The Info List - Environmental Ethics

--- Advertisement ---

Environmental ethics
Environmental ethics
is the part of environmental philosophy which considers extending the traditional boundaries of ethics from solely including humans to including the non-human world. It exerts influence on a large range of disciplines including environmental law, environmental sociology, ecotheology, ecological economics, ecology and environmental geography. There are many ethical decisions that human beings make with respect to the environment. For example:

Should humans continue to clear cut forests for the sake of human consumption? Why should humans continue to propagate its species, and life itself? [1] Should humans continue to make gasoline-powered vehicles? What environmental obligations do humans need to keep for future generations?[2][3] Is it right for humans to knowingly cause the extinction of a species for the convenience of humanity? How should humans best use and conserve the space environment to secure and expand life?[4] What role can Planetary Boundaries play in reshaping the human-earth relationship?[5]

The academic field of environmental ethics grew up in response to the work of scientists such as Rachel Carson
Rachel Carson
and events such as the first Earth Day
Earth Day
in 1970, when environmentalists started urging philosophers to consider the philosophical aspects of environmental problems. Two papers published in Science had a crucial impact: Lynn White's "The Historical Roots of our Ecologic Crisis" (March 1967)[6] and Garrett Hardin's "The Tragedy of the Commons" (December 1968).[7] Also influential was Garett Hardin's later essay called "Exploring New Ethics
for Survival", as well as an essay by Aldo Leopold
Aldo Leopold
in his A Sand County Almanac, called "The Land Ethic," in which Leopold explicitly claimed that the roots of the ecological crisis were philosophical (1949).[8] The first international academic journals in this field emerged from North America in the late 1970s and early 1980s – the US-based journal Environmental Ethics
in 1979 and the Canadian-based journal The Trumpeter: Journal of Ecosophy
in 1983. The first British based journal of this kind, Environmental Values, was launched in 1992.


1 Marshall's categories

1.1 Libertarian extension 1.2 Ecologic extension 1.3 Conservation ethics

2 Humanist theories 3 Applied theology 4 Anthropocentrism 5 Status of the field 6 See also 7 Notes 8 Further reading 9 External links

