I'll Stand By You (Carrie Underwood Song)

"I'll Stand by You" is a song recorded by English-American rock band the Pretenders from their sixth studio album, ''Last of the Independents'' (1994). The song was written by Chrissie Hynde and the songwriting team of Tom Kelly and Billy Steinberg, and produced by Ian Stanley. The song is a ballad in which the singer pledges love and faithful assistance to a loved one in times of personal darkness.

Released on April 11, 1994, "I'll Stand by You" reached the top 20 in several countries, including Australia, Belgium, Canada, Iceland, the United Kingdom, and the United States. It also became a major hit for British girl group Girls Aloud in 2004 and American country singer Carrie Underwood in 2007, both times recorded as a charity single. Colombian singer Shakira performed the song for the live charity telethon ''Hope for Haiti Now'' in 2010; her cover version was released on the charity benefit album, which was also entitled ''Hope for Haiti Now''.

Release and commercial reception

"I'll Stand by You" was released as the second single from the album ''Last of the Independents'' (1994), and it reached number 16 on the US ''Billboard'' Hot 100, number 21 on ''Billboard''s Modern Rock Tracks chart, and number 10 in the United Kingdom. It charted higher in the UK and the US than "Night in My Veins", the album's first single. The music video for "I'll Stand by You" was released in 1994 and features Chrissie Hynde caring for an ill man. On the long-running BBC program Songwriters Circle, Hynde mentions her embarrassment at having set out to write a “hit.” She goes on to say that she felt better about the song after Noel Gallagher said “he wished he’d written it.”
It was later featured in the pilot episode of ''Dawson's Creek''. Since 2010 the song has been used in an appeal advert for the NSPCC, and also the Girls Aloud version was used in an advert for Aptamil follow-on milk.

Critical reception

Larry Flick from ''Billboard'' wrote that Chrissie Hynde "returns with a worn, but warm vocal that evokes a powerful, moving presence." Steve Baltin from '' Cashbox'' felt that "from the opening note, this song oozes "nice". Hard to believe this is the same Chrissie Hynde who, in the song " Precious", once told the world to "fuck off". Fourteen years ago, what drew people to her was the conviction she sang with. Though this song has a decidedly different tone, the feeling is as strong as ever. In addition, Hynde's singing has grown to where she can wail with the best of them, as she does here against a backdrop that increases perfectly with the rising emotion in her voice." Ken Tucker from ''Entertainment Weekly'' stated that the singer "matches form with content again and again" on the album, noting that she is "pledging solemn faithfulness to a loved one on the somber anthem". Irish ''Evening Herald'' opined that the song "showcases an updated Pretenders' sound." Linda Ryan from the ''Gavin Report'' declared it as one of the album's "beautiful, heart-stopping ballads", adding that it "will be a monster hit in a variety of formats." Caroline Sullivan from ''The Guardian'' remarked its "simple vow".

Jonathan Riggs from ''Idolator'' said in 2014, "Regardless of how representative of Hynde's oeuvre with The Pretenders it really was, "I'll Stand By You" continues to resonate decades later." James Masterton wrote in his weekly UK chart commentary, "Stand by to have your heartstrings tugged." He explained that it is "a gorgeous ballad of the kind Ms Hynde can churn out easily if she puts her mind to it. A potential classic to rival "2000 Miles" and the ode to motherhood that was their last chart hit, the track may well rise further." Pan-European magazine ''Music & Media'' named it "this spring's biggest ballad", adding, "Such symmetry between big time sensuality, kitsch, pathos and wall of sound!" Alan Jones from ''Music Week'' rated it four out of five, writing, "Unlike Pretenders' hits of the past it is slightly formulaic but it nonetheless a seductively swaying rock anthem." A reviewer from ''People Magazine'' felt it is the "weakest track" of the album, describing it as "an anthem of blind support." ''Sandwell Evening Mail'' viewed it as "excellent".

Music video

A music video was made to accompany the song. It begins in an old wooden hut. A man arrives and is met by Hynde, who knocks over a glass of milk and then sings towards him, though it is not clear whether he hears her, or if he is aware of her presence. The man is obviously worried, holding a bullet in his hand. He also looks into a map. Other times he plays with a coin or a card deck. Hynde tries to comfort him. She holds her arms around him, and also mends his clothes with needle and sewing thread. She helps him with tools when he tries to fix a machine. Later after struggling with awakening him, she carries the ill man to a bath tub, where she washes and nurses him. In the end, the man, now fully dressed again, leaves the hut, while Hynde watches him. On the table lies an ace card with a knife stuck through it.

