Gherman Pântea
   HOME

TheInfoList



OR:

Gherman Vasile Pântea (; surname also spelled Pîntea; russian: Герман Васильевич Пынтя, translit=German Vasilyevich Pyntya; uk, Герман Васильович Пинтя, translit=Herman Vasylyovich Pyntia; May 13, 1894 – February 1, 1968) was a Bessarabian-born soldier, civil servant and political figure, active in the
Russian Empire The Russian Empire was an empire and the final period of the Russian monarchy from 1721 to 1917, ruling across large parts of Eurasia. It succeeded the Tsardom of Russia following the Treaty of Nystad, which ended the Great Northern War. ...
and
Romania Romania ( ; ro, România ) is a country located at the crossroads of Central, Eastern, and Southeastern Europe. It borders Bulgaria to the south, Ukraine to the north, Hungary to the west, Serbia to the southwest, Moldova to the east, and ...
. As an officer of the Imperial Russian Army during most of
World War I World War I (28 July 1914 11 November 1918), often abbreviated as WWI, was one of the deadliest global conflicts in history. Belligerents included much of Europe, the Russian Empire, the United States, and the Ottoman Empire, with fightin ...
, he helped organize the committees of Bessarabian soldiers, oscillating between loyalty to the
Russian Provisional Government The Russian Provisional Government ( rus, Временное правительство России, Vremennoye pravitel'stvo Rossii) was a provisional government of the Russian Republic, announced two days before and established immediately ...
and the cause of Bessarabian emancipation. Pântea was subsequently Military Director of the
Moldavian Democratic Republic The Moldavian Democratic Republic (MDR; ro, Republica Democratică Moldovenească, ), also known as the Moldavian Republic, was a state proclaimed on by the '' Sfatul Țării'' (National Council) of Bessarabia, elected in October–Novemb ...
, answering to
President President most commonly refers to: *President (corporate title) * President (education), a leader of a college or university * President (government title) President may also refer to: Automobiles * Nissan President, a 1966–2010 Japanese ...
Ion Inculeț. He personally created a Bessarabian defense force, tasked with combating
Bolshevik The Bolsheviks (russian: Большевики́, from большинство́ ''bol'shinstvó'', 'majority'),; derived from ''bol'shinstvó'' (большинство́), "majority", literally meaning "one of the majority". also known in English ...
subversion and Russian intimidation, but also braced for defeat after the
October Revolution The October Revolution,. officially known as the Great October Socialist Revolution. in the Soviet Union, also known as the Bolshevik Revolution, was a revolution in Russia led by the Bolshevik Party of Vladimir Lenin that was a key mome ...
. With some hesitance, Gherman Pântea endorsed the Republic's union with Romania, affiliating with the local
Bessarabian Peasants' Party The Bessarabian Peasants' Party ( ro, Partidul Țărănesc din Basarabia, PȚB or PȚ-Bas; also ''Partidul Țărănesc Basarabean'', ''Partidul Țărănist Basarabean'') or Moldavian National Democratic Party (''Partidul Național-Democrat Moldove ...
, then with Romania's National Liberals. Having parallel careers as teacher, lawyer and journalist, Pântea remained a presence in Romanian political life, as member of
Parliament In modern politics, and history, a parliament is a legislative body of government. Generally, a modern parliament has three functions: representing the electorate, making laws, and overseeing the government via hearings and inquiries. Th ...
, negotiator of
détente Détente (, French: "relaxation") is the relaxation of strained relations, especially political ones, through verbal communication. The term, in diplomacy, originates from around 1912, when France and Germany tried unsuccessfully to reduce ...
with the
Soviet Union The Soviet Union,. officially the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. (USSR),. was a List of former transcontinental countries#Since 1700, transcontinental country that spanned much of Eurasia from 1922 to 1991. A flagship communist state, ...
, and three times
Mayor of Chișinău The Mayor of Chișinău, officially the General Mayor of the Municipality of Chișinău ( ro, Primar general al municipiul Chișinău), is the head of the executive branch of Chișinău's government and a member of the city's Municipal Counci ...
. He was however mistrusted for his defense of arrested Bolsheviks, his critique of
centralized government A centralized government (also united government) is one in which both executive and legislative power is concentrated centrally at the higher level as opposed to it being more distributed at various lower level governments. In a national contex ...
, and his alleged corruption. During
World War II World War II or the Second World War, often abbreviated as WWII or WW2, was a world war that lasted from 1939 to 1945. It involved the vast majority of the world's countries—including all of the great powers—forming two opposing ...
, Pântea was Mayor of Odesa under a Romanian occupation. He intervened to save Jews from the 1941 Odesa massacre and the subsequent deportations to camps in
Transnistria Transnistria, officially the Pridnestrovian Moldavian Republic (PMR), is an unrecognised breakaway state that is internationally recognised as a part of Moldova. Transnistria controls most of the narrow strip of land between the Dniester riv ...
. He had a tumultuous relationship with Ion Antonescu, the Romanian dictator, and was kept in check by the occupation authority. His administration managed to set in motion a plan for
Odesa Odesa (also spelled Odessa) is the third most populous city and municipality in Ukraine and a major seaport and transport hub located in the south-west of the country, on the northwestern shore of the Black Sea. The city is also the administrati ...
, and helped the city overcome devastation through the adoption of
free trade Free trade is a trade policy that does not restrict imports or exports. It can also be understood as the free market idea applied to international trade. In government, free trade is predominantly advocated by political parties that hold econ ...
, but also created various controversies. Pântea was long suspected of war crimes, and spent much of his post-war life as a fugitive. He was eventually apprehended, and became a
political prisoner A political prisoner is someone imprisoned for their political activity. The political offense is not always the official reason for the prisoner's detention. There is no internationally recognized legal definition of the concept, although n ...
of the Romanian communist regime. In 1956, he managed to have the war crimes verdict overturned but, albeit rehabilitated in part, continued to be harassed by the communist apparatus until the 1960s.


