The Bern Disputation was a debate over the theology of
the Swiss Reformation that occurred in
Bern
german: Berner(in)french: Bernois(e) it, bernese
, neighboring_municipalities = Bremgarten bei Bern, Frauenkappelen, Ittigen, Kirchlindach, Köniz, Mühleberg, Muri bei Bern, Neuenegg, Ostermundigen, Wohlen bei Bern, Zollikofen
, website ...
from 6 to 26 January 1528 that ended in Bern becoming the second Swiss canton to officially become
Protestant
Protestantism is a Christian denomination, branch of Christianity that follows the theological tenets of the Reformation, Protestant Reformation, a movement that began seeking to reform the Catholic Church from within in the 16th century agai ...
.
Background
As the
reformation in Zürich
The Reformation in Zürich was promoted initially by Huldrych Zwingli, who gained the support of the magistrates of the city of Zürich and the princess abbess Katharina von Zimmern of the Fraumünster Abbey, and the population of the city of Hist ...
progressed in the 1520s, the surrounding Swiss cantons were also affected.
Bern was the capital of the
Swiss Confederacy
The Old Swiss Confederacy or Swiss Confederacy (Modern German: ; historically , after the Reformation also , "Confederation of the Swiss") was a loose confederation of independent small states (, German or In the charters of the 14th century ...
and was "the largest, most conservative and aristocratic of the Swiss cantons" at the time.
The early Protestant movement spearheaded by
Martin Luther
Martin Luther (; ; 10 November 1483 – 18 February 1546) was a German priest, theologian, author, hymnwriter, and professor, and Order of Saint Augustine, Augustinian friar. He is the seminal figure of the Reformation, Protestant Refo ...
had an effect on Bern as early as 1518, and Protestant teaching was being debated in Bern by 1522.
By 1523, Protestants already held significant posts in Bern, including artist
Niklaus Manuel
Niklaus Manuel Deutsch (''Niklaus Manuel'', c. 1484 – 28 April 1530), of Bern, was a Swiss artist, writer, mercenary and Reformed politician.
Biography
Niklaus was most likely the son of Emanuel Aleman (or Alleman), a pharmacist whose own fat ...
and preacher
Berchtold Haller
Berchtold Haller (c. 149225 February 1536) was a German Protestant reformer. He was the reformer of the city of Bern, Switzerland, where the Reformation received little to none opposition.
Haller was born at Aldingen in Württemberg. After scho ...
.
Disputations with Luther and his followers had already occurred in different parts of Germany, and Switzerland had also already been home to the Zürich Disputations that saw Zürich officially become Protestant in January of 1524.
The Baden Disputation
The Swiss government called for an official disputation in 1526 in the
Catholic
The Catholic Church, also known as the Roman Catholic Church, is the largest Christian church, with 1.3 billion baptized Catholics worldwide . It is among the world's oldest and largest international institutions, and has played a ...
town of
Baden in Aargau.
Many Protestants deemed it unsafe to attend, especially and notably the leading Swiss reformer
Huldrych Zwingli
Huldrych or Ulrich Zwingli (1 January 1484 – 11 October 1531) was a leader of the Reformation in Switzerland, born during a time of emerging Swiss patriotism and increasing criticism of the Swiss mercenary system. He attended the Unive ...
.
The two leading Protestant delegates to Baden were
Johannes Oecolampadius
Johannes Oecolampadius (also ''Œcolampadius'', in German also Oekolampadius, Oekolampad; 1482 – 24 November 1531) was a German Protestant reformer in the Calvinist tradition from the Electoral Palatinate. He was the leader of the Protestant f ...
, in the stead of Zwingli, and Bern's Berchtold Haller.
The Disputation saw many more Roman Catholic representatives, who heavily outnumbered the Protestants, and the leading Roman Catholic disputant was
Johannes Eck
Johann Maier von Eck (13 November 1486 – 13 February 1543), often anglicized as John Eck, was a German Catholic theologian, scholastic, prelate, and a pioneer of the counter-reformation who was among Martin Luther's most important inter ...
, who had famously debated
Martin Luther
Martin Luther (; ; 10 November 1483 – 18 February 1546) was a German priest, theologian, author, hymnwriter, and professor, and Order of Saint Augustine, Augustinian friar. He is the seminal figure of the Reformation, Protestant Refo ...
in 1519.
