Freshwater, Yarmouth and Newport Railway

The Freshwater, Yarmouth and Newport Railway was a railway line on the Isle of Wight, United Kingdom, connecting Freshwater and Yarmouth to Newport. It was intended to connect the thinly populated west of the island, and it opened in 1889. At Newport it relied on the existing Isle of Wight Central Railway's station, but trains entering it had to shunt back from the junction. The IoWCR worked the line until 1913.

The line was never commercially successful, and a break with the IoWCR in 1913 obliged the FY&NR hastily to build its own Newport station and acquire locomotives and rolling stock while in receivership.

After the Southern Railway absorbed the FY&NR in 1923, the SR developed holiday traffic, but it was highly seasonal and the heavy losses resulted in the line's closure in 1953.

Concept and construction

By 1880 the Isle of Wight was well supplied with railways in its eastern and northern areas, connecting Ryde with Newport and Cowes, and Ryde and Newport with Sandown and Ventnor. The more beautiful, but more thinly-populated west was untouched. Newport was the industrial centre on the island, and its geographical position on the River Medina made it a natural connection point. The Cowes and Newport Railway had a junction station there.

In 1868 a Bouldnor, Yarmouth and Freshwater Railway was proposed, but it did not proceed.Alan Blackburn and John Mackett, ''Freshwater, Yarmouth and Newport Railway'', Forge Books, Bracknell, second edition 1988, In 1872 a Freshwater, Bouldnor and Newport Railway was promoted; Bouldnor is a hamlet a mile or so east of Yarmouth; this venture was unsuccessful.Michael Robbins, ''The Isle of wight (Newport Junction) Railway'', in the Railway Magazine, October 1959

A parliamentary bill was submitted for a line connecting Freshwater and Newport, and this received royal assent on 26 August 1880, authorising the ''Freshwater, Yarmouth and Isle of Wight Railway''. Share capital was £100,000.E F Carter, ''An Historical Geography of the Railways of the British Isles'', Cassell, London, 1959 The new company was encouraged by support from the London and South Western Railway, which operated a ferry service from Lymington on the mainland to Yarmouth. There were many wealthy residents in the area to be served, and some also expressed support for a railway which, they believed, would facilitate their journeys to the mainland.K Westcott Jones, ''The Freshwater, Yarmouth and Isle of Wight Railway'', in the Railway Magazine, May and June 1947

The line was surveyed between 1883 and 1885, a second Act of 20 August 1883 was passed having authorised a further £42,000 of share capital. Construction started in 1886. The relaxed pace of events indicates a serious failure to generate share subscription.Carter gives the authorised capital including 33% loans in both cases.

The line was laid out so as to avoid major engineering works, at the expense of many curves and steep gradients; there was a trestle viaduct in length at Hunny Hill, Newport, and a concrete viaduct over the Newtown River. The line was constructed with passing loops at Carisbrooke, Ningwood and Yarmouth. The line was opened for goods traffic on 10 September 1888 and for passengers on 20 July 1889.

Opening

An inaugural train was run on 10 August 1888 hauled by an 0-6-0 tank engine that had been used by the contractor constructing the line, and named ''Freshwater'' for the occasion. For this demonstration run the locomotive pulled a single mineral wagon fitted with seats. A revenue earning goods train ran from Newport to Freshwater with two wagons of coal on 1 September 1888.

Passenger operation had to be approved by the Board of Trade and Major General Hutchinson visited the line on 2 May 1889 to inspect it. Reservations were expressed about some of the works, and an undertaking was required from the Board as to rectification; after some delay the approval was given, and a ceremonial opening took place on 11 July 1889, followed by a full public operation from 20 July 1889.

The line was worked by the Isle of Wight Central Railway for 53.625% of gross receipts, but the FY&NR remained responsible for maintenance of the infrastructure. The junction with the Cowes and Newport line was on the Cowes side of Newport station, and faced Cowes, so that the FY&NR trains running to Newport had to run round at the point of junction and run back to the station. (The Board had been required to give a formal undertaking that propelling without running round would not be carried out. After many years a dispensation was procured from the Board of Trade permitting propelling for the short distance between the junction and the station.)

End of the working agreement

From the outset the working agreement between the FY&NR and the IoWCR was contentious, due to the supposed inadequacy of structures and earthworks, for which the IoWCR was unwilling to accept the liability. The IoWCR may have suggested that a third-party contractor take that responsibility, for the FY&NR wrote to the IoWCR stating that "the principle of our line being maintained by any other person than the working company is not feasible. We find that there is no such case in the whole railway systems of Great Britain."Letter from FY&NR to IoWCR prior to July 1889, partly quoted in Blackburn, page 11

Whether the FY&NR did the maintenance by direct labour or by contract, it was inadequate from the outset. There were also several disputes about charges for the use of stations. A further review of the working agreement in 1896 resulted in a 14-year arrangement, by which the IoWCR got 45% of traffic receipts.