Track listing

Personnel

*Chrissie Hynde – guitar, vocals
* Adam Seymour – guitar

Additional musicians
*J.F.T. Hood – drums
*David Paton – bass guitar
* Tom Kelly – piano, guitar
*London Gospel Choir – choir
* David Lord – string arrangement
*Bob Clearmountain – mixing
* Tony Philips – mixing
*Steve Williams – engineer

Charts and certifications

Weekly charts

Year-end charts

Certifications

Girls Aloud version

In 2004, the British-Irish all-female pop group Girls Aloud recorded a cover of "I'll Stand by You" as the official charity single for the 2004 Children in Need fundraising campaign. Their version was produced by Brian Higgins and his production team Xenomania. The track was announced a single just ten days before its November 15, 2004, release. It became Girls Aloud's second number one on the UK Singles Chart, spending two weeks at the top position and receiving a silver certification from the British Phonographic Industry. The song appears on Girls Aloud's second studio album ''What Will the Neighbours Say?'' (2004).

The music video, directed by Trudy Bellinger, saw Girls Aloud stranded in a desert as they "stand by" each other. "I'll Stand by You" was promoted through various live appearances and has since been performed on a number of the group's concert tours. Despite its success, Girls Aloud's cover of the song was largely panned by contemporary music critics.

Background and release

The first version of "I'll Stand by You" that Xenomania created was described as a "weird, modernist breakbeat version", which was scrapped upon deciding an updated version of the original song would be better suited for Children in Need. The track's release was announced a single just ten days before its release date. Nicola Roberts said, "Hopefully if our single does well it's a lot of money going to the charity."

The single was released on November 15, 2004, in the UK, the week of the Children in Need 2004 telethon. It was available on two different CD singles. The first disc includes "Real Life", a song taken from Girls Aloud's second album ''What Will the Neighbours Say?''. The second CD format featured a medley of songs taken from the album, as well as the Tony Lamezma's Club Romp remix of the track. The Gravitas Vocal Dub Mix Edit of "I'll Stand by You" appears on the " Wake Me Up" single.

In order to promote the release, Girls Aloud toured radio stations across the United Kingdom and performed an acoustic arrangement of "I'll Stand by You" that they arranged themselves. They also visited children's hospitals.

Critical reception

Girls Aloud's version of "I'll Stand By You" was largely panned by music critics. It was called "a particular soggy area" on Girls Aloud's album. Alexis Petridis of ''The Guardian'', who praised Girls Aloud's album, said that "I'll Stand by You" was "a thing of death-dealing tedium." BBC Music felt it was "arguable whether this cover adds much to the Pretenders' original." Sam Shepherd of musicOMH bluntly stated "perhaps the children most in need, are those that part with their pocket money for this drivel ..This is a sub-karaoke version, limp, tired, and uninspired."

However, Stylus Magazine actually commended the song, comparing it to Shakespears Sister and calling it "far, far better than anyone gives it credit for."

Chart performance

"I'll Stand by You" debuted at number one on the UK Singles Chart on November 21, 2004, becoming Girls Aloud's second single to do so. Despite competition from four new top ten entries, the song also remained at the top for a second week. It slipped to number four in its third week, making way for Band Aid 20's take on "Do They Know It's Christmas?". Girls Aloud spent a fourth week in the top five. The single spent two further weeks in the top ten, holding on at number nine. Overall, "I'll Stand by You" spent fourteen weeks in the top 75, including nine weeks in the top forty. The single was ranked thirty-fourth on the year-end chart (see 2004 in British music). It was certified silver by the British Phonographic Industry. Following Sarah Harding's death in September 2021, the song had a resurgence in popularity with a surge of 1068%.

The song entered the Irish Singles Chart at number four. It spent a second week at number four, before rising to number three. It spent three more consecutive weeks at number three. It then slipped back down to number four, and spent two more weeks in the top five.

Music video

The video for Girls Aloud's version of "I'll Stand by You" was directed by Trudy Bellinger. It begins with each member of the group lying or sitting motionless in a parched desert. At the song's climax, a thunderstorm begins, and the members of Girls Aloud come together and stand in a circle. A special ''Children in Need'' version of the video depicts the group members holding "Pudsey" teddy bears, the mascot of the organisation, towards the end of the video.

Live performances

Girls Aloud toured radio stations across the United Kingdom and performed an acoustic arrangement of "I'll Stand by You" that they arranged themselves. As the charity's official single of the year, the song was showcased as the Children in Need 2004 telethon. They also performed the song on television programmes such as ''Blue Peter'', '' CD:UK'', ''Countdown'', ''Diggin' It'', ''GMTV'', ''Ministry of Mayhem'', ''Popbusters'', ''Top of the Pops'', and ''Xchange''. In 2005, Girls Aloud performed "I'll Stand by You" at Dublin's ChildLine Concert and on the TV show ''All Time Greatest Love Songs''. In 2006, they performed the song on Australia's ''Sunrise''. The group also performed the cover version on their 2005 MTV special (as seen on the ''Girls on Film'' DVD) and ITV1's ''The Girls Aloud Party'' (2008).