Biography


Early years and World War I service

Much of Gherman Pântea's life remain mysterious, inaccessible to researchers, and, according to historian Ion Constantin, "a permanent crossover of myth and reality." Of ethnic Romanian and lower-middle-class origins, Gherman Pântea was born on May 13, 1894, in the northern Bessarabian village of Zăicani; he was one of several children born to lawyer Vasile Pântea and his wife Ioana.Constantin, p.35, 98 They were of the
Eastern Orthodox Eastern Orthodoxy, also known as Eastern Orthodox Christianity, is one of the three main branches of Chalcedonian Christianity, alongside Catholicism and Protestantism. Like the Pentarchy of the first millennium, the mainstream (or " canonical ...
religion, and Gherman was a practicing
Romanian Orthodox The Romanian Orthodox Church (ROC; ro, Biserica Ortodoxă Română, ), or Patriarchate of Romania, is an autocephalous Eastern Orthodox church in full communion with other Eastern Orthodox Christian churches, and one of the nine patriarchates ...
until late in life. The boy had trouble adapting himself to the requirements of living in what was then Russia's
Bessarabia Governorate The Bessarabia Governorate (, ) was a part of the Russian Empire from 1812 to 1917. Initially known as Bessarabia Oblast (Бессарабская область, ''Bessarabskaya oblast'') as well as, following 1871, a governorate, it included ...
: although he was studious and completed primary school with honors, he had difficulty learning the official Russian language.Constantin, p.35 He finished secondary school in
Glodeni Glodeni (; russian: Глодяны; pl, Głodziany; uk, Глодяни) is a city in the northwest of Moldova; it is the seat of Glodeni District. Its population as of 2012 was 11,600. One village, Stîrcea, is administered by the city. Medi ...
, before leaving for
Akkerman Bilhorod-Dnistrovskyi ( uk, Бі́лгород-Дністро́вський, Bílhorod-Dnistróvskyy, ; ro, Cetatea Albă), historically known as Akkerman ( tr, Akkerman) or under different names, is a city, municipality and port situated on ...
, where he attended Russian
normal school A normal school or normal college is an institution created to train teachers by educating them in the norms of pedagogy and curriculum. In the 19th century in the United States, instruction in normal schools was at the high school level, turni ...
and witnessed the start of World War I. He frequently sailed to Odesa, the
Black Sea The Black Sea is a marginal mediterranean sea of the Atlantic Ocean lying between Europe and Asia, east of the Balkans, south of the East European Plain, west of the Caucasus, and north of Anatolia. It is bounded by Bulgaria, Georgia, Rom ...
port which was to fascinate him for the rest of his life. In June 1915, shortly after completing his studies, Pântea was drafted into the Imperial Russian Army, and relocated to
Kyiv Kyiv, also spelled Kiev, is the capital and most populous city of Ukraine. It is in north-central Ukraine along the Dnieper River. As of 1 January 2021, its population was 2,962,180, making Kyiv the seventh-most populous city in Europe. Kyi ...
, where he attended a Junker School. He was again in Odesa, where Bessarabian-born officer Emanoil Catelli was giving standard
Romanian language Romanian (obsolete spellings: Rumanian or Roumanian; autonym: ''limba română'' , or ''românește'', ) is the official and main language of Romania and the Republic of Moldova. As a minority language it is spoken by stable communities in ...
classes to Russian officers, and became close friends with his new teacher. (Some sources represent Pântea as a graduate of
Odesa University Odesa I. I. Mechnykov National University ( uk, Одеський національний університет Iмені І. І. Мечникова, translit=Odeskyi natsionalnyi universytet imeni I. I. Mechnykova), located in Odesa, Ukraine, i ...
.) Upon graduation from the Junker School, the young ''
Podporuchik ''Podporuchik'' ( sh-Cyrl-Latn, потпоручник, potporučnik, cs, podporučík, pl, podporucznik, russian: подпору́чик, bg, подпоручик, sk, podporučík) is the most Junior officer in some Slavic armed forces, an ...
'' was dispatched to the
Romanian front The Romanian Front ( ro, Frontul Românesc, FR) was a moderate fascist party created in Romania in 1935. Led by former Prime Minister Alexandru Vaida-Voevod, it originated as a right-wing splinter group from the mainstream National Peasants' Part ...
, to function as a translator between the Russian Ninth Army and their colleagues in the
Romanian Land Forces The Romanian Land Forces ( ro, Forțele Terestre Române) is the army of Romania, and the main component of the Romanian Armed Forces. In recent years, full professionalisation and a major equipment overhaul have transformed the nature of the Lan ...
. He also fought with valor during battles against the German Army, and twice received the
Order of St. George The Order of Saint George (russian: Орден Святого Георгия, Orden Svyatogo Georgiya) is the highest military decoration of the Russian Federation. Originally established on 26 November 1769 Julian (7 December 1769 Gregorian) a ...
. Russia's February Revolution caught Pântea entrenched with his men somewhere near the town of
Roman Roman or Romans most often refers to: *Rome, the capital city of Italy *Ancient Rome, Roman civilization from 8th century BC to 5th century AD *Roman people, the people of ancient Rome *'' Epistle to the Romans'', shortened to ''Romans'', a lette ...
. The news, he later wrote, was a wake-up call for the Bessarabian Romanians in foreign lands, since it offered the prospect of self-determination at home. As the Provisional Government took hold of military matters, Pântea became President of the Ninth Army's
Soviet The Soviet Union,. officially the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. (USSR),. was a transcontinental country that spanned much of Eurasia from 1922 to 1991. A flagship communist state, it was nominally a federal union of fifteen nation ...
, and also helped organize the Bessarabian soldiers into a single political body. Similar actions were being taken by other nationally minded Bessarabian officers. Some—Catelli, Anton Crihan, Constantin Osoianu, Ion Păscăluță, Andrei Scobioală—were active on Bessarabia's borders, while others addressed Bessarabian units in places such as
Novorossiya Novorossiya, literally "New Russia", is a historical name, used during the era of the Russian Empire for an administrative area that would later become the southern mainland of Ukraine: the region immediately north of the Black Sea and Crimea. ...
(
Elefterie Sinicliu Elefterie Sinicliu (born 4 October 1895, Echimăuţi, Orhei - died in 20th century) was an agronomist and politician from Bessarabia, member of the Moldovan Parliament (1917–1918). Biography In 1917 he participated in the local congress held ...
) or
Crimea Crimea, crh, Къырым, Qırım, grc, Κιμμερία / Ταυρική, translit=Kimmería / Taurikḗ ( ) is a peninsula in Ukraine, on the northern coast of the Black Sea, that has been occupied by Russia since 2014. It has a pop ...
(
Grigore Turcuman Grigore Turcuman (20 October 1890 – 28 May 1942) was a Bessarabian Romanian politician. As a member of Sfatul Țării (the Bessarabian Parliament), he voted the Union of Bessarabia with the Kingdom of Romania on 27 March 1918. Biography ...
). Here was the nucleus for a single military and political unit of the Bessarabian, or "Moldavian", national movement, which sought to gain control of Chișinău (the informal Bessarabian capital). At the time, tensions were sparked between ''Podporuchik'' Pântea's Roman organization and the inner-Bessarabian faction which demanded a social revolution, namely the Chișinău Soviet of Workers and Soldiers; he also had to struggle with Bessarabian apathy, communist gains, and territorial claims stated by the neighboring
Ukrainian People's Republic The Ukrainian People's Republic (UPR), or Ukrainian National Republic (UNR), was a country in Eastern Europe that existed between 1917 and 1920. It was declared following the February Revolution in Russia by the First Universal. In March 1 ...
. Through Pântea and Scobioală, the Roman group communicated directly with a civilian network formed by the Bessarabian expatriates of Iași, who endorsed the effort to consolidate political unity. On behalf of the Roman leadership, Pântea made a journey to Odesa, where he contacted the eastern committee formed by Catelli and the others (May 1917). At the time, Odesa Bessarabians were forming their "Moldavian Cohorts", armed units which were supposed to challenge the Chișinău Soviet.


