unanimously agreed to accept the recommendations and committed $100 million to their short- and long-term implementation. Martha Minow, a University Professor and former Dean of Harvard Law School, was appointed to lead the implementation.

Harvard Law School

Isaac Royall Jr. was a wealthy merchant who donated land and funds to the university. He also funded the first professorship in law. The Royalls were so involved in the slave trade that “the labor of slaves underwrote the teaching of law in Cambridge.” The Royall's legacy at Harvard is lasting: Harvard Law School adopted the family's crest as a part of its own. That crest features a blue background with three bushels of wheat. Until recently this connection was unknown to many. After it was revealed that Harvard Law had historic ties to slavery, Dean Martha L. Minow began telling incoming law students about the school's past. The law school retired the seal in 2016 and in 2019 announced the formation of a working group to design a new one. In August 2021, the school unveiled a new seal featuring an abstract motif inspired by the architecture of Austin Hall and Hauser Hall. In conjunction with the university's release of the Report on Harvard and the Legacy of Slavery in spring of 2022, the Law School announced the permanent retirement of the Royal Chair, which was funded by an original gift from the Royal family, would be retired and never occupied again.

At the law school's bicentennial in 2017, President Drew Faust, Dean John Manning, and Professor Annette Gordon-Reed unveiled a new commemorative plaque to the slaves who helped build the schools. Faust said of the law school, “How fitting that you should begin your bicentennial with this ceremony reminding us that the path toward justice is neither smooth nor straight. Let us dedicate ourselves to the clear-eyed view of history that will enable us to build a more just future in honor of the stolen lives we memorialize here.”

2011 Report: Harvard and Slavery – Seeking a Forgotten History

In 2011, professor Sven Beckert, then graduate student Katherine Stevens, and the students of the Harvard and Slavery Research Seminar published a report about Harvard University and its ties to slavery. They were inspired by the work of Ruth Simmons at Brown University and began work in 2007. It begins by locating Harvard's ties to slavery in the larger concepts of American slavery, Northern slavery, and Triangular Trade. The report notes that, “by the mid-seventeenth century, slaves were part of the fabric of everyday life in colonial Massachusetts. They lived and labored in the colony. Their owners were often political leaders and heads of prominent families.” However unlike the Brown University report it did not make any official recommendations.

Photographs

Harvard was sued in 2019 by descendants of an enslaved man whose daguerreotype is in the possession of the university. According to the lawsuit, the university profits off of the publication of the photographs without permission of the enslaved man's descendants. In 2021, Middlesex County Superior Court Judge Camille Sarrouf dismissed the case, writing "the law as it currently stands, does not confer a property interest to the subject of a photograph regardless of how objectionable the photograph's origins may be."

In the 1990s, artist Carrie Mae Weems used the photograph in a series entitled "From Here I Saw What Happened and I Cried."

Johns Hopkins University

In 2020, historians at Johns Hopkins University discovered that its founder, original benefactor and namesake, Johns Hopkins, claimed four men as property in the 1850 census. Hopkins had also used slaves as collateral for debt.

Prior to the discovery, the university had held its founder was a "strong abolitionist," based on the representation of Hopkins in a 1929 publication written by his grandniece and published by the school's press.Jaclyn Dia
Johns Hopkins, Long Believed An Abolitionist, Actually Owned Slaves, University Says
''NPR'', December 10, 2020. The main claim being that Johns Hopkins' parents freed all their slaves by 1807. Many also pointed to his specification that people of any race should be cared for in his hospital and his encouragement for the trustees of the hospital to establish an orphanage for black children. This information may have remained unknown for so long due to the fact that most of Hopkins' personal papers were destroyed or lost since his death.

According to the university, "the current research... finds no evidence to substantiate [the] description of Johns Hopkins as an abolitionist." In an open letter the university's president, Ronald J. Daniels, stated the findings "complicate the understanding" of the school towards its founder.

University of Pennsylvania

The University of Pennsylvania's founders, benefactors, trustees, and faculty included slave owners. Among these were the university's founder and first president, Benjamin Franklin, who also profited from and facilitated the slave trade by running advertisements for the sale of enslaved people in his newspaper, the ''Pennsylvania Gazette''.

