Key terms
- Abomination of desolation
- Antichrist
- Armageddon
- The Beast
- False prophet
- Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse
- Gog and Magog
- Great Apostasy
- Great Tribulation
- Katechon
- Kingdom of God
- Lake of fire
- Last Judgment
- Man of sin
- New Heaven and New Earth
- New Jerusalem
- Number of the Beast
American Christian radio host Harold Camping stated that the Rapture and Judgment Day would take place on May 21, 2011,[1][2] and that the end of the world would take place five months later on October 21, 2011.
Camping, who was then president of the Family Radio Christian network, claimed the Bible as his source and said May 21 would be the date of the Rapture and the day of judgment "beyond the shadow of a doubt".[3] Camping suggested that it would occur at 6 p.m. local time, with the Rapture sweeping the globe time zone by time zone,[4][5] while some of his supporters claimed that around 200 million people (approximately 3% of the world's population) would be 'raptured'.[6] Camping had previously claimed that the Rapture would occur in September 1994.
The vast majority of Christian groups, including most Protestant and Catholic believers, did not accept Camping's predictions;[7] some explicitly rejected them,[8][9][10][11] citing Bible passages including the words of Jesus stating "about that day or hour no one knows" (Matthew 24:36). An interview with a group of church leaders noted that all of them had scheduled church services as usual for Sunday, May 22.[12]
Following the failure of the prediction, media attention shifted to the response from Camping and his followers. On May 23, Camping stated that May 21 had been a "spiritual" day of judgment, and that the physical Rapture would occur on October 21, 2011, simultaneously with the destruction of the universe by God.[13][14] However, on October 16, Camping admitted to an interviewer that he did not know when the end would come,[15] and made no public comment after October 21 passed without his predicted apocalypse.[16]
In March 2012, Camping "humbly acknowledged" in a letter to Family Radio listeners that he had been mistaken, that the attempt to predict a date was "sinful", and that critics had been right in pointing to the scriptural text "of that day and hour knoweth no man". He added that he was searching the Bible "even more fervently [...] not to find dates, but to be more faithful in our understanding."[17]
Predictions
Camping's predictionsFamily Radio Christian network, claimed the Bible as his source and said May 21 would be the date of the Rapture and the day of judgment "beyond the shadow of a doubt".[3] Camping suggested that it would occur at 6 p.m. local time, with the Rapture sweeping the globe time zone by time zone,[4][5] while some of his supporters claimed that around 200 million people (approximately 3% of the world's population) would be 'raptured'.[6] Camping had previously claimed that the Rapture would occur in September 1994.
The vast majority of Christian groups, including most Protestant and Catholic believers, did not accept Camping's predictions;[7] some explicitly rejected them,[8][9][10][11] citing Bible passages including the words of Jesus stating "about that day or hour no one knows" (Matthew 24:36). An interview with a group of church leaders noted that all of them had scheduled church services as usual for Sunday, May 22.[12]
Following the failure of the prediction, media attention shifted to the response from Camping and his followers. On May 23, Camping stated that May 21 had been a "spiritual" day of judgment, and that the physical Rapture would occur on October 21, 2011, simultaneously with the destruction of the universe by God.[13][14] However, on October 16, Camping admitted to an interviewer that he did not know when the end would come,[15] and made no public comment after October 21 passed without his predicted apocalypse.[16]
In March 2012, Camping "humbly acknowledged" in a letter to Family Radio listeners that he had been mistaken, that the attempt to predict a date was "sinful", and that critics had been right in pointing to the scriptural text "of that day and hour knoweth no man". He added that he was searching the Bible "even more fervently [...] not to find dates, but to be more faithful in our understanding."[17]
Camping presented several arguments labeled "numerological" by the mainstream media,[24] which he considered biblical proofs, in favor of the May 21 end time. A civil engineer by training, Camping stated he had attempted to work out mathematically-based prophecies in the Bible for decades. In an interview with the San Francisco Chronicle he explained "... I was an engineer, I was very interested in the numbers. I'd wonder, 'Why did God put this number in, or that number in?' It was not a question of unbelief, it was a question of, 'There must be a reason for it.'"[25]
In 1970, Camping dated the Great Flood to 4990 BC.[26] Using this date, taking the statement in Genesis 7:4 ("Seven days from now I will send rain on the earth") to be a prediction of the end of the world, and combining it with 2 Peter 3:8 ("With the Lord a day is as a thousand years, and a thousand years are as a day"), Camping concluded that the end of the world would occur in 2011, 7000 years from 4990 BC.[6] Camping takes the 17th day of the second month mentioned in Genesis 7:11 to be May 21, and hence predicts the Rapture to occur on this date.[6]
Another argument[27] that Camping used in favor of the May 21 date is as follows:
- The number five equals "atonement", the number ten equals "completeness", and the number seventeen equals "heaven".