Moldavian Central Committee

Eventually, in June 1917, Gherman Pântea and two other Ninth Army soldiers—Petre Vărzaru, Ion Mitrean—were mandated by their colleagues to leave for Chișinău and organize the national movement locally. The youngest of all activists involved in the project, Pântea was elected head of the resulting Moldavian Central Committee of the Soldiers and Officers' Union. Pântea, Vărzaru and Mitrean benefited from some Russian support, after Commander Alexander Shcherbachov gave them a free pass and an indefinite leave from the Romanian front. However, their Central Committee met a new rival in the parallel
Military Revolutionary Committee The Military Revolutionary Committee (russian: Военно-революционный комитет, ) was the name for military organs created by the Bolsheviks under the soviets in preparation for the October Revolution (October 1917 – Marc ...
, formed by revolutionary Russians loyal to the Chișinău Soviet. This authority gave formal backing to its Moldavian equivalent, supporting its struggle for self-determination and even discussing a merger, but discreetly tried to combat Bessarabian Romanian influence in all other fields. A truce was agreed upon between Pântea and the Russian Committee representative Levenzon, which even allowed both organisms to share office space in the same building. During September, after clashes with some of the radicalized peasants hampered propaganda efforts in the countryside, and Ukrainian or Russian pressures increased, the Moldavian Committee began issuing its own political newspaper. Known as ''Soldatul Moldovan'' ("The Moldavian Soldier"), it had poet Gheorghe (Iorgu) Tudor as manager and Pântea as one of three editors. Pântea carried from Iași a large bag of propaganda literature, in
Cyrillic letters , bg, кирилица , mk, кирилица , russian: кириллица , sr, ћирилица, uk, кирилиця , fam1 = Egyptian hieroglyphs , fam2 = Proto-Sinaitic , fam3 = Phoenician , fam4 = G ...
—Vasile Harea of ''Cuvânt Moldovenesc (magazine), Cuvânt Moldovenesc'' paper, who witnessed the event, described Pântea as "a rather affected young man, with a nervous gaze, ambitious and conceiving of all sorts of schemes".Constantin, p.56 At around the same time, the Moldavian Central Committee took steps to create a Bessarabian national force within Russia's Army, with Vasile Cijevschi as Commander. The request was presented to the ''Stavka'' (supreme command of the Russian forces) in Mogilev. It provided an ambiguous response, and Pântea led a delegation to request further clarification. On their way through Kyiv, the Bessarabian envoys chanced upon Romania's own delegates to Russia: Dinu Brătianu and Constantin Iancovescu. The two missions shared a train carriage, and the time they shared prompted ''Stavka'' staff to suspect a conspiracy. The Bessarabians tried to mend the situation, and Pântea had interviews with Commander Nikolay Dukhonin and Prime Minister of Russia, Russian Premier Alexander Kerensky. Pântea later wrote that Kerensky was the most welcoming, allowing the gradual creation of a single Bessarabian army (and even promising to transfer the Odessa 40th Regiment its jurisdiction), but forbidding any unilateral Bessarabian decision on this matter. Before and after the
October Revolution The October Revolution,. officially known as the Great October Socialist Revolution. in the Soviet Union, also known as the Bolshevik Revolution, was a revolution in Russia led by the Bolshevik Party of Vladimir Lenin that was a key mome ...
overturned the Provisional Government and brought the
Bolshevik The Bolsheviks (russian: Большевики́, from большинство́ ''bol'shinstvó'', 'majority'),; derived from ''bol'shinstvó'' (большинство́), "majority", literally meaning "one of the majority". also known in English ...
(communist) movement to power in Russia, Gherman Pântea played a game of intricate diplomacy. According to Ion Constantin, he was good at seizing political opportunities "in those murky, troubled times, subject to fast and radical changes to the map of East-Central Europe". By early October 1917, Pântea was realizing that Kerensky and the Provisional Government could lose the battle. In a bid to discover the other side's intentions regarding Bessarabia, he traveled to Petrograd and met Bolshevik ideologue Vladimir Lenin. As Pântea later stated, Lenin declared himself for revolutionary self-determination in the national issue—some researchers regard this claim as an urban legend, with which Bessarabian intellectuals tried to convince communists that Lenin himself validated their national aspirations. Returning to Bessarabia, Pântea attended meetings of the Bolshevik club, alongside Ion Buzdugan.


''Sfatul Țării'' and Moldavian Directorate

Meanwhile, Pântea's Committee organized a Moldavian Soldiers' Congress, which was to form the basis for a Bessarabian legislature, called ''Sfatul Țării''. A dispute endures surrounding the initiative behind this Congress, since both Pântea and Ștefan Holban claimed to have had the idea first. In order to ensure attendance, Pântea (or Holban) appealed to a ruse, circulating a telegram which misleadingly suggested that the Russian Provisional Government was backing the Congress. Within days, Pântea was designated Vice President of the Bessarabian soldiers' assembly; Cijevschi was its President. Their act of insubordination enraged Kerensky: just before Lenin ousted him from power, the Russian Prime Minister issued a warrant for Pântea's arrest; by then, however, the Bessarabian Congress had been recognized by third parties, from the Mensheviks to the General Jewish Labour Bund in Lithuania, Poland and Russia, Bundistn. In the confusion that followed Lenin's seizure of power, Pântea still recognized the Russian Constituent Assembly, and presented his candidature in the 1917 Russian Constituent Assembly election, Russian parliamentary election. He was included on a
Bessarabian Peasants' Party The Bessarabian Peasants' Party ( ro, Partidul Țărănesc din Basarabia, PȚB or PȚ-Bas; also ''Partidul Țărănesc Basarabean'', ''Partidul Țărănist Basarabean'') or Moldavian National Democratic Party (''Partidul Național-Democrat Moldove ...
(PȚB) list headed by Ion Inculeț and Pantelimon Erhan.Charles Upson Clark
''Bessarabia. Russia and Roumania on the Black Sea'': Chapter XVII, "Organization of the Diet"
, at the University of Washington'
DXARTS/CARTAH Electronic Text Archive
; retrieved October 30, 2011
The election itself was a chaotic affair, and votes were never officially counted anywhere in Bessarabia. Once ''Sfatul Țării'' came into existence, Pântea was involved in more political maneuvering, helping his colleagues to topple Ion Pelivan, the designated first President of the Assembly. In doing so, Pântea gave approval to the demands of non-Romanian or pro-Russian delegates, who were scandalized by Pelivan's vocal Romanian nationalism. Ion Negrei
"Ion Pelivan – candidat la funcția de președinte al Sfatului Țării"
, in ''Literatura și Arta'', Nr. 13/2011, p.3
Like Crihan and Buzdugan, and eventually Pelivan himself, he transferred his support to Inculeț, who was widely perceived as a moderate, a loyalist, and a product of the February Revolution. Pântea too was designated a ''Sfatul Țării'' member, representing both the Soldiers' Congress and a Bălți Country constituency. His first address, in Russian, spoke about the opportunity for reform, and promised that, under ''Sfatul Țării'', Bessarabia would bloom into "a rose". Pântea was then an active as legislator, serving on the ''Sfatul Țării'' Commission for Schooling and the Commission for Liquidation. Additionally, he was a delegate to the Congress of Schoolteachers, wherein he recommended teaching Romanian to all Bessarabian schoolchildren. From 1918 to 1925, he edited the Russian-language regional daily ''Golos''. When Bessarabian deputies created the autonomous
Moldavian Democratic Republic The Moldavian Democratic Republic (MDR; ro, Republica Democratică Moldovenească, ), also known as the Moldavian Republic, was a state proclaimed on by the '' Sfatul Țării'' (National Council) of Bessarabia, elected in October–Novemb ...
, Pântea was integrated on the governing Moldavian Directorate: he had in his care the General Directorate for War and Navy, initially as ''Locum'' for Teodor Cojocaru, and then as ''de facto'' Director. His main task was the creation of a Military of Moldova, "Moldavian" armed force, which integrated the previous Cohorts, guarded over the unruly withdrawal of Russian forces, and established friendly contacts with the French Army. The Director witnessed with growing alarm as some components of his new army were coming under Bolshevik influence. Such was the case of Chișinău Garrison, which was being maneuvered by Ilie Cătărău, a mysterious adventurer and political radical. After Cătărău openly questioned ''Sfatul Țării'' authority over his troops, Pântea took a singular measure: together with a rogue unit of Amur Cossacks, he surprised Cătărău on New Year's Eve, arresting and deporting him into the Ukraine. Radu Petrescu
"Enigma Ilie Cătărău (II)"
, in ''Contrafort'', Nr. 7-8/2012
Between the two distinct phases of this incident, the Republic's army was sworn in during a ceremony attended by President of Moldova, Moldavian President Inculeț.