In 1910 that agreement expired, and the IoWCR was once more concerned that renewal of the working agreement committed them to steeply rising expenditure due to life expiry of much of the original FY&NR equipment, and discussions took place over the future working charge. In 1911 an 18-month agreement was settled, in which the IoWCR took 75% of receipts, their obligation including most infrastructure maintenance. The FY&NR agreed but was unhappy, and sought advice from Sam Fay of the Great Central Railway, who had a residence on the island. Fay recommended that the FY&NR should work its own line, and the FY&NR decided to proceed on that basis, procuring some passenger coaches from the Manchester, South Junction and Altrincham Railway, then starting electric passenger services with new stock. The FY&NR gave notice that they would work their line from 1 July 1913, and that they would not use the IoWCR station at Newport (to avoid the toll for its use).

The FY&NR provided its own station, a short distance before the point of junction at Newport. Goods sidings too had to be provided there. White refers to the station as being "a small corrugated iron one" but he meant the booking office; the platform and the accommodation generally was remarkably extensive.H P White, ''A Regional History of the Railways of Great Britain: volume 2: Southern England'', Phoenix House Limited, London, 1961 The IoWCR had acquired additional passenger coaches under the 1911 agreement, and the FY&NR were obliged under that agreement to buy them on. They had to issue debenture stock to pay for them.

Blackburn and Mackett state:

Some accounts of the events leading to the break between the two companies imply that it was the IWCR who took the initiative by banning the Freshwater Company's trains from Newport station, and even that they forced the FYN to run its own services by refusing to work the line. No evidence could be found to support these views. On the contrary it appears that the FYN were entirely responsible for the break. Naturally there was some opposition from the Central, and Harry Willmott, who owned some FYN stock, tried to organise some of the other shareholders to veto the proposal to build another station at Newport, but was unable to get sufficient votes. It also appears that after the break the IWCR did all they could to facilitate the exchange of passengers, luggage and parcels between the two stations.Blackburn and Mackett, page 16

The engine power the FY&NR procured now consisted of two locomotives only, indicating the limited volume of traffic it was running. They were second-hand 0-6-0 tank engines, dating from 1902 and 1876. The 1902 locomotive, no. 1, was the youngest to work on the Island and one of only two built in the twentieth century.Vic Mitchell and Keith Smith, ''Branch Lines to Newport'', Middleton Press, Midhurst, 1985, No. 2 was only fitted with the vacuum brake and consequently could only work one set of coaches, which were similarly fitted. No 1 was dual fitted. In addition an open-sided Drewry petrol railcar seating 12 passengers was obtained, working from 1 July 1913.C F Dendy Marshall, revised by R W Kidner, ''History of the Southern Railway'', Ian Allan Limited, Shepperton, 1963 revised edition 1982,

These expenditures pushed the FY&NR into insolvency almost immediately, and Fay was appointed by the receivers to manage the line, and in fact he assisted in getting hold of the rolling stock. Allen and MacLeod suggest that Fay's interest was in the possible Solent tunnel.P C Allen and A B MacLeod, ''Rails in the Isle of Wight'', second edition, David & Charles, Newton Abbot, 1986, In fact from this time the FY&NR was operated practically as a remote branch of the Great Central Railway.

The arrangement of the station, some considerable walking distance from the IoWCR station, was very inconvenient to through passengers changing trains at Newport. This resulted in complaints to the Railway and Canal Commissioners, who put pressure on the companies to ameliorate the situation, and from 1914 most FY&NR passenger trains resumed using the IoWCR station, although running beyond that point remained discontinued.

A Solent tunnel

In 1900 a proposal was put forward to construct a tunnel under the Solent connecting the FY&NR with the mainland network at Lymington. The idea got as far as an authorising Act of Parliament of 1901, incorporating the South Western & Isle of Wight Junction Railway. Nothing came of the scheme, but it was revived in 1913 as a means of reviving the finances of the FY&NR. However raising the capital for the works was problematical, and the onset of World War I put paid to the idea.

