So Why So Sad

"So Why So Sad" is a song by Welsh rock band Manic Street Preachers, jointly released in February 2001 as the first single from their sixth studio album, '' Know Your Enemy'' (2001), alongside "Found That Soul". All three members of the band—James Dean Bradfield, Sean Moore and Nicky Wire—share the writing credits. The song reached number eight on the UK Singles Chart, one place above "Found That Soul".

Background

The song includes the line "burns an expressway to your skull", a reference to the final track on Sonic Youth's ''EVOL'' album and a Buddy Miles song. The song deals mainly with the paradoxical high rates of depression and anxiety experienced by those living in affluence and comfort. It has also been suggested that a reference to the Dead Sea scrolls and the line "dependent on above" imply that there is a religious connection, but there's no further support for this outside the chorus. The single version is shorter, with the phrase "So Why, So Why So Sad?" sung only three times instead of four at the end and the drums finish two bars earlier without a fill.

'' Exclaim! Canada'' called the track "an outstanding pop song" with a production style "scarily similar" to the Beach Boys. It was the only single from ''Know Your Enemy'' to be included on the 2002 compilation ''Forever Delayed'', appearing as an edited version.

Release

The CD version of "So Why So Sad" includes versions of "Pedestal" and a remix of "So Why So Sad" by Australian outfit the Avalanches, whereas the cassette single includes a live version of "You Stole the Sun from My Heart". Issued on 26 February 2001, the same day as "Found That Soul", "So Why So Sad" was Manic Street Preachers' first hit since " The Masses Against the Classes" 13 months earlier.

The single reached number eight on the UK Singles Chart on 10 March 2001. Spending 16 weeks on the chart, it is the second-longest charting Manic Street Preachers single in the UK, after "If You Tolerate This Your Children Will Be Next", which spent 17 weeks on the chart. In Ireland, it peaked at number 16. In Finland, the single reached number four on the Finnish Singles Chart, spending three weeks on the ranking. In Sweden, it reached number 26, while in the Netherlands, it peaked at number 88. In Germany, it reached number 94.

Track listings

All tracks were written and composed by Nick Jones, James Dean Bradfield and Sean Moore.

UK CD single
# "So Why So Sad" – 3:55
# "So Why So Sad" (Sean Penn mix—Avalanches) – 4:58
# "Pedestal" – 4:50

UK cassette single
# "So Why So Sad" – 4:02
# "You Stole the Sun from My Heart" (live at Millennium Stadium, 31 December 1999) – 4:25

European CD single
# "So Why So Sad" – 3:55
# "So Why So Sad" (Sean Penn mix—Avalanches) – 4:58

Australian CD single
# "So Why So Sad" – 3:55
# "So Why So Sad" (Sean Penn mix—Avalanches) – 4:58
# "Pedestal" – 4:50
# "You Stole the Sun from My Heart" (live at Millennium Stadium, 31 December 1999) – 4:25

Charts

Release history

References

{{Authority control

2000 songs
2001 singles
Epic Records singles
Manic Street Preachers songs
Song recordings produced by Dave Eringa
Songs written by James Dean Bradfield
Songs written by Nicky Wire
Songs written by Sean Moore (musician)