Liu Buchan

Liu Buchan (; 1852 – 1895) was a naval officer of the Beiyang Fleet, the most prominent of China's naval units in the late Qing Dynasty. He is best remembered for his actions as commander of the fleet flagship, the '' Dingyuan'', during the First Sino-Japanese War. After his death and the ship being destroyed at the end of the war, he was raised to national hero status in modern China. At his death, Liu was commander of the fleet flagship, with the rank Admiral of the Right, and reserve Admiral of the Fleet.

Life

Liu was born in the town of Houguan, in Fuzhou, China. Liu's father died before he was born, and he was brought up by his mother. In 1867, he passed the entry examinations and entered the Foochow Arsenal Naval School established by Shen Baozhen to study navigation. In 1871, was on the training ship Jianwei, and he visited Amoy, Hong Kong, Singapore and the Bohai Bay. In 1872, with the best results, Liu graduated in the first class of the Foochow Arsenal Naval School. In 1875, he was appointed commander of the training ship ''Jianwei''. In 1876, he was sent to Britain for further training. He served on the Royal Navy's Mediterranean Fleet flagship HMS ''Hercules'' as a trainee first mate. He returned to China in 1878 and was given command of the ''Zhenbei'' in the Beiyang Fleet.

In 1881, Viceroy Li Hongzhang, the Beiyang minister, sent a command with a German shipyard for the construction of two battleships (the ''Dingyuan'' and the ''Zhenyuan''). Liu was sent to monitor construction and inspect the ships, and to assist in delivering the two warships back to China. In 1885 got back to China aboard the ''Dingyuan'', upon which he was given command of the ''Dingyuan'', with Commodore rank. In 1888, the Beiyang Fleet was officially established. Liu participated in drawing up the Fleet's charter, and was subsequently promoted to the Right Wing command of Admiral. Viceroy Li was highly impressed with Liu, and in his secret missive to the court said Liu had "talents that could be placed to great use".

In 1890, the Beiyang Fleet visited Hong Kong. When Fleet Admiral Ding Ruchang left his ship, Liu took down the fleet admiral flag and put up his admiral flag. The fleet's chief training officer, Royal Navy captain and Englishman William Lang raised issue with this, and complained to Li Hongzhang. In the subsequent dispute, Li supported Liu, and in response William Lang resigned from the Beiyang Fleet.

In the years leading up to the First Sino-Japanese War in 1894, Liu repeatedly pressed Li Hongzhang to develop the Beiyang Fleet. He pointed out that Japan was enthusiastically expanding its navy, and to keep up the Beiyang Fleet must adopt an annual program to add new ships. However, Li Hongzhang was unable to expand the Beiyang Fleet due to the realities of court politics. The First Sino-Japanese War began in 1894, and on 17 September of that year, the Beiyang Fleet encountered the Japanese Combined Fleet on the Yellow Sea, sparking the Battle of the Yalu River.

During the Battle of the Yalu River, Liu Buchan commanded the flagship ''Dingyuan'' - the most powerful ship of the Beiyang Fleet - in battle against the Japanese fleet. The battle lasted into the afternoon and the ''Dingyuan'' was struck multiple times. As Admiral Ding Ruchang, the fleet commander, had been seriously wounded early in the battle, Liu had to assume command of the entire fleet. For his bravery during the battle, Liu was promoted to reserve Admiral of the Fleet after the battle, and acted as commander of the fleets while Ding Ruchang recovered from his injuries.

Shortly afterwards, on 4 February 1895, Japanese torpedo boats launched a surprise attack on the Beiyang Fleet's home base at Weihaiwei, during which the ''Dingyuan'' was hit and began taking on water. Liu ordered the ship run aground and to continue firing as an artillery battery. On 9 February 1895 the Japanese army took over the shore batteries, and fired upon and hit the ''Dingyuan''. Fearing that the naval base at Liugong Island would soon fall, and that the ''Dingyuan'' would fall into enemy hands, he ordered that the ''Dingyuan'' be scuttled. That night, Liu killed himself by swallowing opium. The Qing government, appreciating his service, ordered that benefits be given with the status of an admiral of the fleet.

Assessment

In the 20th century, there was praise as well as criticism in all kinds of books about him. The criticism was mainly from William Tyler's - an English sailor on ''Dingyuan'' - memoir. But there were also widely accepted ideas that there was a personal enmity between William Tyler and Liu Buchan and that William Tyler's words were unreliable.
But there were two opinions that were really accepted. First, Liu Buchan lacked adequate experience before he was appointed as the captain of ''Dingyuan'' and training and command were very bad under him. Second, he was addicted to taking opium all the time, which was universal among his troops.

References

Sources

*"LiHongzhang (李鸿章) Complete" chief editor, GuTinglong (), YeYalian () I, II, III, printed by ShangHai RenMing press in 1986.
*"Naval historical materials in the late Qing Dynasty", edited by ZhangXia (), YangZhibeng (), LuoPengshu (), ZhangLiming (), printed in 1982 by BeiJing HaiYang press.
*"Sino-Japanese History", editor, QiQizhang (), printed in 1990 by BeiJing RenMing press.
*"The Fleet under the Flying Dragon Flag" (the revised edition), edited by Jiang Ming (姜鸣, jiāng míng), printed in December 2001 by Bei Jing Sanlian press.
*"China's Recent Navy Historical Events Log", edited by Jiang Ming (姜鸣, jiāng míng), printed in December 1994 by Bei Jing Sanlian press.
*"Fujian Ship-building Burean Historical Manuscript", edited by Lin Qingyuan (林庆元, lín qìng yuán), printed in October 1986 by Fujian People's press.
*"Ding Ruchang Volumes", edited by Qi Junjie (戚俊杰, Qī Jùn Jíe), Wang Jihua (王记华, Wáng Jì huá) printed in August 1997 by Shandong University press.

{{DEFAULTSORT:Liu, Buchan
Chinese admirals
Qing dynasty admirals
Qing dynasty politicians from Fujian
Suicides in the Qing dynasty
Suicides by poison
Politicians from Fuzhou
Generals from Fujian
1852 births
1895 deaths
Beiyang Fleet personnel
Chinese military personnel of the First Sino-Japanese War