But Daddy I Love Him

"But Daddy I Love Him" is a song by the American singer-songwriter Taylor Swift from her eleventh studio album, ''The Tortured Poets Department'' (2024)''.'' Swift and Aaron Dessner wrote the track, and they produced it with Jack Antonoff. Musically, "But Daddy I Love Him" is an electronica and folk rock ballad with elements of country and rock. The song is instrumented by fingerpicked guitars, live drums, and dynamic shifts in the chorus. In the lyrics, a narrator condemns the detractors of her love life and calls out their hypocrisy and self-righteousness.

Critics generally praised the songwriting as intense yet humorous and the production as catchy; some reviews picked the track as an album highlight. The song peaked at number seven on the ''Billboard'' Global 200 and peaked within the top 10 in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Singapore, and the United States. Swift performed the song for the revamped 2024 shows of her sixth concert tour, the Eras Tour.

Development

Swift announced ''The Tortured Poets Department'' on February 4, 2024, at the 66th Annual Grammy Awards during her acceptance speech for the Best Pop Vocal Album award for ''Midnights'' (2022). Shortly after the announcement, the album's artwork was shared on her Instagram profile. Swift's website also enabled the album to be pre-ordered in vinyl, CD, cassette and digital format. "But Daddy I Love Him" appears on the album as track six. According to Swift, she developed ''The Tortured Poets Department'' immediately after releasing ''Midnights'' and worked on it for two years. She further developed the album during the US leg of the Eras Tour. During one of the Eras Tour shows in Melbourne, Swift described writing the album as a "lifeline" for her. Swift included "But Daddy I Love Him" on the revamped setlist of the Eras Tour beginning in May 2024 at the Paris shows.

Music and lyrics

"But Daddy I Love Him" is 5 minutes and 40 seconds long. It is an electronica and folk rock ballad with elements of country and rock. The verses are instrumented by fingerpicked guitars, while the chorus is dynamic, described by ''Billboard'''s Jason Lipshutz as "large, open-hearted" that evoked Swift's "early country-pop anthems". Meskin Fekadu from '' The Hollywood Reporter'' opined that the track could have "easily fit" on Swift's albums ''Fearless'' (2008) or ''Speak Now'' (2010). Alexis Petridis of '' The Guardian'' noted that there are subtle fiddles in the mix. Lyrically, the song discusses detractors who criticise Swift's love life. The title is a quote from the 1989 animated film '' The Little Mermaid''; the protagonist Ariel says the line in response to her merman father's disapproval of her human crush Prince Eric.

The lyrics may be interpreted as Swift's response to criticism received for her previous romance, where she rejects the idea of seeking approval from the public and following one's inner feelings. The track is viewed as the mature sister of "Love Story" from ''Fearless'' (2008) which Swift sings about her father objecting to a relationship. In "But Daddy I Love Him", the critics involves many denigrators who were disappointed with her love interest. The opening verse containing the line "I just learned these people only raise you just to cage you" establishes the tension between Swift and others. The line also echoes of Swift's previous track "This Is Me Trying" where she sings: "They told me all of my cages were mental". The song's bridge reiterates the central theme of how others believe their intentions are in the interest of Swift's. The song's chorus, where Swift sings "I’m having his baby, No I’m not, but you should see your faces," may be intended to evoke a reaction from listeners.

The bridge and overall song can be interpreted as a message to the public and fans to consider if dating a man, who is a separate entity to her, should change their opinions of her, through the lyric "I'll tell you something about my good name, it's mine alone to disgrace". The lyrics "No, I'm not coming to my senses", and "I know he's crazy, but he's the one I want" asserts her prerogative to make choices despite other's and her own negative judgement. She also extends her own judgement for those critics, with lyrics "Don't cater to all these vipers dressed in empath's clothing... God save the most judgmental creeps who say they want what's best for me". She postulates that her critics will change their stances, and will not be welcomed with the lyrics "Time, doesn't it give some perspective / And no, you can't come to the wedding".

Reception

In a review for the parent album, Helen Brown of '' The Independent'' wrote "the force wiftbrings to 'But Daddy I Love Him' is thrilling, as she lassos a few country tropes to charge her horses at online trolls." Samantha Olson of ''Cosmopolitan'' ranked the song fifth in her ranking of the top five best songs from the album. Lindsay Zoladz of '' The New York Times'' groups this song as part of a "project hatremains fixed on her internal world", described as the "unexpectedly venomous" track about "the "wine moms" and "Sarahs and Hannahs in their Sunday best" who cluck their tongues at our narrator's dating decisions. (Some might speculate that these are actually shots at her own fans.)" A similar sentiment shared John Wohlmacher of ''Beats Per Minute'' who writes that in the song, she "butts heads with overzealous fans" with its "outrageously cheeky and confrontational" lyrics. Thom Donovan of ''American Songwriter'' ranked the second best songs off the album, calling it a "blistering attack on the fanbase she cultivated by letting them into nearly every aspect of her life." Writing for ''British GQ'', Lucy Ford interpreted the song as Swift telling her fans to "back off and leave her personal life alone". Although ''Paste'' panned the parent album, "But Daddy I Love Him" was a standout track, praising its lyricsm and "awe-striking, stand-still melodies".

Commercial performance

Following the album's release, its tracks occupied the top nine of the ''Billboard'' Global 200; "But Daddy I Love Him" debuted at its peak of number seven on the chart, where it extended Swift's top-10 entries to 33. In the United States, the song opened and peaked at number seven on the ''Billboard'' Hot 100. It along with 13 tracks from the album made Swift the first artist to monopolize the top 14 of the Hot 100. In Australia, "But Daddy I Love Him" reached number seven on the ARIA Singles Chart and made her the artist with the most entries in a single week with 29.

Elsewhere, "But Daddy I Love Him" reached the top 10 in Canada, New Zealand, and Singapore, with peaks of number seven, eight, and number nine, respectively. The song also charted within the top 25 in the Philippines (11), Ireland (12), Malaysia (18), Luxembourg (19), Portugal (20), Denmark (23), South Africa (23), and Belgium (24).

Personnel

* Taylor Swift – vocals, songwriter, producer
* Jack Antonoff – producer, programming, cello, Juno, bass, electric guitar, acoustic guitar, background vocals, Mellotron
* Aaron Dessner – producer, songwriter, acoustic guitar
* Serban Ghenea – mixing
* Bryce Bordone – mix engineer
* Laura Sisk – recording engineer
* Oli Jacobs – recording engineer
* Jon Sher – assistant recording engineer
* Jack Manning – assistant recording engineer
* Sean Hutchinson – drums
* Michael Riddleberger – recording engineer
* Mikey Freedom Hart – synthesizer
* David Hart – recording engineer
* Evan Smith – synthesizer
* Zem Audu – synthesizer
* Jonathan Low – recording engineer
* Bella Blasko – recording engineer
* Bobby Hawk – strings
* Randy Merrill – mastering

Charts

Certifications

References

{{Taylor Swift songs

Taylor Swift songs
2024 songs
Song recordings produced by Taylor Swift
Song recordings produced by Aaron Dessner
Song recordings produced by Jack Antonoff
Songs written by Taylor Swift
Songs written by Aaron Dessner
American folk rock songs
Electronica songs
Folk ballads
Rock ballads
2020s ballads