Union with Romania

Bolshevik agitation, endorsed from a distance by Lenin's Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic, Russian Soviet Republic, peaked over the early days of 1918. The withdrawing Russians were sacking the region, and Bolshevik factions such as ''Front-Ordel'' stood to gain the upper hand in Chișinău, Cotiujeni and the Budjak. Pântea instituted a state of emergency, and attempted to introduce more severe sanctions for insubordination. The Bolshevik groups resorted to intimidating acts in the capital, kidnapping some of the ''Sfatul Țării'' deputies and attacking the Romanian-organized Romanian Volunteer Corps in Russia, Volunteer Corps in Russia. In his addresses to ''Sfatul'', Pântea began identifying the Republic's enemy as exclusively "non-Moldavian", but noted that the Bessarabian army behaved "like a flock of rams", with no leadership and morale. On January 9, 1918, the Director was himself a victim of a Bolshevik maneuver, being apprehended by ''Front-Ordel'' men and only released, together with soldiers of the Volunteer Corps, when the Bessarabian army intervened in force. Facing the threats of Russian Civil War expansion into the Republic and communization in his own ranks, Pântea became a major contributor to the accelerated political process of union with Romania. In January 1918, he welcomed the Romanian Land Forces and General Ernest Broșteanu, who had a mandate to reinstate order, and who arrived in Chișinău alongside the French military envoy Henri Mathias Berthelot. There followed a common offensive against the Bolshevik insurgents, part of the larger Allied intervention in the Russian Civil War, Western intervention in the Civil War. In the end, the Bolsheviks retreated to Bender, Moldova, Tighina, and the Russian Soviet government broke Romania–Russia relations, diplomatic contacts with Romania (''see Odesa Soviet Republic''). Later that month, the Moldavian Republic proclaimed itself an independent state, with Daniel Ciugureanu as the new head of government. The administration was reorganized, and Pântea lost his position to Colonel Constantin Brăescu, the Minister of War.Constantin, p.69 President Inculeț compensated for the loss of prestige, raising Gherman Pântea to the rank of Major and making him Knight of the Moldavian Order of St. Vladimir.Constantin, p.72 By then, Romanian intervention posed a fundamental dilemma, since the political class became undecided about whether to cement Bessarabian statehood or look forward to a union. Inconclusiveness touched the Bessarabian army. Its new uniforms, on the Romanian model, led Bessarabians to assume that it was a branch of the Romanian Land Forces; the monogram ''R.M.'', for ''Republica Moldovenească'' ("Moldavian Republic"), was commonly misread as standing for "Greater Romania" (''România Mare''). Pântea himself appeared undecided about the situation, and, in a letter to pro-Russian officer Anatol Popa (later Capital punishment in Romania, sentenced to death by the Romanian military), argued: "I promise you that I'll be defending republican Bessarabia next to Russia, even if it costs me my life [...]. I gave the order for all the Moldavian army to take action; when it turned out that the Romanians were arriving with too great a force, I changed that order. The Romanians hold on tight [...]. I fear greatly that the Romanians are here to steal away our Bessarabia."Constantin, p.70-71 This correspondence remains a problematic aspect of Pântea' career. While some take it to imply double dealing or at least an ideological ambiguity, Ion Constantin suggests that it may have been in fact a ruse.Constantin, p.71 At the time, Romanian authorities were less convinced of Pântea's loyalty. They suspected him of playing the Romanians and the Russians against each other, and subjected him to a formal inquiry. Years later, Pântea referred to Broșteanu's intervention as misguided and sanguinary, because it carried out summary executions of suspected rebels, encouraged denunciations, and stained the unionists' international reputation. The union was effected on March 27, 1918, when a ''Sfatul Țării'' majority voted in favor. The 86 yea votes, which carried the day, included Pântea's. He also voted in favor of a Land reform in Romania, Romanian-wide land reform, an additional condition to the union. Contrary to later Bolshevik allegations, he and the other pro-union voters did not receive land property in exchange for their loyalty. Igor Cașu
"Arhivele comunismului. Cum era urmărită elita militară a Basarabiei de poliția politică sovietică"
, in ''Adevărul Moldova'', January 19, 2011


Lawyer, journalist and PNL politician

Over the following period, Pântea campaigned internally for further recognition of the assembly's decision, approaching the reluctant communities of Black Sea Germans. In March 1919, he was at Tarutyne, Tarutino, where a mass of Germans was persuaded into voting for the ''Sfatul Țării'' union resolution. Vasile Ciobanu
"Elita politică a germanilor din România în anii 1918-1919"
, in Vasile Ciobanu, Sorin Radu (eds.), ''Partide politice și minorități naționale din România în secolul XX'', Vol. III, TechnoMedia, Sibiu, 2008, p.63.
He subsequently accompanied a deputation of Black Sea Germans to Bucharest, capital of Greater Romania, and, with them, was received by King of Romania, King Ferdinand I of Romania, Ferdinand I. His rank in the Bessarabian army was recognized by the Romanian military reserve force, which integrated him as Major. Ottmar Trașcă
"Ocuparea orașului Odessa de căre armata română și măsurile adoptate față de populația evreiască"
, in the Romanian Academy's George Bariț Institute of History ''Historica Yearbook'' 2008, p.421
In April, Pântea was promoted a member of the Central Committee of the PȚB, and Chairman of its Club. He was in Romania for a while, taking his license degree from the University of Iași Faculty of Law (September 1919). Later investigation into his career resulted in allegations that Pântea never did attend class, and that his diploma was abusively released by Rector A. C. Cuza (answering the special request of Prime Minister of Romania, Romanian Premier Ion I. C. Brătianu). Whether or not this is true, Pântea is known to have been enlisted with the Bessarabian bar association as of 1919.Constantin, p.76 Late in the year, he began publishing another Russian-language daily, ''Bessarabia'', which went under in short while and was revived by Vasile Bârcă in 1923. This venture drew suspicions from the Romanian authorities, who organized a search of the premises and, reputedly, uncovered samples of communist propaganda.Constantin, p.77 Inside the PȚB, Pântea was loyal to Inculeț, and fought against the factions headed by Pan Halippa and Pelivan. He edited the party's ''Basarabia'' newspaper, where he launched tirades against Halippa, and again rose to a leadership position after Halippa's expulsion. Pântea followed Inculeț into Romania's National Liberal Party (Romania, 1875), National Liberal Party (PNL), and became deputy leader of the group's Bessarabian section. This affiliation got him elected into the Chamber of Deputies of Romania, Romanian Assembly of Deputies (lower chamber of
Parliament In modern politics, and history, a parliament is a legislative body of government. Generally, a modern parliament has three functions: representing the electorate, making laws, and overseeing the government via hearings and inquiries. Th ...
), the first of ten consecutive terms. Pântea was nevertheless considered suspect by the Romanian establishment, who believed him a man of left-wing sympathies and a promoter of communist literature. He was attorney for the group of Bessarabian communists, led by Pavel Tcacenco, who had agitated against the Romanian state. The ''pro bono'' activity was largely successful: Tcancenco and other three men were found guilt of sedition, and sentenced to death ''trial in absentia, in absentia''; 65 detainees were acquitted; 39 others were set free after trial de novo. This implied placing himself against the PNL government, particularly since Pântea reported to the world on the alleged the abuse of power by Romanian administrators in Bessarabia. His intervention in Parliament prompted the Ministry of Administration and Interior (Romania), Interior Ministry (headed by Nicolae L. Lupu) to sack the leadership of Siguranța Statului, ''Siguranța'' police in Chișinău. In 1922, from Tighina, Gherman Pântea began issuing another Russian daily. Titled ''Yuzhnaya Bessarabia'' or ''Iujnaia Besarabia'' ("Southern Bessarabia"), it survived until April 1923. He first had a stint as
Mayor of Chișinău The Mayor of Chișinău, officially the General Mayor of the Municipality of Chișinău ( ro, Primar general al municipiul Chișinău), is the head of the executive branch of Chișinău's government and a member of the city's Municipal Counci ...
, beginning and ending in 1923, when he outlined plans to improve education and the urban landscape of peripheral quarters.Constantin, p.27, 87 In October 1923, he was elected one of four Vice Presidents of the Assembly of Deputies, the first of two such assignments he would receive in his career.