The disputation officially condemned all Protestant teachings as well as excommunicated Zwingli. Although the Baden Disputation was a decisive Roman Catholic victory, its incisive language drew many away from the Roman Catholic side, including the leaders of Bern.
In addition, the Swiss government refused to let the leaders of Bern see the documentation of the proceedings of the disputation.
Bern therefore distanced itself from the Baden Disputation and continued reforming.
The Bern Disputation
Development
In 1527, the Bern city elections installed a Protestant majority in the city council.
The council promptly called for a disputation to take place on 6 January 1528.
The
Holy Roman Emperor
The Holy Roman Emperor, originally and officially the Emperor of the Romans ( la, Imperator Romanorum, german: Kaiser der Römer) during the Middle Ages, and also known as the Roman-German Emperor since the early modern period ( la, Imperat ...
Charles V Charles V may refer to:
* Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor (1500–1558)
* Charles V of Naples (1661–1700), better known as Charles II of Spain
* Charles V of France (1338–1380), called the Wise
* Charles V, Duke of Lorraine (1643–1690)
* Infan ...
called for it to be cancelled, but the letter arrived too late to take effect.
The council invited clergy of all Swiss cantons, as well as delegations from the Swiss government and towns in southern Germany. The Bernese bishops were required by the council to attend, but did not actually attend, in defiance of the council.
The council invited both Roman Catholics and Protestants, but most of the Roman Catholic delegates refused to come.
Johannes Eck, the chief Roman Catholic in the Baden Disputation, refused "to follow the heretics into their nooks and corners."
The leading Protestant representatives included Huldrych Zwingli,
Heinrich Bullinger
Heinrich Bullinger (18 July 1504 – 17 September 1575) was a Swiss Reformer and theologian, the successor of Huldrych Zwingli as head of the Church of Zürich and a pastor at the Grossmünster. One of the most important leaders of the Swiss Re ...
, Johannes Oecolampadius,
Martin Bucer
Martin Bucer ( early German: ''Martin Butzer''; 11 November 1491 – 28 February 1551) was a German Protestant reformer based in Strasbourg who influenced Lutheran, Calvinist, and Anglican doctrines and practices. Bucer was originally a me ...
, and
Wolfgang Capito
Wolfgang Fabricius Capito (also Koepfel) ( – November 1541) was a German Protestant reformer in the Calvinist tradition.
His life and revolutionary work
Capito was born circa 1478 to a smith at Hagenau in Alsace. He attended the famous Latin ...
.
In total, there were around 350 attendees, around 200 of them being from Bernese territory.
The Ten Theses
The disputation was to debate the following ten theses:
These theses were drafted by
Berthold Haller and Franz Kolb, and were sent to Zwingli who suggested revisions that were made to it.
Haller was a close friend of Zwingli, and the theses clearly embody the influence of Zwingli, as well as the negative influence of the Baden Disputation in 1526.
Decision
Due to most of the Roman Catholics not attending, the Protestants heavily outnumbered the Roman Catholics this time, and reversed all the decisions of the Baden Disputation.
The council also approved the 10 theses, and most of the clergy in Bern subscribed to them.
It led to an immediate abolition of the
Mass
Mass is an intrinsic property of a body. It was traditionally believed to be related to the quantity of matter in a physical body, until the discovery of the atom and particle physics. It was found that different atoms and different elementar ...
as well as a wave of
iconoclasm
Iconoclasm (from Ancient Greek, Greek: grc, wikt:εἰκών, εἰκών, lit=figure, icon, translit=eikṓn, label=none + grc, wikt:κλάω, κλάω, lit=to break, translit=kláō, label=none)From grc, wikt:εἰκών, εἰκών + wi ...
.
Aftermath
These ten theses were approved by the Bern city council on 7 February 1528. The council also approved 13 additional articles drafted by Zwingli that furthered ecclesiastical reforms that abolished the priesthood and installed a new liturgy.
Bern would host another three major disputations in the 1530s, furthering the reformation in Switzerland, and distinguishing itself from the Lutheran Reformation in Germany.
[{{Cite thesis , title=The Bernese disputations of 1532 and 1538 : a historical and theological analysis , url=https://research-repository.st-andrews.ac.uk/handle/10023/2566 , publisher=University of St Andrews , date=2011 , degree=Thesis , language=en , first=Stephen Brett , last=Eccher, hdl=10023/2566 ]
References
1528 in Europe
Disputations
History of Bern
Huldrych Zwingli
Reformation in Switzerland