- The number of days (as calculated below) between April 1, 33 AD, and May 21, 2011 AD, is 722,500.
- Christ is believed by Camping to have hung on the cross on April 1, 33 AD. The time between April 1, 33 AD, and April 1, 2011, is 1,978 years.
- If 1,978 is multiplied by 365.2422 days (the number of days in a solar, as distinct from lunar, year), the result is 722,449.
- The time between April 1 and May 21 is 51 days.
- 51 added to 722,449 is 722,500.
- (5 × 10 × 17)2 or (atonement × completeness × heaven)2 also equals 722,500.
Camping said that 5 × 10 × 17 is telling us a "story from the time Christ made payment for our sins until we're completely saved."[25]
Camping was not precise about the timing of the event, saying that "maybe" we can know the hour.[28] He has suggested that "days" in the Bible refer to daylight hours particularly.[28] Another account said the "great earthquake" which signals the start of the Rapture would "start in the Pacific Rim at around the 6 pm local time hour, in each time zone."[29]
In Camping's book 1994?, self-published in 1992, he predicted that the End Times would come on 6 September 1994.[30] When the Rapture failed to occur on the appointed day, Camping said he had made a mathematical error.[31]
Criticism
Camping's rapture prediction, along with some of his other teachings and beliefs, sparked controversy in the Christian and secular Western worlds. His critics often quoted Bible verses (such as Matthew 24:36) they interpret as saying that the date of the end will never be known by anyone but God until it actually happens. However, Camping and his followers responded that this principle only applied during the "church age" or pre-Tribulation period and did not apply to the present day, citing other verses (such as 1 Thessalonians 5:1–5:5) in their rebuttal.[32]
In a 2001 pamphlet, Camping asserted that believers should "flee the church", resigning from any church they belong to, because the "Church Age" is over and the "Great Tribulation" has begun.[33] This assertion was controversial[34] and drew "a flurry of attacks".[33]
Edwin M. Yamauchi critiqued Camping's dating of the Flood when Camping first published his ideas in 1970.[26]
Criticism of the May 21 prediction ranged from serious critique to ridicule. Theology professor Matthew L. Skinner, writing at the Huffington Post, noted the "long history of failed speculation" about the End Times and cautioned that end-of-the-world talk can lead Christians to social passivity instead of "working for the world's redemption".[35] Some columnists mocked the prediction with humorous essays.[36][37] A group of Christians set up a website called "RaptureFail" with the stated intention of undermining "this embarrassment to the Body of Christ."[38]
Evolutionary biologist and atheist Richard Dawkins dismissed Camping's prediction, writing that "he will inevitably explain, on May 22, that there must have been some error in the calculation, the rapture is postponed to ... and please send more money to pay for updated billboards."[39] California Director of American Atheists Larry Hicock said that "Camping's well-intentioned rapture campaign is indicative of the problems with religion".[40]
Prediction for May 21, 2011
Information campaign
Great Flood to 4990 BC. [26] Using this date, taking the statement in Genesis 7:4 ("Seven days from now I will send rain on the earth") to be a prediction of the end of the world, and combining it with 2 Peter 3:8 ("With the Lord a day is as a thousand years, and a thousand years are as a day"), Camping concluded that the end of the world would occur in 2011, 7000 years from 4990 BC. [6] Camping takes the 17th day of the second month mentioned in Genesis 7:11 to be May 21, and hence predicts the Rapture to occur on this date. [6]
Another argument[27] that Camping used in favor of the May 21 date is as follows:
Camping said that 5 × 10 × 17 is telling us a "story from the time Christ made payment for our sins until we're completely saved."[25]
Camping was not precise about the timing of the event, saying that "maybe" we can know the hour.[28] He has suggested that "days" in the Bible refer to daylight hours particularly.[28] Another account said the "great earthquake" which signals the start of the Rapture would "start in the Pacific Rim at around the 6 pm local time hour, in each time zone."[29]
In Camping's book 1994?, self-published in 1992, he predicted that the End Times would come on 6 September 1994. Camping was not precise about the timing of the event, saying that "maybe" we can know the hour.[28] He has suggested that "days" in the Bible refer to daylight hours particularly.[28] Another account said the "great earthquake" which signals the start of the Rapture would "start in the Pacific Rim at around the 6 pm local time hour, in each time zone."[29]
In Camping's book 1994?, self-published in 1992, he predicted that the End Times would come on 6 September 1994.[30] When the Rapture failed to occur on the appointed day, Camping said he had made a mathematical error.[31]
