Butler's General Order No. 28

General Order No. 28 was a military decree made by Maj. Gen. Benjamin Butler during the American Civil War. Following the Battle of New Orleans, Butler established himself as military commander of that city on May 1, 1862. Many of the city's inhabitants were strongly hostile to the Federal government, and many women in particular expressed this contempt by insulting Union troops.

Accordingly, on May 15, Butler issued an order to the effect that any woman insulting or showing contempt for any officer or soldier of the United States should be "treated as a woman of the town plying her avocation," the solicitation of prostitution. The order had no sexual connotation, but it permitted soldiers not to treat women performing such acts as ladies. For example, if a woman punched a soldier, he could punch her back. Known as the Woman's Order, it was very controversial both at home and abroad, as women throughout New Orleans interpreted it as Butler legalizing rape. The general dislike over No. 28 even went so far as people printing his portrait on the bottom of chamber pots, and was a cause of Butler's removal from command of New Orleans on December 16, 1862.

Text

Women in the Confederacy

With many men away from home fighting for the Confederacy, women sacrificed "physical conveniences and comforts... for what was considered a holy cause" by becoming the front lines of war morale. They inspired troops and kept up morale by retaining "an uncritical faith in the soldiers and a mystical faith in Providence" which they expressed through letters to soldiers and personal diaries. To add to their burden, women had to figure out how to support themselves without men to provide for them. Many women "leaped from their spheres" to assume duties and roles that were almost always performed by men. Women became managers of farms or plantations or sought employment outside of the home in order to provide for themselves and their families.

The plight was observed by not only personal correspondence and diaries but also demonstrations known as bread riots. The Richmond Bread Riot occurred on April 2, 1863. Women were distressed due to the food shortages, the failure of relief efforts, and the general struggle of independence in a world based on paternalism and benevolence. The women of Richmond raided stores on Cary Street and Main Street and interrupted only by Confederate President Jefferson Davis, who allowed them to keep the goods they stole from the stores.

By the end of the war, Confederate women had made sacrifices that were compared to the "stern resolution and self-abnegation of Rome and Lacedaemon." They willingly deprived themselves of things such as food and clothing to help the suffering troops. In 1864, Augusta Jane Evans published a novel, ''Macaria; or, Alters of Sacrifice'', about a woman who discovered her usefulness in the Confederate cause and likened her to the woman "who sacrificed herself on the altar of the gods in order to save Athens time of war." To many white Confederate women, the Confederacy was their Athens for which they would sacrifice all.

The extreme sacrifice made by white Confederate women is one of the tenets of the Lost Cause memory of the Civil War. Women are to be revered for their sacrifices and identified for their important roles in a society dominated by paternalism and the patriarchal power structure.

Union control of New Orleans

Major General Benjamin F. Butler occupied the city of New Orleans on May 1, 1862. The residents of New Orleans, especially the women, did not take Butler's appointment as military general very well. Butler's troops faced "all manner of verbal and physically symbolic insults" from women, including obvious physical avoidance such as crossing the street or leaving a streetcar to avoid a Union soldier, being spat upon, and having chamber pots being dumped upon them. The Union troops were offended by the treatment, and after two weeks of occupation, Butler had had enough. He issued his General Order No. 28, which instructed Union soldiers to treat any woman who offended a soldier "as a woman of the town plying her avocation."

Reactions

The order was highly publicized. It was heavily criticized in the South, and earned him the nickname "Butler the Beast" from Confederate General P.G.T. Beauregard, which stuck amongst Confederates. Predictably, it was supported in the North, with newspapers noting New Orleans had calmed since the Order was issued, and a Maine newspaper noting Beauregard's hypocrisy for criticizing the Order while entrusting his own wife to Butler's personal care. Southern women were offended by the Order. Catherine Ann Devereux Edmonston, a staunch secessionist who enslaved 88 people on a North Carolina plantation, wrote in her diary that the Order was "cold blooded barbarity" and expressed disdain for Butler and all other Northerners: "We no longer will hold any intercourse with you, ye puritanical, deceitful race." She blamed Butler's wife, believing she had connived the Order to demonstrate her "ferocity against the real ladies of New Orleans" for rejecting her from their society. Clara Solomon, a 17-year-old girl from New Orleans, expressed similar feelings. The war impoverished her family: her father had moved to Virginia to supply war materiel to Confederates, forcing her mother and sisters to work, sewing for money. She hated the Union soldiers, and found the Order unnecessary and offensive, asking "what anyway could a woman's taunts do to" the Union soldiers.