In 2017, the university began the Penn & Slavery Project to explore the connections of its funders, trustees, and faculty to slavery as well as uncover the stories of people enslaved by them. Among the trustees of the university who enslaved people were John Cadwalader (general), John Cadwalader, Benjamin Chew, Benjamin Franklin, Isaac Norris (mayor), Isaac Norris, William Plumsted, James Potter (Pennsylvania politician), James Potter, Joseph Reed (politician), Joseph Reed, and Thomas Willing.

Caesar was one enslaved man who worked at the university from 1756-1770. He was enslaved by Ebenezer Kinnersley, a colleague of Benjamin Franklin and faculty member. Caesar's duties on the early university campus included ringing the school bell and building fires for the students, but Kinnersley was paid by the university for Caesar's work. It is unclear if Caesar was ever freed. Caesar's Bell became the symbol for the Penn & Slavery Project as it had rested in the Van Pelt Library without acknowledgement of Caesar's work.

Princeton University

Sixteen out of Princeton University, Princeton University's first twenty-three trustees "bought, sold, traded, or inherited slaves during their lifetimes" and the school had "deep and intimate ties to human bondage." The first nine presidents of Princeton University enslaved people. Upon the death of its fifth president, Samuel Finley, in 1766, the people he held captive were auctioned on campus. John Maclean Jr. (1854-1868) was the first president to not forcibly hold people against their will. Princeton also had connections to the colonization movement which aimed to stop the Atlantic Slave Trade but also repatriate emancipated slaves to Africa as they were perceived as a burden on public resources.

White supremacy and structural racism at Princeton did not end with the end of the slavocracy. Princeton President Woodrow Wilson (1902-1910), for example, was an avowed white supremacist.

Rutgers University

The namesake of Rutgers was Henry Rutgers, a trustee of the institution. He was a third generation slave owner and as a real estate developer he used slave labour to build his own wealth.

Rutgers has a long history of involvement with the slave trade. Some of the founders, early benefactors, and early presidents were involved in the slave trade. During the Revolutionary War the college relocated the homestead of slaveowner. The first president of Rutgers (then Queen's College), Jacob Rutsen Hardenbergh was a slaveholder, among his slaves was Sojourner Truth who later escaped to freedom. Rutgers University's oldest extant building, Old Queens, was built in part by enslaved laborers including one man named Will.

Shortly before Rutgers University reached its 250th anniversary Chancellor-Provost Richard Edwards announced the formation of the Committee on Enslaved and Disenfranchised Populations in Rutgers History. This committee created the Scarlet and Black Project which published 3 volumes of books by the same name and digital archives covering the entire racial history of Rutgers.

Additionally the committee put forward recommendations including explicit acknowledgement on campus of its history, establishing and expanding affirmative action programs, commissioning a memorial for the dispossessed and enslaved, renaming buildings, funding of further research, and making a diversity course required for all students.

University of Virginia

The University of Virginia in Charlottesville, Virginia owned and rented slaves for decades. Between 1817 and 1865, approximately 4,000 enslaved people worked on the University of Virginia's campus. All of the men involved in the founding of the university were slaveowners. These individuals maintained the university's grounds, worked to construct buildings, served the students and faculty, and sometimes lived in quarters below student residences. The majority of students during this period were able to attend due to the wealth of their slave-owning families, though these students were not permitted to bring their own slaves.

After the Civil War, though the slaves of the university gained their freedom they were still employed for very low wages.

Thomas Jefferson

The University of Virginia's founder, Thomas Jefferson enslaved more than 600 African American people during his lifetime. Most historians believe that after the death of his wife Martha Jefferson, Martha, Jefferson had Jefferson–Hemings controversy, a decades-long relationship with her half-sister, Sally Hemings, a slave at his plantation, Monticello.''Jefferson's Blood''
, PBS ''Frontline (U.S. TV series), Frontline,'' 2000. Section: "Is It True?" Quote: "[T]he new scientific evidence has been correlated with the existing documentary record, and a consensus of historians and other experts who have examined the issue agree that the question has largely been answered: Thomas Jefferson fathered at least one of Sally Hemings' children, and quite probably all six.", accessed 26 September 2014 According to DNA evidence from surviving descendants and oral history, Jefferson probably fathered at least six children with Hemings, including four that survived to adulthood. Many argue that given her position, Hemings was not able to consent to sexual contact, making Jefferson's actions rape.