Marshall's categories[edit] Some scholars have tried to categorise the various ways the natural environment is valued. Alan Marshall and Michael Smith are two examples of this, as cited by Peter Vardy in "The Puzzle of Ethics".[9] According to Marshall, three general ethical approaches have emerged over the last 40 years: Libertarian Extension, the Ecologic Extension and Conservation Ethics.[10] Libertarian extension[edit] Marshall’s Libertarian extension echoes a civil liberty approach (i.e. a commitment to extend equal rights to all members of a community). In environmentalism, though, the community is generally thought to consist of non-humans as well as humans. Andrew Brennan was an advocate of ecologic humanism (eco-humanism), the argument that all ontological entities, animate and in-animate, can be given ethical worth purely on the basis that they exist. The work of Arne Næss
Arne Næss
and his collaborator Sessions also falls under the libertarian extension, although they preferred the term "deep ecology". Deep ecology
Deep ecology
is the argument for the intrinsic value or inherent worth of the environment – the view that it is valuable in itself. Their argument, incidentally, falls under both the libertarian extension and the ecologic extension. Peter Singer's work can be categorized under Marshall's 'libertarian extension'. He reasoned that the "expanding circle of moral worth" should be redrawn to include the rights of non-human animals, and to not do so would be guilty of speciesism. Singer found it difficult to accept the argument from intrinsic worth of a-biotic or "non-sentient" (non-conscious) entities, and concluded in his first edition of "Practical Ethics" that they should not be included in the expanding circle of moral worth.[11] This approach is essentially then, bio-centric. However, in a later edition of "Practical Ethics" after the work of Næss and Sessions, Singer admits that, although unconvinced by deep ecology, the argument from intrinsic value of non-sentient entities is plausible, but at best problematic. Singer advocated a humanist ethics. Ecologic extension[edit] Alan Marshall's category of ecologic extension places emphasis not on human rights but on the recognition of the fundamental interdependence of all biological (and some abiological) entities and their essential diversity. Whereas Libertarian Extension can be thought of as flowing from a political reflection of the natural world, ecologic extension is best thought of as a scientific reflection of the natural world. Ecological Extension is roughly the same classification of Smith's eco-holism, and it argues for the intrinsic value inherent in collective ecological entities like ecosystems or the global environment as a whole entity. Holmes Rolston, among others, has taken this approach. This category might include James Lovelock's Gaia hypothesis; the theory that the planet earth alters its geo-physiological structure over time in order to ensure the continuation of an equilibrium of evolving organic and inorganic matter. The planet is characterized as a unified, holistic entity with ethical worth of which the human race is of no particular significance in the long run. Conservation ethics[edit] Marshall's category of 'conservation ethics' is an extension of use-value into the non-human biological world. It focuses only on the worth of the environment in terms of its utility or usefulness to humans. It contrasts the intrinsic value ideas of 'deep ecology', hence is often referred to as 'shallow ecology', and generally argues for the preservation of the environment on the basis that it has extrinsic value – instrumental to the welfare of human beings. Conservation is therefore a means to an end and purely concerned with mankind and inter-generational considerations. It could be argued that it is this ethic that formed the underlying arguments proposed by Governments at the Kyoto summit in 1997 and three agreements reached in Rio in 1992.[citation needed] Humanist theories[edit] Following the bio-centric and eco-holist theory distinctions, Michael Smith further classifies Humanist theories as those that require a set of criteria for moral status and ethical worth, such as sentience.[citation needed] This applies to the work of Peter Singer who advocated a hierarchy of value similar to the one devised by Aristotle
which relies on the ability to reason. This was Singer's solution to the problem that arises when attempting to determine the interests of a non-sentient entity such as a garden weed. Singer also advocated the preservation of "world heritage sites," unspoilt parts of the world that acquire a "scarcity value" as they diminish over time. Their preservation is a bequest for future generations as they have been inherited from human's ancestors and should be passed down to future generations so they can have the opportunity to decide whether to enjoy unspoilt countryside or an entirely urban landscape. A good example of a world heritage site would be the tropical rainforest, a very specialist ecosystem that has taken centuries to evolve. Clearing the rainforest for farmland often fails due to soil conditions, and once disturbed, can take thousands of years to regenerate. Applied theology[edit]

Play media

Pope Francis’s environmental encyclical Laudato si'
Laudato si'
has been welcomed by many environmental organisations of different faiths - Interfaith march in Rome to call for climate action

