HOME
The Info List - Pragmatic Ethics


--- Advertisement ---



(i)

PRAGMATIC ETHICS is a theory of normative philosophical ethics . Ethical pragmatists, such as John Dewey
John Dewey
, believe that some societies have progressed morally in much the way they have attained progress in science . Scientists can pursue inquiry into the truth of a hypothesis and accept the hypothesis, in the sense that they act as though the hypothesis were true; nonetheless, they think that future generations can advance science, and thus future generations can refine or replace (at least some of) their accepted hypotheses. Similarly, ethical pragmatists think that norms, principles, and moral criteria are likely to be improved as a result of inquiry .

CONTENTS

* 1 Contrast with other normative theories * 2 Relationship to pragmatism * 3 Criticisms * 4 Moral ecology * 5 Notes * 6 References * 7 Further reading

CONTRAST WITH OTHER NORMATIVE THEORIES

Much as it is appropriate for scientists to act as though a hypothesis were true despite expecting future inquiry to supplant it, ethical pragmatists acknowledge that it can be appropriate to practice a variety of other normative approaches (e.g. consequentialism , deontological ethics , and virtue ethics ), yet acknowledge the need for mechanisms which allow society to advance beyond such approaches, a freedom for discourse which does not take any such theory as assumed. Thus, aimed at social innovation , the practice of pragmatic ethics supplements the practice of other normative approaches with what John Stuart Mill called "experiments of living".

Pragmatic ethics
Pragmatic ethics
also differs from other normative approaches theoretically, according to Lafollette (2000) :

* It focuses on society, rather than on lone individuals, as the entity which achieves morality. In Dewey's words, "all conduct is ... social." * It does not hold any known moral criteria as beyond potential for revision. Pragmatic ethics
Pragmatic ethics
may be misunderstood as relativist , as failing to be objective, but that is like suggesting that science fails to be objective. Ethical pragmatists, like scientists, can maintain that their endeavor is objective on the grounds that it converges towards something objective. * It allows that a moral judgment may be appropriate in one age of a given society, even though it will cease to be appropriate after that society progresses (or may already be inappropriate in another society). For example, the writings of Thomas Jefferson
Thomas Jefferson
on slavery framed slavery as ultimately immoral, yet temporarily moral until America was ready for abolition.

RELATIONSHIP TO PRAGMATISM

Establishing that this normative theory entails pragmatism (or vice versa) remains an open challenge. The Blackwell Guide to Ethical Theory refers to this theory as pragmatic and finds it in the writings of John Dewey
John Dewey
(a pragmatist). However, it also finds key concepts in the writings of John Stuart Mill and Martha Nussbaum
Martha Nussbaum
, and we can see at least some of its distinguishing characteristics in the concept of social gadfly attributed to Socrates
Socrates
in Plato\'s Apology .

CRITICISMS

Pragmatic ethics
Pragmatic ethics
has been criticized as conflating descriptive ethics with normative ethics , as describing the way people do make moral judgments rather than the way they should make them. While some ethical pragmatists may have questioned the distinction between normative and descriptive truth, the theory of pragmatic ethics itself does not conflate them any more than science conflates truth about its subject matter with current opinion about it.

MORAL ECOLOGY

Moral ecology is a variation of pragmatic ethics which additionally supposes that morality evolves like an ecosystem , and ethical practice should therefore include strategies analogous to those of ecosystem management (e.g. protecting a degree of moral diversity). The term "moral ecology" has been used since at least 1985 to imply a symbiosis whereby the viability of any existing moral approach would be diminished by the destruction of all alternative approaches. According to Tim Dean, current scientific evidence confirms that humans do take diverse approaches to morality, and such polymorphism gives humanity resilience against a wider range of situations and environments (which makes moral diversity a natural consequence of frequency-dependent selection ).