Diplomatic missions and Georgist dissidence

In summer 1923, mandated by Ministry of Foreign Affairs (Romania), Foreign Affairs Minister Ion G. Duca of the PNL, he played a part in negotiations to restore contacts with the Russian government. He was in Paris, meeting with the Romanian communist Christian Rakovsky, who was the List of Ambassadors of Russia to France, Soviet Ambassador to France. They discussed the litigious issue of Bessarabia, which the Bolsheviks still refused to recognize as part of Romania: Pântea was supposed to convince them that the union had been a legitimate affair, and, according to Pântea, Rakovsky showed himself unusually receptive. With a delegation which included Constantin Langa-Rășcanu, Mircea Djuvara, Petru Cazacu, and Anton Crihan, Pântea represented Romania in bilateral talks with a delegation from the
Soviet Union The Soviet Union,. officially the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. (USSR),. was a List of former transcontinental countries#Since 1700, transcontinental country that spanned much of Eurasia from 1922 to 1991. A flagship communist state, ...
, headed by diplomat Nikolay Krestinsky. These negotiations took place in Vienna during late March 1924. In conversation with Krestinsky, Pântea even transmitted the government's offer to renounce claims to the Romanian Treasure in Russia, in exchange for the Soviet recognition of the 1918 union. Contacts broke down when the Soviets presented their proposal: a plebiscite in the disputed region or, alternatively, Romania's cession of the Budjak. Pântea believed that their uncompromising stance showed the swift radicalization of Soviet foreign policy under new Bolshevik leader Joseph Stalin, who was Rakovsky's enemy. The same year, Tcacenco returned to Romania, instigating the "Tatarbunary Uprising". This rebellion was quashed by the Romanian authorities, and Pântea was again defense attorney for the Bessarabian communist cell. Pântea also received his second term as Vice President of the Assembly after the 1927 Romanian general election, 1927 election. He still held the office in 1925, when he took part in debates to extend the scope of Jewish emancipation. To the alarm of Antisemitism, antisemitic groups such as the National-Christian Defense League, he assessed that all Bessarabian Jews had the right of naturalization. By then, the former Military Director was also a managerial director for Chișinău's chamber of commerce, and tried to obtain tax reductions for the Bessarabian artisans. Gherman Pântea returned as Mayor of Chișinău, in office from 1927 to 1928. In 1930, dissatisfied with the PNL and in dispute with Inculeț, he became a member of the dissident National Liberal Party-Brătianu (the "Georgists").Constantin, p.27, 86 He was notoriously critical of the PNL's party line, alleging that Inculeț had exploited Bessarabia for the Romanian Old Kingdom, Old Kingdom's benefit. Around the same time as Bessarabia marked its first full decade of Romanian rule, Pântea, Buzdugan, Crihan and Catelli were members of the Chișinău Union of Reserve Officers. A rough equivalent of the pre-union Assembly of the Nobility, this association stood out for demanding equal access to Romanian pensions for veterans of the Bessarabian army.


Early 1930s

The Georgist party failed to register much success, and Pântea left it before the 1931 Romanian general election, 1931 election; he joined the "National Union" list of incumbent Prime Minister Nicolae Iorga, and was returned to the lower chamber. His third and final mandate as Mayor of Chișinău was in 1932, when he began taking steps to erect a local statue of Ferdinand I. As the region suffered the consequences of the Great Depression, he helped Chișinău's poor, using public funds to buy back their Pawnbroker, pawned property items. As claimed by his political rivals (including historian Ștefan Ciobanu (politician), Ștefan Ciobanu), Pântea was corrupt and irresponsible in office, pocketing large sums of public money, and partying at Chișinău's expense on a visit to Kingdom of Italy (1861–1946), Italy (where he was supposed to reward Pietro Badoglio's support of the Bessarabian union). An anonymous brochure called the mayor a "Rasputin", alleging that he stole public furniture, while an antisemitic city councilor depicted him as "in cahoots" with the Bessarabian Jews. During those years, Pântea also became an active member of the Bucharest Bessarabian Circle of Nicolae Bosie-Codreanu, which monitored the evolution of Soviet attitudes on Romania. By then, there was a visible rapprochement between the Romania and the Soviet Union, effected by Romania's Foreign Minister Nicolae Titulescu and his PNL faction. The two governments had signed the London Convention for the Definition of Aggression and resumed diplomatic contacts. Renewing his attempts to obtain a definitive Romanian–Soviet agreement on Bessarabia, Pântea had informal talks with Mikhail Ostrovsky (commissar), Mikhail Ostrovsky, the Russian Ambassador to Romania, Soviet Envoy to Bucharest. Pântea preserved the image of a philo-Romanian Ostrovsky, who believed that Stalin would in time accept the union; the initiative, however, came to nothing, as both Ostrovsky and Titulescu were sidelined by their respective governments. Pântea was also focusing on writing his memoirs of World War I and the union. Some of these texts were originally published by ''Dreptatea'' daily in 1931, and were later collected into the book ''Unirea Basarabiei. Rolul organizațiilor militare moldovenești în actul unirii'' ("Bessarabia's Union. The Role of Moldavian Military Units in the Act of Union"). A second edition, published in 1932, had a eulogistic foreword by Nicolae Iorga, the historian and political ally; the book also received endorsements from Pântea's former colleagues (Catilli, Cijevschi etc.). Around 1935, Pântea's account was rejected by historian Emanoil Hagi-Moscu and ''Epoca (Romania), Epoca'' newspaper, who discussed Pântea's statements of loyalty toward the Russian Republic, and even alleged that the Director had been responsible for the January 1918 attack on the Transylvanian volunteers. With his own version of events supported by Iorga, Pântea sued Hagi-Moscu for slander. Between 1934 and 1937, when he resumed his activity a lawyer, Pântea sat on Chișinău City Hall's Board of Revision.Constantin, p.88 He reconciled with the PNL, but the party resented his earlier disloyalty: also in 1937, he left the PNL, never to return. In October 1937, he was an honored guest at the festive anniversary of the Moldavian Soldiers' Congress, in Chișinău. That year, he alo published the second volume of his memoirs: ''Unirea Basarabiei. Două decenii de la autonomia Basarabiei'' ("Bessarabia's Union. Two Decades since the Bessarabian Autonomy").Constantin, p.191


Carol II's regime and the loss of Bessarabia

Pântea witnessed the rise of fascism in Romania, confirmed when the PNL lost the 1937 Romanian general election, December 1937 election; in those circumstances, King of Romania, King Carol II of Romania, Carol II appointed the far right's Octavian Goga as Premier. The move alarmed the Soviets, and clashed with their popular front policy: according to Pântea, Ambassador Ostrovsky called on him to inform Romanians that Stalin and France's Léon Blum insisted that Goga should be deposed and Romania taken out of "the fascist camp". Pântea maintained that, on its own, Ostrovsky's warning to Carol II resulted in the formation of a new Romanian cabinet, headed by Miron Cristea. The new regime was an Authoritarianism, authoritarian one, centered on Carol II, and confirmed by the 1938 Constitution of Romania. Parliament was practically dissolved, but, as a long-time member of the former Assembly, Gherman Pântea was assigned a permanent seat in the reorganized Senate of Romania, Romanian Senate. Following Carol's administrative restructuring, he was also named counsel at the superior court of Ținutul Nistru. He was at odds with Grigore Cazacliu, the King's Resident (Governor), accusing him of dishonest business practices. During the first years of
World War II World War II or the Second World War, often abbreviated as WWII or WW2, was a world war that lasted from 1939 to 1945. It involved the vast majority of the world's countries—including all of the great powers—forming two opposing ...
, Romania was caught between the hostile governments of Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union (''see Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact, Romania in World War II''). In that context, the Soviets communicated an ultimatum to Romania, and Soviet occupation of Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina, occupied Bessarabia (June 1940). Pântea and his family escaped to Bucharest, where the refugee politician continued his work with the Bessarabian Circle. Later that year, German pressures resulted in the loss of Northern Transylvania, which confirmed the break-up of Greater Romania. By then, the Bessarabian Circle represented a 120,000-strong refugee community, having Inculeț and Daniel Ciugureanu as Presidents, Bosie-Codreanu and Pântea as Vice Presidents. The major territorial losses resulted in Carol's fall from power, and inaugurated the National Legionary State, with Ion Antonescu as ''Conducător''. Initially, this regime followed Nazi policy, and prevented the more obvious displays of Bessarabian unionism, leading Pântea to exclaim: "General Antonescu [...] cannot speak his mind on all subjects, so hopefully he would allow us to discuss and to shout out the issue of our justice". In May, shortly after the Antonescu regime had restructured itself (''see Legionary Rebellion''), Pântea entered a dispute with other members of the Bessarabian Circle, and resigned from the post of Vice President.


