Plot
The film opens to a shot of a large polluting factory which appears to be outdated. A local resident details how members of his village are saddened by the transformation and pollution of their home. Government officials and wealthy businessmen have forced their village to be home to several polluting plants, including the largest Jiucailuo Chemical. Local environmental advocates, Green Anhui interview local residents about environmental impact. They identify that while everyone wants a cleaner environment, no one wants to be the first to act. Local residents experience high rates of cancer and local grains must be grown in polluted fields. Fish populations have diminished because of polluted waterways. Residents claim local officials and inspectors are bribed or intentionally mislead during inspections including by shutting down production, releasing clean water before inspections, covering up pollution sites, and releasing pollution during nighttime hours. Village heads are receiving funds from company executives and this has led to hesitation among local residents to speak up. Some residences have filed legal suits against the chemical companies, however, they have failed. Most residents do not know how to read and write and lack the funds to bring forward any serious suit. One resident identified as Zhang Gongli has taught himself Chinese law and sued in 2004 and 2005 and lost both times. 40 local school children wrote to the environmental protection bureau and made national headlines when their essays were published in the papers. Officials then ordered plants to clean their waste before resuming production. While environmental laws exist in China, most of their enforcement is left to local agencies, meaning that they are poorly enforced. Residents claim alerting inspection officers can lead to their own arrest. Village elders gather residents to sign petitions for the relocation of the plants. 1801 out of 1876 residents sign the petition. During the circulation of the petition, death threats were made against leaders in the community. However, these petitions still failed at the local level. Zhang and a member of Green Anhui venture to Beijing to file a petition with national officials. While in Beijing we hear from other local villagers who are subject to the same threats and legal failures as Zhang. After returning, we learn that Zhang's trip has increased pressure from Beijing and a local chemical plant representative promises that the factory's ways are changing and new parts are on the way. Zhang still continued to find other violations. However, the local government is seen giving full permissions to the factory to begin production, leading to another protest and altercation. The villages remained steadfast to their movement and in 2008 TV crews and journalists publicized the factory's wrongdoings. Water and power are shut off to the plants and Jiucailuo Chemical is forced to relocate to an industrial park. While the environment has recovered, still long-lasting effects remain. Each villager plans to sue Jiucailuo Chemical to clean up their mess.Production Members
Background
Over the last few decades, China's pollution has been a major global concern. This film focuses solely on environmental pollution in a single village and the devastating effects it has had on the local populous. The documentary was made over a period of three years from 2007-2010. A small pesticide factory first moved to Qiugang in the 1970s and was state-owned. Privately owned chemical plants appeared in Qiugang in 2004 to produce pesticides and dyes. One such chemical isThemes
Environmental Activism- Even when facing death threats and experiencing vandalism Zhang and the rest of the villagers remained steadfast thin their fight against pollution. Of course, getting to this step was not easy. No one in the village wanted to be the first to act. That person would be subject to arrest and harassment. Zhang was fortunate to have an education up to the middle school level because unlike so many others he is able to write and file suits. His suits did fail, but gained support and opened up possibilities for the residents. Aside from education, financial flexibility is another important, but unfortunate necessity for activism. Zhang sacrificed time and money in his cases, he traveled to Beijing and took the time to learn the environmental laws of China. For most, it is necessary to hire lawyers who charge premium rates. This is most likely why plants take advantage of small rural villages that cannot defend themselves (legally or physically). Corruption- As seen in the documentary, environmental laws are enforced at the local level. This means that excessive pollution and failures to comply with the law can be overlooked with bribes. We saw village leaders receive money from executives, which likely caused them not to raise alarm. Economic Incentive- Nations must allow for growth and economical activities. Without an expanding economy, there is poverty and the nation would be at a dead end. However, nations must protect their own citizens. Allowing economic expansions at the health and lives of its citizens isn't beneficial either. Therefore there must be a balance between these interests. How these balances are determined and enforced must be carefully inspected as nations typically favor greed and production over the wellbeing of their citizens, especially rural, poor citizens. In the film, we see the government allow pollution or turn a blind eye to it because stopping it would "hurt the economy." In this case, the local government has chosen capital gain over the well being of its citizens. This is fully on display when villagers are threatened to be arrested (by the government) for pointing out pollutant problems to inspectors. We also see villagers beaten and harassed by local officials when they protest the plant because these officials value chemical production over the wellbeing of the villagers.References
External links