NOTES

* ^ A B Liszka, James. "What Is Pragmatic Ethics?". Retrieved 2011-07-01. * ^ Mill (1863) * ^ A B C D E Lafollette (2000) * ^ Dewey (1922) * ^ Almeder, R. (1983). "Scientific Progress and Peircean Utopian Realism". Erkenntnis (20): 253–280. * ^ Bateman, Newton; Paul Selby; Frances M. Shonkwiler; Henry L Fowkes (1908). Historical Encyclopedia of Illinois. Chicago, IL: Munsell Publishing Company. p. 259. * ^ "Apology 30e". * ^ Bellah (1985) * ^ Hertzke (1998) * ^ "Tim Dean, Evolution & Moral Ecology". Philo Agora. Retrieved 2012-06-27. * ^ Dean, T. (2012). "Evolution and Moral Diversity". The Baltic International Yearbook of Cognition, Logic and Communication. 7. doi :10.4148/biyclc.v7i0.1775 .

REFERENCES

* Bellah, Robert Neelly (1985). Habits of the Heart: Individualism and Commitment in American Life. Berkeley: University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-25419-0 . * Dewey, John (1922). Human Nature and Conduct. New York: Henry Holt and Company . ISBN 978-0-486-42097-4 . * Hertzke, Allen D.; McRorie, Chris (1998). "The Concept of Moral Ecology". In Lawler, Peter Augustine; McConkey, Dale. Community and Political Thought Today. Westort, CT: Praeger . * LaFollette, Hugh (2000). "Pragmatic ethics". In LaFollette, Hugh. The Blackwell Guide to Ethical Theory. Wiley-Blackwell . pp. 400–419. * Mill, John Stuart (1863). On Liberty. Boston: Ticknor and Fields. ISBN 0-486-42130-9 .

FURTHER READING

* Bernstein, R. (1983) Beyond Objectivism and Relativism. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press. * Dewey, John (1988) . Human Nature and Conduct. Southern Illinois University Press. * Dewey, John (1985) . Ethics. Southern Illinois University Press. * Dewey, John (1970) . Reconstruction in Philosophy. Henry Holt. * Gibbard, Allan (2009). "7 A pragmatic justification of morality". In Voorhoeve, Alex. Conversations on ethics. Oxford University Press. pp. 157–178. ISBN 978-0-19-921537-9 . * Lekan, T. (2003) Making Morality: Pragmatist Reconstruction in Ethical Theory (The Vanderbilt Library of American Philosophy) Vanderbilt University Press . ISBN 978-0-8265-1421-9 * Margolis, J. (1986) Pragmatism without Foundations: Reconciling Realism and Relativism. Oxford, OX, UK ; New York: Blackwell Publishers. * Margolis, J. (1996) Life without Principles. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers.

* v * t * e

Philosophy
Philosophy

BRANCHES

TRADITIONAL

* Metaphysics

* Ontology

* Epistemology * Logic * Ethics * Aesthetics

PHILOSOPHY OF

* Action

* Art

* Culture * Design * Music * Film

* Business * Color * Cosmos * Dialogue * Education * Environment * Futility * Happiness * Healthcare * History * Human nature * Humor * Feminism * Language * Life * Literature * Mathematics

* Mind

* Pain * Psychology

* Philosophy
Philosophy
of psychiatry * Philosophy
Philosophy
of perception * Philosophy
Philosophy
* Religion

* Science
Science

* Physics * Chemistry * Biology * Geography

* Sexuality

* Social science

* Culture * Economics * Justice
Justice
* Law * Politics * Society

* Space and time * Sport

* Technology

* Artificial intelligence * Computer science * Engineering * Information

* War

SCHOOLS OF THOUGHT

BY ERA

* Ancient

* Western

* Medieval * Renaissance * Early modern * Modern * Contemporary

ANCIENT

CHINESE

* Agriculturalism * Confucianism * Legalism * Logicians * Mohism * Chinese naturalism * Neotaoism * Taoism * Yangism * Zen
Zen

