''Allen v Flood''

898 __NOTOC__ Year 898 ( DCCCXCVIII) was a common year starting on Sunday (link will display the full calendar) of the Julian calendar. Events By place Europe * January 1 – King Odo I (or Eudes) dies at La Fère (Northern France) af ...

AC 1 is a leading case in English tort law and UK labour law on intentionally inflicted economic loss.

Facts

A trade union official told an employer his members would not work alongside the claimants. The employer was pressured to get rid of the claimants. For the loss of work, the claimants sued the trade union official. An important fact is that all the workers in the case were only hired day by day. Therefore, the trade union official had never threatened a

breach of contract Breach of contract is a legal cause of action and a type of civil wrong, in which a binding agreement or bargained-for exchange is not honored by one or more of the parties to the contract by non-performance or interference with the other party ...

because the contracts began afresh with a new day's work.

Judgment

High Court

Kennedy J presided over the trial where the jury found that the plaintiffs had suffered damage to the extent of £20 each, and assessed the damage accordingly.

Court of Appeal

Lord Esher MR, Lopes LJ and Rigby LJ held that the action was maintainable against the district delegate.

House of Lords

The House of Lords held by a majority (Lord Watson, Lord Herschell, Lord Macnaghten, Lord Shand, Lord Davey, and Lord James) that even though there was a malicious motive, this could not render the conduct unlawful, because the effect actually complained of (not rehiring) was in itself entirely lawful. As one of those invited to give an opinion, Cave J said the following. Giving the last judgment, Lord Davey said the following. Lord Halsbury LC, Lord Ashbourne and Lord Morris dissented.

Significance

''Allen v Flood'' has come under criticism in some quarters. In another leading tort case in the context of union

strike action Strike action, also called labor strike, labour strike, or simply strike, is a work stoppage caused by the mass refusal of employees to Labor (economics), work. A strike usually takes place in response to grievance (labour), employee grievance ...

, '' Rookes v Barnard'',

Lord Devlin Patrick Arthur Devlin, Baron Devlin, PC, FBA (25 November 1905 – 9 August 1992) was a British judge and legal philosopher. The second-youngest English High Court judge in the 20th century, he served as a Lord of Appeal in Ordinary fro ...

expressed disapproval. However ''Allen v. Flood'' was approved by the House of Lords in the recent case of ''

OBG v Allan was a combined appeal with ''Douglas v Hello! Ltd'' and ''Mainstream Properties Ltd v Young'' and stands as the leading case on economic torts in English law. Facts Lord Hoffmann in his judgment summarised the facts. Judgment Elaborating ...

.'' ''Allen v Flood'' also held that the earlier economic tort case of '' Keeble v Hickeringill'' was just a nuisance case, and not an economic torts case.

Notes

{{Law English tort case law United Kingdom labour case law House of Lords cases 1898 in case law 1898 in British law United Kingdom trade union case law