Camping's rapture prediction, along with some of his other teachings and beliefs, sparked controversy in the Christian and secular Western worlds. His critics often quoted Bible verses (such as Matthew 24:36) they interpret as saying that the date of the end will never be known by anyone but God until it actually happens. However, Camping and his followers responded that this principle only applied during the "church age" or pre-Tribulation period and did not apply to the present day, citing other verses (such as 1 Thessalonians 5:1–5:5) in their rebuttal.[32]
In a 2001 pamphlet, Camping asserted that believers should "flee the church", resigning from any church they belong to, because the "Church Age" is over and the "Great Tribulation" has begun.[33] This assertion was controversial[34] and drew "a flurry of attacks".[33]
Edwin M. Yamauchi critiqued Camping's dating of the Flood when Camping first published his ideas in 1970.[26]
Criticism of the May 21 prediction ranged from serious critique to ridicule. Theology professor Matthew L. Skinner, writing at the Huffington Post, noted the "long history of failed speculation" about the End Times and cautioned that end-of-the-world In a 2001 pamphlet, Camping asserted that believers should "flee the church", resigning from any church they belong to, because the "Church Age" is over and the "Great Tribulation" has begun.[33] This assertion was controversial[34] and drew "a flurry of attacks".[33]
Edwin M. Yamauchi critiqued Camping's dating of the Flood when Camping first published his ideas in 1970.[26]
Criticism of the May 21 prediction ranged from serious critique to ridicule. Theology professor Matthew L. Skinner, writing at the Huffington Post, noted the "long history of failed speculation" about the End Times and cautioned that end-of-the-world talk can lead Christians to social passivity instead of "working for the world's redemption".[35] Some columnists mocked the prediction with humorous essays.[36][37] A group of Christians set up a website called "RaptureFail" with the stated intention of undermining "this embarrassment to the Body of Christ."[38]
Evolutionary biologist and atheist Richard Dawkins dismissed Camping's prediction, writing that "he will inevitably explain, on May 22, that there must have been some error in the calculation, the rapture is postponed to ... and please send more money to pay for updated billboards."[39] California Director of American Atheists Larry Hicock said that "Camping's well-intentioned rapture campaign is indicative of the problems with religion".[40]
In 2010, Marie Exley of Colorado Springs made news by purchasing advertising space in her locality, promoting the alleged Rapture date on a number of park benches.[41] After that, more than 3,000[42] "Judgment Day" billboards were erected in locations across the world, including the Dominican Republic, Ethiopia, Ghana, Indonesia, Israel, Jamaica, Jordan, Lebanon, Lesotho, the Philippines, Tanzania and the United States.[43][44] Some people adorned their vehicles with the information.[45] Many who believed in the prediction took time off work to prepare for the Rapture.[46] Others spent their life savings on advertising material to publicise the prophecy.[46] One retired transportation agency worker from New York spent $140,000 on advertising.[46]
Family Radio spent over US$100 million on the information campaign, financed by sales and swap of broadcast outlets.[47] On October 27, 2010, they launched "Project Caravan". Five recreational vehicles announcing on their sides that Judgment Day was to begin on May 21, 2011 were sent out from their headquarters in Oakland, California, to Seattle, Washington. Upon arrival, teams were sent out to distribute tracts.[48] The caravan subsequently made stops in many states in the U.S.[49][50] and Canada.[51][52]
Impact
Family Radio spent over US$100 million on the information campaign, financed by sales and swap of broadcast outlets.[47] On October 27, 2010, they launched "Project Caravan". Five recreational vehicles announcing on their sides that Judgment Day was to begin on May 21, 2011 were sent out from their headquarters in Oakland, California, to Seattle, Washington. Upon arrival, teams were sent out to distribute tracts.[48] The caravan subsequently made stops in many states in the U.S.[49][50] and Canada.[51][52]
Camping's prediction and his promotion of it via his radio network and other promotional means spread the prediction globally,[24] which led believers and non-believers to a variety of actions.[53] Some followers of Camping gave up their jobs, sold their homes, stopped investing in their children's college funds and spent large sums promoting Camping's claims.[54]