GRECO- ROMAN

* Aristotelianism * Atomism * Cynicism * Cyrenaics * Eleatics * Eretrian school * Epicureanism * Hermeneutics

* Ionian

* Ephesian * Milesian

* Megarian school * Neoplatonism * Peripatetic * Platonism * Pluralism * Presocratic * Pyrrhonism * Pythagoreanism * Neopythagoreanism
Neopythagoreanism
* Sophistic * Stoicism

INDIAN

* Samkhya * Nyaya * Vaisheshika * Yoga * Mīmāṃsā
Mīmāṃsā
* Ājīvika
Ājīvika
* Ajñana * Cārvāka

* Jain

* Anekantavada * Syādvāda

* Buddhist

* Śūnyatā
Śūnyatā
* Madhyamaka
Madhyamaka
* Yogacara * Sautrāntika * Svatantrika

PERSIAN

* Mazdakism * Zoroastrianism * Zurvanism

MEDIEVAL

EUROPEAN

* Christian philosophy * Scholasticism * Thomism
Thomism
* Renaissance humanism

EAST ASIAN

* Korean Confucianism * Edo Neo- Confucianism * Neo- Confucianism

INDIAN

* Vedanta

* Acintya bheda abheda * Advaita * Bhedabheda * Dvaita * Dvaitadvaita * Shuddhadvaita
Shuddhadvaita
* Vishishtadvaita
Vishishtadvaita

* Navya-Nyāya

ISLAMIC

* Averroism * Avicennism * Illuminationism * ʿIlm al-Kalām * Sufi

JEWISH

* Judeo-Islamic

MODERN

PEOPLE

* Cartesianism
Cartesianism
* Kantianism
Kantianism
* Neo- Kantianism
Kantianism
* Hegelianism * Marxism * Spinozism
Spinozism

0

* Anarchism * Classical Realism
Classical Realism
* Liberalism * Collectivism * Conservatism * Determinism * Dualism
Dualism
* Empiricism * Existentialism * Foundationalism * Historicism
Historicism
* Holism
Holism
* Humanism

* Idealism

* Absolute * British * German * Objective * Subjective * Transcendental

* Individualism * Kokugaku * Materialism
Materialism
* Modernism * Monism * Naturalism * Natural law
Natural law
* Nihilism * New Confucianism * Neo- Scholasticism * Pragmatism * Phenomenology * Positivism * Reductionism * Rationalism * Social contract
Social contract
* Socialism * Transcendentalism
Transcendentalism
* Utilitarianism

CONTEMPORARY

ANALYTIC

* Applied ethics * Analytic feminism * Analytical Marxism * Communitarianism * Consequentialism * Critical rationalism * Experimental philosophy * Falsificationism * Foundationalism / Coherentism * Generative linguistics * Internalism and Externalism * Logical positivism * Legal positivism * Normative ethics * Meta-ethics * Moral realism * Neo-Aristotelian * Quinean naturalism * Ordinary language philosophy
Ordinary language philosophy
* Postanalytic philosophy * Quietism * Rawlsian * Reformed epistemology * Systemics * Scientism * Scientific realism * Scientific skepticism * Contemporary utilitarianism * Vienna Circle * Wittgensteinian

CONTINENTAL

* Critical theory * Deconstruction
Deconstruction
* Existentialism * Feminist * Frankfurt School * New Historicism
Historicism
* Hermeneutics * Neo-Marxism * Phenomenology * Postmodernism * Post-structuralism * Social constructionism
Social constructionism
* Structuralism
Structuralism
* Western Marxism

OTHER

* Kyoto School * Objectivism * Russian cosmism * more...