The Christian world view sees the universe as created by God, and humankind accountable to God for the use of the resources entrusted to humankind. Ultimate values are seen in the light of being valuable to God. This applies both in breadth of scope - caring for people (Matthew 25) and environmental issues, e.g. environmental health (Deuteronomy 22.8; 23.12-14) - and dynamic motivation, the love of Christ controlling (2 Corinthians 5.14f) and dealing with the underlying spiritual disease of sin, which shows itself in selfishness and thoughtlessness. In many countries this relationship of accountability is symbolised at harvest thanksgiving. (B.T. Adeney : Global Ethics
in New Dictionary of Christian Ethics
and Pastoral Theology 1995 Leicester) Abrahamic religious scholars have used theology to motivate the public. John L. O'Sullivan, who coined the term Manifest destiny, and other influential people like him used Abrahamic ideologies to encourage action. These religious scholars, columnists and politicians historically have used these ideas and continue to do so to justify the consumptive tendencies of a young America around the time of the Industrial Revolution. In order to solidify the understanding that God had intended for humankind to use earths natural resources, environmental writers and religious scholars alike proclaimed that humans are separate from nature, on a higher order.[12] Those that may critique this point of view may ask the same question that John Muir asks ironically in a section of his novel A Thousand Mile Walk to the Gulf, why are there so many dangers in the natural world in the form of poisonous plants, animals and natural disasters, The answer is that those creatures are a result of Adam and Eve's sins in the garden of Eden.[13] Since the turn of the 20th century, the application of theology in environmentalism diverged into two schools of thought. The first system of understanding holds religion as the basis of environmental stewardship. The second sees the use of theology as a means to rationalize the unmanaged consumptions of natural resources. Lynn White and Calvin DeWitt represent each side of this dichotomy. John Muir
John Muir
personified nature as an inviting place away from the loudness of urban centers. "For Muir and the growing number of Americans who shared his views, Satan's home had become God's Own Temple."[14] The use of Abrahamic religious allusions assisted Muir and the Sierra Club
Sierra Club
to create support for some of the first public nature preserves. Authors like Terry Tempest Williams as well as John Muir
John Muir
build on the idea that "...God can be found wherever you are, especially outside. Family worship was not just relegated to Sunday in a chapel."[15] References like these assist the general public to make a connection between paintings done at the Hudson River School, Ansel Adams' photographs, along with other types of media, and their religion or spirituality. Placing intrinsic value upon nature through theology is a fundamental idea of Deep ecology. Anthropocentrism[edit] Main article: Anthropocentrism Anthropocentrism is the position that humans are the most important or critical element in any given situation; that the human race must always be its own primary concern. Detractors of anthropocentrism argue that the Western tradition biases homo sapiens when considering the environmental ethics of a situation and that humans evaluate their environment or other organisms in terms of the utility for them (see speciesism). Many argue that all environmental studies should include an assessment of the intrinsic value of non-human beings.[16] In fact, based on this very assumption, a philosophical article has explored recently the possibility of humans' willing extinction as a gesture toward other beings.[17] The authors refer to the idea as a thought experiment that should not be understood as a call for action. What anthropocentric theories do not allow for is the fact that a system of ethics formulated from a human perspective may not be entirely accurate; humans are not necessarily the centre of reality. The philosopher Baruch Spinoza
Baruch Spinoza
argued that humans tend to assess things wrongly in terms of their usefulness to us.[citation needed] Spinoza reasoned that if humans were to look at things objectively, they would discover that everything in the universe has a unique value. Likewise, it is possible that a human-centred or anthropocentric/androcentric ethic is not an accurate depiction of reality, and there is a bigger picture that humans may or may not be able to understand from a human perspective. Peter Vardy distinguished between two types of anthropocentrism.[18] A strong anthropocentric ethic argues that humans are at the center of reality and it is right for them to be so. Weak anthropocentrism, however, argues that reality can only be interpreted from a human point of view, thus humans have to be at the centre of reality as they see it. Another point of view has been developed by Bryan Norton, who has become one of the essential actors of environmental ethics by launching environmental pragmatism, now one of its leading trends. Environmental pragmatism refuses to take a stance in disputes between defenders of anthropocentrist and non-anthropocentrist ethics. Instead, Norton distinguishes between strong anthropocentrism and weak-or-extended-anthropocentrism and argues that the former must underestimate the diversity of instrumental values humans may derive from the natural world.[19] A recent view relates anthropocentrism to the future of life. Biotic ethics are based on the human identity as part of gene/protein organic life whose effective purpose is self-propagation. This implies a human purpose to secure and propagate life.[1][4] Humans are central because only they can secure life beyond the duration of the Sun, possibly for trillions of eons.[20] Biotic ethics values life itself, as embodied in biological structures and processes. Humans are special because they can secure the future of life on cosmological scales. In particular, humans can continue sentient life that enjoys its existence, adding further motivation to propagate life. Humans can secure the future of life, and this future can give human existence a cosmic purpose.[1][4] Status of the field[edit] Only after 1990 did the field gain institutional recognition at programs such as Colorado State University, the University of Montana, Bowling Green State University, and the University of North Texas. In 1991, Schumacher College of Dartington, England, was founded and now provides an MSc in Holistic Science. These programs began to offer a master's degree with a specialty in environmental ethics/philosophy. Beginning in 2005 the Department of Philosophy and Religion Studies at the University of North Texas offered a PhD program with a concentration in environmental ethics/philosophy. In Germany, the University of Greifswald
University of Greifswald
has recently established an international program in Landscape Ecology
& Nature Conservation with a strong focus on environmental ethics. In 2009, the University of Munich and Deutsches Museum
Deutsches Museum
founded the Rachel Carson
Rachel Carson
Center for Environment and Society, an international, interdisciplinary center for research and education in the environmental humanities. See also[edit]

