Open Veins of Latin America

''Open Veins of Latin America: Five Centuries of the Pillage of a Continent'' (in es, Las venas abiertas de América Latina) is a book written by Uruguayan journalist, writer, and poet Eduardo Galeano, published in 1971, that consists of an analysis of the impact that European settlement, imperialism, and slavery have had in Latin America.

The book was published during the ideological divide caused by the Cold War, when most of Latin American countries had brutal, right-wing dictatorships. ''Open Veins'' was banned in several countries and quickly became a bible for an entire generation of left-wing thinkers.

In the book, Galeano analyzes the history of the Americas as a whole, from the time period of the European settlement of the New World to contemporary Latin America, describing the effects of European and later United States economic exploitation and political dominance over the region. Throughout the book, Galeano analyses notions of colonialism, imperialism, and the dependency theory.

''Open Veins'' illustrates Latin America's resistance literature of the twentieth century, characterized by opposition to imperialism and a heightened Pan-American sentiment. The book has sold over a million copies and been translated into over a dozen languages. It has been included in university courses "ranging from history and anthropology to economics and geography."

Background

Before gaining international recognition for ''Open Veins of Latin America'', Galeano was a commentator on social and political issues, journalist, novelist, essayist, historian, and also a writer of children’s literature.

His work encompasses a wide array of literary genres, including journalism, political analysis, documentaries, fiction, and history. When questioned about the latter, Galeano stated that he does not identify as a historian. "I am a writer who would like to contribute to the rescue of the kidnapped memory of all America,” Galeano defended, “but especially of Latin America, a despised and endearing land."

Galeano wrote ''Open Veins of Latin America'' in the context of the 1970s, when right-wing, US-sponsored dictatorships were ruling in the majority of Latin American countries. At the time, Galeano was working in Uruguay as an independent journalist and editor, and in the publishing department of the University of the Republic. He said, "It took four years of researching and collecting the information I needed, and some 90 nights to write the book".

Historical context

The publication of ''Open Veins'' in 1971 arrived amid a fast process of militarization that had deep consequences in Latin America between the 1960s and 1970s. This period in Latin America’s history continues to influence the political, social, and economic transformations the region has experienced in the last five decades.

Such a process of militarization manifested in the shape of military coups, which were commonplace in the region during the 1960s. Although some Latin American countries, such as Argentina and Brazil, previously had complex histories of military dictatorships, this time period was characterized by regional integration and an expansive character of repression. Latin American dictatorships were aligned under the anti-Soviet, anti-communist National Security doctrine promoted by the United States during the Cold War.

The integration of Latin America’s military dictatorships occurred through international programs, such as Operation Condor, that sought to eradicate from the region all influences from the left, communism, and revolutionary utopianism. This integration led to widespread violence and repression, and a massive effort to “destroy, torture, and make disappear” the ideological left from Latin American politics.

Plot summary

Structure

''Open Veins of Latin America'' has a foreword written by Chilean writer Isabel Allende, followed by a preface by Galeano titled “In Defense of the Word” and a series of acknowledgments. The book has an introduction titled “120 Million Children in the Eye of the Hurricane,” and it is then divided into three parts: “Part I: Mankind’s poverty as a consequence of the wealth of the land;” “Part II: Development is a voyage with more shipwrecks than navigators;” and “Part III: Seven Years After.”

Each of the first two parts has subcategories. Part I is divided into “Lust for Gold, Lust for Silver,” “King Sugar and Other Agricultural Monarchs,” and “The Invisible Sources of Power.” Part II is divided into “Tales of Premature Death” and “The Contemporary Structure of Plunder.” Lastly, Part III is considered to be the conclusion of the book, and it was written seven years later and annexed to future editions.

Summary

In the book, Galeano discusses topics such as the exploitation of natural resources, poverty in Latin America, and the “exportation” of wealth to Europe. He argues that the transfer of such wealth solidified capitalism and, consequently, the development of Europe and the United States.

The book also discusses the progress indigenous communities had achieved by the time the colonizers arrived and seeks to explain why the West, which Galeano refers to as the “North,” is developed whereas the Global South remains underdeveloped. Galeano also criticizes the corruption of the “creole oligarchy,” which refers to the political system in which the distribution of power is concentrated among a few people, often belonging to privileged families from the colonial period. Galeano claims that Latin America’s oligarchy is controlled by foreign powers and has contributed to perpetuating the exploitation of the region.

''Open Veins'' begins with the time of European settlement of the Americas. Galeano narrates how the men of Spanish Conquistador Hernán Cortés destroyed the city of Tenochtitlan, capital of the Mexica Empire, and how Spanish Conquistador Francisco Pizarro, after receiving a ransom equivalent to two rooms filled with gold and silver to free Inca emperor Atahualpa, still decided to kill him. Galeano also discusses how the sugar cane brought by the Spaniards destroyed the ecological landscape of considerable areas of Brazil and the Caribbean. As a whole, Part I of the book focuses on Latin America’s natural resources and how their exploitation generated wealth for the Europeans while exacerbating poverty for Latin Americans. In this section Galeano also emphasizes the suffering European settlement meant for indigenous communities, who were dispossessed of their land, enslaved, and killed.

