Michelangelo phenomenon
   HOME

TheInfoList



OR:

The Michelangelo phenomenon is an interpersonal process observed by psychologists in which close, romantic partners influence or 'sculpt' each other. Over time, the Michelangelo effect causes individuals to develop towards what they consider their "ideal selves". This happens because their partner sees them and acts around them in ways that promote this ideal. The phenomenon is referred to in contemporary
marital therapy Couples therapy (also couples' counseling, marriage counseling, or marriage therapy) attempts to improve romantic relationships and resolve interpersonal conflicts. History Marriage counseling originated in Germany in the 1920s as part of the eu ...
. Recent popular work in couples therapy and conflict resolution points to the importance of the Michelangelo phenomenon. Diana Kirschner reported that the phenomenon was common among couples reporting high levels of marital satisfaction. It is the opposite of the Blueberry phenomenon "in which interdependent individuals bring out the worst in each other." The Michelangelo phenomenon is related to the
looking-glass self The term ''looking-glass self'' was created by American sociologist Charles Horton Cooley in 1902, and introduced into his work ''Human Nature and the Social Order''. It is described as our reflection of how we think we appear to others. Cooley ...
concept introduced by
Charles Horton Cooley Charles Horton Cooley (August 17, 1864 – May 7, 1929) was an American sociologist and the son of Michigan Supreme Court Judge Thomas M. Cooley. He studied and went on to teach economics and sociology at the University of Michigan, was a foundi ...
in his 1902 work ''Human Nature and the Social Order''.


Description


The model

The Michelangelo phenomenon describes a three-step confirmation process in which an individual affirms their partner's ideal self and thereby helps move them towards their ideal self. # An individual sees their partner as the partner's own ideal self # The individual behaves around their partner in a way that elicits qualities in the partner they themselves consider ideal # This leads to the partner moving towards and realising their ideal self The model posits a close romantic partner rather than a friend or acquaintance because they are "especially likely to yield strong confirmation effects."


Partner affirmation

A couple of concepts are understood to constitute the Michelangelo phenomenon. The model relies on behavioural confirmation as the principle force that shapes the self. In interdependent relationships, behavioural confirmation takes place when the ideas and expectations an individual has of their partner come to be realised in the partner because of the individual's behaviour. The Michelangelo phenomenon requires that individuals see their partner as their partner's self-conceived ideal. This entails ''partner perceptual affirmation'', or the degree to which an individual's perception of their partner corresponds with their partner's ideal self. It also requires ''partner behavioural affirmation'' which refers to whether the behaviour of an individual brings out qualities in their partner that the partner themselves see as ideal. Both perceptual and behavioural aspects of partner affirmation can take place consciously or unconsciously. For example, someone with a partner who wants to be more sociable may consciously encourage them to spend more time with their friends, in an effort to help them meet this goal. This is conscious behavioural affirmation. On the other hand, knowing that sociability is a goal of their partner, someone may feel less apprehension when organising a social gathering in their space. This would inadvertently give the partner an opportunity to socialise and is an example of unconscious behavioural affirmation.


Movement towards the ideal self

According to the Michelangelo phenomenon, affirmation from a partner helps individuals move towards their ideal self. Stephen Drigotas (''et al.'') uses insights from
interdependence theory Interdependence theory is a social exchange theory that states that interpersonal relationships are defined through interpersonal interdependence, which is "the process by which interacting people influence one another's experiences"Van Lange, P.A ...
to explain how partner affirmation leads to movement towards the ideal self. An affirming partner may shape someone through a series of selection mechanisms: * ''Retroactive selection'' in which an individual reinforces behaviours of their partner by punishing or rewarding them * ''Preemptive selection'' wherein an individual initiates an interaction that promotes certain behaviours in their partner * ''Situation selection'' where an individual creates a situation in which the elicitation of desired partner behaviours is probable


Partner disaffirmation and movement away from the ideal self

It is also possible for the inverse of the Michelangelo phenomenon to take place. A partner may in fact disaffirm their partner's ideal self and in doing so facilitate a movement away from their ideal self. An individual may disaffirm their partner "by communicating indifference, pessimism, or disapproval, by undermining heirideal pursuits, or by affirming qualities that are antithetical to heirideal self." This disaffirmation may occur passively, in the failure to affirm, or actively, in disaffirmation.


The metaphor

The phenomenon is named after the
Italian Renaissance The Italian Renaissance ( it, Rinascimento ) was a period in Italian history covering the 15th and 16th centuries. The period is known for the initial development of the broader Renaissance culture that spread across Europe and marked the trans ...
painter, sculptor, architect, poet and engineer Michelangelo (1475-1564). Michelangelo "described sculpting as a process whereby the artist released a hidden figure from the block of stone in which it slumbered." The metaphor of chipping away at a block of stone to reveal the 'ideal form', which extends to close relationships. According to the Michelangelo phenomenon, a person will be 'sculpted' into their self-conceived ideal form by their partner. The metaphor and term was first introduced by the US psychologist Stephen Michael Drigotas (''et al.'') in 1999.


Personal and couple well-being

Evidence suggests the Michelangelo phenomenon is conducive to both personal well-being and the well-being of relationships. The increased personal well-being is believed to be due to individuals being in a gratifying relationship and enjoying higher self-esteem. Well-being hypotheses are often incorporated into models that test the Michelangelo phenomenon.


Related phenomena


Growth-as-hell model

In contrast, it has been posited by Guggenbühl-Craig that it is precisely through ''dis''affirmation that we grow and move towards our ideal-selves. This is because it is through disaffirmation that we are made aware of our flaws and can overcome them. Much like the Michelangelo phenomenon, this growth-as-hell model of self-growth and movement towards the ideal self is understood to occur most potently in close, romantic relationships.


The Pygmalion phenomenon

The Pygmalion phenomenon, similar to a self-fulfilling prophecy, occurs when someone's belief about how a person should be informs their behaviour towards them, which in turn shapes the person's actual behaviour and self. This could take place in a close relationship. For example, an individual's ideal self might be someone who is conscientious and as a consequence affirm that conscientious quality in their partner and shape their behaviour. Where the Michelangelo phenomenon brings out the sculpture's ideal''', the Pygmalion phenomenon instead brings the '''sculptor's idea''l' into being. For the person being 'sculpted', this can be seen as a movement away from their own ideal self and therefore the process would not enhance personal or couple well-being according to the model of the Michelangelo phenomenon.


See also

* Symbolic interactionism *
William James William James (January 11, 1842 – August 26, 1910) was an American philosopher, historian, and psychologist, and the first educator to offer a psychology course in the United States. James is considered to be a leading thinker of the lat ...
*
George Herbert Mead George Herbert Mead (February 27, 1863 – April 26, 1931) was an American philosopher, sociologist, and psychologist, primarily affiliated with the University of Chicago, where he was one of several distinguished pragmatists. He is regarded a ...


References

{{DEFAULTSORT:Michelangelo Phenomenon Interpersonal relationships 1999 introductions