Background and recording
Vocalist Frances Quinlan stated that much of the album was tracked live.Composition
Musical style
Pitchfork likened the album's style to the "romantic, middle-American indie" of artists such as Bright Eyes (band), Bright Eyes and Rilo Kiley, while crediting punk rock for the band's "energy".Lyrical content
The album's lyrical subject matter addresses topics such as poverty, abuse and mental illness. The album's seventh track "Powerful Man" is based on an experience Quinlan had as a teenager, where they claim to have witnessed a young child being physically abused by their father. Quinlan admitted that the track was the first time they had felt uneasy about sharing lyrics, due to their personal nature.Critical reception
Allmusic awarded the album four-and-a-half stars, directing praise towards Frances Quinlan's vocal performance. In 2017, ''Spin (magazine), Spin'' ranked ''Painted Shut'' #6 on their list of the emo revival's best albums. The site's Leor Galil saw it as the record where Hop Along "focused their frisson and aimed it towards pop music, pop", resulting in "hits only they could create."Accolades
Track listing
Charts
References
{{Authority control 2015 albums Albums produced by John Agnello Hop Along albums Saddle Creek Records albums