''Murray v Foyle Meats Ltd'' UKHL_30
is_a_ UKHL_30
is_a_UK_labour_law">999
UKHL_30
is_a_UK_labour_law_case,_concerning_redundancy_in_English_law.html" ;"title="UK_labour_law.html" ;"title="999
UKHL 30
is a UK labour law">999
UKHL 30
is a UK labour law case, concerning redundancy in English law">redundancy, specifically the interpretation of the Employment Rights Act 1996.

Facts

Foyle Meats Ltd's slaughtering business was declining. The company eliminated one production line in the slaughter hall, and 35 meat plant operatives were made redundant from the slaughter hall. The employees all had flexibility clauses, and they sometimes rotated departments to the boning or loading hall, etc. The dismissed employees claimed they were not redundant because the employer still needed workers under the same terms, just in different departments.

Judgment

Lord Irvine LC held that the operatives were redundant and that "the language of the mployment Rights Act 1996 section 139(1)(b)is in my view simplicity itself". He referred to ''

Nelson v BBC Nelson may refer to: Arts and entertainment * ''Nelson'' (1918 film), a historical film directed by Maurice Elvey * ''Nelson'' (1926 film), a historical film directed by Walter Summers * ''Nelson'' (opera), an opera by Lennox Berkeley to a lib ...

977 Year 977 ( CMLXXVII) was a common year starting on Monday (link will display the full calendar) of the Julian calendar. Events By place Europe * May – Boris II, dethroned emperor (''tsar'') of Bulgaria, and his brother Roman ma ...

ICR 649, Megaw LJ, Roskill LJ and Browne LJ which had wrongly propagated the "contract test" view, which was wrong. A simple causation test was applied, based on the word "attributable" in the statute. Did diminishing demand for labor cause the dismissal?

Notes

{{Clist redundancy United Kingdom labour case law House of Lords cases 1999 in United Kingdom case law