Odesa massacre

On June 22, 1941, a little more than a year into the Soviet occupation of Bessarabia, Romania partook in the Operation Barbarossa, surprise attack on Soviet territory as an Axis Powers, Axis country. Gherman Pântea was mobilized and dispatched to the Fourth Army (Romania), Fourth Army, where he was legal adviser to General Nicolae Ciupercă. The latter asked him to review a list of 100 Bessarabian "undesirables", singled out for their left-wing opinions and facing summary execution—Ciupercă wanted his secretary to ensure that no "good Romanians" had been included, but Pântea was able to obtain that the order itself be postponed. Among those rescued as a result of his objection were the communist activists Gheorghe Stere (son of Bessarabian unionist Constantin Stere) and Alexandru Mîță. The extension of Romanian rule into a new eastern province, carved out under the name of "
Transnistria Transnistria, officially the Pridnestrovian Moldavian Republic (PMR), is an unrecognised breakaway state that is internationally recognised as a part of Moldova. Transnistria controls most of the narrow strip of land between the Dniester riv ...
", brought Pântea to high office. As Pântea later noted, Antonescu considered him a suitable Transnistria Governor, but revised his stance when he discovered that Pântea still did not support his policies. Consequently, Pântea was assigned Mayor of Odesa, Mayorship of Odesa, taking hold of his seat only after the city's Siege of Odesa (1941), violent siege had been completed. In order to appease the Germans, Odesa was formally kept out of Transnistria, and the Odesa Mayor's office remained separated from those of other Romanian administrators. Among the latter, Transnistrian Governor Gheorghe Alexianu, Gendarmerie (Romania), Gendarmerie commander Constantin Vasiliu and Army General Nicolae Ghineraru regarded Pântea with particular disdain or mistrust. Instead of condoning the Romanian- and German-led mass murder of History of the Jews in Ukraine, Ukrainian and Bessarabian Jews (''see Holocaust in Romania''), Pântea is credited with having saved many of the potential victims—probably numbering in the thousands. Iulia Blaga, Florin Iepan
"Intențiile lui Florin Iepan - ''Odessa'' la Festivalul ''One World România'', 2011"
, Editura LiterNet release (originally published by HotNews.ro), March 2011, retrieved November 2, 2011
On October 22, 1941, Pântea issued a proclamation in ''Odesskaya Gazeta'', promising a return to normal, and announced freedom and equality between all Odesans. However, this statement was rendered ineffectual by events which occurred on the same day: an explosion on Marazlie Street took the life of General Ioan Glogojeanu and other Romanian officials. The Antonescu regime supposed a terrorist attack, ignoring all accounts according to which the retreating Red Army had mined the location. Reportedly, Pântea and his Transnistrian colleague Nichita Smochină were informed of the mining, and tried to warn their superiors not to enter the Marazile building. Antonescu's reaction was sanguinary, and a collective blame was placed on the Odesa Jews. The community was decimated during what became known as the " 1941 Odesa massacre". As a witness to this slaughter, Pântea noted that 450 Jewish people were hanged on the first day, others were randomly shot, and still others were rounded up, their fate to be determined by General Nicolae Macici. Pântea thereafter worked to persuade Macici that the killing quota imposed by Antonescu was excessive. On October 23, he and Macici asked Governor Alexianu to turn back the column of Jews sent on a death march. They registered only partial success, as some of the deportees returned: according to Pântea, all but 2,000 survived the experience. However, researchers of the events record a much higher death toll. According to them, Romanian troops randomly murdered some 20,000 or 30,000Rotman, p.95 of those sent on convoys. The following week, the Mayor contacted socialite Alexandrina Cantacuzino and presented her with a report on the Massacre, which she was to hand over to Antonescu. In assigning blame for the killings, Pântea noted that he himself was not a defender of the Jews, but a man concerned with justice. His document highlighted the acts of "barbarity" and the "un-Romanian" behavior of various officials; Antonescu threatened to have the author shot on the spot, but later ordered an investigation into some cases of abuse.


Plan for Odesa

Pântea maintained Odesa a functional metropolis, with adequate food and electricity supplies, and as such, when compared to the rest of Transnistria, city life flourished under most of his mandate. Viktor Faytelberg-Blank, V. Savchenko
"Василий Вронский – «Луч света в темном царстве»" (I)
, in ''Porto Franko'', Nr. 24 (563), June 2001
He assigned engineer Lisenko, who had flooded the Odesa power station during the Soviet retreat, to build a new electrical substation; once this began operating, he reopened the Odesa Opera and Ballet Theater, refurbished
Odesa University Odesa I. I. Mechnykov National University ( uk, Одеський національний університет Iмені І. І. Мечникова, translit=Odeskyi natsionalnyi universytet imeni I. I. Mechnykova), located in Odesa, Ukraine, i ...
(while building a close relationship with the students), and cleared for use the city's tramway lines. Businesses also reopened, benefiting from
free trade Free trade is a trade policy that does not restrict imports or exports. It can also be understood as the free market idea applied to international trade. In government, free trade is predominantly advocated by political parties that hold econ ...
and voluntary taxation—the city treasury, Pântea claimed, collected some 170 million ''Reichsmark'' in revenue. According to historian Mark Mazower, the experiment was largely carried by corrupt practices, but also gave the Soviet-born Odesans a unique experience of capitalism. Liberal enterprise coexisted with the minute regulation of social life: in Russia, Pântea's resolutions on this subject are remembered as farcical and unwittingly humorous. A. V.
"Память. ...И фантастичен документ"
in ''Literaturnaya Gazeta'', Nr. 24/2006
Constantin, p.150-151 One of them limited children's use of bicycles and roller skates, under the pain of court-martial for their parents. The cultural projects he promoted doubled as a propaganda effort: the new authorities staged shows which suggested that Odesa was, and would remain, part of a new Greater Romania. During 1943, he renamed Avchinnikov Street after Octavian Goga, and turned a lodging once visited by Goga into a hotel for Romanian writers on vacation to "Romanian Odesa". Some of the Russian locals played along, in a bit to ensure cultural survival. Among the latter was actor Vasily Vronsky (Vasile Vronschi), who knew Pântea from Chișinău, and who received permission to establish the Russian-language Vronsky Theater; granted Romanian citizenship, he gave speeches denouncing Soviet agitprop. Viktor Faytelberg-Blank, V. Savchenko
"Василий Вронский – «Луч света в темном царстве»" (II)
in ''Porto Franko'', Nr. 25 (564), June 2001
During January 1942, there was another planned exodus of Jews from Odesa. Pântea, whose official reports described the claim of "Jewish instigation" as a canard,Constantin, p.121-122 was reportedly alarmed by the decision. Mostly in vain, he tried persuading Alexianu to reduce the number of Odesa Jews delivered to Berezivka concentration camp—the Mayor hoped to at least obtain the return of Jews who were artisans, teachers or Crimean Karaites. His own membership of the Eviction Bureau remains a contended issue: Pântea categorically denied it (a negation that is backed by Ion Constantin, and reflected in various primary sources); nevertheless, one archive document refers to him as one of ten supervisors of the 1942 deportation. He also took measures against squatting in formerly Jewish houses, but, historian and former Soviet partisans, Soviet partisan Yitzhak Arad argues, meant to "keep those apartments for the Romanian administration [...] and to sell a certain number of the apartments to turn a profit." In time, Mayor Pântea found a middle ground between the various political factors, and selected his own administrative team from a mixture of Bessarabian and Soviet clerks. In addition to Vice Mayor Vidrașcu, it included old unionist combatants (Vladimir Chiorescu,
Elefterie Sinicliu Elefterie Sinicliu (born 4 October 1895, Echimăuţi, Orhei - died in 20th century) was an agronomist and politician from Bessarabia, member of the Moldovan Parliament (1917–1918). Biography In 1917 he participated in the local congress held ...
) and Odesan notabilities (Dr. M. Zaevloshin, architect Vladimir Cundert). Reportedly, City Hall did not exercise political repression against known communists, who were merely required to register on a special list. The Romanian Mayor was also careful to preserve contacts with the two most powerful forces battling each other for control, namely the Germans and the Soviet partisans.Constantin, p.28 His intervention saved the life of Yelena Rudenko, sister of Soviet General Fyodor Tolbukhin, who had fallen severely ill at the family home in Odesa. Alexianu was especially weary of the Mayor's web of connections. In December 1941, he inquired Pântea about his alleged employment of political suspects, which Pântea categorically denied. In 1942, government embarked on a complex, but erratic, investigation into the presence of former Komsomolists among Odesa's public sector employees. Allegations regarding Pântea's complicity in some acts of corruption prompted additional surveillance from Serviciul Special de Informații, Romanian Special Intelligence. Its subsequent reports accused the Mayor and some in his staff of keeping company with covert communists, and of trading on the black market of Chișinău. Later, sources adverse to Pântea claimed that he was the main beneficiary of trade in Moldovan wine and used goods, and that he had vested interest in aiding the Transnistrian Jews, who were his business partners. By late 1942, Pântea again irritated the Romanian commandants, when he complained that General Vasiliu had requisitioned Odesa's trolleybuses and moved them to Craiova, in southern Romania. Pântea still tried to enforce his own plans for Odesa's development. In October 1943, on the 2-year anniversary of the occupation, he issued, by means of ''Molva'' gazette, a new address to the city's residents, in which he proudly listed his contributions. A few weeks later, he began employing laborers from the neighboring ''Reichskommissariat Ukraine'' for a new set of public works in Odesa.