Anarcho-primitivism Biocentrism Bioethics Climate ethics Conservation ethic Conservation movement Crop art Deep ecology Earth Economics
Earth Economics
(policy think tank) Ecocentrism Ecofeminism Ecological economics EcoQuest
(a series of two educational games) Environmental design Environmental engineering Environmental health
Environmental health
ethics Environmental movement Environmental organization Environmental racism Environmental resource management Environmental skepticism Environmental studies Environmental virtue ethics Environmentalism Hans Jonas Human ecology List of environmental philosophers Population
control Resource depletion Self-validating reduction Solastalgia Sustainability Terraforming Trail ethics Van Rensselaer Potter


^ a b c Mautner, Michael N. (2009). "Life-centered ethics, and the human future in space" (PDF). Bioethics. 23: 433–440. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8519.2008.00688.x. PMID 19077128.  ^ Climate change victims estimated at millions in the near future, according to Christian Aid[dead link] ^ 150,000 people killed already by climate change ^ a b c Mautner, Michael N. (2000). Seeding the Universe with Life: Securing Our Cosmological Future (PDF). Washington D. C.: Legacy Books. ISBN 0-476-00330-X.  ^ Steffen, Will (2015). "Planetary boundaries: Guiding human development on a changing plant" (PDF).  ^ White, Lynn (March 1967). "The Historical Roots of our Ecologic Crisis". Science. 155 (3767): 1203–1207. doi:10.1126/science.155.3767.1203. PMID 17847526.  ^ Hardin, Garrett (December 1968). "The Tragedy of the Commons" (PDF). Science. 162 (3859): 1243–8. doi:10.1126/science.162.3859.1243. PMID 5699198. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2011-07-19.  ^ Leopold, Aldo (1949). "The Land Ethic". A Sand County Almanac. ISBN 1-59726-045-2.  ^ Peter Vardy, Paul Grosch: The Puzzle of Ethics. New York: Harper Collins 1999. ^ Marshall, Alan. Ethics
and the Extraterrestrial Environment. In: Journal of Applied Philosophy, Vol. 10, No. 2, 1993, pp. 227-236. ISSN 1468-5930.  ^ Peter Singer: Practical Ethics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2011. ^ Scott, Peter. Ecology: Religious or Secular? Heythrop Journal. Jan 1997, Vol. 38 Issue 1. ^ Muir, John. From A Thousand-mile Walk to the Gulf. American Earth: Environmental Writing Since Thoreau. Ed. Bill McKibben. N.p.: The Library of America, 2008. 85-89. ^ William Cronon, ed., Uncommon Ground: Rethinking the Human Place in Nature, New York: W. W. Norton & Co., 1995, 69-90; ^ Williams, Terry T. Refuge : an unnatural history of family and place. New York: Vintage Books, 1992. Print. ^ Singer, Peter. "Environmental Values. The Oxford Book of Travel Stories. Ed. Ian Marsh. Melbourne, Australia: Longman Cheshire, 1991. 12-16. ^ Tarik Kochi & Noam Ordan, "An Argument for the Global Suicide of Humanity". Borderlands, 2008, Vol. 3, 1-21. ^ Peter Vardy and Paul Grosch (1999), ..The Puzzle of Ethics.., p. 231. ^ Afeissa, H. S. (2008). "The Transformative value of Ecological Pragmatism. An Introduction to the Work of Bryan G. Norton". S.A.P.I.EN.S. 1 (1). ^ Mautner, Michael N. (2005). "Life in the cosmological future: Resources, biomass and populations" (PDF). Journal of the British Interplanetary Society. 58: 167–180. 

