China Daily

''China Daily'' () is an English-language daily newspaper owned by the Central Propaganda Department of the Chinese Communist Party.

Overview

''China Daily'' has the widest print circulation of any English-language newspaper in China. The headquarters and principal editorial office is in the Chaoyang District of Beijing. The newspaper has branch offices in most major cities of China as well as several major foreign cities including New York City, Washington, D.C., London, and Kathmandu. The paper is published by satellite offices in the United States, Hong Kong, and Europe. ''China Daily'' also produces an insert of sponsored content called ''China Watch'' that has been distributed inside other newspapers including ''The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal'', ''The Washington Post'', and ''Le Figaro''.

Within mainland China, the newspaper targets primarily diplomats, foreign expatriates, tourists, and locals wishing to improve their English. The China edition also offers program guides to Radio Beijing and television, daily exchange rates, and local entertainment schedules. It has been used as a guide to Chinese government policy and positions of the Chinese Communist Party. Scholar Falk Hartig describes the newspaper and its various international editions as an "instrument of China's public diplomacy."

''China Daily'''s editorial policies have been described as slightly more liberal than other Chinese news outlets. Its coverage of the 1989 Tiananmen Square protests and massacre was overwhelmingly sympathetic to the student protests with many of its journalists joining in at the height of mass demonstrations. The newspaper's coverage of the 2002–2004 SARS outbreak was reported to be more critical, fact-driven, and less laudatory than that of the ''People's Daily''. A 2018 discourse analysis from Uppsala University found that prior to Xi Jinping's accession, many ''China Daily'' articles portrayed their government as a particular kind of democracy, with democratic ideals such as the implementation of universal suffrage (in Hong Kong) and grassroots elections sometimes endorsed. After his accession, articles became more negative in tone toward democracy and shifted focus to portraying the "vices" of democracies in the West, particularly the United States.

Editorial control

Scholars have described ''China Daily'' as effectively controlled by the Central Propaganda Department of the Chinese Communist Party. Ideologically, it tends to adopt similar perspectives to the ''People's Daily''. According to its 2014 annual report, ''China Daily'' is formally managed by the State Council Information Office (SCIO), which was formed from the Central Propaganda Department in 1991. The SCIO holds regular meetings with journalists and editors from ''China Daily'' on what they should publish. In 2014, the SCIO was absorbed into the CCP's Central Propaganda Department.

A former copy-editor (or "polisher" as termed at ''China Daily'') for the newspaper described her role being "to tweak propaganda enough that it read as English, without inadvertently triggering war." Journalist Michael Ottey described his time working for ''China Daily'' as "almost like working for a public relations firm" and added "it wasn't really honest journalism. It was more 'Let's make the Chinese government look good.'" Writer Mitch Moxley, who worked at ''China Daily'' from 2007 to 2008, wrote in 2013 that many of the articles published in the newspaper's opinion pages "violated everything ehad ever learned about journalistic ethics, including ''China Dailys own code: 'Factual, Honest, Fair, Complete.'"

History

''China Daily'' was officially established in June 1981 after a one-month trial. It was initially led by Jiang Muyue, with Liu Zhunqi as editor in chief. It was the first national daily English-language newspaper in China after the establishment of the People's Republic in 1949. Its initial circulation was 22,000, which grew to 65,000 by the following year. The paper was a departure from other Chinese newspapers at the time: it was "a Western-style paper", in content, style, and organizational structure. By July 1982, the newspaper had plans to publish editions in the United States, the United Kingdom, and tentatively Australia. Initially, it struggled to find English-speaking journalists.

''China Daily'' began distribution in North America in 1983. It has been registered as a foreign agent in the United States under the Foreign Agents Registration Act since 1983.

''China Daily'' introduced an online edition in 1996 and a Hong Kong edition in 1997. By 2006, it had a reported circulation of 300,000, of which two thirds were in China and one third international. In 2010, it launched ''China Daily Asia Weekly,'' a tabloid-sized pan-Asian edition.

In December 2012, ''China Daily'' launched an Africa edition, published in Nairobi, the capital of Kenya. This edition aimed expand the ''China Daily'' readership, of both African people and Chinese people who live in Africa, and showcase China's interests in Africa.

In 2015, ''China Daily'' published a fake op-ed which the publication claimed was penned by Peter Hessler. They combined part of the transcript of an interview he had done with comments from another person interviewed as well as completely fabricated parts and ran it as an op-ed under Hessler's byline without his knowledge or permission. The fabricated op-ed contained made up praise for China and misrepresented Hessler's own words by taking them out of context. According to the Associated Press, the editorial repeated Chinese Communist Party talking points and ''China Daily'' refused to retract it although it subsequently removed the English language version of the op-ed.