1945 prosecution

During January 1944, as the Eastern Front (World War II), Eastern Front moved closer to Romania, Alexianu's bureaucracy was replaced with a defensive military structure, headed by General Gheorghe Potopeanu. Pântea considered his own position redundant, and asked to be recalled, but Antonescu ordered him to continue with his mandate. He was still at his post when Potopeanu relinquished his command to the Germans, and protested as Potopeanu handed over to the Nazis all property that Romania had confiscated from Soviet citizens. Enmity between the two Romanian administrators was on the rise. According to one account, Potopeanu still remembered that Pântea had tried to sell him a grossly overpriced used car. During March, Pântea was himself forced to relinquish City Hall property, assigning it to the Germans. After farewell ceremonies at the University and in the factories, he and his wife Lucia left to join the retreating Romanian troops. The Pânteas were in Bucharest during King Michael's Coup (August 23, 1944), with which Romania effectively changed sides in the war by toppling Antonescu. Their house on Argentina Street was damaged in the subsequent Bombing of Bucharest in World War II, Nazi air raid, and the family moved with politician Petre Ghiață, in Colentina, Bucharest, Colentina. On August 24, Gheorghe Potopeanu, who had emerged as Ministry of Public Finance (Romania), Finance Minister, demanded Pântea's arrest as a potential turncoat; and since the political transition found Pântea included on the transitional regime's list of enemies, it was also assumed that he was one of Antonescu's war criminals. The post-Antonescu government of Constantin Sănătescu proceeded to include him Pântea a revised list of war criminals, even though its Soviet partners still did not describe him as such. When the Red Army entered Bucharest in September, it arrested Potopeanu at his Ministry desk. Meanwhile, Pântea decided to obey the new legislation, and handed down to the state all items of property he had taken on as Mayor. By January 1945, when the Sănătescu list was published, Pântea turned fugitive: for a while, he lived in Craiova, where his brother Constantin resided; later, he was in Sibiu, living under the assumed name of ''Lozont'' (or ''Lozony'') ''Cernescu''. Like Antonescu and Potopeanu, Pântea faced trial in front of the newly created Romanian People's Tribunals, People's Tribunal. In the end, he was acquitted, since Yelena Rudenko and Tolbukhin informed the Romanian state about Pântea's honorable conduct, and since the Allied Commission recommended his release. Pântea was arrested on several other occasions, but, singularly among Romanians prosecuted for war crimes, he was acquitted each time. Although his rivals in the Transnistrian administration were by then destroying evidence of his more positive role in the affairs of state, Pântea preserved Certified copy, certified copies as a precautionary measure.


Communist sentencing and rehabilitation

In 1947, Ilie Cătărău vindicated his 1918 deportation on Pântea's orders, and began circulating serious allegations against his rival. Published in the Romanian press, these resulted in a national manhunt for Pântea. Fearing a political retribution, the latter made himself lost in Sibiu, where he lived with false papers until December 1949. He was making short visits to Bucharest with forged identity papers and the alias ''George Mincu'', and kept contacts with Anton Crihan, who was preparing for a defection to Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, Yugoslavia. Meanwhile, Soviet occupation of Romania, Soviet occupation gave way to a satellite Socialist Republic of Romania, Romanian communist regime. Pântea was tracked down by famed Commissar Eugen Alimănescu and handed down to the Securitate (that is, the communist secret police). He was interrogated by Securitate commandant Alexandru Nicolschi, and confronted with allegations made against him by Gheorghe Stere and Alexandru Mîță, whose lives Pântea had helped save. Pântea was sent to Jilava Prison, and kept without trial for three years; in late 1952, a Military Tribunal sentenced him to a further 10-years Penal labour, hard labor, as a "war criminal" and "Enemy of the people, enemy of the working class". His first year after the verdict was spent under heavy regime, at Aiud Prison, but Pântea was later moved into other infamously tough detention facilities: Gherla Prison and Ocnele Mari prison, Ocnele Mari Prison. In November 1954, he was dispatched to a milder prison, at Craiova, and then sent to Poarta Albă, a labor camp on the Danube–Black Sea Canal. In October 1955, Gherman Pântea was included in an amnesty decreed by the Romanian communist authorities, as the early sign of a reluctant liberalization. In January of the next year, he was even partially rehabilitated during a trial de novo for some 800 sentenced war criminals. After gathering evidence and testimonials from Soviet nationals, he took his case to the High Court of Cassation and Justice, Supreme Tribunal, which concluded that his sentencing as a "war criminal" was illegal (while finding little evidence that his were crimes "against the working class"). However, the Securitate still kept a file on Pântea, keeping him and his family under constant surveillance. At a time when repression was organized against the Bessarabian refugees, its staff gathered data according to which Pântea was capable of organizing Bessarabian resistance in Romania-proper. With noted help from the Soviet KGB and a female Soviet envoy (codenamed ''Valeria''), the secret police began re-investigating Pântea's various activities in politics. The Securitate archives also show that Securitate men approached the former Bessarabian Director with an offer to become their informant, but register Pântea's blunt refusal, even after intimidation.