In Part II, Galeano explains the origin of Colombia’s lengthy armed conflict, driven by the wealth generated by land exploitation and coffee production, and how the ambitions of the American United Fruit Company ignited the Guatemalan Civil War. He also explains the history of violence in Mexico, beginning with the US’s occupation of half its territory in 1848. Throughout this part, Galeano continues to narrate tragic historical events encouraged by the United States and corporations that have led to war, poverty, and suffering. Galeano also explains how foreign companies had as an objective the weakening of Latin American states in order to get access to their resources. He criticizes capitalism and its institutions, including the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

Lastly, in Part III, written 7 years later, Galeano summarizes the events that had taken place since the publication of the book. He argues that the events discussed in the second part of the book continue to happen and that the US continues to dominate the region. He concludes by stating that Latin America’s situation has continued to worsen.

Themes

Colonialism

Galeano discusses colonialism in terms of the negative consequences it had in Latin America. He argues that colonialism gave entry to violent capitalism, which, in turn, brought discrimination, exploitation of natural resources, and oppression.

Imperialism

Colonialism transforming into imperialistic exploitation is an important theme of the book: “It is Latin America, the region of open veins. From the discovery to the present day, everything has always been transmuted into European capital or, later, North American capital, and as such it has accumulated and accumulates in the distant centers of power.”

Dependency theory

The Dependency theory is at the core of ''Open Veins'', which argues that the underdeveloped status of the Global South is not a natural state but rather the result of the economic exploitation of such a region by the developed countries in the North.

Dependency theory opposes Modernization theory, which proposes that differentiation, specialized institutions, and certain societal values are necessary for countries to develop. This theory assumes that the pattern of modernization that developed countries took was the correct one, encouraging developing countries to follow in the footsteps of the North.Olstein, Diego. "LATIN AMERICA IN GLOBAL HISTORY: AN HISTORIOGRAPHIC OVERVIEW." ''Estudos Históricos'', vol. 30, no. 60, 2017, pp. 253-272''.'' While the Modernization theory considers solely internal factors affecting society, the Dependency theory takes into account both internal factors and the role such a society plays in the global context.

''Open Veins'' discusses Dependency theory by arguing that Latin America, since colonial times, has been looted by Europe and then by the United States, which explains why Latin America remains underdeveloped. Galeano argued that Latin America was not an example of underdevelopment due to lack of modernization but rather a victim of Europe’s and the US’s exploitation. “We lost; others won. But it happens that those who won, won because we lost,” Galeano stated.

Genre

Latin American Resistance Literature

Latin America has a long history of expressing its culture of resistance through various means; for instance, during colonization, oral tradition allowed indigenous communities to share their dissent. Since the nineteenth century, this attitude of resistance found its expression through writers who were vocal opponents of imperialist forms of power.Arango-Ramos, Fanny D. "Resistance Literature in Spanish America." ''Concise Encyclopedia of Latin American Literature'', edited by Verity Smith, Routledge, 1st edition, 2000.

In the twentieth century, this notion was coupled with an increased Pan-American sentiment and led to detailed literature analyzing Latin America’s resistance culture. A common theme among this body of work was the idea of a fragmented Latin American society as a consequence of oppression and violence. ''Open Veins'' exemplifies Latin America’s resistance literature of the twentieth century.

Reception

Shortly after the publication of ''Open Veins'', the book quickly gained popularity throughout developed countries, but for its left-wing perspective the book was banned under the right-wing military governments of Brazil, Chile, Argentina and Uruguay.

Since its publication in the early 1970s, ''Open Veins'' has been taught extensively in American universities, including in geography, economics, history, and anthropology courses. However, Galeano’s controversial comments criticizing his own book pose a challenge to scholars who teach the book in their classes.

In 2014, at an event in Brazil honoring Galeano on the 43rd anniversary of the book's publication, Galeano said he no longer felt connected to ''Open Veins''. He said he was not sorry he had written it, but that he lacked the knowledge to write a book on political economy at the time. He also criticized the book's prose as "extremely boring". This was interpreted as a renunciation of the book.

These statements garnered different reactions. opponents of the book saw it as proof of the book’s inaccuracy and used it to validate their position. Carlos Alberto Montaner, exiled Cuban writer, answered with a text called: “Galeano Corrects Himself and the Idiots Lose their Bible.” Conversely, supporters have argued that the book is an “independent entity” and that the author’s opinion has little impact on the relevance of the book; others claimed that Galeano, considering that he was dealing with cancer and recovering from a heart attack, was mentally impaired.