In 2018, the paper fabricated a quote by the mayor of Davos, Tarzisius Caviezel.

A January 2020 report by Freedom House, a U.S. non-governmental organization, noted that ''China Daily'' had increased its spending from $500,000 in the first half of 2009 to over $5 million in the latter half of 2019 for increased print runs. ''China Daily'' said it had a circulation of 300,000 in the U.S. and 600,000 overseas.

In February 2020, a group of U.S. lawmakers asked the United States Department of Justice to investigate ''China Daily'' for alleged violations of the Foreign Agents Registration Act. Later the same month, the United States Department of State designated ''China Daily'', along with several other Chinese state media outlets, as foreign missions owned or controlled by the Chinese Communist Party.

In June 2020, ''China Daily'' awarded a tender for a "foreign personnel analysis platform" to the Communication University of China to scan social media and automatically flag "false statements and reports on China."

In September 2020, India's Ministry of External Affairs issued a statement saying that comments made by ''China Daily'' were falsely attributed to Ajit Doval.

Reception

Overall

In a 2004 journal article, University of Sheffield professor Lily Chen stated that ''China Daily'' was "essentially a publicly funded government mouthpiece". Judy Polumbaum stated in the ''Berkshire Encyclopedia of China'' (2009) that ''China Daily'' "resists definition as a simple mouthpiece" and has a "distinctive, if quixotic, status". In 2009, ''China Daily'' was called "the most influential English language national newspaper in China" according to University of St. Thomas scholar Juan Li. It is known for original reporting. Non-governmental organization Reporters Without Borders has accused ''China Daily'' of engaging in censorship and propaganda.

''The New York Times'' wrote that ''China Daily'''s inserts published in US newspapers "generally offer an informative, if anodyne, view of world affairs refracted through the lens of the Communist Party." In response to criticism, ''The New York Times'', ''The Washington Post'', ''The Daily Telegraph'', and Nine Entertainment Co. ceased publishing ''China Daily'''s ''China Watch'' inserts in their newspapers.

Disinformation

Media outlets such as ''The New York Times'', NPR, ''Quartz'', and '' BuzzFeed News'' have published accounts of ''China Daily'''s dissemination of disinformation related to the 2019–20 Hong Kong protests. In September 2019, ''China Daily'''s official Facebook account stated that Hong Kong protesters were planning on launching terrorist attacks on 11 September of the same year.

In May 2020, CNN, ''Financial Times'', and other media outlets reported that ''China Daily'' censored references to the origin of the COVID-19 pandemic from an opinion piece authored by European Union ambassadors. In January 2021, ''China Daily'' inaccurately attributed deaths in Norway to the Pfizer–BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine. In April 2021, the European External Action Service published a report that cited ''China Daily'' and other state media outlets for "selective highlighting" of potential vaccine side-effects and "disregarding contextual information or ongoing research" to present Western vaccines as unsafe. In October 2021, the German Marshall Fund reported that ''China Daily'' was one of several state media outlets propagating a conspiracy theory concerning the origins of COVID-19.

In January 2022, ''China Daily'' alleged that the U.S. planned to pay athletes to "sabotage" the 2022 Winter Olympics. In March 2022, ''China Daily'' published an article in Chinese which falsely claimed that COVID-19 was created by Moderna, citing a page on '' The Exposé'', a British conspiracist website.

Portrayal of Muslims

A 2019 critical discourse analysis of ''China Daily'''s coverage of Chinese Muslims found them to be portrayed as "obedient and dependent Chinese citizens who benefit from the government’s intervention." In January 2021, a ''China Daily'' article praised a report from the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, stating that government policies in Xinjiang had "emancipated" the minds of Uyghur women so that they are "no longer baby-making machines." The article drew condemnation as being a justification for reproductive policies of Uyghur genocide, and sparked calls for Twitter to remove links to the article. Twitter removed a reposting of the ''China Daily'' article by the PRC's official U.S. embassy account and subsequently suspended the account for contravening its stated policy against "dehumanization of a group of people."

See also

* List of newspapers in China
* Mass media in China
* Propaganda in China
* Chinese information operations and information warfare

References

External links

*

{{coord, 39.980092, 116.423802, region:CN-BJ, display=title, name=China Daily

1981 establishments in China
English-language newspapers published in China
Newspapers published in Beijing
Newspapers established in 1981
Chinese propaganda organisations
Chinese Communist Party newspapers
Daily newspapers published in China
Disinformation operations
Information operations units and formations
State media
Organizations listed by the United States as foreign agents
Uyghur genocide denial
Conspiracist media