POSITIONS

AESTHETICS

* Formalism * Institutionalism * Aesthetic response

ETHICS

* Consequentialism * Deontology * Virtue

FREE WILL

* Compatibilism
Compatibilism
* Determinism * Libertarianism

METAPHYSICS

* Atomism * Dualism
Dualism
* Monism * Naturalism

EPISTEMOLOGY

* Constructivism * Empiricism * Idealism * Particularism * Fideism * Rationalism / Reasonism * Skepticism * Solipsism
Solipsism

MIND

* Behaviorism * Emergentism * Eliminativism * Epiphenomenalism * Functionalism * Objectivism * Subjectivism

NORMATIVITY

* Absolutism * Particularism * Relativism * Nihilism * Skepticism * Universalism

ONTOLOGY

* Action * Event * Process

REALITY

* Anti-realism * Conceptualism * Idealism * Materialism
Materialism
* Naturalism * Nominalism * Physicalism * Realism

* Philosophy
Philosophy
by region * Philosophy-related lists * Miscellaneous

BY REGION

* African * Ethiopian * Aztec * Native America * Eastern * Chinese * Egyptian * Czech * Indian * Indonesian * Iranian * Japanese * Korean * Vietnam * Pakistani * Western * American * Australian * British * Danish * French * German * Greek * Italian * Polish * Romanian * Russian * Slovene * Spanish * Turkish

LISTS

* Outline * Index * Years * Problems * Schools * Glossary * Philosophers * Movements * Publications

MISCELLANEOUS

* Women in philosophy
Women in philosophy
* Sage (philosophy)

* Portal * Category
Category
* Book
Book

* v * t * e

Ethics

THEORIES

* Casuistry * Consequentialism

* Deontology

* Kantian ethics
Kantian ethics

* Ethics of care * Existentialist ethics * Meta-ethics * Particularism * Pragmatic ethics * Role ethics * Virtue ethics

CONCEPTS

* Autonomy * Axiology * Belief * Conscience * Consent * Equality * Care * Free will
Free will
* Good and evil
Good and evil
* Happiness * Ideal * Justice
Justice
* Morality * Norm * Freedom * Principles * Suffering or Pain * Stewardship * Sympathy
Sympathy
* Trust * Value * Virtue * Wrong * FULL INDEX...

PHILOSOPHERS

* Laozi * Plato
Plato
* Aristotle
Aristotle
* Diogenes
Diogenes
* Valluvar * Cicero
Cicero
* Confucius * Augustine of Hippo * Mencius * Mozi
Mozi
* Xunzi * Thomas Aquinas
Thomas Aquinas
* Baruch Spinoza
Baruch Spinoza
* David Hume
David Hume
* Immanuel Kant
Immanuel Kant
* Georg W. F. Hegel * Arthur Schopenhauer * Jeremy Bentham * John Stuart Mill * Søren Kierkegaard
Søren Kierkegaard
* Henry Sidgwick * Friedrich Nietzsche
Friedrich Nietzsche
* G. E. Moore
G. E. Moore
* Karl Barth * Paul Tillich * Dietrich Bonhoeffer
Dietrich Bonhoeffer
* Philippa Foot * John Rawls * John Dewey
John Dewey
* Bernard Williams
Bernard Williams
* J. L. Mackie
J. L. Mackie
* G. E. M. Anscombe
G. E. M. Anscombe
* William Frankena * Alasdair MacIntyre * R. M. Hare * Peter Singer
Peter Singer
* Derek Parfit * Thomas Nagel * Robert Merrihew Adams * Charles Taylor * Joxe Azurmendi * Christine Korsgaard
Christine Korsgaard
* Martha Nussbaum
Martha Nussbaum
* MORE...

APPLIED ETHICS

* Bioethics * Business ethics * Discourse ethics * Environmental ethics
Environmental ethics
* Legal ethics * Media ethics * Medical ethics
Medical ethics
* Nursing ethics * Professional ethics * Sexual ethics * Ethics of eating meat * Ethics of technology

RELATED ARTICLES

* Christian ethics
Christian ethics
* Descriptive ethics * Ethics in religion * Evolutionary ethics * Feminist ethics * History of ethics * Ideology
Ideology
* Islamic ethics * Jewish ethics * Normative ethics *