The order was also criticized in Britain; British Foreign Minister, the Lord Russell, proclaimed the imprisonment of women a "more intolerable tyranny than any civilized country in our day asbeen subjected to." London's pro-Confederate '' Saturday Review'', which believed the American Civil War had nothing to do with slavery, also criticized the order, accusing Butler of "gratifying his own revenge" and likening him to an uncivilized dictator:

If he had possessed any of the honourable feeling which is usually associated with a soldier's profession, he would not have made war on women. If he had even been endowed with the ordinary magnanimity of a Red Indian, his revenge would have been satiated before now. It required not only the nature of a savage, but of a very mean and pitiful kind of savage, to be induced by indignation at a woman's smile to inflict an imprisonment so degrading in its character as that which seems to constitute his favourite punishment, and accompanied by privations so cruel.... It is only a pity that so unadulterated a barbarian should have got hold of an Anglo-Saxon name.

''The New York Times'' responded to British criticism of the order by defending Butler, noting that he "was in a rebellious city trying to restore order, so he was free to impose any measure he saw fit that would help quell the rebellion and restore order"; the newspaper also noted the alleged "Beauty and Booty" battle cry of British forces in the Battle of New Orleans during the War of 1812, "suggesting that haughty Britain ought not throw rocks from its own crystal palace". Butler defended his command in New Orleans in a letter to the Boston Journal, claiming "the devil had entered the hearts of the women of ew Orleans.. to stir up strife" and that the order had been very effective. Contemporary sources supported Butler, stating that the order was unequivocally effective and resulted in women in the city and Union soldiers patrolling the city to be “honored equally” by one another, further evidenced by the fact that the Order was essentially never acted upon. Butler wrote that the most effective way to deal with a defiant Confederate woman was to ignore her unless she becomes a "continuous and positive nuisance," in which case treat her as an "undignified woman of the town" and hand her to a watchman. He further noted that he had had to arrest Confederate men for similar defiant actions against the United States.

Eugenia Levy Phillips

Eugenia Levy Phillips claimed to have been imprisoned under the Woman's Order, though her espionage weighed heavily against her. South Carolina-born Phillips lived in Washington, DC at the beginning of the war, married to former U.S. Representative Philip Phillips. Using her connections to Washington's elite, she spied for South Carolina, and boasted of it in her personal papers. When suspected of espionage by the Union, Phillips was detained to the house of Confederate spy Rose Greenhow. The investigators failed to find proof of espionage but banished the Phillipses and the other suspects to the Confederacy; the Phillips moved to New Orleans, months before the city fell to Union troops.

In May 1862, United States Lieutenant George Coleman de Kay, Jr. was killed leading an excursion into Baton Rouge. Butler commissioned a funeral cortège for de Kay's body, accompanied by military guard, to the cemetery in Metairie. As the funeral cortège passed by, Phillips "laughed gaily" and mocked the dead soldier, per Butler's witnesses. Phillips said her laughter was unrelated to the solemn ceremony filling her street, and she was simply enjoying her veranda. Butler treated the suspected spy as he would a repeat male offender, ordering her arrested and sentenced to two years' imprisonment in a military prison at Ship Island. Though her sentence was "without communication," she was permitted to bring a "servant" of color, ate the same food as the soldiers, and her captors so gracious that she sent letters of gratitude after her release some months later (earlier than sentenced because she claimed pregnancy at age 42). Nonetheless, she wrote a memoir highlighting her stoic Lost Cause forbearance, casting her treatment as harsh and herself as a martyr. Though she admitted espionage in her private papers, Phillips publicly protested being called a spy, labeling the accusations "shameful" and condemnatory.https://repository.tcu.edu/bitstream/handle/116099117/40352/Edwards_tcu_0229D_11131.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

Perhaps unaware of Phillips's espionage, family friend Clara Solomon expressed "great shock" that Phillips was imprisoned for "laughing and mocking" a dead soldier's funeral cortège. Catherine Edmonston sympathized with Phillips and the "foul wrong" and "horrible outrage" placed against her.

Aftermath

Butler claimed that the order was effective in quieting the women of New Orleans, but he was only partially correct. Women in New Orleans still presented a very real political and military threat to the imposing Union Army, despite only a small number of women continuing to be politically active after the order and the arrest of Phillips.

Butler was removed from his command of New Orleans on December 16, 1862. The international attention garnered from the order contributed to his removal from New Orleans, as did his threats aimed at foreign consuls.

References

{{reflist

New Orleans in the American Civil War
General orders
Benjamin Butler
History of women in Louisiana
Social history of the American Civil War