Critical reception
Billy Dukes of ''Taste of Country'' gave the song three stars out of five, writing that "McGraw certainly sounds refreshed on this new song from a new record label partner, but much like songs late in his career with Curb, it feels like an attempt is made to make every moment a huge moment." Matt Bjorke of ''Roughstock'' gave the song four stars out of five, calling it "a sweet little song with one of McGraw's most engaging vocals and a well-produced backing track." Ben Foster of ''Country Universe'' gave the song a C grade, saying that "a better hook could have compensated to some extent for the generally uninspiring lyrical content, but the way it is, there’s precious little for the listener to grab onto."Music video
The music video was directed by Sherman Halsey and premiered in December 2012. It depicts the process of making a music video, and is McGraw's final video to be directed by Halsey before his death in 2013.Chart performance
"One of Those Nights" debuted at number 29 on the U.S. ''Billboard (magazine), Billboard'' Hot Country Songs chart for the week of November 17, 2012. It also debuted at number 96 on the U.S. ''Billboard'' Hot 100 chart for the week of December 15, 2012. It also debuted at number 77 on the Canadian Hot 100 chart for the week of November 17, 2012. On the chart dated March 9, 2013, it became McGraw's first number one since "Felt Good on My Lips" in January 2011.Year-end charts
Certifications
References
{{Tim McGraw singles 2012 singles 2012 songs Tim McGraw songs Songs written by Luke Laird Songs written by Rodney Clawson Songs written by Chris Tompkins Song recordings produced by Byron Gallimore Song recordings produced by Tim McGraw Music videos directed by Sherman Halsey Country ballads Big Machine Records singles