"I'll Stand by You" has been performed by Girls Aloud on most of their concert tours. For 2005's What Will the Neighbours Say...? Tour, Girls Aloud's first tour, they sang the song in colourful, simple evening gowns. It was also included on 2006's Chemistry Tour and 2007's The Greatest Hits Tour. "I'll Stand by You" was included on a ballad section on 2008's Tangled Up Tour, in which Girls Aloud walk along a catwalk which reaches the middle of the crowd.

Track listings and formats

These are the formats and track listings of major single releases of "I'll Stand by You".

UK CD1 (Polydor / 9869129)
# "I'll Stand by You" – 3:44
# "Real Life" – 3:41

UK CD2 (Polydor / 9869130)
# "I'll Stand by You" – 3:44
# "I'll Stand by You" (Tony Lamezma's Club Romp) – 5:05
# "''What Will the Neighbours Say?'' Album Medley" – 3:14
# "I'll Stand by You" (video) – 3:44
# "I'll Stand by You" (karaoke video) – 3:44
# "I'll Stand by You" (game)

''The Singles Boxset'' (CD7)
# "I'll Stand by You" – 3:44
# "Real Life" – 3:41
# "I'll Stand by You" (Tony Lamezma's Club Romp) – 5:05
# "''What Will the Neighbours Say?'' Album Medley" – 3:14
# "I'll Stand by You" (Gravitas Vocal Dub Mix) – 7:27
# "I'll Stand by You" (video) – 3:44
# "I'll Stand by You" (karaoke video) – 3:44
# "I'll Stand by You" (game)

Personnel

*Nadine Coyle – co-lead vocals
*Cheryl Tweedy – co-lead vocals
*Sarah Harding – co-lead vocals
*Nicola Roberts – co-lead vocals
*Kimberley Walsh – co-lead vocals

Charts

Weekly charts

Year-end charts

Certifications

Carrie Underwood version

"I'll Stand by You" was covered in 2007 by Carrie Underwood as a charity single, recorded for the ''American Idol'' special, ''Idol Gives Back'' which aired on April 25, 2007.

Carrie Underwood performed the song during her visit to Africa, which was used as soundtrack for a video vignette, where Underwood is seen singing to children and doing different activities with them. The single and the video were released on the U.S. iTunes Store on April 26, 2007. Ryan Seacrest announced that all money made on digital downloads would be donated to charity to help millions of poor children at the time.

On its first few days of release, the song sold 124,496 digital downloads, prompting a debut on the U.S. ''Billboard'' Hot 100 at number six, Underwood's highest Hot 100 position since her 2005 debut single "Inside Your Heaven", which debuted at number one.

It was eventually removed from iTunes, leading the single to have one of the biggest falls in Hot 100 history. The single collected over 300,000 digital downloads in the time period it was available for download. As announced, all profits from the sale of the single were donated to charity. The single also received unsolicited airplay on U.S. country music radio stations, despite not being officially released to country radio.

During one of the elimination episodes of ''American Idol'' Season Six, the song was used as the send-off song for contestant Phil Stacey (the first of two eliminated contestants that week) in lieu of Daughtry's "Home," the show's main send-off song that season. Underwood performed the song during the Idol Finale on May 23, 2007.

Music video

The music video was filmed in Africa. Underwood is seen singing to young children and helping them with different art projects, such as painting. At one point in the video, she is seen walking into a cemetery with a girl on her arms, and a boy by her hand who is carrying flowers. Underwood is also seen crying towards the end of the video, when she is helping an ill person. This music video was made available for download on the U.S. iTunes Store.

Charts

Shakira version

"I'll Stand by You" is a cover in 2010 by the Colombian singer Shakira as a promotional charity single for the Hope for Haiti Now campaign and was released on January 23, 2010, in the wake of the devastating 2010 Haiti earthquake. Recorded live on the charity telethon '' Hope for Haiti Now: A Global Benefit for Earthquake Relief'' on January 22, 2010, in New York City. She performed the song during the program, exactly before Wyclef Jean's speech and after Reese Witherspoon's call on the phone bank. The song is found on the charity benefit album, ''Hope for Haiti Now''.

Track listing

Album version
# " I'll Stand by You" (with the Roots)-

Charts

References

{{Authority control

1990s ballads
1994 singles
1994 songs
2004 singles
2007 singles
2010 singles
Carrie Underwood songs
Charity singles
Girls Aloud songs
Music videos directed by Trudy Bellinger
Number-one singles in Scotland
Polydor Records singles
The Pretenders songs
Rock ballads
Rod Stewart songs
Sire Records singles
Song recordings produced by Xenomania
Songs written by Billy Steinberg
Songs written by Chrissie Hynde
Songs written by Tom Kelly (musician)
Torch songs
UK Singles Chart number-one singles
Warner Music Group singles
Warner Records singles