Final years and death

Communist harassment continued over the following years. After the Hungarian Revolution of 1956, the Securitate kept close watch on Pântea's reaction, reporting about his anti-communism, his contacts with the exiled Crihan or underground PNL-ists such as Aurelian Bentoiu, and his hopes for an Vin americanii!, American intervention. Consequently, through a decision signed by Nicolschi in 1960, he and his wife were stripped of their pensions. Officially, the Pânteas stood accused of illegally trading in gold coins; a brutal police inquiry followed, and Lucia Pântea's arm was fractured in the process, but the prosecution was stopped in its tracks by the Great National Assembly (Socialist Republic of Romania), Great National Assembly. Gherman and brother Constantin were again picked up in April 1961, and detained in the prison of Craiova together with other 5 "reactionary elements" from Bessarabia—in 1962, all were sentenced to 1 year in jail. Around 1964, as Romania embraced (nominally anti-Soviet) national communism, Pântea began hoping that Censorship in Communist Romania, communist censorship would revisit the Bessarabian dispute from a traditional viewpoint. In this context, he corresponded with official historian Andrei Oțetea, praising his "courage and clarity" in exposing the hidden side of Marxist historiography. He himself began writing new memoirs for the Nicolae Iorga Institute of History, Bucharest Institute of History, and, on International Workers' Day, May Day 1965, began receiving a state pension honoring his "outstanding contributions in service to the working class during the years 1919–1926". By 1967, Pântea made a final return to the public sphere, openly restating his version of historical events. He spoke on the subject at the funeral of fellow Bessarabian refugee Ion Buzdugan, at the ''parastas'' of Gurie Grosu, and again at a commemoration for Alexe Mateevici, reportedly causing panic among his public (most of whom were by then the survivors of communist jails). The Pântea family moved back to Bucharest, at the old home on Argentina Street. Gherman Pântea died on February 1, 1968, in unusual circumstances: he had been absent from home for almost two days, and the family was informed that he had collapsed in the street, minutes after being spotted at a Piața Amzei diner; medical investigation showed that he was not suffering from any life-threatening condition. The funeral was at Bucharest's Bellu Cemetery, on February 4. The ceremony, which included an Orthodox service by priest Vasile Țepordei, doubled as a low-key political rally: it brought together the community of Bessarabian refugees, who regarded Pântea as their hero, and was closely monitored by the Securitate. The funeral orations were delivered by, among others, Father Țepordei, Sinicliu, and his 1921 rival, Halippa.


Legacy

Gherman Pântea is briefly mentioned in ''For Soviet Power'', a 1953 war novel by Soviet author Valentin Kataev. Here, in keeping up with Historiography in the Soviet Union, Soviet historiography of the late Stalin period, he is mainly depicted as a criminal figure who takes absurd decisions. In contrast, the Bessarabian folklorist Tatiana Gălușcă-Crâșmaru composed the 1968 poem ''Lui Gh. Pântea, vechi luptător'' ("To Gh. Pântea, and Old Combatant"), which depicts the Moldavian Republic's Director as a hero of the entire Romanian people. Between these images is one proposed by the Bessarabian expatriate and Romanian historian Alexandru I. Gonța, according to whom Pântea is a relevant but second-rate figure in the history of Bessarabian unionism (this view, first made public in 1973, is hotly contested by other authors and activists). After the Romanian Revolution of 1989, as Romania's participation in the Holocaust was being acknowledged, various commentators contrasted Gherman Pântea's behavior with that of other Transnistria administrators. According to Romanian-born Israeli historian Jean Ancel, Pântea's protest against Antonescu's orders is compatible with the work of his Chernivtsi, Cernăuți colleague Traian Popovici, known for defending Bukovina Jews from planned extermination. In 2008, a similar point was made by writer Boris Marian in the History of the Jews in Romania, Jewish community magazine ''Realitatea Evreiască'': "The Romanian Mayor of Odesa was shocked by the cruelty with which the orders coming in from Bucharest were being executed. His name was Gherman Pântea and he was a normal man. Like Mayor Traian Popovici of Cernăuți, Gh. Pântea wished above all to fulfill his duty as a human being." On the commemoration of the 1941 Odesa massacre, Odesa Massacre in 2011, Romanian filmmaker Florin Iepan produced the documentary ''Odessa'', which gives evidence about the scale of murder. In an earlier interview, Iepan mentioned that Pântea was "an interesting character" and "a rather luminous figure in that context of bitterness and violence." During debates with the public, held after the film's release, Iepan also quoted Pântea's report to Antonescu as proof that some Romanian officials knew about (and, in this case, deplored) the killings in the city. However, Pântea's own testimonies on the Holocaust subject have various ambiguities and omissions. Mark Mazower notes that, in writing his reports, Pântea never realized the level of Antonescu's involvement in the 1941 Massacre. Before the Wiesel Commission, official recognition of Holocaust crimes, the Odesa mayor's accounts were being cited against themselves by those who tried to minimize Romanian involvement. In reaction, Jewish community historian Teodor Wexler argued that the attempt was missing its target: "Gherman Pântea's letter [is] of an unrestrained tragicalness", confirming "once and for all the historical responsibility of those who dictated the undertaking of the Holocaust in Romania." Following the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991, most of Bessarabia returned to independence, as the Republic of Moldova. As of that moment, Pântea's name continues to be a subject of contention in the Controversy over linguistic and ethnic identity in Moldova, debates over Moldovan nationhood: a hero to the Movement for the unification of Romania and Moldova, pro-unionists, he is largely ignored by the Moldovenism, Moldovenists. This was noted in 2010 by unionist politician Mircea Druc, who assessed that, other than a commemorative plaque in Chișinău, there was little left to attest Pântea's significance to the Moldovan Republic. Nicolae Costin, who was
Mayor of Chișinău The Mayor of Chișinău, officially the General Mayor of the Municipality of Chișinău ( ro, Primar general al municipiul Chișinău), is the head of the executive branch of Chișinău's government and a member of the city's Municipal Counci ...
between 1990 and 1994, reportedly sought to revive Pântea's urban projects (continued, after another long hiatus, by Dorin Chirtoacă).Constantin, p.27


Notes


References

*Andrei Cemârtan, "Le Parti des Paysans de Bessarabie et la rivalité entre Pantelimon Halippa et Ion Inculeț", in ''Codrul Cosminului'', Nr. 2, 2011, p. 121–145. * Vitalie Ciobanu
"Directoratul general de război și marină al Basarabiei (1917–1918)"
in ''Cohorta. Revistă de Istorie Militară'', Nr.1/2007, p. 93-102 * Ion Constantin
''Gherman Pântea între mit și realitate''
(with a foreword by Mircea Druc), Editura Biblioteca Bucureștilor, Bucharest, 2010. *Dennis Deletant, ''Hitler's Forgotten Ally: Ion Antonescu and His Regime, Romania, 1940-1944'', Palgrave Macmillan, London, 2006. * Lidia Kulikovski, Margarita Șcelcikova (eds.)
''Presa basarabeană de la începuturi pînă în anul 1957. Catalog''
at th
B. P. Hasdeu Municipal Library of Chișinău
retrieved October 31, 2011 *Mark Mazower, ''Hitler's Imperium: Europa unter der Herrschaft des Nationalsozialismus'', C. H. Beck, Munich, 2009. * Doina Otelița
"Problema Basarabiei în evoluția raporturilor româno-sovietice: 1918-1924"
in ''Buletinul Cercurilor Științifice Studențești, Arheologie - Istorie'', Nr. 1, 1995, p. 213-216 * Liviu Rotman (ed.),
Demnitate în vremuri de restriște
', Editura Hasefer, Federation of Jewish Communities of Romania & Elie Wiesel National Institute for Studying the Holocaust in Romania, Bucharest, 2008.


External links

{{DEFAULTSORT:Pantea, Gherman 1894 births 1968 deaths Moldovan Ministers of Defense Moldovan MPs 1917–1918 Romanian people of Moldovan descent Mayors of Chișinău Mayors of Odesa Mayors of places in Romania Moldovan lawyers Moldovan newspaper editors Male journalists Moldovan newspaper founders Moldovan memoirists Moldovan schoolteachers Military personnel of the Russian Empire Russian military personnel of World War I Military personnel of the Moldavian Democratic Republic Members of the Chamber of Deputies (Romania) Members of the Senate of Romania National Liberal Party (Romania) politicians Romanian civil servants Romanian diplomats 20th-century Romanian lawyers Bessarabian Bolsheviks Romanian anti-communists Moldovan anti-communists Romanian military personnel of World War II Political office-holders in Transnistria Governorate Romanian people convicted of war crimes Inmates of Aiud prison Inmates of Gherla prison Inmates of the Danube–Black Sea Canal Socialist Republic of Romania rehabilitations Romanian newspaper editors Romanian newspaper founders 20th-century memoirists Romanian memoirists People from Rîșcani District Members of the Romanian Orthodox Church Recipients of the Order of St. George Alexandru Ioan Cuza University alumni Burials at Bellu Cemetery Inmates of Jilava Prison