Further reading[edit]

Ip, King-Tak (2009). Environmental Ethics: Intercultural Perspectives. Rodopi. ISBN 9789042025950.  Yunt, Jeremy D. 2017. Faithful to Nature: Paul Tillich
Paul Tillich
and the Spiritual Roots of Environmental Ethics. Barred Owl Books.

External links[edit]

Wikiversity has learning resources about Topic:Climate change

Bioethics Literature
Database Brief History of Environmental Ethics Thesaurus Ethics
in the Life Sciences EnviroLink Library: Environmental Ethics
- online resource for environmental ethics information EnviroLink Forum - Environmental Ethics
Discussion/Debate Environmental Ethics
online (journal, 1979-present) Sustainable and Ethical Architecture Architectural Firm Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy Environmental Ethics
entry in the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Center for Environmental Philosophy UNT Dept of Philosophy Creation Care Reading Room: Extensive online resources for environment and faith (Tyndale Seminary) Category List --- Religion-Online.org "Ecology/Environment" Islam, Christianity and the Environment

v t e



Casuistry Consequentialism Deontology

Kantian ethics

of care Existentialist ethics Meta-ethics Particularism Pragmatic ethics Role ethics Virtue


Autonomy Axiology Belief Conscience Consent Equality Care Free will Good and evil Happiness Ideal Justice Morality Norm Freedom Principles Suffering
or Pain Stewardship Sympathy Trust Value Virtue Wrong full index...


Laozi Plato Aristotle Diogenes Valluvar Cicero Confucius Augustine of Hippo Mencius Mozi Xunzi Thomas Aquinas Baruch Spinoza David Hume Immanuel Kant Georg W. F. Hegel Arthur Schopenhauer Jeremy Bentham John Stuart Mill Søren Kierkegaard Henry Sidgwick Friedrich Nietzsche G. E. Moore Karl Barth Paul Tillich Dietrich Bonhoeffer Philippa Foot John Rawls John Dewey Bernard Williams J. L. Mackie G. E. M. Anscombe William Frankena Alasdair MacIntyre R. M. Hare Peter Singer Derek Parfit Thomas Nagel Robert Merrihew Adams Charles Taylor Joxe Azurmendi Christine Korsgaard Martha Nussbaum more...

Applied ethics

Bioethics Business ethics Discourse ethics Engineering ethics Environmental ethics Legal ethics Media ethics Medical ethics Nursing ethics Professional ethics Sexual ethics Ethics
of eating meat Ethics
of technology

Related articles

Christian ethics Descriptive ethics Ethics
in religion Evolutionary ethics Feminist ethics History of ethics Ideology Islamic ethics Jewish ethics Normative ethics Philosophy of law Political philosophy Population
ethics Social philosophy

Portal Category

v t e

Environmental humanities


Crop art Environmental art Environmental sculpture Land art Landscape painting Photography

conservation landscape nature wildlife

Sculpture trail Site-specific art Sustainable art


Cultural ecology Cultural landscape Ecolinguistics Ecological anthropology Ecosemiotics Environmental anthropology Ethnoecology Traditional ecological knowledge


Ecocomposition Ecocriticism Ecopoetry Geocriticism Nature writing Outdoor literature Zoopoetics


Aesthetics of nature Constructivism Cosmology Critical realism Deep ecology Ecofeminism Ecophenomenology Ecosophy Environmental ethics Environmental justice Environmental philosophy Materialism Natural philosophy Philosophy of mind Philosophy of science Social ecology


Ecotheology Environmental theology Religion and environmentalism Spiritual ecology Stewardship


Anthrozoology Ecomusicology Environmental communication Environmental education

adult arts-based

Environmental history Environmental interpretation Environmental journalism Environmental law Outdoor education Psychogeography Thematic interpretation