About 5,000[24] ethnic Hmong gathered at a remote town in Vietnam's [24] ethnic Hmong gathered at a remote town in Vietnam's Mường Nhé District in Điện Biên Province in early May, where they planned to await the arrival of Christ. The Vietnamese government broke up the gathering and arrested some people, describing them as "extremists".[55] Pastor Doan Trung Tin indicated that a translated version of Camping's prediction had influenced about 300 of his parishioners to go to the assembly point, selling their belongings to be able to afford the journey via bus.[56] Many of the Hmong Christians who escaped arrest were reportedly forced into hiding after the gathering.[57]
On May 19, 2011, the search term "end of the world may 21st" reached second position on Google Trends, based on the popularity of the search term in the United States. The related searches "Harold Camping", "May 21 doomsday", and "May 21 rapture" were also represented among the top 10 positions.[58] The New York Police Department stated: "We don't plan any additional coverage for the end of the world. Indeed, if it happens, fewer officers will be required for streets that presumably will be empty."[59]
On the weekend of May 21–22, the Family Radio headquarters was closed with a paper note in the window stating, "This office is closed. Sorry we missed you!"[60] The Family Radio network remained on the air during May 21 and May 22, mostly broadcasting its normal schedule of programming, but with no mention of the Rapture and without the usual replays of Harold Camping's program Open Forum.
On Sunday, May 22, Camping emerged briefly from his home, saying "Give me a day, no interviews today ... I've got to live with it, I've got to think it out."[61] He said he would make a public statement on Monday, May 23.[62][63] Camping said he was "flabbergasted" that the Rapture did not occur, that he was "looking for answers," and would say more when he returned to work on May 23.[64]On Sunday, May 22, Camping emerged briefly from his home, saying "Give me a day, no interviews today ... I've got to live with it, I've got to think it out."[61] He said he would make a public statement on Monday, May 23.[62][63] Camping said he was "flabbergasted" that the Rapture did not occur, that he was "looking for answers," and would say more when he returned to work on May 23.[64]
On May 23, he returned to his Open Forum radio program, with members of the press in attendance, and, departing from his typical format, took questions from the reporters present instead of from callers.[65] He stated that May 21 had been an "invisible judgment day" which was purely spiritual in nature, and that he now realized that the physical Rapture would take place on October 21, simultaneously with the destruction of the universe. "We've always said May 21 was the day, but we didn't understand altogether the spiritual meaning," he said. "May 21 is the day that Christ came and put the world under judgment."[13] He offered no apology for his earlier interpretation and said that all of his predictions had actually been fulfilled: on May 21, 1988, judgment came upon the churches; on September 7, 1994, judgment continued on the churches; then on May 21, 2011, judgment came upon the entire world.[65]
He said that the publicity campaign would not continue, explaining that since God's judgment had already occurred, there was no point in continuing to warn people about it.[66] He added, "We're not going to put up any more billboards – in fact they're coming down right now."[67] Responding to a question, Camping said his organization would not return money donated by followers to publicize the May 21 prediction, saying "We're not at the end. Why would we return it?"[68]
As October 21 approached, the Family Radio website stated:
What really happened (on May 21) is that God accomplished exactly what He wanted to happen. That was to warn the whole world that on May 21 God's salvation program would be finished on that day. For the next five months, except for the elect (the true believers), the whole world is under God's final judgment. To accomplish this goal God withheld from the true believers the way in which two phases were to be understood. Had He not done so, the world would never have been shaken in fear as it was.[69] A Family Radio staffer suggested that the delay might be God's way of separating true believers from those willing to doubt the "clear biblical warnings."[13]
A Family Radio staffer suggested that the delay might be God's way of separating true believers from those willing to doubt the "clear biblical warnings."[13]
Individual followers who had spent time and money promoting Camping's prediction were "crestfallen" after May 21 passed without evidence of the Rapture. A New York man commented "I was doing what I've been instructed to do through the Bible, but now I've been stymied. It's like getting slapped in the face."[66]
There were rumors that people had killed themselves or attempted suicide to escape the predicted Judgment Day.[70] There was one documented case, in which a 14-year-old Russian girl killed herself on May 21. Her family told a Russian tabloid, LifeNews, that she did it because of her fear of the "terrible sufferings" predicted by Camping;[71] however, police noted that the girl had been obsessed with death and threatening suicide since she was 12.[72]
