School of Resentment

''The Western Canon: The Books and School of the Ages'' is a 1994 book about Western literature by the American literary critic Harold Bloom, in which the author defends the concept of the Western canon by discussing 26 writers whom he sees as central to the canon.

Summary

Bloom argues against what he calls the "school of resentment", which includes feminist literary criticism, Marxist literary criticism, Lacanians, New Historicism, Deconstructionists, and semioticians. ''The Western Canon'' includes four appendices listing works that Bloom at the time considered canonical, stretching from earliest scriptures to Tony Kushner's ''Angels in America''. Bloom later disowned the list, saying that it was written at his editor's insistence and distracted from the book's intention.

Bloom defends the concept of the Western canon by discussing 26 writers whom he sees as central to the canon:

# William Shakespeare
# Dante Alighieri
# Geoffrey Chaucer
# Miguel de Cervantes
# Michel de Montaigne
# Molière
# John Milton
# Samuel Johnson
# Johann Wolfgang von Goethe
# William Wordsworth
# Jane Austen
# Walt Whitman
# Emily Dickinson
# Charles Dickens
# George Eliot
# Leo Tolstoy
# Henrik Ibsen
# Sigmund Freud
# Marcel Proust
# James Joyce
# Virginia Woolf
# Franz Kafka
# Jorge Luis Borges
# Pablo Neruda
# Fernando Pessoa
# Samuel Beckett

Reception

Norman Fruman of ''The New York Times'' wrote that "''The Western Canon'' is a heroically brave, formidably learned and often unbearably sad response to the present state of the humanities."

The novelist A. S. Byatt wrote:
Piotr Wilczek and criticized Bloom's for narrow interpretation of the concept of the West, ignoring works from with which countries he was not familiar, such as Poland, which are significantly underrepresented in his scheme. They interpret his list as dominated by British and American culture, with a small dose of ancient Western classics and a few non-English works from other Western European countries. At the same time, they concur that such a group is pretty standard for the Western canon as understood by most Western European scholars.

School of resentment

"School of resentment" is a pejorative term coined by Bloom and expounded upon in his work. It is used to describe related schools of literary criticism that have gained prominence in academia since the 1970s and which Bloom contended are preoccupied with political and social activism at the expense of aesthetic values. Broadly, what Bloom termed "schools of resentment" approaches associate with Marxist critical theory, including African-American studies, Marxist literary criticism, New Historicist criticism, feminist criticism and post-structuralism—specifically as promoted by Jacques Lacan, Jacques Derrida and Michel Foucault. The "school of resentment" is usually defined as comprising all scholars who wish to enlarge the ''Western Canon'' by adding to it more works by authors from minority groups without regard to aesthetic merit and/or influence over time, or those who argue that some works commonly thought canonical promote sexist, racist or otherwise biased values and should therefore be removed from the canon. Bloom contended that the school of resentment threatens the nature of the canon itself and may lead to its eventual demise.

Philosopher Richard Rorty agreed that Bloom is at least partly accurate in his description of the "school of resentment", writing that those identified by Bloom do in fact routinely use "subversive, oppositional discourse" to attack the canon specifically and Western culture in general. Yet "this school deserves to be taken seriously—more seriously than Bloom's trivialization of it as mere resentment."''Shifting the Scene: Shakespeare in European Culture'', edited by Ladina Bezzola Lambert.

See also

* ''Ressentiment''

References

External links

Harold Bloom's canonical list

{{DEFAULTSORT:Western Canon, The
1994 non-fiction books
Books about books
Books by Harold Bloom
English-language books
Harcourt (publisher) books
Lists of books