Leslie Cooper Perelman is an American scholar and authority on writing assessment. He is a critic of

automated essay scoring Automated essay scoring (AES) is the use of specialized computer programs to assign grades to essays written in an educational setting. It is a form of educational assessment and an application of natural language processing. Its objective is to c ...

(AES), and influenced the

College Board The College Board is an American nonprofit organization that was formed in December 1899 as the College Entrance Examination Board (CEEB) to expand access to higher education. While the College Board is not an association of colleges, it runs a ...

's decision to terminate the Writing Section of the SAT. Perelman is currently a research affiliate at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). Perelman taught writing and composition at MIT, where he served as Director of Writing Across the Curriculum and an Associate Dean of Undergraduate Education. He was an executive committee member of the Conference on College Composition and Communication. and Co-Chair of its Committee on Assessment.

Teaching

Perelman taught in and directed writing programs at Tulane University and the University of Southern California. At MIT, he taught writing and composition and served as the director of Writing Across the Curriculum and an Associate Dean in the Office of Undergraduate Education.

Criticism of essay scoring

SAT

Following his 2005 study of essay samples as well as graded essays provided by the

for reference on the writing portion of the SAT, Perelman reported a high correlation between an essay's length and score. He also noted that the essays were not penalized for any factual inaccuracies. In 2013, Perelman met with David Coleman, the incoming President of the College Board, and an outcome of that conversation was Coleman's decision to abolish the mandatory SAT Writing Section.

Automatic scoring

In 2012, Perelman demonstrated that long, pretentious essays could achieve higher scores from the ETS scoring engine e-Rater as opposed to well written essays. In 2014, Perelman collaborated with students at MIT and Harvard to develop BABEL, the "Basic Automatic B.S. Essay Language" Generator. The nonsense essays generated by BABEL are claimed to perform well when graded by AES systems. Automated graders, Perelman argues, "cannot read meaning, and they cannot check facts. More to the point, they cannot tell gibberish from lucid writing." Perelman's work is cited by the NCTE in their Position Statement on Machine Scoring, which expresses similar concerns about the limitations of AES:

Computer scoring systems can be "gamed" because they are poor at working with human language, further weakening the validity of their assessments and separating students not on the basis of writing ability but on whether they know and can use machine-tricking strategies.

Influence on Australian Educational Testing

During 2017-2018, Perelman was commissioned by the New South Wales Teachers Federation to write three reports to assist in efforts to reform Australia's national primary and secondary school assessments, the National Assessment Program – Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN). His work was a major factor in the decision of the National Education Council to overrule the Federal Education Minister and prevent the use of Automated Essay Scoring for the writing portion of the NAPLAN tests.

References

External links

BABEL Generator

Les Perelman's Web Site
{{DEFAULTSORT:Perelman, Les Living people Year of birth missing (living people) Place of birth missing (living people)