Reaction from other Christians
A group of Christians in Milpitas, California, offered a session to comfort those who had believed in the prophecy. Church deacon James Bynum told a local newspaper that "We are here because we care about these people. It's easy to mock them. But yo There were rumors that people had killed themselves or attempted suicide to escape the predicted Judgment Day.[70] There was one documented case, in which a 14-year-old Russian girl killed herself on May 21. Her family told a Russian tabloid, LifeNews, that she did it because of her fear of the "terrible sufferings" predicted by Camping;[71] however, police noted that the girl had been obsessed with death and threatening suicide since she was 12.[72]
A group of Christians in Milpitas, California, offered a session to comfort those who had believed in the prophecy. Church deacon James Bynum told a local newspaper that "We are here because we care about these people. It's easy to mock them. But you can go kick puppies, too. But why?"[46]
Reaction from non-believers and protesters
No statement was issued by Camping or Family Radio on October 21 or 22.[16] It was later reported that Camping told an interviewer on October 16 that God has not given anyone the power to know exactly when the Rapture would come.[15] He retired from his leadership position at Family Radio.[15] Sometime after October 21, Family Radio posted an audio message from Harold Camping on their home page. In the message, Camping stated, regarding end times prophecy, that "we are finding it very very difficult". He also told followers to "not feel abandoned by God" and that "God is still in charge of everything".
As October 21 approached, the Freedom from Religion Foundation bought space on more than 40 billboards in the Bay Area to mock Camping's predictions and urge viewers to use rational judgment. The billbo As October 21 approached, the Freedom from Religion Foundation bought space on more than 40 billboards in the Bay Area to mock Camping's predictions and urge viewers to use rational judgment. The billboards featured slogans such as, "Fool me once...", "Still here", and "Every day is judgment day. Use yours. Use reason."[87]
Media reports on October 21 and 22 stressed that Camping had been "wrong again".[88][89] The International Business Times proclaimed him a "false prophet."[90] On October 21, 2011, Time magazine's website listed Camping's end times predictions as one of the "Top 10 Failed Predictions", a list compiled in Camping's "honor".[91]
Family Radio removed from its web site the archive of audio recordings of Camping's Open Forum program recorded prior to May 2011.[92]
On June 9, 2011, Camping suffered a stroke and was hospitalized.[93] Family Radio broadcast reruns of his May 23 – June 9 Open Forum segments for several weeks. As of June 23, Family Radio began to provide new programming in his time slot.On June 9, 2011, Camping suffered a stroke and was hospitalized.[93] Family Radio broadcast reruns of his May 23 – June 9 Open Forum segments for several weeks. As of June 23, Family Radio began to provide new programming in his time slot.[94]
Camping died on December 15, 2013 at the age of 92, as a result of complications from a fall at home two weeks earlier. His death was confirmed by an employee of the network.[95][96]
In September 2018, Family Radio announced it would no longer air programs featuring the voice of Harold Camping, and would no longer distribute literature of Camping's teachings. The decision was made as part of an effort to both move away from Camping's theology, and to reintroduce programs from outside ministries into the network's schedule. The changes went into effect on October 8, 2018.[97]
Camping's writings that detail the timing of the end include:
- Books
- 1994? (1992) – predicts the End Times for September 1994
- Time Has An End: A Biblical History of the World 11,013 B.C. - 2011 A.D. (2005)
References
- ^ "A Conversation With Harold Camping, Prophesier of Judgment Day". New York Magazine. May 11, 2011. Retrieved October 13, 2011.[108][109]
At the end of 2012, McCann began teaching the possibility that the last day would be October 7, 2015.[110] He said that there was "a strong likelihood that this will happen" and "an unlikely possibility that it will not".[110] He said that there was "a strong likelihood that this will happen" and "an unlikely possibility that it will not".[111]
This date was arrived at by adding 1,600 days (taken from Revelation 14:20) to May 21, 2011, which McCann still teaches is the beginning of the day of judgment. He noted that October 7, 2015 is last day of the Feast of Tabernacles, and exactly 10,000 days from May 21, 1988, which he claims is the date the Church Age came to an end.[112]
|