''Open Veins'' has been commonly known as the “Idiot’s Bible” among its opponents and those defending free-market policies.O'Grady, Mary A. "Americas: The Idiot's Bible." ''Wall Street Journal'', Apr 28, 2009, pp. 14''.'' Such a nickname stems from the publication of '' Guide to the Perfect Latin American Idiot'', a 1996 bestseller written by authors Álvaro Vargas Llosa, Carlos Alberto Montaner, and Plinio Apuleyo Mendoza. The book has an entire chapter on the importance of ''Open Veins'' for the “Latin America idiot”.Guide to the Perfect Latin American Idiot
Amazon.com. Retrieved 2020-12-09 It reads:

“For the past quarter-century, the Latin American idiot has had the notable advantage of having at his disposal a kind of sacred text, a bible filled with all the nonsense that circulates in the cultural atmosphere that the Brazilians call the 'festive left.' Naturally, we refer to Open Veins of Latin America."

The ''Library Journal'' review stated, "Well written and passionately stated, this is an intellectually honest and valuable study."

Cultural and political significance

In his analysis of the impact of ''Open Veins'', Director of Georgetown University’s Center for Latin American Studies, Marc Chernik, stated that Eduardo Galeano’s worldview in the book has had transformational consequences for an entire generation of intellectuals, students, and politicians. One consequence was the rise of a new approach to marginalized communities, who were no longer perceived as “underdeveloped” regions but rather as areas that were striving to overcome the negative impact colonization and imperialism had in the subcontinent. This argument, later known as the Dependency theory, was presented by several authors but it was Galeano who shared the idea with the entire region.

Mexican author Elena Poniatowska, winner of the 2013 Miguel de Cervantes Prize, said in an interview with BBC that what Galeano did in ''Open Veins'' had never been done before. "He gathered thousands of the most forgotten voices of Latin America," Poniatowska stated. Similarly, Jorge Volpi, another Mexican author, argued that ''Open Veins'' is one of the most influential texts written in Latin America during the twentieth-century and that "it opened the eyes of many young writers and political activists regarding the exploitation of this atin Americapart of the world."

''Open Veins'' also was and continues to be part of the battle of ideas that initiated during the Cold War, by becoming a symbol of opposition to the intervention of the United States and other foreign powers in Latin American affairs.

In the foreword to the 1997 edition, Isabel Allende stated that "after the military coup of 1973 I could not take much with me: some clothes, family pictures, a small bag of dirt from my garden, and two books: an old edition of the ''Odes'' by Pablo Neruda and the book with the yellow cover, ''Las venas abiertas de América Latina''".Allende, Isabel. Foreword. Open Veins of Latin America: Five Centuries of the Pillage of a Continent by Allende claims that the 1973 Military Coup against her uncle and leftist Chilean president Salvador Allende that gave rise to the long dictatorship of Augusto Pinochet could have been predicted based on ''Open Veins''. The book, she argues, was proof that "no safe islands" existed in Latin America and that the government of Salvador Allende was “doomed from the beginning.”

Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez gave United States President Barack Obama a Spanish copy of ''Open Veins of Latin America'' as a gift at the 5th Summit of the Americas in 2009, as an attempt to reinvigorate the argument of the book. As a result of this international exposure, the book's sales rose sharply—it was the 54,295th most popular book on Amazon.com before the event, but it became second a day later. In the opinion of El Espectador the core ideas of ''Open Veins'' have not been able to retake the central position they once had in Latin American discussions of political economy and development.

In the environmental context, some have argued that the continued exploitation of land for the benefit of a few demonstrates that the book remains relevant.Díaz, Reinaldo G., and Libia Gómez Esperanza Nieto. "Editorial." ''Revista De Investigación Agraria y Ambiental'', vol. 6, no. 2, 2015, pp. 10–15. This argument is based on the first part of the book, "Mankind’s poverty as a consequence of the wealth of the land."

Moreover, Galeano’s 2014 renunciation to the book did not diminish the role it played in creating awareness about the inequality between the Global North-Global South interactions; scholars have argued that ''Open Veins'' had a part in encouraging movements of integration in the South, including the formation of MERCOSUR.

''Open Veins'' has also inspired numerous works of art and musical compositions. Among them: The Latin American Memorial in São Paulo, Brazil, an art assemblage by artist Oscar Nemieyer from which a large sculpture of a left hand bleeding, representing the “open veins of Latin America,” stands out; and the song ''Las venas abiertas de América Latina'' by composer Caio Facó, which touches upon the thematics of colonization in the cultural sphere.

References

External links

Book Profile
'' Monthly Review Press''

{{Eduardo Galeano

1971 non-fiction books
1971 essays
Uruguayan essays
Spanish-language books
Eduardo Galeano