When establishing the University of Virginia Jefferson's vision was that it would be an institution to protect against the abolitionists of the North. Jefferson's own slaves were involved in the construction of the university.

Memorial to Enslaved Laborers

In 2020, the university completed the construction of its Memorial to Enslaved Laborers. Designed by Höweler+Yoon, the memorial honors the community of enslaved African American laborers that constructed and facilitated the operation of the university.

College of William and Mary

The College of William & Mary benefitted from enslaved labor from its inception in 1693 until the Emancipation Proclamation made slavery illegal in 1863. An academic inquiry into its slavery history, the Lemon Project, is underway.

Between 1760 and 1765, the Prince George House may have been used by English philanthropists, the Associates of Dr. Bray (named for Thomas Bray), to Christianization, Christianize and educate local enslaved and free black children. Adam and Fanny, two children who were enslaved by William & Mary, attended the school at its second location, assumed to have been on Capitol Landing Road in Williamsburg, Virginia, Williamsburg.

Furman University

On October 26, 2016, Marian Baker wrote an article in the student newspaper ''The Paladin'' discussing the Furman family's history of slaveholding and questioning a plaque on the humanities building named in honor the university's first president, James C. Furman. In response, the university joined Universities Studying Slavery in 2017, commissioning a Task Force on Slavery and Justice. The task force's report came out a year later under the title "Seeking Abraham" with documentation of the university namesake Richard Furman's leadership in Baptist views on slavery, as well as responding to the questions regarding James C. Furman raised by Marian Baker. The title of the report refers to Abraham Sims, who was enslaved by the Furman family but was referred to as an "ex-slave" in a 1890 photo of the Furman home, the search for information on Abraham is used as an analogy for the reports wider goal of searching for the whole history of Furman University. The report also documented the movement of the university due to its reliance on funding from slavers, use of slave labor in building the original Greenville (South Carolina) campus, and the legacies of slavery up to the present day. It also focused on resistance to desegregation at the university, the experience of black students encountering racism and micro-aggressions, and limited African-American attendance throughout the twentieth century.

In response, the Furman University Board of Trustees voted to approve the report's accuracy and commit to repair historical harms, including a reparation scholarship that benefited African-American students, especially those who live in the historic locations of the college. Trustees installed a plaque that renamed the building "Furman Hall" instead of "James C. Furman Hall," and drew attention to the racist arguments Furman had used to support secession. An annual event Joseph Vaughn Day began in 2019 and a central plaza on campus Joseph Vaughn Plaza was installed in 2020. Clark Murphy Residential Housing Complex became the first building on campus named for an African-American person, a person enslaved by the Greenville Woman's College that merged with Furman University in the 1930s. The mission and values statement of the university was significantly altered the same year to reflect the university's changed perspective on its history, to say, "As we draw lessons from thoughtful consideration of our university’s past, we advocate respect for all people and actively welcome perspectives from a wide variety of backgrounds, cultures, and beliefs."

Yale University

Yale University is named for slave-trader and merchant Elihu Yale. According to historian Craig Steven Wilder, Yale also "inherited a small slave plantation in Rhode Island that it used to fund its first graduate programs and its first scholarships... [the university] aggressively sought out opportunities to benefit from the slave economies of New England and the broader Atlantic world."

In 1998, the university established the Gilder Lehrman Center for the Study of Slavery, Resistance, and Abolition at the MacMillan Center for International and Area Studies.

The legacy of slavery at Yale was addressed in the February 2002 edition of the ''Yale Alumni Magazine.''

In 2017, following years of protest, Yale University renamed Calhoun College — one of its residential colleges — to Grace Hopper College. The college had previously been named for Vice President John C. Calhoun, a South Carolina Slavery in the United States, slave owner and anti-abolitionist. Other buildings have retained the names of slave owners, including Bishop George Berkeley, Timothy Dwight IV, Timothy Dwight and Ezra Stiles.

References

{{Reflist

Slavery in the United States
Education controversies in the United States
History of universities and colleges in the United States