It was suggested again after 1923, but at the time the Southern Railway had invested heavily in piers and ferryboats, and were opposed to the idea; the local authorities too considered it unacceptably expensive. In fact in 1932 Dendy Marshall wrote to ''The Engineer'' magazine, proposing a tunnel with a revival of the atmospheric system. In a smooth-walled tunnel; there would be trains of "one carriage fitted with about half a dozen transverse fins of india-rubber nearly fitting the tunnel". Powerful fans would propel the vehicle at up to .Letter from Dendy Marshall partly quoted in Blackburn, page 13

Grouping of the railways

After World War I the Government considered the future of the railways of Great Britain, and passed the Railways Act 1921. In a process referred to as the "grouping", this set up four new railway companies which were to take over nearly all the existing companies. The Southern Railway absorbed all lines on the Isle of Wight from 1 January 1923, except for the FY&NR. The compensation to shareholders was to be negotiated, and although the FY&NR was in receivership, it argued that its prospects were good because of the hoped-for Lymington tunnel connection, and it attempted to obtain a better financial settlement. The negotiation dragged on and it was not until 1 August 1923 that the transfer took place. During the hiatus period, the FY&NR trains had to revert to using the separate station at Newport, with renewed inconvenience to passengers.

The Southern Railway brought new vigour to the railways of the island, and a new Tourist Express was laid on in the summer months, with limited stops, linking Freshwater with Sandown. This started as the ''East and West Through Train'', a name shown on carriage roofboards in 1932, and it proved a considerable success. In the following year further trains of this type were run, and the previous year's East and West Through Train was extended from Sandown to Ventnor, and named ''The Tourist'' in the public timetable. A through fast train from Ryde to Freshwater was also introduced, the first such for twenty years. The crossing loop at Ningwood was lengthened to in 1936 to accommodate these services, while the loops at Carisbrooke and Yarmouth were removed.

In the summer of 1939 there were thirteen trains in each direction with extra trains on Saturdays, and eight each way on Sundays. The journey time was about 37 minutes.

The final years

The traffic on the line had always been highly seasonal, and the thin population in its area meant that the financial situation was precarious. Road transport of passengers and goods became increasingly dominant from the 1930s and further accelerated after World War II, and the losses on the line were unsustainable in the face of the low volume of custom. The line closed on 21 September 1953. The locomotive used on the final journey was ''Alverstone'', built in 1891 and brought to the Island in 1926.

Stations

The line opened on 20 July 1889 and closed on 21 September 1953.

* Freshwater;
* Yarmouth;
* Ningwood;
* Calbourne & Shalfleet;
* Watchingwell; opened 20 July 1889 as a private station for Sir John Stephen Barrington Simeon; publicly advertised in 1923 and 1924;
* Carisbrooke;
* Newport (FY&NR station); opened 14 July 1913; closed 1 August 1923; intermittent use from 1914;
* Newport; Isle of Wight Central Railway (former Cowes and Newport Railway) station.M E Quick, ''Railway Passenger Stations in England Scotland and Wales—A Chronology'', The Railway and Canal Historical Society, 2002

Gradients

The first section of the line from Freshwater followed easy gradients, but then a climb of 1 in 64 followed for a mile, and that was the ruling gradient for of largely switchback (sawtooth) profile to beyond Watchingwell. After the summit a descent of the same gradient followed for into Newport.

Locomotives

Rolling stock

Until June 1913, the FYNR was worked by the IWCR. At the termination of the agreement, the IWCR sold five passenger coaches and 31 goods vehicles to the FYNR, and these all lasted to grouping in 1923.

The ex-IWCR passenger vehicles were insufficient, so the FYNR bought seven more secondhand from the Great Central Railway, and a four-wheeled Drewry petrol railcar was also bought in 1913. At the grouping, the FYNR had 12 passenger coaches and one railcar. These comprised five third-class (allotted SR numbers 2457–61), four composites (SR nos. 6358–61), two brake thirds (SR 4104–5), one brake composite (6990) and one railcar (2462).

The goods vehicles bought from the IWCR comprised 26 open goods wagons (allotted SR numbers 28227–52), four covered goods wagons (SR nos. 47032–5) and one brake van (SR 56038). The open goods wagons were also used for coal, and had carrying capacities of . Four or five of these were converted into cattle wagons by the FYNR, and soon after the grouping the SR reconverted them back to open wagons, replacing them with proper cattle wagons from the mainland.

Current situation

Former station buildings:
* Freshwater is now demolished and occupied by a garden centre
* Yarmouth is now a café
* Ningwood and Watchingwell are private houses
* Calbourne and Carisbrooke have been demolished.

Former locomotives
* No. 2 "Freshwater" is now preserved on the Isle of Wight Steam Railway as W8 "Freshwater".

See also

*Railways on the Isle of Wight

Notes

References

External links

Railscot

{{Authority control

Pre-grouping British railway companies
Rail transport on the Isle of Wight
Railway companies established in 1880
Railway lines opened in 1888
Railway companies disestablished in 1923
Southern Railway (UK) constituents
1880 establishments in England
British companies established in 1880
1923 disestablishments in England
British companies disestablished in 1923