Animal studies Bioethics Biophilia hypothesis Do it yourself
Do it yourself
(ethic) Natural history
Natural history
(museums) Popular science Property
theory (common property) Science, technology and society

science studies

Simple living Slow food Spirit of place Sustainability


Arts and Crafts movement Acoustic ecology Biomimicry Ecodesign Ecological design Ecomuseum Educational trail Environmental design Landscape architecture

assessment planning

Nature center New Urbanism Sustainable architecture Sustainable design Sustainable fashion Themed walk Urban acupuncture

Environment portal Category Commons Journals Degrees

v t e

Environmental science

Main fields

Atmospheric sciences Biogeochemistry Ecology Environmental chemistry Geosciences Hydrology Limnology Oceanography Soil science

Related fields

Biology Chemistry


Ecological economics Environmental design Environmental economics Environmental engineering Environmental health


Environmental studies Environmental toxicology Geodesy Physics Sustainability
science Systems ecology Urban ecology


Energy conservation Environmental technology Natural resource management Pollution control Recycling Remediation Renewable energy Road ecology Sewage treatment Urban metabolism Water purification Waste management

See also

Human impact on the environment Sustainability

Environment portal Category


Glossary Degrees Journals Research institutes

v t e

Environmental social science


Ecological anthropology Ecological economics Environmental anthropology Environmental economics Environmental communication Environmental history Environmental politics Environmental psychology Environmental sociology Human ecology Human geography Political ecology Regional science


Agroecology Anthrozoology Behavioral geography Community studies Demography Design

ecological environmental

Ecological humanities Economics

energy thermo


education ethics law science studies


botany ecology zoology

Forestry Industrial ecology Integrated geography Permaculture Rural sociology Science, technology and society

science studies


science studies

Systems ecology Urban

ecology geography metabolism studies



landscape sustainable

Ecopsychology Engineering

ecological environmental

Green criminology Health

environmental epidemiology occupational public


environmental fisheries forest natural resource waste


environmental land use regional spatial urban


energy environmental

Environment portal Category Concepts Degrees Journals Research institutes Scholars

v t e



Anthropocene Earth system governance Ecological modernization Environmental governance Environmentalism Global catastrophic risk Human impact on the environment Planetary boundaries Social sustainability Stewardship Sustainable development


Anthropization Anti-consumerism Earth Overshoot Day Ecological footprint Ethical Over-consumption Simple living Sustainability
advertising Sustainability
brand Sustainability
marketing myopia Sustainable Systemic change resistance Tragedy of the commons


Birth control Family planning Control Overpopulation Zero growth


Appropriate Environmental Sustainable


Biosecurity Biosphere Conservation biology Deep ecology Endangered species Holocene extinction Invasive species


Carbon footprint Climate change mitigation Conservation Descent Efficiency Emissions trading Fossil-fuel phase-out Peak oil Renewable Energy poverty


Forest gardening Local Permaculture Security Sustainable agriculture Sustainable fishery Urban horticulture


Conservation Crisis Efficiency Footprint Reclaimed


accounting Sustainability
measurement Sustainability
metrics and indices Sustainability
reporting Standards and certification Sustainable yield


Advertising Architecture Art Business City College programs Community Design Ecovillage Education for Sustainable Development Fashion Gardening Geopark Green marketing Industries Landscape architecture Living Low-impact development Sustainable market Organizations Packaging Practices Procurement Tourism Transport Urban drainage systems Urban infrastructure Urbanism


Environmental Fisheries Forest Materials Natural resource Planetary Waste


UN Conference on the Human Environment (Stockholm 1972) Brundtlandt Commission Report (1983) Our Common Future
Our Common Future
(1987) Earth Summit
Earth Summit
(1992) Rio Declaration on Environment and Development Agenda 21
Agenda 21
(1992) Convention on Biological Diversity
Convention on Biological Diversity
(1992) ICPD Programme of Action (1994) Earth Charter Lisbon Principles UN Millennium Declaration (2000) Earth Summit
Earth Summit
2002 (Rio+10, Johannesburg) United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development
United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development
(Rio+20, 2012) Sustainable Development Goals

Category Lists Outline Portal Science Studies Degrees

Authority control

GND: 40785