"Who Said I Would" is a song performed by

Phil Collins Philip David Charles Collins (born 30 January 1951) is an English singer, musician, songwriter, record producer and actor. He was the drummer and lead singer of the rock band Genesis and also has a career as a solo performer. Between 1982 and ...

that was originally recorded for his 1985 album ''

No Jacket Required ''No Jacket Required'' is the third solo studio album by English drummer and singer-songwriter Phil Collins. It was originally released on 25 January 1985 or 18 February 1985 on Virgin Records, Virgin (UK and Ireland), Atlantic Records, Atlanti ...

'' but was released in 1991 as a single from his live album '' Serious Hits... Live!'' in the United States and Japan.

History

Collins originally wrote and recorded the song for the album, ''

''. The live version was released as the sole single from the '' Serious Hits... Live!'' album in the United States, reaching number 73 on the ''Billboard'' Hot 100. The original version was later remixed into the '' 12"ers'' album.

Music video

A music video of the original version was filmed, for the ''No Jacket Required'' home video. It featured Collins playing the song in a concert. The single version also had a music video, of Collins playing the song during his ''... But Seriously'' tour. Only the second video is available on Phil Collins' YouTube channel (and was uploaded here in 2018).

Charts

Credits

– lead vocals * Brad Cole – keyboards *

Daryl Stuermer Daryl Mark Stuermer (born November 27, 1952) is an American musician, songwriter, and producer best known for playing the guitar and bass for Genesis during live shows, and lead guitar for Phil Collins during most solo tours and albums. He has ...

– guitar *

Leland Sklar Leland Bruce Sklar (born May 28, 1947) is an American bassist and session musician. Sklar rose to prominence as a member of James Taylor's backing band, which coaleced into a group in its own right, The Section. This group of musicians so frequ ...

– bass *

Chester Thompson Chester Cortez Thompson (born December 11, 1948) is an American drummer best known for his tenures with Frank Zappa and The Mothers of Invention, Weather Report, Santana, the progressive rock band Genesis and Phil Collins as a solo artist. Thomp ...

– drums *

The Phenix Horns , originally known as the EWF Horns, were the main horn section for the band Earth, Wind & Fire. The horn section were composed of Don Myrick on saxophone, Louis "Lui Lui" Satterfield on trombone, Rahmlee Michael Davis on trumpet, and Michael ...

Don Myrick Donald Myrick (April 6, 1940 – July 30, 1993) was an American saxophonist. A member of The Phenix Horns, he is best known for his work with Earth, Wind & Fire and Phil Collins. He played alto, tenor, and soprano sax as a member of Earth, Wind ...

– saxophone, sax solo **

Louis Satterfield Louis Edward Satterfield (April 3, 1937 – September 27, 2004) was an American bassist and trombonist. Satterfield was a member of both The Pharaohs and the Phenix Horns. He also collaborated with prominent artists such as Earth, Wind & Fire, ...

– trombone ** Harry Kim and Rhamlee Michael Davis – trumpets *

Arnold McCuller Arnold McCuller (born August 26, 1950) is an American vocalist, songwriter, and record producer, born and raised in Cleveland, Ohio. He was active as a solo artist and session musician, but is perhaps best known for his work as a touring back-u ...

, Bridgette Bryant and Fred White – backing vocals

Original version (1985)

– vocals,

vocoder A vocoder (, a portmanteau of ''voice'' and ''encoder'') is a category of speech coding that analyzes and synthesizes the human voice signal for audio data compression, multiplexing, voice encryption or voice transformation. The vocoder was ...

Simmons drums Simmons is an electronic drum brand, which originally was a pioneering British manufacturer of electronic drums. Founded in 1978 by Dave Simmons, it supplied electronic kits from 1980 to 1994. The drums' distinctive, electronic sound can be foun ...

kalimba Mbira ( ) are a family of musical instruments, traditional to the Shona people of Zimbabwe. They consist of a wooden board (often fitted with a resonator) with attached staggered metal tines, played by holding the instrument in the hands and pl ...

, the "odd" keyboard * David Frank – keyboards, Minimoog bass *

– guitars *

Gary Barnacle Gary Barnacle (born 1959 in Dover, England) is an English saxophonist, flautist, brass instrument arranger, composer, and producer. Barnacle is primarily noted for his session work and live work, including various Prince's Trust concerts at Wem ...

– sax solo *

– saxophone **

– trombone **Rhamlee Michael Davis – trumpet **Michael Harris – trumpet

References

1991 singles Phil Collins songs Songs written by Phil Collins Song recordings produced by Hugh Padgham 1990 songs Atlantic Records singles Virgin Records singles Warner Music Group singles Song recordings produced by Phil Collins 1985 songs Live singles {{1990s-single-stub